Dr de Cock says circumcision reduces HIV risk

No difference????

Between an amputation of a sex organ and a tiny hole in your ear that will just close and heal over time when the ring is taken out????

I'm not cool with peircing babies' ears....but geez....it's nothing like amputating a sex organ!
It's interesting that you find this comparison invalid yet some of the comparisons you've made are even less valid.

And it also illustrates an interesting continuum of value judgments here. I consider removing the clitoris to certainly be removing a sex organ but somehow the skin which covers the sex organ (penis) is hard to equate with the organ itself.
 
You stated that you were not able to find population based information on complications from circumcision. I am suggesting that one starting point would be to follow the references from the CDC fact sheet. It also looked like the report that Skeptigirl linked to may have some references, although I cannot tell if it is referring only to the immediate post-op period, or long term. I don't know if your search will be fruitful, I was only trying to suggest some leads.

Linda
The study itself examined the first month after birth and was concerned with more serious complications, but the discussion and bibliography extensively covered the existing research including one study with results out of range of the majority of research. That's why I suggested kelly read it.

I must say, however, the original reference on the meatal stenosis complication stated it was a very minor problem, was easily corrected and rarely if ever had more serious sequelae. The lack of other papers including meatal stenosis in the discussion also suggests the minor nature of the problem.
 
It's the incidence of meatal stenosis that I'm looking for. Everything available says's it's around 7-10%.
But "everything available" is not enough to draw that conclusion.

Just as a point of science here, one must be careful not to claim a measurement more accurate than the measuring device. Just as it is improper to give a result carried out several decimals when calculating measurements which were not that precise, neither is is accurate to state a concluded figure on such tentative data.

In other words if I measure in inches and put the resulting measurements into some calculation, I can't claim increased precision based on the math result. If I am averaging many results, my average can be carried out to more places than the original numbers, but not other calculations.

By the same token, in research it isn't valid to claim a conclusion when you know the data is not sufficient to draw the conclusion. Unless you find something else, you cannot say the rate is 10%. All you can say is it was x% in study y.
 
BTW, kelly, speaking again of those exaggerated comparisons, they do not help your argument.

amputation: "especially : to cut (as a limb) from the body "

One does not amputate the appendix for example. Nor is a mole amputated. In my opinion, you are letting some emotional reaction here distort your perception. Many of the analogies you are making are unrealistic.
 
...snip...

Many of the analogies you are making are unrealistic.

I disagree - for instance if you look at the "traditional" reasons given for both male and female circumcision you will see that there is a lot of cross over - the fact that female circumcision is a much more severe mutilation does not mean it cannot be used as an analogy.

Hanny Lightfoot-Klein (http://www.lightfoot-klein.com/)

"The reasons given for female circumcision in Africa and for routine male circumcision in the U.S. are essentially the same. Both falsely tout the positive health benefits of the procedures. Both promise cleanliness and the absence of "bad" genital odors, as well as greater attractiveness and acceptability of the sex organs. The affected individuals in both cultures have come to view these procedures as something that was done for them and not to them."
 
...snip...

And it also illustrates an interesting continuum of value judgments here. I consider removing the clitoris to certainly be removing a sex organ but somehow the skin which covers the sex organ (penis) is hard to equate with the organ itself.

Why? The clitoris is "just" part of the female genitalia like the foreskin is "just part" of the male genitalia.
 
It was after your patient rights post, you posted one in between while I was composing mine.

But your premise is unrealistic. You expect a prepubescent boy to decide something involving sexual satisfaction? And if you waited until the child could make that judgment, sexual risks would already be occurring.

And you expect someone else to decide something regarding personal, subjective satisfaction for them.

And, you have to be kidding asking a 12 year old if he wants to have a painful procedure on his penis.

That’s what education is for. So he makes a good choice with the help of his parents and other care givers. But what I find interesting is you are saying no or very few boys of 12 will make the choice to have it done but you’re ok with it being done when they have no ability to choose.

Again, it might sound good but it is unrealistic. The parents decide all sorts of other things for that child which will also affect him throughout his life. That's what has to happen here if we are to prevent unnecessary HIV infections and deaths.

Yes they do. But hopefully they don’t decide things for their children that won’t affect them for 10-20 years in advance that can’t be reversed. Have you planned who your children are going to marry? Are the contracts drawn up yet?

Everyone's griping about giving teen girls this HPV vaccine to prevent cervical cancer. But the studies looking at prevalence of the virus show it is extensive in teens! The time to give the vaccine is prior to independent decision making. Those earlier independent decisions are not always the wisest ones we make in our lives.

I’m not griping about it. In the UK it’s being planned (as far as I’m aware) to be offered to girls just before they are likely to be sexually active. I’m not talking about independent decision making, I’m talking about including the child in the decision making process at a level they are capable of and being able to explain to them why it’s a good choice to make. If a young girl was terrified and wrestling to get away would you strap her down / sedate her to impose your or her parents will? I would hope you would stop, talk to the girl and explain to her why it’s important for her to have the vaccination.

Also vaccination affects you on a scale that you cannot perceive (immune system) or has perceptible effects that are temporary (e.g. a mild fever for a day or two). Take for example the BCG vaccination:

(BCG Jab, Injection, Inoculation)
BCG vaccination, (also called a jab, injection or immunisation) has been shown to give 70%-80% protection against TB (Tuberculosis). The vaccine is given in a single dose following a ‘negative’ mantoux test.
The vaccine contains a weak form of the disease.
Local policy differs regarding the vaccination of babies. Some babies considered “at risk” will be given the vaccine at birth. This includes those born into families with members from high-risk countries, those babies who will be traveling to high-risk countries and those babies living in households were persons of a high risk are also living. Advice should be taken from a health professional.

Sounds like a sensible policy to me. Given your argument about 12-year olds not choosing to be circumcised, why would millions of 10 year olds (the age I think I was when I had mine) in the UK choose to have a painful injection (I remember seeing at least one kid pass out after having his while I was queuing up outside the room at school where they were being performed) that gives them an itchy scab for a few weeks and forms a scar on your arm for the rest of your life?

As for making mistakes your signature says it all, doesn’t it?

I think the problem we’re having agreeing here is that we have different reference points for what we think is the morally optimal solution to this problem. You and Linda are coming from a ‘The benefit to the many outweighs the cost (i.e. no choice) to the individual’ point of view and I’m seeing it as ‘The right of the individual to be included in a choice outweighs the gains to the many by him not being included.’

I think it’s a really fine line that divides us.
 
Last edited:
Yes and the head is just "part" of the human body. So I take it you'd as easily cut the head of a baby as it's foreskin? That argument is silly.

The clitoris and foreskin are not comparible.
 
What you really don't know?

One is just skin. The other is the major nerve centre and the main source of sexual pleasure.

I really can't believe you are arguing this point.
 
What you really don't know?

One is just skin.

The foreskin is full of nerves, it protects the sensitive skin of the tip of the penis, it is not "just skin".

The other is the major nerve centre and the main source of sexual pleasure.

I really can't believe you are arguing this point.

I am trying to help people understand our views on male circumcision is primarily a cultural issue and that is why we don't see it the same as we do female circumcision.

The supporters of female circumcision use the exact same arguments for female circumcision as the supporters for male circumcision do for male circumcision - yet one is considered OK the other is not. And by exactly the same I mean hygiene, appearance, preference of partners and so on.

Can I ask what type (using the WHO categories) of female circumcision you are against?
 
The foreskin is full of nerves, it protects the sensitive skin of the tip of the penis, it is not "just skin".
Yes it is just skin. All skin has nerves in it. I have a foreskin. I have a wife with a clitoris. I'd rather have my foreskin cut off than her clitoris. One wouldn't completely take away the ability to enjoy sex ruin our sex life, the other would. The two are not the same thing. They are functionally different. And you seizing on the words "just skin" doesn't change that. The nearest equivalent would be the hood of the clitoris. Cutting off the clitoris is more like cutting off the glans.

I am trying to help people understand our views on male circumcision is primarily a cultural issue and that is why we don't see it the same as we do female circumcision.
There may be cultural reasons but there are also obvious anatomical ones too. The anatomical reasons are extremely important and to pretend they don't exist does your position nor you any justice IMO.

The supporters of female circumcision use the exact same arguments for female circumcision as the supporters for male circumcision do for male circumcision - yet one is considered OK the other is not. And by exactly the same I mean hygiene, appearance, preference of partners and so on.
I don't know what reasons "the supporters" of female circumcision use. I would rather imagine they have varied reasons depending on who they are. Again there are obvious and very important anatomical reasons that make the procedure of removal of the clitoris completely unacceptable.

Can I ask what type (using the WHO categories) of female circumcision you are against?

I don't even know what they are. I wasn't commenting on female circumcision in it's various forms. I'm arguing that your statement "The clitoris is "just" part of the female genitalia like the foreskin is "just part" of the male genitalia" is invalid.

FWIW my position on circumcision is that I wouldn't have it done to my little boy or my little girl without a very strong medical reason that vastly overcame the risks or effects of the procedure. If the female circumcision involved removing just skin - labia, clitoral hood etc then I'd be more likely to accept a lesser medical reason than if it involved removing or mutilating the clitoris, which would need pretty much an immediate life-or-death reason. Ie I'd take it on a case by case basis on risk management basis. I don't agree with purely cultural circumcision but I'm not exactly appalled by foreskin removal of Jewish boys etc on the basis that I know plenty of circumsized people who don't suffer and are generally pleased with their anatomy and sex lives.
 
FWIW my position on circumcision is that I wouldn't have it done to my little boy or my little girl without a very strong medical reason that vastly overcame the risks or effects of the procedure. If the female circumcision involved removing just skin - labia, clitoral hood etc then I'd be more likely to accept a lesser medical reason than if it involved removing or mutilating the clitoris, which would need pretty much an immediate life-or-death reason. Ie I'd take it on a case by case basis on risk management basis. I don't agree with purely cultural circumcision but I'm not exactly appalled by foreskin removal of Jewish boys etc on the basis that I know plenty of circumsized people who don't suffer and are generally pleased with their anatomy and sex lives.

I know people who were beaten by their parents and have come out with the line "It didn't do me any harm."
 
Complete and utter ********!

Wow talk about putting words into someone's mouth.

You COMPLETELY misquoted and misrepresented what I actually wrote me making that comment even more pointless.

If you need me to explain why let me know.
 
Last edited:
I know people who were beaten by their parents and have come out with the line "It didn't do me any harm."

I can't really comment on this seeing as it is unclear as to what point you making in response to what it is you think I said. It's too vague to address.

As it happens I don't have a huge problem with limited physical punishment personally. I've not had cause to use it on my own children and don't think I ever will but I wouldn't rule it out completely.
 
I can't really comment on this seeing as it is unclear as to what point you making in response to what it is you think I said. It's too vague to address.

As it happens I don't have a huge problem with limited physical punishment personally. I've not had cause to use it on my own children and don't think I ever will but I wouldn't rule it out completely.

My point is what people say and believe is often based on their experiences. Read this:

http://www.nlm.nih.gov/medlineplus/ency/article/007225.htm

...Child neglect and psychological abuse appear to co-exist with child physical abuse about 50% to 75% of the time. The risk factors for both are essentially the same and may include poverty, other stresses in the family, mental illness, or substance abuse by parents or caregivers. Abused children are at risk of becoming abusers themselves as adults.

We learn both good and bad ways to deal with the problems life presents from our parents and usually with a minimum of thought believe they're the "right thing to do". If we knew another way to cope we may not think or behave in the way we do.
 
My point is what people say and believe is often based on their experiences. Read this:

http://www.nlm.nih.gov/medlineplus/ency/article/007225.htm

We learn both good and bad ways to deal with the problems life presents from our parents and usually with a minimum of thought believe they're the "right thing to do". If we knew another way to cope we may not think or behave in the way we do.

Are you addressing my point that I know people who are circumcised and seem happy with it?

Re: hitting children. This is getting off the point and I think it's value as a parallel is very limited anyway. However, I think there is a large difference between abuse and limited use of physical punishment.

You appear to misunderstand what I thought I'd written anyway - at least from your "complete ********" post. I never said there were compelling reasons for male circumcision without just medical cause. I said there are reasons why people view male circumcision and female circumcision differently - if the female version involves removing the clitoris.
 
Yes it is just skin. All skin has nerves in it. I have a foreskin. I have a wife with a clitoris. I'd rather have my foreskin cut off than her clitoris. One wouldn't completely take away the ability to enjoy sex ruin our sex life, the other would. The two are not the same thing. They are functionally different. And you seizing on the words "just skin" doesn't change that. The nearest equivalent would be the hood of the clitoris. Cutting off the clitoris is more like cutting off the glans.

The foreskin is much more then just skin - it is for a start it is in fact more like lips - skin on the outside and mucous membranes on the inside see this brief article you may be surprised to learn it is indeed much more then just skin.

There may be cultural reasons but there are also obvious anatomical ones too. The anatomical reasons are extremely important and to pretend they don't exist does your position nor you any justice IMO

I don't understand your point.

I don't know what reasons "the supporters" of female circumcision use. I would rather imagine they have varied reasons depending on who they are. Again there are obvious and very important anatomical reasons that make the procedure of removal of the clitoris completely unacceptable.

I did include the major arguments they tend to share in common: And by exactly the same I mean hygiene, appearance, preference of partners and so on.


I don't even know what they are. I wasn't commenting on female circumcision in it's various forms. I'm arguing that your statement "The clitoris is "just" part of the female genitalia like the foreskin is "just part" of the male genitalia" is invalid. ...snip...

My comment was in relationship to skepticgirl's comment of "I consider removing the clitoris to certainly be removing a sex organ but somehow the skin which covers the sex organ (penis) is hard to equate with the organ itself."

I was trying to illustrate that the foreskin is just as much part of the male sex organ as the clitoris is of the female organ. Anatomically and physiologically they are both integral structures to the male and female sex organs respectively. Indeed removal of either does not affect major function of both sets of sex organs i.e. urination and sexual reproduction. (Note only talking about type 1 female "circumcision".)

Unfortunately because we tend to view our own traditions quite differently to other cultures' traditions many people just do not accept that we also have a culturally approved tradition of genital mutilation, many people indeed even hunt for excuses why "our" tradition is OK and "rational" but "theirs" isn't. So "we" all tend to agree that female circumcision is bad, but male well obviously that is different.... (Yet we do not in the USA or the UK culturally accept that even Type 1 female circumcision limited to removal of just what could be described as "female foreskin" is OK even when done for "traditional reasons".)

I'm afraid I've drifted away from the OP topic so to try and not continue my derail let me say why this is relevant to the interesting research in the OP.

If we found that "female circumcision" has a similar reduction in the chance of contracting HIV would that be supported by the WHO? Or is that different?
 
Are you addressing my point that I know people who are circumcised and seem happy with it?

Yes I am. In the case of infant circumcision what other experience could a man know about other than having no foreskin? They get pleasure from their sex organs and have the idea that circumcision is cleaner, looks better, etc. re-enforced by their parents who did it to them and likely a lot of their friends too. Being circumcised becomes part of their self-concept. Far and above all else, the most important thing we all do with regards to our self-concept is search for ways to enhance our view of ourselves. We need to feel good about who we are. When circumcised men have children they use the same marginal benefits to justify doing it to them. So the cycle continues.

For the women who prefer their sexual partner to have a circumcised penis I would suggest sampling a wider variety before making up their minds. I am confident that positive re-enforcement would dilute their preference very quickly if they found a skilled enough un-circumcised man to pleasure them. I’m free a week on Friday:)

I have read (a theory?) that during intercourse the foreskin acts somewhat like a roller bearing and keeps the woman’s vagina better lubricated than a circumcised penis, which tends to drag the lubrication out of the vagina, leading to chafing. Just think of the savings in lube over a lifetime!

Re: hitting children. This is getting off the point and I think it's value as a parallel is very limited anyway. However, I think there is a large difference between abuse and limited use of physical punishment.

The parallel was to the cyclical behaviour people tend to act out in infant circumcision which is extremely valid. As for physical punishment I would say it’s a matter of degree. I accept that there are times when responsible control of a child may make physical means the most appropriate.

You appear to misunderstand what I thought I'd written anyway - at least from your "complete ********" post. I never said there were compelling reasons for male circumcision without just medical cause. I said there are reasons why people view male circumcision and female circumcision differently - if the female version involves removing the clitoris.

There is rarely a just medical cause. As for your examples of male vs. female circumcision I agree with you. The two forms of mutilation are different. Removing the head of the clitoris would be the equivalent of cutting off the glans of a man’s penis. Ouch.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom