Yes it is just skin. All skin has nerves in it. I have a foreskin. I have a wife with a clitoris. I'd rather have my foreskin cut off than her clitoris. One wouldn't completely take away the ability to enjoy sex ruin our sex life, the other would. The two are not the same thing. They are functionally different. And you seizing on the words "just skin" doesn't change that. The nearest equivalent would be the hood of the clitoris. Cutting off the clitoris is more like cutting off the glans.
The foreskin is much more then just skin - it is for a start it is in fact more like lips - skin on the outside and mucous membranes on the inside see this brief
article you may be surprised to learn it is indeed much more then just skin.
There may be cultural reasons but there are also obvious anatomical ones too. The anatomical reasons are extremely important and to pretend they don't exist does your position nor you any justice IMO
I don't understand your point.
I don't know what reasons "the supporters" of female circumcision use. I would rather imagine they have varied reasons depending on who they are. Again there are obvious and very important anatomical reasons that make the procedure of removal of the clitoris completely unacceptable.
I did include the major arguments they tend to share in common:
And by exactly the same I mean hygiene, appearance, preference of partners and so on.
I don't even know what they are. I wasn't commenting on female circumcision in it's various forms. I'm arguing that your statement "The clitoris is "just" part of the female genitalia like the foreskin is "just part" of the male genitalia" is invalid. ...snip...
My comment was in relationship to skepticgirl's comment of "
I consider removing the clitoris to certainly be removing a sex organ but somehow the skin which covers the sex organ (penis) is hard to equate with the organ itself."
I was trying to illustrate that the foreskin is
just as much part of the male sex organ as the clitoris is of the female organ. Anatomically and physiologically they are
both integral structures to the male and female sex organs respectively. Indeed removal of either does not affect major
function of both sets of sex organs i.e. urination and sexual reproduction. (Note only talking about type 1 female "circumcision".)
Unfortunately because we tend to view our own traditions quite differently to other cultures' traditions many people just do not accept that we also have a culturally approved tradition of genital
mutilation, many people indeed even hunt for
excuses why "our" tradition is OK and "rational" but "theirs" isn't. So "we" all tend to agree that female circumcision is bad, but male well obviously that is
different.... (Yet we do not in the USA or the UK culturally accept that even Type 1 female circumcision limited to removal of just what could be described as "female foreskin" is OK even when done for "traditional reasons".)
I'm afraid I've drifted away from the OP topic so to try and not continue my derail let me say why this is relevant to the interesting research in the OP.
If we found that "female circumcision" has a similar reduction in the
chance of contracting HIV would that be
supported by the WHO? Or is that different?