Does E = MC2 ... Or What?

Iacchus: I do not think you entirely understand set theory and its applications and limitations.

Now I admit that the last time I actually studied set theory was in ninth grade, and that was in 1961, and I sucked at math anyway, so my memory may be a little rusty. But before we go too far down the Planck road again, how about starting at the beginning, and figuring out by what stretch of the definition 1 is a subset of 2!
For all very large values of 1 and very small values of 2.

Obviously.

Quantum or something...
 
Isn't one person but a subset of the crowd? If you had ten apples in a basket, wouldn't one of those apples be a subset of the ten? Or, when counting beyond two fixed points -- of time let's say -- isn't the temporal but a subset of the eternal?

I hope I can say this clearly enough, and in enough ways, to impart some slight understanding of the point I'm trying to make.

The set of persons in a crowd is just that: a set of persons, not of their quantity. If there are ten persons in the crowd (small crowd), and I ask you, who are the members of that set, it would be a mistake to tell me that the set consists of "the number 10." It is the members of the set, not the quantification of the members of the set! A set of ten persons does not contain as a subset anything but persons. The fact that it contains a subset of nine persons does not in any way imply that it contains as a subset nine of anything else, or any quality of "nineness" separate from the actual members of the set, which are persons. A single person (not the number which describes his singularity) is a subset of the group of objects that make up the set. A set contains objects, and a set can contain objects that belong to other sets. A subset contains some or all of the objects of its superset. If I have two apples, each of those apples is the subset of the set of two apples. This does not make the number 1 a subset of the number 2. The set is a set of apples, not of numbers. The fact that the set contains two subsets does not mean that 1 is a subset of 2. There can be sets of numbers, too. For example, there is a number set ( a small subset of many other number sets) which is the set of numbers that are the number two. It has one member. Two. Like all one member sets, it also has one subset: itself. The set of the number two does not contain the number one. If I remember rightly (and I hope some more mathematical soul jumps in to correct me if I don't) you're confusing the cardinality of the set with the set itself.
 
Last edited:
If I recall my high-school physics correctly (and that's a stretch - it's been 32 years!), the E=MC2 equation was actually written as: E0=M0C2. It showed that a change in energy was proportional to a change in mass at a rate proportional to C2. From this, it was possible to show that minute amounts of mass would convert to large amounts of energy. Equally, to convert energy to mass would require "some effort" to accomplish (but don't tell the homeopaths! ;)).
 
I am simply asking what is the "stuff" that the Universe is made of ... and, whether this "stuff" has always existed? By your answer, are you suggesting that E=very-thing came about on the fly? Or, are you suggesting nothing ever came about in the first place?

Again, you misunderstand the word "nothing". There was never "nothing" to begin with. At least, not if you consider a singularity to be something; but it's not as if time existed "before" the big bang, so any mention of "always existed" is meaningless.
 
Iacchus:

E=M*c^2 could be described as a conversion formula. It allows you to describe matter in terms of energy and vice versa. Not unlike the following formula:

P=D*10^2

Where P= Pennies, D=Dollars

I suppose now you will argue for pages on how dollars are subsets of pennies.

LLH
 
Yes, yes, and no.

Any other questions I can clear up for you?

A member of a crowd wouldn't be a subset of it, would he? He'd be just that: a member of the set. A set containing a member of a crowd would be a subset of the crowd. Likewise for the apples. Or maybe I'm trying to apply mathematical concepts where it doesn't make any sense to?
 
So, what if you took a number, say the number 2, and divided it in half. You would get 1 + 1 = 2 or, 1 x 2 = 2, correct? So, doesn't this suggest that either half of 2, is a subset of the whole of 2? Sure it does, so long as each half is considered in context with the whole. Hence we can say, 2 = 1 + 1 or, 2 = 1 x 2, correct? So, in what way does this differ with respect to the letter "E," in the equation E = MC2? How does "E" not refer to the whole, and the rest of the equation to the constituent parts thereof? Even if you were to say M = E/C2 or, C2 = E/M, it still shows that both are properties of "E."
(I haven't read throught this thread, so I apologize if I'm repeating points already made. This is in reponse to the OP)

2 and 1 are constants. 1 can only be considered a "subset" of 2 in the sense that you can group 1's together to get 2, but not the other way around. But that makes 1 a "subset" of every other positive integer, which is meaningless unless you're laying down some kind of foundational logic for a proof in number theory.

C is a constant.

E and M are variables. You can solve for either given the other. M is no more a "subset" of E than E is of M. They are related by a simple ratio.

In x=1/y, which is the "subset" of the other: x or y?
 
Iacchus:

E=M*c^2 could be described as a conversion formula. It allows you to describe matter in terms of energy and vice versa. Not unlike the following formula:

P=D*10^2

Where P= Pennies, D=Dollars

I suppose now you will argue for pages on how dollars are subsets of pennies.

LLH

Not just that, but like any mathematical operations involving two-term relationships, you can manipulate the terms to solve for different variables:

E = M*C^2
M = E/C^2
C = Sqrt(E/M)

Obviously Iacchus doesn't understand even the basic principles of mathematics...

The only 'whole' here is the entire relationship.
 
If I recall my high-school physics correctly (and that's a stretch - it's been 32 years!), the E=MC2 equation was actually written as: E0=M0C2. It showed that a change in energy was proportional to a change in mass at a rate proportional to C2. From this, it was possible to show that minute amounts of mass would convert to large amounts of energy. Equally, to convert energy to mass would require "some effort" to accomplish (but don't tell the homeopaths! ;)).
Well actually no.

[latex]E^2 = M^2 c^4 + p^2 c^2[/latex]

is the real equation, where p is the momentum. If the mass is at rest then p=0 and therefore the equation reduces to

[latex]E_0 = M_0 ^2 c^2[/latex] where [latex]M_0[/latex] is called the rest mass.

The change in energy would be expressed as [latex]\Delta E = \Delta M c^2[/latex]
 
I'll take your word for it, Diamond! As I said, it was some time ago, and I was working from memory...
 
2 and 1 are constants. 1 can only be considered a "subset" of 2 in the sense that you can group 1's together to get 2, but not the other way around. But that makes 1 a "subset" of every other positive integer, which is meaningless unless you're laying down some kind of foundational logic for a proof in number theory.
Well yes, in terms of a specific group or bundle ... which, is really all you're doing when counting anyway, counting specific integers of that group.
 
Last edited:
Ok.........

I'm not a math whiz, but I can't get that last post to parse in any way that makes sense.

Or am I just dense, here?
 
Well, I just reworded it and hopefully it will make more sense now? Basically I agree with what he/she says, except the part about it being meaningless. Granted it would be, if numbers weren't used to represent something in actuality.
 
So how do you fit the equation you keep quoting into this?

E = MC2
This implies that energy and matter are interchangeable.

That means that "matter cannot be created nor destroyed" as well. :)
Which of course suggests nothing about that which existed "before" the Big Bang. Unless of course you're saying that matter and energy were "created" at the moment the Big Bang occurred. But then again by a beginning, in a Universe which, is deemed to be "temporal," doesn't that also imply an end? So, what happens to matter and energy at this point?
 
Last edited:
Let's put it this way, if there was no "before the big bang" then there was no time at which there was no matter or energy.

So since we never went from no matter (or no energy) to matter (or energy), they can't be said to have been created.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom