Does E = MC2 ... Or What?

Genesius said:
Argument from Authority - "If Max Planck said it, it must be true!"

Iacchus said:
Not in the least.

By "not in the least", do you mean to say that "if Max Planck said it, it must be true" is not an appeal to authority? If that is the case, you are clearly talking nonsense.

Or do you mean that you have not been using Planck's alleged quotation as an argument from authority? In that case, that fact that you have posted, in this thread alone, this:
Iacchus said:
Perhaps you can see the implications to Max Planck's quote in the other thread?
...and also this:

Iacchus said:
Well, it seems to be according to Max Planck anyway
...indicates that you are clearly talking nonsense.
 
So if I rewrite the equation to M=E/C2 the entire structure of the universe will be changed to organize everything within the context of matter?
Who said that?

E=MC2 or M=E/C2 is the same equation, just written differently.
Yes it is, both of which demonstrate that "E" equals the whole ... at least with respect "E."

And you have demonstrated that you have no clue what either of them means.
And you have demonstrated that you have no more clue about it than I do. And, by any chance did you read the orignal post?
 
Last edited:
Who said that?
I can see that you would not recognise this--it merely applies your reasoning to a different form of the equation. Your reasoning is worthless, which you see in this context.
Yes it is, both of which demonstrate that "E" equals the whole ... at least with respect "E."
No. You could say the same thing about M...at least with respect to M. Or recognise that you are fundamentally misunderstanding the equation.
And you have demonstrated that you have no more clue about it than I do. And, did you by any chance read the orignal post?
No. Genesius did address your OP. G clearly has a better understanding of it than you. Your failure to understand the explanation is not the fault of the explanation, but a result of your blinders.

You are quite simply wrong.
 
Anyone care to argue that we should restate the First Law of Thermodynamics to "Matter cannot be created nor destroyed"?
 
No, it was the response that Mojo made while I was in the midst of responding to this one that cleared it up for me. But, thanks just the same.
Cleared what up for you?

Your subsequent posts have shown that you still don't get it.
 
By "not in the least", do you mean to say that "if Max Planck said it, it must be true" is not an appeal to authority? If that is the case, you are clearly talking nonsense.
No, actually, I'm probably more of an authority on this than Max Planck is/was.

Or do you mean that you have not been using Planck's alleged quotation as an argument from authority? In that case, that fact that you have posted, in this thread alone, this: ...and also this:

...indicates that you are clearly talking nonsense.
What Max Planck said is very clear statement, and it's worth quoting and/or referring to.
 
Dang! Wollery beat me to it! Ah well, it was such an idiotic comment, it deserves even more.

:big:

:crazy:
:hb:
:what:
:bs:
 
No, actually, I'm probably more of an authority on this than Max Planck is/was.
Is this your way of saying he is no authority on it whatsoever?
What Max Planck said is very clear statement, and it's worth quoting and/or referring to.
Yes...it is worth quoting, in its original context, so that it can be evaluated properly. With the sentence alone, unattributed, we don't know at all whether he spoke literally, metaphorically, humorously, or what. This is why people are so insistent on proper attribution of quotes. It matters.

Any luck with that?
 
Ah, so you would find it acceptable when tossing a coin for me to call "Coin!" thus ensuring that I win no matter which side shows?
Of course you never said anything about "flipping" the coin, because then we would be speaking of the "subset" of a coin toss.
 
Last edited:
Yes...it is worth quoting, in its original context, so that it can be evaluated properly. With the sentence alone, unattributed, we don't know at all whether he spoke literally, metaphorically, humorously, or what. This is why people are so insistent on proper attribution of quotes. It matters.

Any luck with that?
So I guess an online encyclopedia doesn't suffice? This is the original link that I posted by the way. Of course if this is not good enough, perhaps we could try looking it up in the Encyclopedia Britannica or something? I know they have an online version of it, but I think they charge you money for any in-depth research. Of course in the three or four hours that I've already spent looking into this damn thing, I haven't seen a single link that decries this quote a foul. So I really don't see what the big fuss is all about.
 
No, actually, I'm probably more of an authority on this than Max Planck is/was.

I see. So when did you win your Nobel Prize?

And where are the Iacchus Institutes scattered all over northern Europe?
 
And as I already said, just a couple of posts above yours in fact, I wasn't referring to physics.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom