Dr de Cock says circumcision reduces HIV risk

I don't have access to it.
But since you're advocating the amputation of newborn sex organs, I think the burdon of proof is on you to prove that your figures are sound.
So, quote to me the relevant parts.
Show me where I'm wrong.

You are sounding like a conspiracy theorist. Yes I am sure that the AMA really is an evil organization bent on taking as much money from people by suppressing cures THEY don't want you to know about.

You are dirrectly attacking the competency and judgement of a large number of medical professionals. So prove it then.
 
Thank you,Darat& Ivor-Can't be said much better than you have said.
I still can't get why, when condoms are so effective and cheap,we should advocate clipping all the little africans.

Seriously doubt the Langerhans' cells male only involvement.
Yes, medical "professionals" can be full of it! Needs no proof. They are people, too.

"Langerhans' cells have been observed in foreskin, vaginal, and oral mucosa of humans; the lower concentrations in oral mucosa suggest that it is not a likely source of HIV infection relative to foreskin and vaginal mucosa.[2]"

# ^ Hussain, LA, Lehner T (1995). "Comparative Investigation of Langerhans' cells and Potential Receptors for HIV in Oral, Genitourinary and Rectal Epithelia". Immunology 85: 475-484.

If the cells' involvement were true, certainly female labial circumcision would also help,unless there are more unknowns in play. Why is this not studied? Certainly would improve looks in the ones that hang down like a peacoat sleeve. Perhaps the churchies would go for this, as then, it wouldn't look so much like a taco, and people might be less likely to engage in toboo oral sex.
Cutting off the oral lips and tongue as well, would probably be stretching things thin. Quieter, tho.
 
Darat said:
If we found that "female circumcision" has a similar reduction in the chance of contracting HIV would that be supported by the WHO? Or is that different?

That's what I want to know, as well. Considering the fact that herpes sores tend to prefer the labia, and they are excellent transmitters of the HIV virus, I'm not seeing how some forms of FGM wouldn't reduce HIV transmission.

So, where are the scientists investigating this? Is it next? Why or why not?


ETA:
And don't forget this:

http://www.ias-2005.org/planner/Abstracts.aspx?AID=3138

Conclusions: A lowered risk of HIV infection among circumcised women was not attributable to confounding with another risk factor in these data. Anthropological insights on female circumcision as practiced in Tanzania may shed light on this conundrum.
 
Last edited:
Precisey,KellyB-As I recall, Female labia and foreskin are homologous structures,share attributes. I could be wrong.
So, pardon the joke,"where's the beef?'
What I have derived from this discussion:
They're africans,it's an epidemic,let's clip half the population at birth.
No, wait-clip the world's male population at birth!
(based on a two year study,cut short-The minute there was confirming evidence)
How's come the NHS is still tracking my sister , who has died some years ago, to find the exact causes of her death???
She was treated for Hodgkin's disease in the sixties. Somehow, it is important to those researchers, who gained her 30 more years, how she died, etc.
I guess curious minds just want to know these details.
Dr. Le Cock,indeed!
 
I disagree - for instance if you look at the "traditional" reasons given for both male and female circumcision you will see that there is a lot of cross over - the fact that female circumcision is a much more severe mutilation does not mean it cannot be used as an analogy.

Hanny Lightfoot-Klein (http://www.lightfoot-klein.com/)

"The reasons given for female circumcision in Africa and for routine male circumcision in the U.S. are essentially the same. Both falsely tout the positive health benefits of the procedures. Both promise cleanliness and the absence of "bad" genital odors, as well as greater attractiveness and acceptability of the sex organs. The affected individuals in both cultures have come to view these procedures as something that was done for them and not to them."
Kellyb was equating the foreskin of the penis to the clitoris. Excuse me D but the analogous male body part to the clitoris is the head of your penis, not the foreskin.

She also compared removing breast buds from an infant to removing the foreskin. Care to tell me how male penile foreskin produces anything other than smegma, let alone milk for one's offspring?

Re, "Both falsely tout the positive health benefits of the procedures", the scientific evidence I cited in this thread disagrees with you here. Do you have any scientific evidence supporting equal rates of HIV in circumcised and uncircumcised males? How about scientific research supporting equal rates of urinary tract infections in circumcised and uncircumcised males? Equal penile cancer rates circumcised and uncircumcised males?
 
skeptigirl said:
Kellyb was equating the foreskin of the penis to the clitoris. Excuse me D but the analogous male body part to the clitoris is the head of your penis, not the foreskin.

She also compared removing breast buds from an infant to removing the foreskin. Care to tell me how male penile foreskin produces anything other than smegma, let alone milk for one's offspring?

First of all, the breast bud thingie was Darat's analogy, not mine. (although I see the point. And you could remove just one as opposed to both and still feed a child and get a 50% reduction in breast cancer).

Second of all, I consider the clitoral hood and labia a more apt analogy to the foreskin of a penis.

Do you have any scientific evidence supporting equal rates of HIV in circumcised and uncircumcised males? How about scientific research supporting equal rates of urinary tract infections in circumcised and uncircumcised males? Equal penile cancer rates circumcised and uncircumcised males?

And if we're going to go down this road again, we need to figure out the rates of all three of those conditions in uncircumcised females, as well, to compare to circumcised and uncircumcised males if we're going to overcome our cultural bias and moral relativisms.

While the anatomy is not completely the same, it's not that different, either.
Remove it in males and get an effect, and you can bet money that removing it's female equivalent would produce a similar effect.
 
Why? The clitoris is "just" part of the female genitalia like the foreskin is "just part" of the male genitalia.
I understand the issue of the glans penis being 'happier' with it's sensual foreskin covering. I understand the moist mucous membrane of the glans penis becomes relatively thicker 'skin' when the foreskin is removed. And I understand the issues of equal genitalia protection. If it weren't for any documented health benefits, all you boys would have an excellent case.

But, if you are going to make comparisons, claiming the foreskin is equal to the clitoris is like claiming the glans penis is equal to the labia. Just because the head of my sex organ is smaller than the head of yours is no reason the claim the skin over the head of your sex organ is equal to the entire head of my sex organ. So let's be honest in this discussion.

The question is about a trade off in some sexual sensitivity for a greater chance of living long enough to actually have sex. The question is not about trading all sexual sensation for a lower HIV infection rate.
 
Complete and utter bulls hit!
You continue to repeat your human rights arguments (all things being equal I don't disagree and I haven't read anyone else disagreeing). You also refute the health claims of circumcisions but provide no evidence the citations noted are controversial.

What you also haven't done is provide any evidence that the HIV reduction research is in question. Without reading how much research has now been completed, you choose instead to question if enough research has been done. Yet you present no case for your position other than your personal lack of awareness about the extent of the current research and existing body of knowledge.

And given that the research is substantial, you have not addressed why in areas of the world where HIV-AIDS is devastating the population, that the trade off of some sexual pleasure for the benefit of significant reduction in the incidence of a fatal disease is not an acceptable trade off.
 
....I did include the major arguments they tend to share in common: And by exactly the same I mean hygiene, appearance, preference of partners and so on.
The articles I cited provided evidence of decreased incidents of penile cancer, of serious complications from urinary tract infections and lowered risk of HIV-AIDS infections in areas of the world where other interventions have not been sufficient. There were no similar health benefits in the literature for FGM that I saw.

My comment was in relationship to skepticgirl's comment of "I consider removing the clitoris to certainly be removing a sex organ but somehow the skin which covers the sex organ (penis) is hard to equate with the organ itself."

I was trying to illustrate that the foreskin is just as much part of the male sex organ as the clitoris is of the female organ. Anatomically and physiologically they are both integral structures to the male and female sex organs respectively. Indeed removal of either does not affect major function of both sets of sex organs i.e. urination and sexual reproduction. ...
This is an incredibly ignorant exaggeration either of the function of the foreskin or an exaggeration of the lack of function of the clitoris. I would question how a male would reproduce without the glans penis since erection would be impossible. And I question your claim that reproduction and urination are the only major functions of the genitourinary system. Sexual gratification is a major function in my life, don't know about yours.

And I've seen no evidence loss of the foreskin prevents sexual gratification. You cannot have a climax without a clitoris just as you cannot have one without a glans penis.
 
skeptigirl said:
And I've seen no evidence loss of the foreskin prevents sexual gratification. You cannot have a climax without a clitoris just as you cannot have one without a glans penis.

Nope.

http://www.newscientist.com/article.ns?id=dn2837

Circumcised women experience sexual arousal and orgasm as frequently as uncircumcised women, according to a study in Nigeria.

The researchers also found no difference in the frequency of intercourse or age of first sexual experience between the two groups of women. These findings remove key arguments used to defend the practice, they say.

Friday Okonofua and colleagues at the Women's Health and Action Research Centre in Benin City studied 1836 women, 45 per cent of whom had been circumcised.
 
Last edited:
That's what I want to know, as well. Considering the fact that herpes sores tend to prefer the labia, and they are excellent transmitters of the HIV virus, I'm not seeing how some forms of FGM wouldn't reduce HIV transmission.

So, where are the scientists investigating this? Is it next? Why or why not?


ETA:
And don't forget this:

http://www.ias-2005.org/planner/Abstracts.aspx?AID=3138
If this study were confirmed, and if removing the anatomy equivalent to the foreskin was done under proper medical care then I would have the same opinion here as with male circumcision.

But I find this study suspect since males ejaculate into the vagina, not onto the surface of the labia.

More research is clearly indicated if the results are legit.
 
First of all, the breast bud thingie was Darat's analogy, not mine. (although I see the point. And you could remove just one as opposed to both and still feed a child and get a 50% reduction in breast cancer).

Second of all, I consider the clitoral hood and labia a more apt analogy to the foreskin of a penis.



And if we're going to go down this road again, we need to figure out the rates of all three of those conditions in uncircumcised females, as well, to compare to circumcised and uncircumcised males if we're going to overcome our cultural bias and moral relativisms.

While the anatomy is not completely the same, it's not that different, either.
Remove it in males and get an effect, and you can bet money that removing it's female equivalent would produce a similar effect.

My apologies on the breast bud attribution. I also saw in your posts as I reviewed them that they have been mostly reasonable and I was mistaken in my overall assessment of your position. My disagreements with you are mainly that meatal stenosis seems a bit overblown. Calling a circumcision an amputation was a bit of an exaggeration as I already noted. And post #182 where you mention "moral consistency, are the lesser forms of FGM morally ok, as long as the clitoris is not removed?" is a sidetrack. Morality is not the issue here, risk benefit is the issue.

kellyb: Should labias be removed at birth if they've been known to rarely become cancerous in old age? What if the inner labia transmits the herpes virus?
Again, you are focused here on "should" as if it is a moral question. The question is, will enough cancer be prevented to make the trade off worth it? So it depends entirely on the cost (that is the cost of physical, emotional, and medical risk - not the financial cost though you can consider financial cost in addition to these other things) and what benefits will be derived.

Much of what else you have said, though has been reasonable, so again, my apologies.
 
Last edited:
If this study were confirmed, and if removing the anatomy equivalent to the foreskin was done under proper medical care then I would have the same opinion here as with male circumcision.

But I find this study suspect since males ejaculate into the vagina, not onto the surface of the labia.

More research is clearly indicated if the results are legit.

Interesting.
At least you're consistent.

And if it were to be implemented on a massive scale, we could follow the lead of what's going to happen with MGM and the "traditional" circumcisors ...
http://www.target-human-rights.com/...ionInCairo.pdf?SID=gvpddaju5df952ei6hlf9mv367
...could be retrained on how to do it "properly" ....to save money.
 
Interesting.
At least you're consistent.

And if it were to be implemented on a massive scale, we could follow the lead of what's going to happen with MGM and the "traditional" circumcisors ...
http://www.target-human-rights.com/...ionInCairo.pdf?SID=gvpddaju5df952ei6hlf9mv367
...could be retrained on how to do it "properly" ....to save money.
I've not been convinced that your discussion FGM is done for health or hygiene is consistent with the facts I am aware of. So if it were to be done for true medical reasons such as removing skin which contained the cells the foreskin contains that have been demonstrated to be portals of entry for HIV, I would promote a hospital procedure done with anesthetic. I would remove the procedure from the hands of traditional 'cutters'.

You have yet to convince me FGM isn't currently practiced as a form of female oppression. The one citation with one country having more education associated with more FGM was likely the result of confounding variables rather than the education. In all other countries, the higher the education, the less likely female offspring were to have FGM. That (along with a million other things) suggests female oppression rather than perceived "health" benefits.

Male circumcision would likely have ended eventually as educated people stopped the religious practice. But the research has shown health benefits. The recent case of the idiot Rabbi who managed to suck the blood after circumcising several infants thus infecting them with HSV may open a few more of those educated eyes that the religious practice needs to be reconsidered. Progress is slow. It's either a medical procedure for EB medical reasons, of it shouldn't be practiced. I'm not one to claim let the religious or cultural preferences prevail in this case.
 
Last edited:
skeptigirl said:
Morality is not the issue here, risk benefit is the issue.

It's both. If it's a human rights issue, then morality comes into play.

Again, you are focused here on "should" as if it is a moral question. The question is, will enough cancer be prevented to make the trade off worth it?

See, and for me, no contest, I'll take the cancer risk all day and all night. And even the UTI's I've staved off with cranberry juice and water a time or two over the years.
Having my bits all there is THE top priority. Until it actually gets cancer, it stays. Period.
I'd be mad as hell if something were chopped off in infancy over a hypothetical risk that could be dealt with in another way. But that's just me.


So it depends entirely on the cost (that is the cost of physical, emotional, and medical risk - not the financial cost though you can consider financial cost in addition to these other things) and what benefits will be derived.

I do understand your POV. But how can one person firmly make that kind of judgment for another?
My labia is PRICELESS to me. My risk of dying without having it removed would have to be...I dunno...pretty much a sure thing, I guess, for me to agree to having it removed.

No two people are going to make the same value judgments on something like this. It's just too personal. I'm not going to draw that line where you are. Which is why it should be up to the individual.
Much of what you have said, though has been reasonable so again, my apologies.
It's cool. :)
 
I've not been convinced that your discussion FGM is done for health or hygiene is consistent with the facts I am aware of. So if it were to be done for true medical reasons such as removing skin which contained the cells the foreskin contains that have been demonstrated to be portals of entry for HIV, I would promote a hospital procedure done with anesthetic. I would remove the procedure from the hands of traditional 'cutters'.

You have yet to convince me FGM isn't currently practiced as a form of female oppression. The one citation with one country having more education associated with more FGM was likely the result of confounding variables rather than the education. In all other countries, the higher the education, the less likely female offspring were to have FGM. That (along with a million other things) suggests female oppression rather than perceived "health" benefits.

Male circumcision would likely have ended eventually as educated people stopped the religious practice. But the research has shown health benefits. The recent case of the idiot Rabbi who managed to suck the blood after circumcising several infants thus infecting them with HSV may open a few more of those educated eyes that the religious practice needs to be reconsidered. Progress is slow. It's either a medical procedure for EB medical reasons, of it shouldn't be practiced. I'm not one to claim let the religious or cultural preferences prevail in this case.

Just google "female circumcision health benefits" and it's pretty easy to see that to the people who practice it, they believe those benefits exist.

Regarding which of those benefits actually exist...this is one of those "absence of evidence isn't evidence of absence" things. Male circumcision has been around for 6,000 years, and it's just now had it's positive effects documented. But no one (understandably) wants to look for how FGM can be beneficial. It's freaky and weird to us. We think nasty things about people who do it. It's "evil".

But that's not logical. There is no way removing the labia wouldn't reduce one's chances of cancer of the labia. There have to benefits to be found in there somewhere. It's just a matter of looking for them.

But should we even go down that road? Information and knowledge are "good"...but there is a price.

Imagine never having been given a choice about having some of your sex organs...because it was just cheaper to snip them when you were a baby?

I'm already with you on the clitoris and foreskin not being the same...but for the sake of hyperbole...imagine if people who you don't even know decided that since girls can climax without a clitoris, and the clitoris can become cancerous...it was best to just snip it at birth?

Between the ethics and the risks and benefits....I don't think it's ok for one person/culture to make that choice for another.
 
Re post 235

You can include moral issues in your risk benefit determination and decision making process.

Your individual preference isn't relevant at least as far as the HIV issue since you don't live in the areas of the world and aren't among the population most affected by HIV-AIDS. And I imagine if you had to have your leg amputated or die from cancer that you would most likely decide to give up the leg.

Re 236: We discussed that already, belief can be something you've been taught but that doesn't preclude the practice being based in sexual oppression.

"Cheaper as a baby" ignores the fact that it is also a safer procedure and one must have the circ before being sexually active. I think most teens who are sexually active are not necessarily ready to make the decision here. You can't solve the HIV problem by ignoring it and saying let the boys grow up and decide. The parents have to decide in this case as they would also have to decide the child should lose the leg to cancer rather than their life to cancer.

We are talking about circ vs death here. Perhaps it is circ vs x% chance of death, but it is still circ vs death. I don't have as hard of a time with that one as you do.

And as for the "other person's culture" does that include saying we shouldn't share the research results or the implications?
 
Last edited:
skeptigirl said:
Re 236: We discussed that already, belief can be something you've been taught but that doesn't preclude the practice being based in sexual oppression
.
MGM was once practiced in the US because of a type of sexual oppression, as well. A strange hybrid of pseudoscience and Victorian era morality regarding masturbation and mental health, in addition to "sanitary" reasons.
Now that valid health reason have been discovered, there's a more "solid" reason to continue in a way. Just like if the health benefits of FGM were discovered, it could become a medically advised procedure and the sexually oppressive aspects could be dismissed.

I think most teens who are sexually active are not necessarily ready to make the decision here.

Why? Because they might not choose it? Because they might prefer to keep their foreskins just like our European male members of this forum would?

You can't solve the HIV problem by ignoring it and saying let the boys grow up and decide.

Oh no ya' don't.
Don't equate allowing boy/men of reproductive age to choose for themselves with "ignoring it". That's not the case. Allowing them to choose is not ignoring anything.

The parents have to decide in this case as they would also have to decide the child should lose the leg to cancer rather than their life to cancer.

We are talking about circ vs death here. Perhaps it is circ vs x% chance of death, but it is still circ vs death. I don't have as hard of a time with that one as you do.

Cancer of the female genitalia/death or female circ? (I'm aware of the hyperbole, again.)

There are women who have died who would not have had it been snipped at birth. The difference is likelihood. AIDS is more likely. Yes. Far more. And while I'd like to see all forms of GM go away, I can respect parental rights, and I see the urgency of the situation, and sympathize with why one might choose this for their son.

And as for the "other person's culture" does that include saying we shouldn't share the research results or the implications?
No.
I've already elaborated on the possible ways the presentation of the information might go down that I find unsettling, so I'll let that part go before ponderingturtle comes back and calls me a conspiracy theorist again.
:)
 
The articles I cited provided evidence of decreased incidents of penile cancer, of serious complications from urinary tract infections and lowered risk of HIV-AIDS infections in areas of the world where other interventions have not been sufficient. There were no similar health benefits in the literature for FGM that I saw.

And perhaps that is just because "we" haven't looked for the health benefits in female genital mutilation like we have been doing for decades for male genital mutilation?

This is an incredibly ignorant exaggeration either of the function of the foreskin or an exaggeration of the lack of function of the clitoris. ...snip....

It is neither - my statement was accurate.

I would question how a male would reproduce without the glans penis since erection would be impossible.

A clitoris is not necessary for reproduction.

And I question your claim that reproduction and urination are the only major functions of the genitourinary system.

...snip...

Which is not a claim I made.

And I've seen no evidence loss of the foreskin prevents sexual gratification. You cannot have a climax without a clitoris just as you cannot have one without a glans penis.

This is an incredibly ignorant statement regarding female sexual gratification.
 
You continue to repeat your human rights arguments (all things being equal I don't disagree and I haven't read anyone else disagreeing). You also refute the health claims of circumcisions but provide no evidence the citations noted are controversial.

Thank you for acknowledging my argument. I do not refute the health claims of circumcision at all. My reply you've quoted was to the phrase ”extremely significant” being used to describe the benefits of circumcision. The benefits are anything but “extremely significant” except for reducing the risk of contracting sexually transmitted diseases and maybe some others for people with very poor personal hygiene.

What you also haven't done is provide any evidence that the HIV reduction research is in question. Without reading how much research has now been completed, you choose instead to question if enough research has been done. Yet you present no case for your position other than your personal lack of awareness about the extent of the current research and existing body of knowledge.

I do not question the circumcision-prevents-HIV research. I have been convinced the results are valid and useful. I do not think any more research needs to be done to act. Circumcision should be used as soon as possible to help tackle HIV in Africa.

And given that the research is substantial, you have not addressed why in areas of the world where HIV-AIDS is devastating the population, that the trade off of some sexual pleasure for the benefit of significant reduction in the incidence of a fatal disease is not an acceptable trade off.

I am addressing the trade offs of neonatal circumcision vs. ~12 year old circumcision. To me that’s what this discussion is about. I fully agree with you that we need to do something about HIV in Africa, including using circumcision. There is a limited amount of money to spend on the solution(s). Neonatal circumcision is one of the solutions but has both tangible and intangible costs.

Pros:

It is cheaper and safer to circumcise infants and the compliance is likely to be higher than older males. Most men who are circumcised at birth appear to be happy with it later in life. There are other much less significant health benefits to circumcision which become more significant if personal hygiene is an issue.

Cons:

The most important benefit of male circumcision in Africa is the risk reduction of contracting HIV by 60%. However, the risk does not occur for the vast majority of males until after an age they become able to take part in the decision making process and would therefore feel they had some choice in the decision to have the procedure. Sexual sensation is affected by an indeterminate but probably small amount. Most men in the studies were satisfied with the circumcisions they had as young men. It will be ~15 years before neonatal circumcision starts to save lives.

I can understand why many people way all this up and conclude the pros out way the cons. I too would support neonatal circumcision in Africa *if* there was a significant risk to the child that circumcision would reduce before they were old enough to become involved in the decision making process. However, I have yet to see evidence of any such benefit existing.

I’m not going to be horrified if the decision is to circumcise infants is made since I still believe the outcome will be much better than if circumcision is not used. I just think waiting and including the child in the decision is an even better solution, even if it costs more to save the same number of lives. As with all optimisation problems the optimum solution is dependent on how the various criteria are weighted.

Skeptigirl, I hope I’ve explained my point of view sufficiently well to convince you that our positions on this issue are remarkably close and the main difference is our relative weightings of the various pros and cons, leading to us to slightly different ideas about what would be the best solution.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom