Dr de Cock says circumcision reduces HIV risk

thomps said:
*Those* qualify as mutilation, and there exist a variety of reasons to despise them. Unfortunately, I think many people hear "circumcision" in its typical usage and immediately think "amputation", which is an absurd hyperbole.

Calling it amputation is not hyperbole. If I were to have my labia removed it would be labial amputation.

Amputate:
http://www.m-w.com/dictionary/amputation
Etymology: Latin amputatus, past participle of amputare, from am-, amb- around + putare to cut, prune -- more at AMBI-
: to remove by or as if by cutting; especially : to cut (as a limb) from the body
- am·pu·ta·tion /"am-py&-'tA-sh&n/ noun


It is true that many people are inconsistent on many moral questions. It's a shame in its own right, but that's a discussion for another thread.

So in your opinion, speaking of moral consistency, are the lesser forms of FGM morally ok, as long as the clitoris is not removed?
Should labias be removed at birth if they've been known to rarely become cancerous in old age? What if the inner labia transmits the herpes virus?

Why should we not give our girl children what we give our boys?
 
Last edited:
UN Convention on the Rights of the Child said:
Article 12
1. States Parties shall assure to the child who is capable of forming his or her own views the right to express those views freely in all matters affecting the child, the views of the child being given due weight in accordance with the age and maturity of the child.
2. For this purpose, the child shall in particular be provided the opportunity to be heard in any judicial and administrative proceedings affecting the child, either directly, or through a representative or an appropriate body, in a manner consistent with the procedural rules of national law.

UN Convention on the Rights of the Child said:
Article 24
1. States Parties recognize the right of the child to the enjoyment of the highest attainable standard of health and to facilities for the treatment of illness and rehabilitation of health. States Parties shall strive to ensure that no child is deprived of his or her right of access to such health care services.
2. States Parties shall pursue full implementation of this right and, in particular, shall take appropriate measures:

(a) To diminish infant and child mortality;

(b) To ensure the provision of necessary medical assistance and health care to all children with emphasis on the development of primary health care;

(c) To combat disease and malnutrition, including within the framework of primary health care, through, inter alia, the application of readily available technology and through the provision of adequate nutritious foods and clean drinking-water, taking into consideration the dangers and risks of environmental pollution;

(d) To ensure appropriate pre-natal and post-natal health care for mothers;

(e) To ensure that all segments of society, in particular parents and children, are informed, have access to education and are supported in the use of basic knowledge of child health and nutrition, the advantages of breastfeeding, hygiene and environmental sanitation and the prevention of accidents;

(f) To develop preventive health care, guidance for parents and family planning education and services.

3. States Parties shall take all effective and appropriate measures with a view to abolishing traditional practices prejudicial to the health of children.

4. States Parties undertake to promote and encourage international co-operation with a view to achieving progressively the full realization of the right recognized in the present article. In this regard, particular account shall be taken of the needs of developing countries.

The rest of it can be viewed here:

http://www.unhchr.ch/html/menu3/b/k2crc.htm

I can see it being used as evidence for both sides of the argument over infant circumcision, which by the way, is the only objection I have left to circumcision being used for HIV prevention.

To get me to drop this objection all you have to do is demonstrate that the child, before an age when it could reasonably be expected to make the decision for itself, will have significant advantages or protection from serious illness. Anyone up for that? Linda? Skeptigirl?
 
Last edited:
All these comparisons of breasts, removal of the entire clitoris, and whatever the cyber comment was referring to are getting a bit tiresome. Breast buds and foreskin are hardly comparable. Preventing significant amount of HIV-AIDS vs preserving the foreskin and preventing breast cancer vs preserving the breasts are hardly comparable. Those arguments are ludicrous.

So, if you have to use false analogies to support your case, you must not have much else.

Have any of you presented any scientific research supporting the claims about just how significant this loss of sensation is? I'm wondering how you know. You would have to have been circumcised as an adult to have any personal experience with this. One circumcised as an infant couldn't know the difference and one not circumcised couldn't know. And any anecdotal reports not collected systematically would be subject to other variables.

Unless I see some decent research, I'm inclined to think it is an imaginary problem. Maybe there is some minor difference. But it could just as easily be circumcised men who are unable to achieve sexual gratification have blamed their circumcisions when there is some other cause for their problem.
 
All these comparisons of breasts, removal of the entire clitoris, and whatever the cyber comment was referring to are getting a bit tiresome. Breast buds and foreskin are hardly comparable. Preventing significant amount of HIV-AIDS vs preserving the foreskin and preventing breast cancer vs preserving the breasts are hardly comparable. Those arguments are ludicrous.

So, if you have to use false analogies to support your case, you must not have much else.

Have any of you presented any scientific research supporting the claims about just how significant this loss of sensation is? I'm wondering how you know. You would have to have been circumcised as an adult to have any personal experience with this. One circumcised as an infant couldn't know the difference and one not circumcised couldn't know. And any anecdotal reports not collected systematically would be subject to other variables.

Unless I see some decent research, I'm inclined to think it is an imaginary problem. Maybe there is some minor difference. But it could just as easily be circumcised men who are unable to achieve sexual gratification have blamed their circumcisions when there is some other cause for their problem.

Is the penis hypersensitive? There is also no evidence that it happens because the penis is hypersensitive. Researchers tested the sensitivity of the skin of the penis in men who considered themselves premature ejaculators and men who were not, and found no difference. It also seems to be a myth that circumcision makes a difference; the American sex researchers Masters and Johnson tested the sensitivity of the glans (head) of the penis in circumcised and non-circumcised men and found them to be the same.

Glans sensitivity appears to be insignificantly different according to this.

ETA: Though I can easily determine the difference in sensation between when my foreskin is covering my glans or not.
 
Last edited:
Ivor, I'm certainly in favor of everyone's rights but you have taken an approach to this that simply ignores the reality of the HIV-AIDS pandemic. You can fuss about what should occur ideally. I told you, if we had an ideal situation, HIV would not be a pandemic in the first place.

But it is a pandemic and the measures that look good in theory are not achievable. It's a fact of the real world. Look at the polio resurgence because someone spread the rumor the polio vaccine was secretly designed to sterilize Muslim women. The president of So. Africa publicly stated he doesn't believe HIV causes AIDS because he read it on the Internet and Kevin Trudeau rakes in millions every week selling the "Cures They Don't Want You to Know About".

You can opine all you want about what should happen. Science has to deal with what does happen, not what should happen. So unless you have a magic wand, 25 years into this pandemic we better do more than we are doing because what we are doing isn't enough.

The trade off of a little foreskin and another generation of infants who are not given the choice for a chance to have a serious impact on a disease many of those infants would otherwise die from after a miserable year of rotting from the inside out as every fungus, virus and bacteria eat away at the defenseless host is simply a no brainer.
 
Ivor, I'm certainly in favor of everyone's rights but you have taken an approach to this that simply ignores the reality of the HIV-AIDS pandemic. You can fuss about what should occur ideally. I told you, if we had an ideal situation, HIV would not be a pandemic in the first place.

But it is a pandemic and the measures that look good in theory are not achievable. It's a fact of the real world. Look at the polio resurgence because someone spread the rumor the polio vaccine was secretly designed to sterilize Muslim women. The president of So. Africa publicly stated he doesn't believe HIV causes AIDS because he read it on the Internet and Kevin Trudeau rakes in millions every week selling the "Cures They Don't Want You to Know About".

You can opine all you want about what should happen. Science has to deal with what does happen, not what should happen. So unless you have a magic wand, 25 years into this pandemic we better do more than we are doing because what we are doing isn't enough.

The trade off of a little foreskin and another generation of infants who are not given the choice for a chance to have a serious impact on a disease many of those infants would otherwise die from after a miserable year of rotting from the inside out as every fungus, virus and bacteria eat away at the defenseless host is simply a no brainer.

Is that in response to my latest post? I have stated I’d be happy to support it if it is done at a age when the child is able to be part of the decision process OR even as an infant if you can show me evidence for a significant risk reduction for a serious illness likely to occur between birth and an age when the child would be able to be part of the decision process. For sake of argument, say 12 years old.
 
Last edited:
I don't think it's such a simple decision.

I have no intention of having my little boy circumsized to slow the spread of HIV. I will however educate him into the use of condoms, selection of sexual partners and promotion of monogamous relationships. That is how the majority of people in the West manage not to contract or spread it.
 
I think the main problems are with this idea are:

1. It doesn't provide complete protection whereas a condom does. So one wonders just how useful it really would be.
2. The protection is does offer seems to be more relevant to a large population rather than the individual and so one wonders how likely people are to have it done on the basis of personal benefit - the prime motivator for all human action.
3. If people think they are protected then might they be less likely to use condoms at all.
 
Is that in response to my latest post? I have stated I’d be happy to support it if it is done at a age when the child is able to be part of the decision process OR even as an infant if you can show me evidence for a significant risk reduction for a serious illness likely to occur between birth and an age when the child would be able to be part of the decision process. For sake of argument, say 12 years old.

Yes but that's not really a realistic option. The operation is quite minor for the vast majority of infants but far more serious and risky for an adult man. An infant quickly recovers and forgets.

I don't really buy into this rights based argument. Firstly as above, we cannot reasonably wait until they give consent or the risks are higher. We do stuff to our kids that hurts them or potentially harms them if we think it's to their benefit. If I really thought it would make the difference between life and death and no simple alternative, like a condom, existed then I'd have it done to my child with no compunction. But this of course isn't the case.
 
I think the main problems are with this idea are:

1. It doesn't provide complete protection whereas a condom does. So one wonders just how useful it really would be.

It’s to be used as part of a package of treatment, including all the existing methods. Given that only 1 in 5 has access to condoms and that is unlikely to change significantly in the foreseeable future, offering this treatment to boys and men now would be useful.

2. The protection is does offer seems to be more relevant to a large population rather than the individual and so one wonders how likely people are to have it done on the basis of personal benefit - the prime motivator for all human action.
I’d agree that a significant number of lives will only be saved if implemented at the population level, but the motivation for the individual would be a significantly increased resistance to HIV via unprotected sexual intercourse.

3. If people think they are protected then might they be less likely to use condoms at all.

A real risk factor to me as well that will have to be addressed via education about what protection having the procedure offers. I don’t know how this could be done without negatively impacting the importance of condom usage, or the incentive to use more condoms than they do now. To me, this is a good reason to perform it at an age when the individual could understand why it might be a good idea for them to have it done and how protected they really are by it.

Alternatively they could be circumcised as an infant and actively be given no information that they have more protection from HIV infection because of it, but that seems unethical to me.
 
It’s to be used as part of a package of treatment, including all the existing methods. Given that only 1 in 5 has access to condoms and that is unlikely to change significantly in the foreseeable future, offering this treatment to boys and men now would be useful.

When you say 1-in-5 I assume you mean Africa and the like. I'm slightly more for it in 3rd world countries where condom availability and eduction do seem fraught with difficulty. BUt I'm struggling to see how it would be more likely that a mass circumcism campaign is going to be easier to implement. For adult men you need anaesthetics, aftercare and most likely antibiotic treatment. That's going to cost a lot and be hard to organise.

Alternatively they could be circumcised as an infant and actively be given no information that they have more protection from HIV infection because of it, but that seems unethical to me.

I don't have an ethical problem with this and believe that it would be the only remotely sensible way to implement it.

But if I am to believe the level of ignorance and superstition attached to sexual matter and health in these populations then I can't see swathes of the population agreeing to get their boys done.
 
Yes but that's not really a realistic option. The operation is quite minor for the vast majority of infants but far more serious and risky for an adult man. An infant quickly recovers and forgets.

It was realistic for 5000 young men in Uganda and 2700 in Kenya. Why is it not realistic now? The brain of an infant may not remember, but their body is permanently altered. That cannot be undone. It is a physical memory of the event.

I don't really buy into this rights based argument. Firstly as above, we cannot reasonably wait until they give consent or the risks are higher. We do stuff to our kids that hurts them or potentially harms them if we think it's to their benefit. If I really thought it would make the difference between life and death and no simple alternative, like a condom, existed then I'd have it done to my child with no compunction. But this of course isn't the case.

The risks may be higher but all the studies have been performed on young men who were able to give consent. Obviously the researchers did not think the risks were high enough to stop the trials because of complications. I think you are overstating the risks for young men compared to infants. For example, a boy of 12 will be well aware if something is starting to hurt, swell, or change colour and can inform someone or seek help immediately. An infant requires the wound to be monitored by a parent or care giver.

I would say most parents only make choices for their children for an immediate benefit or for a future time when they will still not be developed enough to make an informed choice.

While the level of input from the parents should be in proportion to the current capabilities of the child to make an informed choice, it does not, in my opinion give a parent the right to make choices that can be deferred to such a time that the child would be able to have a significant input in that choice. For example, I do not agree with the concept of arranged marriages, do you? What if the risk of divorce for an arranged marriage was significantly lower and the reported satisfaction was higher than marriages between people who were allowed to choose? Would that change your view on arranged marriages? Would you wish you’d had an arranged marriage after being given this information?

I believe my point of view is shared by most parents for everyday things that their children need help with to make a good choice. For example, you choose good fitting shoes for your young child's feet but let your 16 year old wear shoes that you know are not good for their feet. I think the emotive subjects of circumcision and HIV are altering (IMO incorrectly but understandably) this intuitive, sensible and moral way parents make choices for their children’s benefit.
 
Last edited:
Why do I have a feeling they only looked at the incidence of really severe, acute meatal stenosis right in the post-operative period, and not toddlers presenting with urinary spraying?

Then look at the article and see what the criteria was.
 
Is that in response to my latest post? I have stated I’d be happy to support it if it is done at a age when the child is able to be part of the decision process OR even as an infant if you can show me evidence for a significant risk reduction for a serious illness likely to occur between birth and an age when the child would be able to be part of the decision process. For sake of argument, say 12 years old.
It was after your patient rights post, you posted one in between while I was composing mine.

But your premise is unrealistic. You expect a prepubescent boy to decide something involving sexual satisfaction? And if you waited until the child could make that judgment, sexual risks would already be occurring.

And, you have to be kidding asking a 12 year old if he wants to have a painful procedure on his penis.

Again, it might sound good but it is unrealistic. The parents decide all sorts of other things for that child which will also affect him throughout his life. That's what has to happen here if we are to prevent unnecessary HIV infections and deaths.

Everyone's griping about giving teen girls this HPV vaccine to prevent cervical cancer. But the studies looking at prevalence of the virus show it is extensive in teens! The time to give the vaccine is prior to independent decision making. Those earlier independent decisions are not always the wisest ones we make in our lives.
 
I think the main problems are with this idea are:

1. It doesn't provide complete protection whereas a condom does. So one wonders just how useful it really would be.
2. The protection is does offer seems to be more relevant to a large population rather than the individual and so one wonders how likely people are to have it done on the basis of personal benefit - the prime motivator for all human action.
3. If people think they are protected then might they be less likely to use condoms at all.
All this has been discussed in this thread in particular how all the condoms and education in the world is not going to get everyone to use them. In countries with high rates of HIV, circumcisions are going to save lives, the research shows it, the research has reached the stage where it's time to act on it, and no one is talking about circumcision in lieu of condoms or education.

Increasing risk behaviors did not occur with circumcision for increased HIV resistance in the studies.
 
How can you say with a straight face that condoms, education and drugs are not enough when only 1 in 5 has access to them?

I shall tell you why male circumcision is being considered for Africa and not the developed world: Because it’s cheap and pretty effective. And the reason infant circumcision is being considered is that it’s cheaper still. A true capitalist solution. I love America.

Will you be upgrading your body if cybernetic implants come out? Even more to the point will you be adding to or taking bits off your children’s bodies if you are given the chance? After all, you’re an “expert”, so you know what’s best.

EX=has been; usedtawas. Spurt= drip under pressure.
 
Hey skeptigirl...

Can you go find for me the rates of cancer of the vulva in uncircumcised women vs. cancer of the penis in uncircumcised men?

Or the rate of UTIs in uncircumcised girls/women?

Waiting...

If I remember correctly, at first you said "Now I'm thinking I should be recommending circumcision" before you edited your post.

:cool:
 
Then look at the article and see what the criteria was.
I don't have access to it.
But since you're advocating the amputation of newborn sex organs, I think the burdon of proof is on you to prove that your figures are sound.
So, quote to me the relevant parts.
Show me where I'm wrong.
 
Hey skeptigirl...

Can you go find for me the rates of cancer of the vulva in uncircumcised women vs. cancer of the penis in uncircumcised men?

Or the rate of UTIs in uncircumcised girls/women?
If you give me a reason this is a logical investigation I'll look. Otherwise your analogy doesn't cut the mustard so I prefer not to jump through false analogy hoops. There's only so much time in a day.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom