I expected that article to be from an anti-abortion web site but it was in what appears to be a valid journal.
On the other hand, I'm big on giving pain meds such as tylenol to kids for pain when many people seem not to think about it. And I'm for that anesthetic with that circ, I already said that.
I'll try to read more on this topic as well. There is no question babies feel pain. It may even be the emotional factors that make adult surgery more complicated than infant surgery. However, after working on a pediatric surgical unit for a few years and after working with adult surgical patients for many more years, I can state unequivocally that kids require less pain medication and for fewer days after surgery compared to adults.
Hi skeptigirl, I have been trying to stay out of this discussion as a lot of what was said has been repeated from earlier threads discussing this work.
I feel I must intervene on the point about children experiencing less pain than adults. I assume that is what you are trying to infer from your statement above. I do not think you are correct, for the following reasons:
1. The nature of surgery that children and adults undergo is often very different. Inguinal hernia repairs, for instance. I would therefore argue that you are not comparing like with like in the above statement.
2. Secondly, if the nurses you worked with shared your feelings, you will have created a self-fulfilling prophecy.
3. I would dispute your orginial assertion, unless it is interpreted literally i.e. a 5kg baby requires fewer milligrams of medication than a 200kg adult to achieve effective analgesia - but I do not think you meant that, I think you meant in proportion to body mass or surface area.
In my experience, children require the same types of analgeia (paracetamol, NSAIDs and opiates, nerve blocks and epidurals/spinal) after equivalent surgery as adults do. The doses are proprtionate and given with the same frequency in the immediate postoperative period.
I will concede that they heal better and therefore may require a shorter duration of analgesia overall, but...
that does not mean that they experience acute postoperative differently.
I realise that we are in agreement that circumcision should not be done with adequate anasethesia, and completely agree with you that children should have effective analgesia, including neonates.