Dr de Cock says circumcision reduces HIV risk

...I'd be mad as hell if something were chopped off in infancy over a hypothetical risk that could be dealt with in another way. But that's just me...

I don't think you would be. You would not know what you were missing. Read the posts of the guys here who were circumcised as infants for trivial / religious reasons. They prefer it because for them it's "normal". Even better, the women they've had sex with tell them how good it looks:)

Have you got young kids? Have you ever manipulated a situation to motivate them to "like" something such as vegetables?

Have you personally ever found your preference for something change because it helped get you the attention or affections of someone you found sexy?
 
Last edited:
post 238: "Why? Because they might not choose it? Because they might prefer to keep their foreskins just like our European male members of this forum would?"

No, because kids if given a choice would prefer to defer pain in the present regardless of gain in the future, and they tend to feel invincible. If they felt vulnerable to HIV, they'd be using condoms and we wouldn't be having this conversation.

If my teenager was afraid of needles should I let him decide to skip his vaccinations?

Your conclusion I want a certain outcome or that a certain decision be made ignores the reason I have taken the position I have. There is evidence from 15 years of scientific research and there is a worldwide pandemic of a devastating disease.

You are so focused on one criteria for the decision making process, you are ignoring the other criteria. I accept the individual rights arguments, I accept the claim men are better off sexually with their foreskins.

and
"Oh no ya' don't.
Don't equate allowing boy/men of reproductive age to choose for themselves with "ignoring it". That's not the case. Allowing them to choose is not ignoring anything.
"

But the evidence shows if you circumcise you decrease the number of new HIV infections. The evidence also shows, if you wait until boys are adults, the number of HIV cases you prevent will be less. The evidence also shows that regardless of the ideal, the real is, education and condoms are not enough. The risk is measurable, not hypothetical.

Circumcisions vs HIV-AIDS. That is the decision. Period. All the other issues are wonderful to discuss, the goals of decreasing HIV in other ways is fine, who would argue there?

But when the dust settles you still have circumcisions vs HIV-AIDS here and now.
 
Last edited:
And perhaps that is just because "we" haven't looked for the health benefits in female genital mutilation like we have been doing for decades for male genital mutilation?
Could be true, is it relevant to this discussion? We aren't discussing male vs female circumcisions. We are discussing male circs vs HIV-AIDS prevention.

....

This is an incredibly ignorant statement regarding female sexual gratification.
I'm not going to debate your absurd claim foreskins and clitorises are equivalent. Provide some evidence one can have a climax without the clitoris otherwise you make a baseless statement.
 
...
Skeptigirl, I hope I’ve explained my point of view sufficiently well to convince you that our positions on this issue are remarkably close and the main difference is our relative weightings of the various pros and cons, leading to us to slightly different ideas about what would be the best solution.
I think we have actually reached a consensus! I'm am amazed.

I see your point about the trade off when HIV is not involved. But I'll need more evidence the loss of sexual gratification is as great as being claimed to consider the other trade offs not entirely worth it. That is the difficult part. I've never had sex with a circumcised partner who didn't enjoy it and didn't reach a climax. The fact some believe they are missing so much is hard to judge since as you say, how would they know?

I could understand it if there was an anecdotal body of evidence from men who had before and after experiences and the sample was large enough to control for other variables involved.

If you reach an orgasm, how can you say it would have been a better orgasm without the circ? And there was mention on some of these activist web sites that circs increase premature ejaculation. That seems contradictory.

So is there any evidence of the degree of loss here besides the emotional evidence?
 
I think we have actually reached a consensus! I'm am amazed.

See it wasn’t so hard, was it? Please don’t be amazed. I’m always open to good arguments. Thank you (and Linda if she’s still reading) for presenting some.

I see your point about the trade off when HIV is not involved. But I'll need more evidence the loss of sexual gratification is as great as being claimed to consider the other trade offs not entirely worth it. That is the difficult part. I've never had sex with a circumcised partner who didn't enjoy it and didn't reach a climax. The fact some believe they are missing so much is hard to judge since as you say, how would they know?

Now you’re just bragging:)

I think all you could say for certain the sensation would be different. Whether it’s judged to be better or worse by the man (or woman for that matter) is influenced by such things as positive or negative re-enforcement from their peers and sexual partners. Having said that I think I would miss my foreskin if I had to have it removed for medical reasons in the future.

I could understand it if there was an anecdotal body of evidence from men who had before and after experiences and the sample was large enough to control for other variables involved.

If you reach an orgasm, how can you say it would have been a better orgasm without the circ? And there was mention on some of these activist web sites that circs increase premature ejaculation. That seems contradictory.

If you were circumcised at birth you couldn’t. Perhaps that’s a reason for having it done a birth. I think a man could have earth-shaking orgasms with or without a foreskin.

So is there any evidence of the degree of loss here besides the emotional evidence?

I have not seen any but I know I prefer to have my foreskin. I get significant sexual pleasure from it.

I’ve thought of a few more questions that I’m not sure of the answer to. They are:

Why are neonatal circumcisions that much safer? Is it just the reduced potential for blood loss?

Generally, do they use local aesthetic for neonatal circumcisions?

If they don’t use local aesthesia, is ok to inflict that much pain on a human (or an animal for that matter) that can experience it at the time even if they don’t explicitly remember later in life?
 
The preferred anesthetic procedure is a nerve block. The anesthetic in injected around the nerve entering through the groin. It is not as safe to inject anesthetic into a confined space such as a finger or a small diameter penis. There's no room for the liquid to go and it can compress the blood supply.

It has only been recently that any anesthetic was used. I've seen many circs where none was used. But those were also done fairly soon after birth. This baby has just had its head squeezed through a vice hard enough the bones moved. Pain nerves, while developed, are not as well developed as they will be later in life.

As a female nurse watching mostly male docs doing circs without anesthetic, I thought it was traumatic for the infants. The docs would always brush it off. But currently in the US anyway, I believe circs without anesthetics are not the norm. However, I'm not sure.

Re age, the most important difference is infants are growing fast and that includes quicker healing. Adults heal more slowly. Pain is the second biggest reason. Kids really are in less post op pain. I was a hospital pediatric nurse in the past and I've worked with many adults. I can tell you unequivocally kids recover more quickly from major surgery and require very few post op pain meds compared with adults. I've seen kids, no pain meds, up running in the halls a day after an appendectomy.

According to the CDC's info page:
In large studies of infant circumcision in the U.S., complications rates range from 0.2 to 2.0% [2]. In the recently completed South African study of adult circumcision by general medical practitioners in their surgical offices, the overall complication rate was 3.8%. The most commonly reported complications were pain (0.8%), followed by swelling or hematoma, bleeding, and problems with appearance (each 0.6%). Damage to the penis (0.3%), infection (0.2%), and delayed wound healing (0.1%) were uncommon. There were no reported deaths or problems with urination [10].
 
Last edited:
skeptigirl said:
The evidence also shows, if you wait until boys are adults, the number of HIV cases you prevent will be less.
Huh? What evidence says that?
Don't just make things up.

The evidence also shows that regardless of the ideal, the real is, education and condoms are not enough. The risk is measurable, not hypothetical.

How can you say that when only one in 5 have access to either?

Circumcisions vs HIV-AIDS. That is the decision. Period. All the other issues are wonderful to discuss, the goals of decreasing HIV in other ways is fine, who would argue there?

But when the dust settles you still have circumcisions vs HIV-AIDS here and now.

If my teenager was afraid of needles should I let him decide to skip his vaccinations?

It's not like the other option is just holding teens down and shooting them up aginst their will. There's no comparison to be made here at all.


And I have no problem with offering it to adults/men of reproductive age.
 
....

I'm not going to debate your absurd claim foreskins and clitorises are equivalent. Provide some evidence one can have a climax without the clitoris otherwise you make a baseless statement.

I agree that foreskins and clitorises aren't the same. But one page back I provided evidence that females can easily climax without a clitoris. I'll put the link up again if you need it.
 
...snip...

I'm not going to debate your absurd claim foreskins and clitorises are equivalent.
Provide some evidence I have made such a claim otherwise you make a baseless statement.

Provide some evidence one can have a climax without the clitoris otherwise you make a baseless statement.

A link has already been provided.
 
Could be true, is it relevant to this discussion? We aren't discussing male vs female circumcisions. We are discussing male circs vs HIV-AIDS prevention.

..snip...

I am discussing what you posted i.e.

...I consider removing the clitoris to certainly be removing a sex organ but somehow the skin which covers the sex organ (penis) is hard to equate with the organ itself...
 
The preferred anesthetic procedure is a nerve block. The anesthetic in injected around the nerve entering through the groin. It is not as safe to inject anesthetic into a confined space such as a finger or a small diameter penis. There's no room for the liquid to go and it can compress the blood supply.

Ok, that makes sense.

It has only been recently that any anesthetic was used. I've seen many circs where none was used. But those were also done fairly soon after birth. This baby has just had its head squeezed through a vice hard enough the bones moved. Pain nerves, while developed, are not as well developed as they will be later in life.

That’s an interesting point – do babies suffer significant trauma during their birth even if everything goes perfectly? From my brief research it appears that it has been discovered that the vice-like pressure has a number of beneficial functions for the infant’s body, though I could be being misled.

This page has an interesting discussion on how “experts” have changed their opinions over time about just how much pain babies actually experience.

As a female nurse watching mostly male docs doing circs without anesthetic, I thought it was traumatic for the infants. The docs would always brush it off. But currently in the US anyway, I believe circs without anesthetics are not the norm. However, I'm not sure.

This study published in the Lancet has some interesting results for infants that were uncircumcised, circumcised with no pain relief and circumcised with pain relief v response to pain at a future time.

It appears to be a constant in human history that the people responsible for suffering (intentional or otherwise) of other beings (human or not) brush it off quickly. The refusal to even contemplate it sounds like a coping strategy to me, along with the ‘it never did me any harm’ catch all defense.

Re age, the most important difference is infants are growing fast and that includes quicker healing. Adults heal more slowly. Pain is the second biggest reason. Kids really are in less post op pain. I was a hospital pediatric nurse in the past and I've worked with many adults. I can tell you unequivocally kids recover more quickly from major surgery and require very few post op pain meds compared with adults. I've seen kids, no pain meds, up running in the halls a day after an appendectomy.

According to the CDC's info page:

Yes, kids do often bounce back remarkably quickly, though we all learn an ‘act’ of how to behave when we are or think we are ill or in pain. As pain is a psychological construct some people have better ‘acts’ than others to deal with it.
 
Huh? What evidence says that?
Don't just make things up.
You can't figure that out from the rate of teen HIV infections? Huh? Are you suggesting teens don't get HIV or that circumcision only prevents HIV in adults? I'm not in the habit of making things up and I think a little common sense on your part would help here.

How can you say that when only one in 5 have access to either?
Regardless of what and why all the current methods of intervening in the HIV pandemic fail, the bottom line is they fail. If you have a great plan to mobilize the condom education army, can get past all the church ladies (and men) who see condoms as tools of Satan, and can assure that a pep talk and a few free condoms will make a difference, and you could find a few financiers, you might make a difference.

The point is the claim that only 1 in 5 has access regardless of how valid the statistic, says nothing about why that is or how to address the problem. There are many many programs promoting education an condoms. Solve women's second class citizen status and economic travesty of women in countries with high rates of HIV and the rates will go down as well. In the mean time, leaving circs out of the battle plan is as stupid as leaving out needle exchange programs and including abstinence only education.

It's not like the other option is just holding teens down and shooting them up aginst their will. There's no comparison to be made here at all....And I have no problem with offering it to adults/men of reproductive age.
But I believe you do have a naive view of the rational thinking of teens.

You still have the time period between beginning sexual activity and the maturing of brain function where many chances to prevent HIV will be lost if waiting for the individual to decide for themselves instead of having the parent decide for them occurs.

It's fine to consider that when determining the best course of action, but it isn't OK to pretend it isn't going to be a factor.
 
....That’s an interesting point – do babies suffer significant trauma during their birth even if everything goes perfectly? From my brief research it appears that it has been discovered that the vice-like pressure has a number of beneficial functions for the infant’s body, though I could be being misled.
There is a specific benefit to compressing the chest cavity. If you've ever seen a significantly molded head just after delivery, you would know it has to hurt unless a bolus of endorphins or incomplete pain receptors in the scalp and head bones is a factor. The brain itself has no pain receptors like those in skin and muscle. We have headaches but they result from a different kind of pain receptor. The periosteum which lines the bones, on the other hand is very rich in pain receptors. It has to hurt going through the birth canal. Speaking from the experience on the birth canal side, pain is an understatement.


...Yes, kids do often bounce back remarkably quickly, though we all learn an ‘act’ of how to behave when we are or think we are ill or in pain. As pain is a psychological construct some people have better ‘acts’ than others to deal with it.
There are two factors, one is the sick role elements we acquire with time, but there is true a physical difference in healing and pain that is age dependent. The nervous system is simply not fully developed at birth and growth hormones speed healing.


Both interesting articles, BTW. The changing opinion re neonatal pain is interesting because I'd say we nurses always knew, it's the docs who were in denial. :)
 
Last edited:
This evidence has a glaring problem, there is no comparison with women in a more sexually permissive society to establish if the "the proportions reporting experience of orgasm during intercourse" is sufficient to detect a difference between "cut and uncut" women in the study.

Here's the actual abstract:

The association between female genital cutting and correlates of sexual and gynaecological morbidity in Edo State, Nigeria.
POPULATION: 1836 healthy premenopausal women [attending family planning and antenatal clinics at three hospitals in Edo State, South-south Nigeria.]

RESULTS:Forty-five percent were circumcised and 71% had type 1, while 24% had type 2 female genital cutting. No significant differences between cut and uncut women were observed in the frequency of reports of sexual intercourse in the preceding week or month, the frequency of reports of early arousal during intercourse and the proportions reporting experience of orgasm during intercourse.

In contrast, cut women were 1.25 times more likely to get pregnant at a given age than uncut women. Uncut women were significantly more likely to report that the clitoris is the most sexually sensitive part of their body (OR = 0.35, 95% CI = 0.26-0.47), while cut women were more likely to report that their breasts are their most sexually sensitive body parts (OR = 1.91; 95% CI = 1.51-2.42).

CONCLUSION: Female genital cutting in this group of women did not attenuate sexual feelings
You have no mention of what percentage of women reported orgasm at all. You have women with complete removal of the clitoris stating their breasts were the site of most sexual stimulation.

If the claim is being made here that women can achieve orgasm equally from nipple stimulation as from clitoral stimulation I'd say that's doubtful. This study certainly doesn't provide evidence of that fact without some documentation of how many of the women in the sample achieve orgasm, cut or not. Many adult women have not experienced orgasm at all. In sexually repressive societies, who knows what the experience of women commonly is. Perhaps there is additional research on the matter.



Diagram from Wiki showing type 1 & 2 cutting


I did a brief search for rates of female orgasm by age and culture but it looks like it will take more time to find appropriate research addressing the question I posed. I did find the following but as an abstract the sources cited supporting the conclusions aren't available.

Medical dangers of female circumcision
Psychosexual complications [of fgm] include a feeling of reduced feminity; diminished desire for coitus; diminished coital frequency; dyspareunia, apareunia or vaginismus; lack of orgasm; anal intercourse; depression and psychotic states; and, social problems.

-
 
There is a specific benefit to compressing the chest cavity. If you've ever seen a significantly molded head just after delivery, you would know it has to hurt unless a bolus of endorphins or incomplete pain receptors in the scalp and head bones is a factor. The brain itself has no pain receptors like those in skin and muscle. We have headaches but they result from a different kind of pain receptor. The periosteum which lines the bones, on the other hand is very rich in pain receptors. It has to hurt going through the birth canal.

That all makes sense.

Speaking from the experience on the birth canal side, pain is an understatement.

I’ve heard it stings a bit:)

There are two factors, one is the sick role elements we acquire with time, but there is true a physical difference in healing and pain that is age dependent. The nervous system is simply not fully developed at birth and growth hormones speed healing.

I fully accept that children heal faster because their bodies are growing but I can’t find anything to show how they experience pain less than adults. If anything, what looks like the most well researched papers on the web state the reverse. Here’s another one:

http://pmj.bmj.com/cgi/content/full/79/934/438

Abstract said:
Infants, including newborn babies, experience pain similarly and probably more intensely than older children and adults. They are also at risk of adverse long term effects on behaviour and development, through inadequate attention towards pain relief in early life. However, the issue of analgesia in young babies has been largely neglected in most clinical settings, despite subjecting them to painful diagnostic and therapeutic procedures. Several therapeutic and preventive strategies, including systemic and local pharmacological and non-pharamacological interventions, are reported to be effective in relieving pain in infants. A judicious application of these interventions, backed by awareness and sensitivity to pain perception, on the part of the caregivers is likely to yield the best results. This article is a review of the mechanisms of pain perception, objective assessment, and management strategies of pain in infants.

None of this seems surprising to since pain is essential for life (people without the ability to experience pain rarely live very long) and conditions us very quickly to avoid painful stimulus.

Both interesting articles, BTW. The changing opinion re neonatal pain is interesting because I'd say we nurses always knew, it's the docs who were in denial. :)

Sometimes commonsense is right.
 

Seems like a well researched article but it isn't original research. I'll try to find references 12 & 13 (the copy command didn't work or I would have copied the titles) when I have time.

I still question just what these "self reported" orgasms actually consist of. The article claims stimulating the cervix causes orgasm. But that isn't my experience and while I can imagine something like a partial orgasm with vaginal contractions occurring, I can't imagine an event which is felt in the clitoris could be anything similar without one. Unless there was some mechanism such as occurs with phantom limb pain.

I'll have to see what the citations from the article actually say. Thanks, however for the excellent citation. It isn't always easy to find just the research one is looking for.
 
I fully accept that children heal faster because their bodies are growing but I can’t find anything to show how they experience pain less than adults. If anything, what looks like the most well researched papers on the web state the reverse. Here’s another one:

http://pmj.bmj.com/cgi/content/full/79/934/438...
I expected that article to be from an anti-abortion web site but it was in what appears to be a valid journal.

I don't doubt the nervous system in children is intact in utero. But the claim infants "feel more pain" wasn't definitively supported in the article. It doesn't make a lot of sense that pain receptors come 100% developed in an infant whose body is certainly not 100% developed.

What they did look at was the physiological response. I'm not surprised to see more stress hormones and other physiological factors with painful stimuli. That reflects the generalized responses typical in infants. Fevers are typically high in infants compared to adults. The startle reflex is a whole body reflex where as later reflexes become localized. And so on. So while I'm not saying the measures looked at in the research weren't indicators of more pain, I don't think you can say for certain they are.

On the other hand, I'm big on giving pain meds such as tylenol to kids for pain when many people seem not to think about it. And I'm for that anesthetic with that circ, I already said that.

I'll try to read more on this topic as well. There is no question babies feel pain. It may even be the emotional factors that make adult surgery more complicated than infant surgery. However, after working on a pediatric surgical unit for a few years and after working with adult surgical patients for many more years, I can state unequivocally that kids require less pain medication and for fewer days after surgery compared to adults.
 
I expected that article to be from an anti-abortion web site but it was in what appears to be a valid journal.

On the other hand, I'm big on giving pain meds such as tylenol to kids for pain when many people seem not to think about it. And I'm for that anesthetic with that circ, I already said that.

I'll try to read more on this topic as well. There is no question babies feel pain. It may even be the emotional factors that make adult surgery more complicated than infant surgery. However, after working on a pediatric surgical unit for a few years and after working with adult surgical patients for many more years, I can state unequivocally that kids require less pain medication and for fewer days after surgery compared to adults.

Hi skeptigirl, I have been trying to stay out of this discussion as a lot of what was said has been repeated from earlier threads discussing this work.

I feel I must intervene on the point about children experiencing less pain than adults. I assume that is what you are trying to infer from your statement above. I do not think you are correct, for the following reasons:

1. The nature of surgery that children and adults undergo is often very different. Inguinal hernia repairs, for instance. I would therefore argue that you are not comparing like with like in the above statement.

2. Secondly, if the nurses you worked with shared your feelings, you will have created a self-fulfilling prophecy.

3. I would dispute your orginial assertion, unless it is interpreted literally i.e. a 5kg baby requires fewer milligrams of medication than a 200kg adult to achieve effective analgesia - but I do not think you meant that, I think you meant in proportion to body mass or surface area.

In my experience, children require the same types of analgeia (paracetamol, NSAIDs and opiates, nerve blocks and epidurals/spinal) after equivalent surgery as adults do. The doses are proprtionate and given with the same frequency in the immediate postoperative period.

I will concede that they heal better and therefore may require a shorter duration of analgesia overall, but...

that does not mean that they experience acute postoperative differently.

I realise that we are in agreement that circumcision should not be done with adequate anasethesia, and completely agree with you that children should have effective analgesia, including neonates.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom