Does E = MC2 ... Or What?

Aggle said:
Maybe it's an assignment operator?
Then in any reasonable programming language it would be:

[latex]$E := mc^2$[/latex]

I told you that using an equal sign for assignment was the Devil's work!

~~ Paul
 
You haven't quite got to where Iacchus's head is on this.He thinks that because you're dividing E to arrive at M, them M is part of E. He's actually used the analogy of cutting up a pie for this!

That's what I did all that faffing around with the equations for him.

:hb:
So, where does E = very-thing begin if, not with energy? Of course we can't really divide up energy either now can we? ... Oh, I mean destroy it. ;) ;) ;)
 
Iacchus, the first law is "Energy cannot be created nor destroyed".
So, what could that mean? ... That energy has always existed, even prior to the Big Bang? ... And, that the creation of matter (the Big Bang itself) was merely an afterthought? :jaw-dropp

Indeed, our anonymous friend's words seem to apply well here ...


THERE IS NO MATTER AS SUCH!

All matter originates and exists only by virtue of a force which brings the particles of an atom to vibration and holds this most minute solar system of the atom together. We must assume behind this force the existence of a conscious and intelligent mind. This mind is the matrix of all matter.
 
the first law is "Energy cannot be created nor destroyed"
So how do you fit the equation you keep quoting into this?

E = MC2
This implies that energy and matter are interchangeable.

That means that "matter cannot be created nor destroyed" as well. :)
 
So how do you fit the equation you keep quoting into this?

E = MC2
This implies that energy and matter are interchangeable.
I admit my error with my First Law of Thermo comment. "Mass" is an attribute of some forms of "matter", and for an idealist, for some forms of "amatter" as well.

That means that "matter cannot be created nor destroyed" as well. :)
Nope. Again, my error. E&M cannot be created nor destroyed.

"Matter" is that stuff, the harder you look for it, the less there is of it. Mass is mass, and no one has a clue what that might be. Higgs Fields, anyone?
 
Last edited:
So, what could that mean? ... That energy has always existed, even prior to the Big Bang? ... And, that the creation of matter (the Big Bang itself) was merely an afterthought? :jaw-dropp

Indeed, our anonymous friend's words seem to apply well here ...
Iacchus, I see that you quote hammegk (and even applaud him), but apparently did not read the response to him. Did you look at Diamond's link? To applaud hammegk's post, but not respond to the answer to it (which was a mere one post below it) seems...dishonest?

Or had you merely not read that far yet? Do you care to retract your applause?
 
And neither did energy.

Remember: there is no "prior to the Big Bang".
I am simply asking what is the "stuff" that the Universe is made of ... and, whether this "stuff" has always existed? By your answer, are you suggesting that E=very-thing came about on the fly? Or, are you suggesting nothing ever came about in the first place?
 
Iacchus: I do not think you entirely understand set theory and its applications and limitations.

Now I admit that the last time I actually studied set theory was in ninth grade, and that was in 1961, and I sucked at math anyway, so my memory may be a little rusty. But before we go too far down the Planck road again, how about starting at the beginning, and figuring out by what stretch of the definition 1 is a subset of 2!
 
I am simply asking what is the "stuff" that the Universe is made of ... and, whether this "stuff" has always existed? By your answer, are you suggesting that E=very-thing came about on the fly? Or, are you suggesting nothing ever came about in the first place?
Current and well supported theory indicates that "this stuff" hasn't always existed. Space and time began at the Big Bang. If you want to argue that this is not the case, you're going to have to do a little better than the vague waffle you have so far presented.

And what is this "E=very-thing" supposed to be? Is it meant to appear profound, or just a typo?
 
Iacchus: I do not think you entirely understand set theory and its applications and limitations.

Now I admit that the last time I actually studied set theory was in ninth grade, and that was in 1961, and I sucked at math anyway, so my memory may be a little rusty. But before we go too far down the Planck road again, how about starting at the beginning, and figuring out by what stretch of the definition 1 is a subset of 2!
Isn't one person but a subset of the crowd? If you had ten apples in a basket, wouldn't one of those apples be a subset of the ten? Or, when counting beyond two fixed points -- of time let's say -- isn't the temporal but a subset of the eternal?
 
Isn't one person but a subset of the crowd? If you had ten apples in a basket, wouldn't one of those apples be a subset of the ten? Or, when counting beyond two fixed points -- of time let's say -- isn't the temporal but a subset of the eternal?

Yes, yes, and no.

Any other questions I can clear up for you?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom