Dr de Cock says circumcision reduces HIV risk

But destroying a pontential desired activity.

As I said no direct benefit to the child.

Ah so haircuts are also a mutilation. Or you just moved the needed definition to define serious injury.

Not really - I suggest you use www.dictionary.com - I am not using words with any special meaning beyond their common usage so that resource should be able to help you understand the definitions of the words I'm using.
 
Can you tell from the CDC's reference?
I'm assuming you have access to it.
Can you quote the relevant part?
It appears to be a study compiling other studies into some sort of review and not a piece of original research. That's why I was surprised there weren't conflicting studies out there that I could find.

I don't have access at the moment.

Skeptigirl provided some references as well. I don't know if you can access the original articles online, or whether it requires a trip to the library.

Linda
 
This thread's become to bloated for me to trawl through it all. However I will say to those of you who are arguing the relative merits of this or that intervention in Africa to reduce the burden of AIDS - it has been looked at before using the concept of disability adjusted life years (DALYs).

Unfortunately none of the studies have looked at where the role of circumcision would sit, but I am sure they are working on it. They also need to factor in the falling cost of antiretrovirals (but these provide the worst value for money by some distance).

The best bang for your buck (pun intended) in HIV prevention in Africa consists of interventions focused on female sex workers, treatment of other sexually transmitted infections, and mass media campaigns.
http://www.bmj.com/cgi/content/full/331/7530/1431
 
So given the statistics you would support a parents decision to have the breast buds of their female (and I suppose male) children removed shortly after birth?

A risk-benefit or cost-benefit analysis would likely have a very different outcome. The loss is much more significant than the loss of the foreskin (for example children will not be able to be breast fed), the benefit is delayed by decades, and the loss of function is more immediate. These analyses are usually weighted by the number of years you receive the benefit and the number of years you bear the cost, meaning that the cost will be dispropotionately represented. On the other side of the equation, since this is not a procedure in common use, we really do not have data on the harm.

And we should recognize that there is already significant individual variation in whether high risk adult women are willing to have a prophylactic mastectomy, which would erode our confidence that we (parents) could reliably speak for our child.

There is no one-size-fits-all way to decide on prophylactic interventions in children, as it very much depends upon the details.

Linda
 
As I said no direct benefit to the child.



Not really - I suggest you use www.dictionary.com - I am not using words with any special meaning beyond their common usage so that resource should be able to help you understand the definitions of the words I'm using.

Ah so

1. of, showing, or characterized by deep thought.
2. of grave or somber disposition, character, or manner: a serious occasion; a serious man.
3. being in earnest; sincere; not trifling: His interest was serious.
4. requiring thought, concentration, or application: serious reading; a serious task.
5. weighty or important: a serious book; Marriage is a serious matter.
6. giving cause for apprehension; critical: The plan has one serious flaw.
7. Medicine/Medical. (of a patient's condition) having unstable or otherwise abnormal vital signs and other unfavorable indicators, as loss of appetite and poor mobility: patient is acutely ill.
–noun 8. that which is of importance, grave, critical, or somber: You have to learn to separate the serious from the frivolous.

So it is still highly subjective about what is serious and how say peirced ears, vacinations and haircuts are not possibly mutilations.
 
Yes, that and the pesky little fact that it seems pretty effective.

And "not the developed world"? My penis would care to disagree. I was circumcised as a baby, not for religious reasons, and certainly not for economic reasons. Partly, it was because of aesthetics (like it or not, uncut guys, the vast majority of north american ladies prefer a circumcised 'lil guy to an uncircumcised one), and partly it was because circumcision is simply the safer and more sanitary route.

I find keeping my penis clean really difficult. I have to grab it between my fingers and vigorously rub it for several minutes at a time, sometimes more than once a day, just to get the lumps of dirt off it. It’s a chore, but I’ve got used to it.

How women cope with that huge dirty hole in-between their legs I’ll never know. It must be a fully time job just keeping it clean. Perhaps that’s why they wear perfume, to cover the stench?

I’m hearing a lot about what North American women prefer, not much about what the men prefer in women’s genitalia. Which do you prefer tight or loose, wet or dry?

I'll never cease to find it amazing that an infant girl can have her ears pierced, an aesthetic choice that can affect her for the rest of her life, and nobody will bat an eye, but you even mention that a child was circumcised, and otherwise reasonable people suddenly turn into raving lunatics accusing you of child abuse.

If a parent was to have their child’s ears pierced before the child was reasonably old enough to decide I would see no difference. A responsible parent would wait until the child is old enough to make the choice for themselves. There are clip on earrings and some women I know prefer them. Many women I know don’t wear jewellery at all. And some don’t feel the need to wear make-up either.

What a stunningly dishonest comparison. Do you have children? Because, and this may just be personal preference, if I had a child who lost a leg, I'd certainly opt to add a cybernetic or prosthetic leg implant. If I had a child with vision so terrible that he or she couldn't see in front of her face, I'd certainly care enough to give her glasses, cybernetic eyes, or laser surgery - whatever the safest, most viable option was to care for my child.

I suggest you read my posts, rather than getting all hot and bothered. You are talking about using technology to make a disabled child’s life more normal. I agree 100% with that. I would not agree to say, lengthening a child’s legs because of a whim of fashion.

The idea that you shouldn't "add to or [take] bits off your children's bodies" is an idea which, it seems to me, can only be supported if you believe in the typical 'natural medicine' woo - that is, if you believe that nature builds us exactly as we should be and there are no modifications that we can make that can make us better, stronger, healthier, etc.

Nature typically does a pretty good job. When it deviates from the norm in a disadvantageous way for the individual I see no reason not to use technology to make a persons life more normal.

At this point, our current medical knowledge indicates that the wisest decision for a child's future well-being is circumcision. It's not a guarantee that the child will never get HIV, or any number of other infections, but it is certainly a good start. In this case, it's *failure* to circumcise that is the true child abuse.

So let the child decide to have it done. You’ll have 12 or so years to brainwash your kid under my proposed scheme. You can make fun of his dirty little penis every time you bath him and tell him how ugly it is and how no woman is ever going to want to have sex with him once she’s seen it.

So, for all the anti-circumcision crowd in the audience, let me pose a question: do you also oppose vaccination of children? It serves a very similar purpose in terms of disease prevention, and poses worse risk for potential side effects.

Vaccination of children is done because the child is in immediate danger from certain illnesses. The child’s physical body is not significantly altered by a vaccination. As for timing, a vaccination should be left until just before the individual is at risk from the disease it protects against.

You had your circumcision done to you when you had no choice and have not known anything different. It is part of your self-concept and my attack on circumcision of infants is perceived by you as an attack on who you are.

How do you know that you would not have preferred having a foreskin?
 
I don't have access at the moment.

Skeptigirl provided some references as well. I don't know if you can access the original articles online, or whether it requires a trip to the library.

Linda

Both of skeptigirl's references supported the 7-10% figure. :confused:

Don't you get the impression that the CDC source is a compilation of other studies and not original research?

Where's the research that disputes the 7-10% figure for eventual meatal stenosis in circumcised boys (which tends to get diagnosed and corrected around potty training time)?

Anyone?
 
Ivor said:
If a parent was to have their child’s ears pierced before the child was reasonably old enough to decide I would see no difference. A responsible parent would wait until the child is old enough to make the choice for themselves.

No difference????

Between an amputation of a sex organ and a tiny hole in your ear that will just close and heal over time when the ring is taken out????

I'm not cool with peircing babies' ears....but geez....it's nothing like amputating a sex organ!
 
skeptigirl said:
So now I have to admit maybe I was wrong. Circs for HIV prevention benefit might be worthwhile in areas with low HIV-AIDS prevalence after all. And, they should be considered as well to prevent cancer and serious complications from urinary tract infections.

Hey skeptigirl...

Can you go find for me the rates of cancer of the vulva in uncircumcised women vs. cancer of the penis in uncircumcised men?

Or the rate of UTIs in uncircumcised girls/women?
 
No difference????

Between an amputation of a sex organ and a tiny hole in your ear that will just close and heal over time when the ring is taken out????

I'm not cool with peircing babies' ears....but geez....it's nothing like amputating a sex organ!

Physically I agree with you, morally it is identical.

If the parent is having something physically done to the child that not everyone, given a free choice might choose to have done and there is no immediate danger to the child then that act is immoral in exactly the same way as male circumcision is for infants.

You don’t have to like it, but it is how I view the issue w.r.t. a child’s human rights and the responsibilities of a parent.

Perhaps others here would like to comment on what rights they think a child has and what right a parent or care giver has to choose for them? How about you kellyb?
 
I find keeping my penis clean really difficult. I have to grab it between my fingers and vigorously rub it for several minutes at a time, sometimes more than once a day, just to get the lumps of dirt off it. It’s a chore, but I’ve got used to it.

I have no doubt that people can easily learn to clean an uncircumcised penis. I don't believe that anything I said brought that into doubt. Congratulations on your cleaning abilities, though. I'm sure that you are very proud.

How women cope with that huge dirty hole in-between their legs I’ll never know. It must be a fully time job just keeping it clean. Perhaps that’s why they wear perfume, to cover the stench?

Again, I never said that people who shower regularly with have trouble with genital cleanliness.

I’m hearing a lot about what North American women prefer, not much about what the men prefer in women’s genitalia. Which do you prefer tight or loose, wet or dry?

Actually, the more appropriate question here would be whether I (or any other North American male) would prefer engaging in intimate relations with a woman who has had a circumcision. To be entirely on target, the question, phrased appropriately, would be whether or not a woman who has had a clitoridectomy would be a preferred sexual partner.

Having never engaged in such relations with a person who has had such a procedure performed, I cannot answer the question. But I'll tell you what - if it ever happens, I'll drop you a line and let you know.


If a parent was to have their child’s ears pierced before the child was reasonably old enough to decide I would see no difference. A responsible parent would wait until the child is old enough to make the choice for themselves. There are clip on earrings and some women I know prefer them. Many women I know don’t wear jewellery at all. And some don’t feel the need to wear make-up either.

At least you are consistent here. Most people are not. If you doubt this, try an informal survey - go and talk to random groups of people, steering the conversation towards child rearing. With one group, discuss plans for circumcising an as-yet unborn male child. With another group, discuss plans to have a young female daughter's ears pierced.

Perhaps the UK will yield different results than North America with these lines of inquiry, but every time I've had discussions about these topics, I find that people tend to be mostly supportive of ear-piercing (with people against the practice in the distinct minority), and people are primarily against circumcision, usually because they are afraid that it will traumatize the infant.


I suggest you read my posts, rather than getting all hot and bothered. You are talking about using technology to make a disabled child’s life more normal. I agree 100% with that. I would not agree to say, lengthening a child’s legs because of a whim of fashion.
...
Nature typically does a pretty good job. When it deviates from the norm in a disadvantageous way for the individual I see no reason not to use technology to make a persons life more normal.

I think you're playing word games here. What do you mean by "normal"?

Do you agree that, when possible, technology and/or surgical procedures should be employed to promote healthier lives and prevention of dangerous diseases?

As far as nature typically doing a good job...funny story, that. Let's listen to a little mini-documentary about a charming young infant that we'll call "thomps1d".

He was born premature - and not just a day or two, but well over a month premature. He was extremely underweight, and born with severe heart defects. Without immediate, intensive, and invasive medical intervention, his chances of surviving the first day of his life would have been nil. Even with that intervention, he was given a less than even chance of survival.

As it happens, he did manage to survive - and even thrive. However, it came at a cost. As a result of the invasive procedures done to save his life, he carries several prominent and marring scars which provide him with a constant reminder that nature, as often as not, manages to screw something up.

People who talk about having been mutilated because of circumcision make me very hot and bothered, and for a very good reason. I've been in a position where a tiny scrap of foreskin was certainly the least of my worries, and yet had parents loving enough to ensure that not only did I get the best medical care available, I would also have every chance of living a long, healthy life - and that included circumcision, because the loss of that tiny scrap of skin meant that I would have a reduced chance of catching certain sexually transmitted diseases in the future.

Obviously, not all infants are as badly off as I was when I was born. But does that mean that we should just shrug off performing a quick, simple procedure that can potentially save them terrible amounts of trouble down the road?


So let the child decide to have it done. You’ll have 12 or so years to brainwash your kid under my proposed scheme. You can make fun of his dirty little penis every time you bath him and tell him how ugly it is and how no woman is ever going to want to have sex with him once she’s seen it.

Ah...so you're against circumcision because you think it's physical mutilation, but you'd be perfectly OK with me basically verbally abusing my child for more than a decade? Very compassionate, that.

Vaccination of children is done because the child is in immediate danger from certain illnesses. The child’s physical body is not significantly altered by a vaccination. As for timing, a vaccination should be left until just before the individual is at risk from the disease it protects against.

Odd. I was always taught that you should try to take care of problems before they start. An ounce of prevention versus a pound of cure, and all that jazz.

You had your circumcision done to you when you had no choice and have not known anything different. It is part of your self-concept and my attack on circumcision of infants is perceived by you as an attack on who you are.

How do you know that you would not have preferred having a foreskin?

It's true that I didn't have a choice in my circumcision, and it's also true that it's part of who I am. I do not, however, consider attacks on infant circumcision to be an attack on who I am - I consider it ill-informed, short sighted, and potentially dangerous.

As far as knowing that I wouldn't have preferred having a foreskin, I can say this: knowing that it has reduced the risk of HIV infection, that my partners have preferred the way it looks, and that I just plain like the way it looks when it's standing at attention, I think it's pretty safe to say that I prefer things just the way they are. If my foreskin magically regenerated overnight, I'd have it removed again.
 
I have no doubt that people can easily learn to clean an uncircumcised penis. I don't believe that anything I said brought that into doubt. Congratulations on your cleaning abilities, though. I'm sure that you are very proud.

Again, I never said that people who shower regularly with have trouble with genital cleanliness.

So the cleanness of a circumcised penis is not a significant advantage then?

Actually, the more appropriate question here would be whether I (or any other North American male) would prefer engaging in intimate relations with a woman who has had a circumcision. To be entirely on target, the question, phrased appropriately, would be whether or not a woman who has had a clitoridectomy would be a preferred sexual partner.

Actually it would be a woman who’d had the clitoral hood trimmed back. The male version of what you described does not bare thinking about!

And as a circumcised or uncircumcised penis is a pretty arbitrary criteria to have a preference for, I see no reason why the options I gave were inappropriate.

Having never engaged in such relations with a person who has had such a procedure performed, I cannot answer the question. But I'll tell you what - if it ever happens, I'll drop you a line and let you know.

Pop over to Africa. It’s remarkably common in certain places there. Don’t worry too much about getting HIV, you’ve got extra protection.

At least you are consistent here. Most people are not. If you doubt this, try an informal survey - go and talk to random groups of people, steering the conversation towards child rearing. With one group, discuss plans for circumcising an as-yet unborn male child. With another group, discuss plans to have a young female daughter's ears pierced.

Lots of people are inconsistent on many moral questions, depending on the context. Actually I’m amazed that no one has set up the African argument as a moral dilemma in which my logic cannot provide a suitable answer. Anyone care to try?

Perhaps the UK will yield different results than North America with these lines of inquiry, but every time I've had discussions about these topics, I find that people tend to be mostly supportive of ear-piercing (with people against the practice in the distinct minority), and people are primarily against circumcision, usually because they are afraid that it will traumatize the infant.

That would probably be a fair assessment of people in the UK, except the vast majority of people would be against circumcision of infants (except those that perform it for religious reasons of course).


I think you're playing word games here. What do you mean by "normal"?

Medical science has enough knowledge to know what each organ in the body should be doing and how well those organs should work for the majority of the sample they have based there models on. Will that do for “normal”?

Do you agree that, when possible, technology and/or surgical procedures should be employed to promote healthier lives and prevention of dangerous diseases?

No, I don’t. I believe that technology and/or surgical procedures should be made available that promote healthier lives and the prevention of dangerous diseases.

So in the case of Africa I would prescribe giving yours and my politicians a kick up the arse and tell them to stop pandering to people who believe in an invisible, immeasurable entity which has been responsible for millions of deaths and the greedy people in corporations who claim poverty when their tax bill goes up, and spend, spend, spend on education (both sexual and conventional), anti-retroviral drugs and condoms by the bucket load for everyone who wants them in Africa. I would also fully support male circumcision being offered to boys and men who are old enough to decide for themselves if they want to use it.

What I will not agree to is a child’s human rights being violated because people want to do the wrong thing for the right reasons.

As far as nature typically doing a good job...funny story, that. Let's listen to a little mini-documentary about a charming young infant that we'll call "thomps1d".

He was born premature - and not just a day or two, but well over a month premature. He was extremely underweight, and born with severe heart defects. Without immediate, intensive, and invasive medical intervention, his chances of surviving the first day of his life would have been nil. Even with that intervention, he was given a less than even chance of survival.

As it happens, he did manage to survive - and even thrive. However, it came at a cost. As a result of the invasive procedures done to save his life, he carries several prominent and marring scars which provide him with a constant reminder that nature, as often as not, manages to screw something up.

People who talk about having been mutilated because of circumcision make me very hot and bothered, and for a very good reason. I've been in a position where a tiny scrap of foreskin was certainly the least of my worries, and yet had parents loving enough to ensure that not only did I get the best medical care available, I would also have every chance of living a long, healthy life - and that included circumcision, because the loss of that tiny scrap of skin meant that I would have a reduced chance of catching certain sexually transmitted diseases in the future.

Science is a wonderful thing. While they were in there, so to speak, did they remove your appendix? That would protect you even more from potential illness.

Obviously, not all infants are as badly off as I was when I was born. But does that mean that we should just shrug off performing a quick, simple procedure that can potentially save them terrible amounts of trouble down the road?

We’re on page 5. I have not shrugged it off. Despite what people such as Linda may think, I’ve personally tried hard to find a way to justify circumcision of infants morally. I cannot do it. Perhaps you would like to try to come up with a logical moral argument that I’ve overlooked?

Ah...so you're against circumcision because you think it's physical mutilation, but you'd be perfectly OK with me basically verbally abusing my child for more than a decade? Very compassionate, that.

No, of course I’m not. But some people here have been using the argument that we don’t stop parents indoctrinating their children with religious ideas (such as sex is sin, etc.). I was giving an example that most people would find obnoxious. You have, so I’m pleased it worked!

Odd. I was always taught that you should try to take care of problems before they start. An ounce of prevention versus a pound of cure, and all that jazz.

Then in case of vaccination I believe you are wrong. Vaccines are only used when there is a threat to your health. Think of the smallpox vaccine which is no longer routinely given.

It's true that I didn't have a choice in my circumcision, and it's also true that it's part of who I am. I do not, however, consider attacks on infant circumcision to be an attack on who I am - I consider it ill-informed, short sighted, and potentially dangerous.

That’s your opinion and you’re entitled to hold it. I disagree with you.

As far as knowing that I wouldn't have preferred having a foreskin, I can say this: knowing that it has reduced the risk of HIV infection, that my partners have preferred the way it looks, and that I just plain like the way it looks when it's standing at attention, I think it's pretty safe to say that I prefer things just the way they are. If my foreskin magically regenerated overnight, I'd have it removed again.

Linda’s argument, which is so spectacularly poor I’m still amazed she presented it. This is why it’s rubbish:

You are the product of your experiences. So the choices you make today are based on the past you’ve had. If you’d had a different past you cannot say what choices you would make today.

An example:

It’s the equivalent of shuffling a deck of cards twice and arguing that both times they should deal out in the same order because it’s the same deck of cards!

Does that make sense or do I need to explain it some more?
 
I meant (sorry, I thought it would be obvious) the reference she gave in support of the lower number here.

Linda

That doesn't mention meatal stenosis at all!

Since it's not a condition diagnosed in the post-operative timeframe it doesn't matter and doesn't count?
 
That doesn't mention meatal stenosis at all!

Since it's not a condition diagnosed in the post-operative timeframe it doesn't matter and doesn't count?

You stated that you were not able to find population based information on complications from circumcision. I am suggesting that one starting point would be to follow the references from the CDC fact sheet. It also looked like the report that Skeptigirl linked to may have some references, although I cannot tell if it is referring only to the immediate post-op period, or long term. I don't know if your search will be fruitful, I was only trying to suggest some leads.

Linda
 
You stated that you were not able to find population based information on complications from circumcision.

It's the incidence of meatal stenosis that I'm looking for. Everything available says's it's around 7-10%.
 
It's the incidence of meatal stenosis that I'm looking for. Everything available says's it's around 7-10%.

Well not those bastard child mutilators at the AMA
Two large series detected a complication rate between 0.2% and 0.6% in circumcised infants.28,29 Bleeding and infection, occasionally leading to sepsis, are the most common adverse events requiring treatment. In the majority of cases, bleeding is minor and hemostasis can be achieved by pressure application. Other untoward events can result from taking too much skin from the penile shaft causing denudation or rarely, concealed penis, or from not removing sufficient foreskin, producing an unsatisfactory cosmetic result or recurrent phimosis.30,31 Other postoperative complications include formation of skin bridges between the penile shaft and glans, meatitis and meatal stenosis, chordee, inclusion cysts in the circumcision line, lymphedema, hypospadias and epispadias, and urinary retention.32 Case reports have associated circumcision with other rare but severe events including scalded skin syndrome, necrotizing fasciitis, sepsis and meningitis, urethrocutaneous fistulas, necrosis (secondary to cauterization), and partial amputation of the glans penis.5,30,32
link

Oh the 32 not is this

32. Kaplan GW. Complications of circumcision. Urol Clin North Am. 1983;10:543-549.

Now if you listen to those trying to scare everyone into believing circumcision is the worst tradgety that can happen to a child
 
So the cleanness of a circumcised penis is not a significant advantage then?

It's *an* advantage, to be certain. However, as has been discussed ad infinitum on this thread, it is only one of several.

Actually it would be a woman who’d had the clitoral hood trimmed back. The male version of what you described does not bare thinking about!

Yikes, that's what I get for grabbing at my biomedical ethics textbook's glossary and just skimming through it for a technical reference. You're right, of course. What I referred to would be the equivalent of cutting off the head of a penis. There is also a much worse version of female circumcision that is the equivalent of castrating a man.

*Those* qualify as mutilation, and there exist a variety of reasons to despise them. Unfortunately, I think many people hear "circumcision" in its typical usage and immediately think "amputation", which is an absurd hyperbole.

And as a circumcised or uncircumcised penis is a pretty arbitrary criteria to have a preference for, I see no reason why the options I gave were inappropriate.

Indeed it is an arbitrary criteria, but it is one in which the women I have known choose to make a distinction. Certainly, they have other criteria as well - length, girth, colour, proportion to the berries below, etc...

But there's a time and a place for discussing those criteria. In the right circumstances, I've got no issue doing so. However, in a thread about circumcision it only makes sense that one would discuss one of the impacts of circumcision on a person's sex life.

Pop over to Africa. It’s remarkably common in certain places there. Don’t worry too much about getting HIV, you’ve got extra protection.

Setting aside the scheduling hardships imposed by being one of the only oilfield electronics engineers in the middle of the Alberta oil patch, I think my wife would take umbrage at the thought of me trying that.

But should circumstances change in the future, and the aforementioned scenario take place, I'll be sure to let everyone know how it turned out.

Lots of people are inconsistent on many moral questions, depending on the context. Actually I’m amazed that no one has set up the African argument as a moral dilemma in which my logic cannot provide a suitable answer. Anyone care to try?

It is true that many people are inconsistent on many moral questions. It's a shame in its own right, but that's a discussion for another thread.

As to the African situation, I think it's too complex for a single solution to work. "Circumcise 'em all" isn't going to be effective, nor is the current style of abstinence-only education. Only proper, accurate education combined with availability of prophylactics, proper medical testing and treatment facilities, and the *option* of circumcision could approach an effective solution.

That would probably be a fair assessment of people in the UK, except the vast majority of people would be against circumcision of infants (except those that perform it for religious reasons of course).

Again, there is the issue of inconsistency. Not a problem of yours, of course, but one which is quite prolific - why would anyone who is against circumcision of infants be in favour of it in religious reasons? But now I'm throwing off shades of Dawkins, and the question of why religion is afforded special treatment in the minds of the populace is a question for yet another thread.

Medical science has enough knowledge to know what each organ in the body should be doing and how well those organs should work for the majority of the sample they have based there models on. Will that do for “normal”?

So, if one could demonstrate that a circumcised penis performs the functions of an uncircumcised one, would that suffice to qualify it as "normal"?

Because I don't have a webcam, but if video proof is absolutely needed, I'm sure I can find some that demonstrates that a circumcised penis is able to perform all the same functions as an uncircumcised one...

In other words, circumcision is a procedure that doesn't impair the functionality of the organ in question, but *does* provide enhanced protection to the host organism as a whole.

No, I don’t. I believe that technology and/or surgical procedures should be made available that promote healthier lives and the prevention of dangerous diseases.

Such as circumcision, correct?

So in the case of Africa I would prescribe giving yours and my politicians a kick up the arse and tell them to stop pandering to people who believe in an invisible, immeasurable entity which has been responsible for millions of deaths and the greedy people in corporations who claim poverty when their tax bill goes up, and spend, spend, spend on education (both sexual and conventional), anti-retroviral drugs and condoms by the bucket load for everyone who wants them in Africa. I would also fully support male circumcision being offered to boys and men who are old enough to decide for themselves if they want to use it.

As far as giving our politicians a swift kick to the nether regions, I'm all for it. Certainly, they are well aware of the situation in Africa and that it has been in dire need of addressing for a very long time now.

What I will not agree to is a child’s human rights being violated because people want to do the wrong thing for the right reasons.

Perhaps I have missed out on some drastic turn of events in the legal precedents of western civilizations in the last few hours. I was under the impression that parents, in their capacity as legal and moral guardians of their children, were specifically empowered to make medical decisions for the minors, particularly when those choices regarded serious medical ramifications (such as HIV).

Unless this has changed, and parents are no longer afforded that responsibility, calling this a violation of human rights is little more than sophist rhetoric.

Now, if rogue doctors are leaping out of the shadows, hauling young children into alleyways, and only setting them loose after a quick -snip- -snip-, we have a whole different situation on our hands.

Science is a wonderful thing. While they were in there, so to speak, did they remove your appendix? That would protect you even more from potential illness.

No, no more than they removed my tonsils, liver, or kidneys.

I think part of the misunderstanding here is the question of whether or not medical treatment should be reserved for cases of imminent catastrophic failure of some part of the body.

Simple, non-invasive treatments that can easily protect against major diseases are appropriate at any age - and generally, the earlier the better. Larger-scale, invasive treatments that themselves could pose a risk to the patient's health are rightfully reserved for cases of emergency.

In my case, the additional procedure of cutting out my appendix would have posed a significant and grave risk to my already fragile infant life. Since my doctor was not Doctor Nick (hi, everybody!), we avoided that fiasco altogether.

We’re on page 5. I have not shrugged it off. Despite what people such as Linda may think, I’ve personally tried hard to find a way to justify circumcision of infants morally. I cannot do it. Perhaps you would like to try to come up with a logical moral argument that I’ve overlooked?

This is where we differ. I don't see any difficulty in justifying the circumcision of infants morally. I can come up with plenty of reasons off the top of my head - heck, this post alone has mentioned aesthetics, cleanliness, and disease prevention - to favour the practice, yet can only come up with one strike against it: the "ick" factor.

No, of course I’m not. But some people here have been using the argument that we don’t stop parents indoctrinating their children with religious ideas (such as sex is sin, etc.). I was giving an example that most people would find obnoxious. You have, so I’m pleased it worked!

Good - you had me worried. I suspected that was your intent, but intent is notoriously hard to communicate over the internet.

Then in case of vaccination I believe you are wrong. Vaccines are only used when there is a threat to your health. Think of the smallpox vaccine which is no longer routinely given.

Smallpox is no longer routinely given because the disease has been all but eradicated.

HIV, measles, mumps, and rubella on the other hand...not so much. Thus, any reasonable measures which can be taken to protect ourselves or our families are worth consideration.

The only question, then, is whether one considers circumcision a reasonable measure. I consider the loss of a small piece of unnecessary skin worth the benefits gained in terms of a measure of protection against a widespread and highly virulent disease. Others do not.

That’s your opinion and you’re entitled to hold it. I disagree with you.

And, like so many others on the internet, that's what this argument is ultimately going to have to boil down to. We've each made our value judgements, and I don't see either of us convincing the other. Hopefully we've at least provided each other with some food for thought.
 
Well not those bastard child mutilators at the AMA
link

Oh the 32 not is this

32. Kaplan GW. Complications of circumcision. Urol Clin North Am. 1983;10:543-549.

Now if you listen to those trying to scare everyone into believing circumcision is the worst tradgety that can happen to a child


Why do I have a feeling they only looked at the incidence of really severe, acute meatal stenosis right in the post-operative period, and not toddlers presenting with urinary spraying?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom