You continue to repeat your human rights arguments (all things being equal I don't disagree and I haven't read anyone else disagreeing). You also refute the health claims of circumcisions but provide no evidence the citations noted are controversial.
Thank you for acknowledging my argument. I do not refute the health claims of circumcision at all. My reply you've quoted was to the phrase
”extremely significant” being used to describe the benefits of circumcision. The benefits are anything but “extremely significant” except for reducing the risk of contracting sexually transmitted diseases and maybe some others for people with very poor personal hygiene.
What you also haven't done is provide any evidence that the HIV reduction research is in question. Without reading how much research has now been completed, you choose instead to question if enough research has been done. Yet you present no case for your position other than your personal lack of awareness about the extent of the current research and existing body of knowledge.
I do not question the circumcision-prevents-HIV research. I have been convinced the results are valid and useful. I do not think any more research needs to be done to act. Circumcision should be used as soon as possible to help tackle HIV in Africa.
And given that the research is substantial, you have not addressed why in areas of the world where HIV-AIDS is devastating the population, that the trade off of some sexual pleasure for the benefit of significant reduction in the incidence of a fatal disease is not an acceptable trade off.
I am addressing the trade offs of neonatal circumcision vs. ~12 year old circumcision. To me that’s what this discussion is about. I fully agree with you that we need to do something about HIV in Africa, including using circumcision. There is a limited amount of money to spend on the solution(s). Neonatal circumcision is one of the solutions but has both tangible and intangible costs.
Pros:
It is cheaper and safer to circumcise infants and the compliance is likely to be higher than older males. Most men who are circumcised at birth appear to be happy with it later in life. There are other much less significant health benefits to circumcision which become more significant if personal hygiene is an issue.
Cons:
The most important benefit of male circumcision in Africa is the risk reduction of contracting HIV by 60%. However, the risk does not occur for the vast majority of males until after an age they become able to take part in the decision making process and would therefore feel they had some choice in the decision to have the procedure. Sexual sensation is affected by an indeterminate but probably small amount. Most men in the studies were satisfied with the circumcisions they had as young men. It will be ~15 years before neonatal circumcision starts to save lives.
I can understand why many people way all this up and conclude the pros out way the cons. I too would support neonatal circumcision in Africa *if* there was a significant risk to the child that circumcision would reduce before they were old enough to become involved in the decision making process. However, I have yet to see evidence of any such benefit existing.
I’m not going to be horrified if the decision is to circumcise infants is made since I still believe the outcome will be
much better than if circumcision is not used. I just think waiting and including the child in the decision is an even better solution, even if it costs more to save the same number of lives. As with all optimisation problems the optimum solution is dependent on how the various criteria are weighted.
Skeptigirl, I hope I’ve explained my point of view sufficiently well to convince you that our positions on this issue are remarkably close and the main difference is our relative weightings of the various pros and cons, leading to us to slightly different ideas about what would be the best solution.