Dr de Cock says circumcision reduces HIV risk

Get a grip Al. We are trying to tell you these questions have been thoroughly answered if you would just read the research for the answers instead of imagining they haven't been looked at.

Yes, circ alone makes it harder to get HIV. It doesn't make it impossible to get.

Of course there are other methods to prevent HIV. But they aren't enough.

Condoms and education go a very long way in this fight. Unfortunately the church lady and her kind think condoms are the tool of Satan and made sure the money we send to the fight go heavily toward abstinence education which fails to do anything.

But there is other money and condoms + education is successful, to a point. In the 30 years since the pandemic first emerged along the prostitution/trucking route in Uganda that was responsible for the local occurrences becoming world occurrences, however, condoms and education are not enough.

How can you say with a straight face that condoms, education and drugs are not enough when only 1 in 5 has access to them?

I shall tell you why male circumcision is being considered for Africa and not the developed world: Because it’s cheap and pretty effective. And the reason infant circumcision is being considered is that it’s cheaper still. A true capitalist solution. I love America.

Will you be upgrading your body if cybernetic implants come out? Even more to the point will you be adding to or taking bits off your children’s bodies if you are given the chance? After all, you’re an “expert”, so you know what’s best.
 
To more fully answer Darth Rotor,

I believe a life is made up of a series of acts. A running average is kept and when you die history decides if you were more good than bad.

While you’re alive I use a complicated (and imperfect) algorithm to estimate where I think your mean is, based on reported (maybe biased or false) and observed acts, relative to mine and the groups I most identify with. If I’m around you enough I’ll even do a second order prediction to estimate which way your mean is heading, relative to my own.

The only way I know which way is better and which way is worse is I believe there are, or as good as are, moral absolutes, which I and everyone else rarely achieve but (hopefully, when I’m feeling optimistic) try to get close to the best they can. I admit I don’t have any good evidence for the existence of these absolutes at all! It’s my woo.

Thus I see being good or bad as a relative optimization problem with some targets to aim for.
 
How can you say with a straight face that condoms, education and drugs are not enough when only 1 in 5 has access to them?

I shall tell you why male circumcision is being considered for Africa and not the developed world: Because it’s cheap and pretty effective. And the reason infant circumcision is being considered is that it’s cheaper still. A true capitalist solution. I love America.
In answer to your question, Ivor, how can I say condoms, education and drugs are not enough when only 1 in 5 has access to them, well access is a funny thing. It would be nice if you could just put those condoms with instructions on a boat and ship 'em where needed. But it isn't that simple.

Just look at the countries where access to these things are actually not too difficult to gage if the problem would be solved if only they had access:

The 25 states that track HIV cases are reporting an increase in new diagnoses, a striking change from the 1990s when the number of new infections remained stable at about 40,000 a year.

The HIV infection rate has doubled among blacks in the United States over a decade

A story in the Toronto Star reports that rates of new HIV infections in Candian young women have soared since 1996.

Then you can look at the real vs the ideal world beyond Western countries:

Global HIV rates at record high
Around 14,000 people are infected with HIV every day
A record number of people were infected with HIV around the world this year, a report says.

Figures from UNAids and the World Health Organization put the number of new infections at five million.

The report also estimates that three million people died from the disease this year.

But it warns that the figures could rise sharply in the years ahead, with Eastern Europe and Central Asia on the verge of epidemics.

Africa hit hardest

The report, which is published ahead of World Aids Day on 1 December, estimates 40 million people around the world are infected with HIV/Aids. Of these, 2.5 million are children.

Russia's Aids timebomb
Around 14,000 people are infected with the disease every day.

Officials say the figures are more reliable than previous year's estimates, following improvements in the way the data is collected.

People living in sub-Saharan Africa continue to be most at risk. About 26.6m people are living with HIV/Aids are in this part of the world.

South Africa, alone, is home to 5.3 million people with HIV - more than any other country in the world. In Botswana, 39% of the population is HIV positive, the report says.

As to your assumptions about why circumcision is now going to be recommended, just who do you mean by "the US"? I'm curious who you think it is that has this power. Perhaps you envision some committee designated to come up with the cheapest way to treat HIV-AIDS in Africa. When you figure it out, let me know. I'd love to lobby them about the misguided ideas of the morality police.

The US donates like everyone else to the Global AIDS fund. Other countries and NGOs have done what they could to minimize the impact of the US AIDS fund donations since we have attached so many rules to the money. Particularly bad are the gag rules. If you take the money they want to see a ban on any discussion of anything to do with abortion. Because of that a couple of countries have even turned down US aid. It was earmarked for programs they felt were ineffective anyway.

So if you want to blame the US, you need to place the blame where it belongs, with the right wing Evangelicals who interfere with HIV-AIDS prevention programs to meet their own needs first.

I suggest you travel more if you get the chance. You might be surprised to know the US is not in control of the rest of the world in quite the way it seems you have pictured. It isn't up to the US to tell the countries on the African Continent how they should lower their HIV-AIDS risk. And for the moment, that's a good thing since we have those pesky church people in our government telling everyone sex is a sin and they should abstain or just suffer God's wrath.

You are correct in that money is an issue and we have enough of it we really should share more. The US pressures governments not to produce low cost anti-retrovirals that aren't off patents. That's another one of those dilemmas. If you wipe out drug company profits, you will have to find other ways to fund research. My assessment of the situation is the profits are currently obscene and the companies could stand to give up some in order to help so many desperate people.

So put pressure on the drug companies. They actually respond if they get enough pressure. When they smell the regulators coming or the frustrated third world governments threaten to make the drugs themselves, the drug companies start donating free drugs to poor countries. Write letters, send emails, make phone calls wherever you think some action might be useful. Don't just gripe about it. (Maybe you are an activist?) You can even donate time and money.

Keep something else in mind. If we spent a fraction of the money that's needed for HIV-AIDS just providing potable drinking water and basic vaccines to the third world, we be saving many more people than HIV will kill. Not that I suggest we only fund one of those, but if you think this whole circumcision thing is just about a cheaper treatment, you are quite misguided.


Will you be upgrading your body if cybernetic implants come out? Even more to the point will you be adding to or taking bits off your children’s bodies if you are given the chance? After all, you’re an “expert”, so you know what’s best.
Hey, when those replaceable parts are ready to go, I'll be the first in line. I have no qualms taking advantage of the incredible medical discoveries we should be seeing in the next few decades.
 
You know I was referring to the behavior studies, right?
I could probably have been more clear about that.

I spent all afternoon looking for meatal stenosis figures, as well.
So are you agreeing that it's 10%, or saying that there's not a lot of data out there?

Did they control for prematurity?
I know I've run across several older "being intact makes babies die of bacterial infections" type studies before, and the intact kids were intact because they were born prematurely. Which obviously skews the findings.

That is breathtakingly tacky, skeptigirl.
But if you think it's cute then whatever.
You were clear enough. I was talking about behavior. Behavior was evaluated in the studies. That was a big part of the research. There are some conclusions one can say the evidence supported.

Re the incidence of stenosis. The sample size was small and the group self selected so no, I don't think that was enough to draw conclusion one way or the other. The study I sited that you ask about the premies has a very good synopsis of the literature. I recommend you read it since you are interested. That study didn't look at outpatient problems. They state they were more interested in serious complications of circumcision. They did not discuss in detail how they controlled for other variables so I sent in this letter:

<P> Dear Researchers,

<P> Since premature birth as well as other pathology in the antenatal
period is a reason to delay circumcision, I would like to know if you
considered prematurity as a confounding factor. And by the same token, was
any analysis done looking at reasons for not circumcising the infant as
the variable rather than the circumcision as the variable?

<P> I realize this is a bit late. Hopefully one or more authors are still
around for a response.

<P> Thank you
Sincerely,

The article is probably too old to get a reply from the authors but who knows? On the other hand, there were several other studies looking at older boys and UTIs remains a problem well past the time period prematurity would affect outcome. And there is that cancer thing.

I suppose you and Ivor and Al will not approve but I came away with the impression I should be recommending circumcision. The benefits were more than I had realized. The meatal stenosis was a very minor problem. And there are measures post op specifically to prevent the irritation which causes the stenosis. The anesthetic is probably riskier than the procedure. I recommend it still be used though.

I really found nothing referring to any loss of sensation. Considering the number of men in the medical field, and the fuss which always comes up in these forums, I was surprised. I think it indicates the loss of sexual pleasure is either more rare or much less pronounced than it would appear from the level of outrage over circumcision.
 
Last edited:
In answer to your question, Ivor, how can I say condoms, education and drugs are not enough when only 1 in 5 has access to them, well access is a funny thing. It would be nice if you could just put those condoms with instructions on a boat and ship 'em where needed. But it isn't that simple.

Just look at the countries where access to these things are actually not too difficult to gage if the problem would be solved if only they had access:

The 25 states that track HIV cases are reporting an increase in new diagnoses, a striking change from the 1990s when the number of new infections remained stable at about 40,000 a year.

The HIV infection rate has doubled among blacks in the United States over a decade

A story in the Toronto Star reports that rates of new HIV infections in Candian young women have soared since 1996.

Then you can look at the real vs the ideal world beyond Western countries:

Global HIV rates at record high

I can’t speak for the US as I don’t know what public health messages have been conveyed over there, but I know in the UK that successive governments have really taken their eye off the ball for many years now w.r.t. sexual health and STDs, after the shock tactics for AIDS were used. (A black tombstone with a John Hurt narration telling you it’s a death sentence if you get it so use a condom.) The general public now believe that STDs are curable and even AIDS is not the death sentence it was in the 1980’s. We have at least one HIV-positive gay politician.

So I would say the reason HIV and STDs in general are on the increase (in the UK at least) is because the public are not being given information in an accessible or effective way. Does Linda’s accurate and valid point about the way we discount the future make it ok to ramp up the impact of the message now, even if it compromises the balance? I don’t know, but I don’t mind so much if it is aimed at the individual who is going to be affected by it and has to choose what to do. I’m a ‘just the facts’ person myself.

As to your assumptions about why circumcision is now going to be recommended, just who do you mean by "the US"? I'm curious who you think it is that has this power. Perhaps you envision some committee designated to come up with the cheapest way to treat HIV-AIDS in Africa. When you figure it out, let me know. I'd love to lobby them about the misguided ideas of the morality police.

The US donates like everyone else to the Global AIDS fund. Other countries and NGOs have done what they could to minimize the impact of the US AIDS fund donations since we have attached so many rules to the money. Particularly bad are the gag rules. If you take the money they want to see a ban on any discussion of anything to do with abortion. Because of that a couple of countries have even turned down US aid. It was earmarked for programs they felt were ineffective anyway.

So if you want to blame the US, you need to place the blame where it belongs, with the right wing Evangelicals who interfere with HIV-AIDS prevention programs to meet their own needs first.

Ok, I apologize if I have offended every American reading my comment. It was more of a critique on the pervasiveness of American culture around the globe, both good and bad. Being the only superpower at the moment, it is not surprising American cultural values are being adopted by others around the world. Having been on this forum for a few months I find myself using Americanisms such as ‘I guess’:)

However are you trying to argue the US doesn’t have a disproportionate influence on global policy, the ultimate example being the invasion of Iraq? As is very often the case, he who pays the piper calls the tune. It’s also ironic that the US argues for free trade only when its own markets are not under threat.

I suggest you travel more if you get the chance. You might be surprised to know the US is not in control of the rest of the world in quite the way it seems you have pictured. It isn't up to the US to tell the countries on the African Continent how they should lower their HIV-AIDS risk. And for the moment, that's a good thing since we have those pesky church people in our government telling everyone sex is a sin and they should abstain or just suffer God's wrath.

I’ve just been convinced by the evidence for global warming and am already feeling guilty for planning three flights this year (two to Europe and one to the USA. I’ll be giving lectures on ethics in Las Vegas, do you think I’ll have much success?:)), so I’m trying to travel less. Perhaps I could go by boat/train instead?

I don’t think the US has “control” of the rest of the world at all. USA cultural values have spread far and wide and it has the military and financial power to influence many areas of the world, if it decides action is in its best interest. How else could 5% of the earth’s population get away with using 25% of its resources?

I think I would stand a good chance of being stoned to death if I expressed my opinions on sexuality in parts of the USA.

You are correct in that money is an issue and we have enough of it we really should share more. The US pressures governments not to produce low cost anti-retrovirals that aren't off patents. That's another one of those dilemmas. If you wipe out drug company profits, you will have to find other ways to fund research. My assessment of the situation is the profits are currently obscene and the companies could stand to give up some in order to help so many desperate people.

Strange isn’t it, that though money has only been found to be a short term motivator why we think nobody would bother to do anything amazing unless they were being paid vast sums of money to do it?

Personally, while I now have more money than I know what to do with, I was most interested in electronics (my job) when I was not being paid for it at all. If my boss is reading this, that does not mean I’ll work harder if you pay me less!

So put pressure on the drug companies. They actually respond if they get enough pressure. When they smell the regulators coming or the frustrated third world governments threaten to make the drugs themselves, the drug companies start donating free drugs to poor countries. Write letters, send emails, make phone calls wherever you think some action might be useful. Don't just gripe about it. (Maybe you are an activist?) You can even donate time and money.

I do donate money to charity and help mothers with prams up stairs. I’m still trying to think of ways that capitalism could be improved. I’ll let you know.

Being an activist will get in the way of my other goal of becoming supreme leader of the world. Have I got your vote?

Keep something else in mind. If we spent a fraction of the money that's needed for HIV-AIDS just providing potable drinking water and basic vaccines to the third world, we be saving many more people than HIV will kill. Not that I suggest we only fund one of those, but if you think this whole circumcision thing is just about a cheaper treatment, you are quite misguided.

So we’re not even spending enough on the basics. I still don’t see how the people focused on HIV and AIDS in Africa would not be greatly influenced by a cheap and reasonably effective solution for that particular problem. I.e. it’s another optimization problem. Given the limited funds we have how many people can we protect/save from HIV/AIDS per dollar spent?

Hey, when those replaceable parts are ready to go, I'll be the first in line. I have no qualms taking advantage of the incredible medical discoveries we should be seeing in the next few decades.

I suggest you get in contact with Prof. Kevin Warwick. I was not thinking so much about replacement limbs for amputees, livers or kidneys, more the redundant but fashionable procedures that will be available along with those useful life saving advances.
 
I'm having a horrible time of finding raw data either way. I must not be using the right keywords or something. I did stumble across the Van Howe 2006 study mentioned in the emedicine article, and that's the best study I've been able to locate thus far.
Have you looked at that one? Is there a structural flaw I'm not seeing in the abstract? Do you want me to find a link on it?

That is the one of the ones I was referring to. "Boys attending a pediatric clinic" is not the same population as "boys in the US". We've been burned on that kind of thinking many times (that the prevalence of something within a sample from a particular clinic can be generalized to the general population). Since the sample wasn't random, we can't even generalize from the sample to the clinic, let alone to any broader population. You simply cannot tell, from any of the studies referenced in that e-medicine article what the rate of stenosis is among boys who have been circumcized (in particular, as neonates).

Where is the conflicting evidence that says that complication rate in newborns is lower?

It has to look strictly at neonatal circumcision, though, since the complication doesn't happen when circumcision takes place after the foreskin separates from the glans.

I think you are referring to the CDC fact sheet? I would follow the references given as the source of the information to see where the information comes from.

Linda
 
<snip>
I suppose you and Ivor and Al will not approve but I came away with the impression I should be recommending circumcision. The benefits were more than I had realized. The meatal stenosis was a very minor problem. And there are measures post op specifically to prevent the irritation which causes the stenosis. The anesthetic is probably riskier than the procedure. I recommend it still be used though.

I really found nothing referring to any loss of sensation. Considering the number of men in the medical field, and the fuss which always comes up in these forums, I was surprised. I think it indicates the loss of sexual pleasure is either more rare or much less pronounced than it would appear from the level of outrage over circumcision.

So you would also recommend mastectomies for women with increased risk of breast cancer? If it could be performed just after the girl was born would you recommend it was done then or would you wait until the girl was old enough to decide for herself?

One of the reasons few people make a fuss about male circumcision is that the affected organ is not on display to the rest of the world. Out of sight, out of mind.

Once you go down the road of taking preventative action for ever decreasing risk factors then I think you’re on a slippery slope.

With the number of things that can go wrong with a penis with foreskin it’s amazing that cultures that circumcise don’t dominate the world’s population.

As for sensation I suggest you elect to have your vagina scared and see if you notice any difference.
 
So you would also recommend mastectomies for women with increased risk of breast cancer? If they could be performed just after the girl was born would you recommend it was done then or would you wait until the girl was old enough to decide for herself?

...snip...

If you did the operation on a female baby or young child it would not need to be a mastectomy - just a rather minor procedure to remove the "breast buds" and the child will never develop breasts - if done in a very young baby probably only need a local anaesthetic.

And given the statistics that would prevent what about 40,000 deaths a year (?) in the USA alone. (And goodness knows how much pain and suffering to hundreds of thousands of women that don't die but most endure the associated treatments.)
 
Last edited:
If you did the operation on a female baby or young child it would not need to be a mastectomy - just a rather minor procedure to remove the "breast buds" and the child will never develop breasts - if done in a very young baby probably only need a local anaesthetic.

And given the statistics that would prevent what about 40,000 deaths a year (?) in the USA alone. (And goodness knows how much pain and suffering to hundreds of thousands of women that don't die but most endure the associated treatments.)

And can you be drawn to answer the second part?

me said:
If they could be performed just after the girl was born would you recommend it was done then or would you wait until the girl was old enough to decide for herself?
 
Three researchers, a Frenchman, an American and a Canadian are at a conference and are discussing why a man’s penis is shaped the way it is.

The Frenchman says “It is clear. We spent $100,000 on a 6 month study and have determined it is shaped to give the woman more pleasure.”

The American replies “Rubbish. We spent $1,000,000 on a 2 year research program and are certain it is shaped the way it is to give the man more pleasure.”

The Canadian researcher, shaking his head from side to side replies “Actually you’re both wrong. We spent $5 on a 15min. trial and have determined it’s to stop your hand flying off and hitting you on the forehead.”
 
That could change in the near future:) And you know, it isn't just Americans that help other countries. There's this place called Europe...

But claiming that abstinence only funding and promotions are minimal is untrue. It is being funded and promoted in an active a serious manor.
 
But claiming that abstinence only funding and promotions are minimal is untrue. It is being funded and promoted in an active a serious manor.

Did I claim they were minimal? I don’t remember doing that. Could you post a link to the post that I made that claim.

Anyhow, don’t get me started on the Catholic Church. Let’s just say I agree 100% that it’s part of the problem.

I have a friend who is catholic who has commented to me how amazing it was the number of families he knew at his church when he was younger with only two children. He is married to a non catholic himself and has two kids. As far as I know they are not planning on any more.

So it would appear Catholic Church goers (even regular ones) do ignore some of the dogma some of the time.

What’s the Catholic Churches view on circumcision? I mean those nasty Jews did kill Jesus after all.

wikipedia said:
Simon Peter, who for Catholic Christians is the first Pope, condemned circumcision for converts according to Acts 15:7-10. Paul, the Apostle to the Gentiles, warned that the advocates of circumcision were "false brothers". (Gal. 2:4) When the various passages from the New Testament regarding circumcision are gathered together, a strongly negative view of circumcision emerges.

So some in the church might not like it either unless the current Pope makes up some new rules.
 
Last edited:
YOu would also be preventing all the health benefits of nursing as well.

Not a direct benefit to the child.

Also define mutilation?

Encarta: destroy body part: to inflict serious injury on the body or a part of the body of a person or animal by removing or destroying parts of it
Microsoft® Encarta® 2006. © 1993-2005 Microsoft Corporation. All rights reserved.
 
I shall tell you why male circumcision is being considered for Africa and not the developed world: Because it’s cheap and pretty effective. And the reason infant circumcision is being considered is that it’s cheaper still. A true capitalist solution. I love America.

Yes, that and the pesky little fact that it seems pretty effective.

And "not the developed world"? My penis would care to disagree. I was circumcised as a baby, not for religious reasons, and certainly not for economic reasons. Partly, it was because of aesthetics (like it or not, uncut guys, the vast majority of north american ladies prefer a circumcised 'lil guy to an uncircumcised one), and partly it was because circumcision is simply the safer and more sanitary route.

I'll never cease to find it amazing that an infant girl can have her ears pierced, an aesthetic choice that can affect her for the rest of her life, and nobody will bat an eye, but you even mention that a child was circumcised, and otherwise reasonable people suddenly turn into raving lunatics accusing you of child abuse.

Will you be upgrading your body if cybernetic implants come out? Even more to the point will you be adding to or taking bits off your children’s bodies if you are given the chance? After all, you’re an “expert”, so you know what’s best.

What a stunningly dishonest comparison. Do you have children? Because, and this may just be personal preference, if I had a child who lost a leg, I'd certainly opt to add a cybernetic or prosthetic leg implant. If I had a child with vision so terrible that he or she couldn't see in front of her face, I'd certainly care enough to give her glasses, cybernetic eyes, or laser surgery - whatever the safest, most viable option was to care for my child.

The idea that you shouldn't "add to or [take] bits off your children's bodies" is an idea which, it seems to me, can only be supported if you believe in the typical 'natural medicine' woo - that is, if you believe that nature builds us exactly as we should be and there are no modifications that we can make that can make us better, stronger, healthier, etc.

At this point, our current medical knowledge indicates that the wisest decision for a child's future well-being is circumcision. It's not a guarantee that the child will never get HIV, or any number of other infections, but it is certainly a good start. In this case, it's *failure* to circumcise that is the true child abuse.

So, for all the anti-circumcision crowd in the audience, let me pose a question: do you also oppose vaccination of children? It serves a very similar purpose in terms of disease prevention, and poses worse risk for potential side effects.
 
That is the one of the ones I was referring to. "Boys attending a pediatric clinic" is not the same population as "boys in the US". We've been burned on that kind of thinking many times (that the prevalence of something within a sample from a particular clinic can be generalized to the general population). Since the sample wasn't random, we can't even generalize from the sample to the clinic, let alone to any broader population. You simply cannot tell, from any of the studies referenced in that e-medicine article what the rate of stenosis is among boys who have been circumcized (in particular, as neonates).

Can you tell from the CDC's reference?
I'm assuming you have access to it.
Can you quote the relevant part?
It appears to be a study compiling other studies into some sort of review and not a piece of original research. That's why I was surprised there weren't conflicting studies out there that I could find.
 
...snip..

At this point, our current medical knowledge indicates that the wisest decision for a child's future well-being is circumcision. It's not a guarantee that the child will never get HIV, or any number of other infections, but it is certainly a good start. In this case, it's *failure* to circumcise that is the true child abuse.

So given the statistics you would support a parents decision to have the breast buds of their female (and I suppose male) children removed shortly after birth?

So, for all the anti-circumcision crowd in the audience, let me pose a question: do you also oppose vaccination of children? It serves a very similar purpose in terms of disease prevention, and poses worse risk for potential side effects.

Before I answer can you provide the evidence to support the claim your question is based on?
 
Not a direct benefit to the child.

But destroying a pontential desired activity.

Encarta: destroy body part: to inflict serious injury on the body or a part of the body of a person or animal by removing or destroying parts of it
Microsoft® Encarta® 2006. © 1993-2005 Microsoft Corporation. All rights reserved.

Ah so haircuts are also a mutilation. Or you just moved the needed definition to define serious injury.
 
So given the statistics you would support a parents decision to have the breast buds of their female (and I suppose male) children removed shortly after birth?

No more so than I would suggest removing the heart of somebody who is at high risk for heart disease.

In the case of circumcision, you have a simple procedure that takes literally seconds to do which can significantly decrease the chances of the child's risk for a terrible disease. Removal of the breast buds (or heart, as in my example) would be a more complex, involved procedure which wouldn't necessarily do the same.

Before I answer can you provide the evidence to support the claim your question is based on?

Which claim?

That vaccinations have side effects:

http://www.quackwatch.com/03HealthPromotion/immu/immu04.html

That side effects from circumcision are generally rare and minor:

http://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2000/01/000111074855.htm

Note that the circumcision article displays a distinct anti-circumcision bias, but still shows that the side effects from circumcision are not only rare, they generally only require a small amount of treatment.

Still, if you'd accept risks for vaccinations, why not accept them for circumcisions?

I realize that many men are very self-conscious about their "little friends", and that as a group we're paranoid about hurting them. However, a little bit of critical thinking goes a long way, and someone who is honestly willing to objectively look at the situation will understand that there's no good reason to *not* get circumcised, given the potential risks versus the potential benefits.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom