Does E = MC2 ... Or What?

You really need to look at Diamond's link, then.

Thanks, Diamond, that was extremely cool...

Sorry, I realise that the equation does in fact explain a lot about the universe, I meant to say why do people think it solves philosophical problems. It doesn't do much for me becuase I don't work with in physics, which is where it belongs, not out in woo-woo land. The equation itself I do admire, especially after seeing a derivation of it and the thought experiment behind it.
 
Belz... said:
ONLY, Iacchus, and only if you keep the equation as "E=MC²". If you convert it (have you EVER done maths ?) to "M=E/C²" then what you said doesn't mean a thing.
You haven't quite got to where Iacchus's head is on this.
Iacchus said:
Yes, but by the equations shown, both C and M are derived by the division of E ... which, of course constitues "the whole."
He thinks that because you're dividing E to arrive at M, them M is part of E. He's actually used the analogy of cutting up a pie for this!

That's what I did all that faffing around with the equations for him.

:hb:
 
He thinks that because you're dividing E to arrive at M, them M is part of E. He's actually used the analogy of cutting up a pie for this!

Must've missed that line. Doesn't he also think that because E is on the other side of the regular equation, it's the whole as well ??


Hey, Iacchus!!

How about "1=MC²/E" ? Is E now a subset to 1 ?
 
Last edited:
Doesn't he also think that because E is on the other side of the regular equation, it's the whole as well ??
I wouldn't like to guess at what he actually thinks.

Or whether he thinks, for that matter. In the other thread he's just gone from a pack of cigarettes to a pack of wolves, presumably because they both involve the word "pack".
 
Iacchus,

So why do monster truck tires cost so much more than regular truck tires?
 
Iacchus,

What are the units of E, m, and c?

Are you interpreting the equal sign as 'is' or as 'is equivalent to'?

It may help you to think of the equation E=mc2 in terms of conversion:

* if I convert X units of mass into energy, how much do I get?
* if I convert Y units of energy into mass, how much do I get?
 
Anyone care to argue that we should restate the First Law of Thermodynamics to "Matter cannot be created nor destroyed"?

I must have missed the answers to this question.


Iacchus, the first law is "Energy cannot be created nor destroyed".
 
I must have missed the answers to this question.


Iacchus, the first law is "Energy cannot be created nor destroyed".
You did not follow Diamond's link, then.

Sheldon Glashow
Theoretical Physicist
Boston University

This is the 100th anniversary of Einstein's development of the special theory of relativity and so, of course, I went back and looked at his original papers, at least translated into English. And it really is amazing. The paper that he wrote in September of 1905 developed a basic idea of E = mc2, except it was more M=e/c2, same equation. But he argued in this paper that when an object emits light, say a flashlight, it becomes lighter, that the decrease in mass would be equal to the amount of energy radiated, divided by the square of the speed of light. And that was kind of a separate development in addition to the theory of relativity, and it is central, because what I'd like people to understand is that once upon a time there was a law of conservation of mass. Lavoisier, in the 1700s, showed that when you have chemical reactions, the mass of the reactants is the same as the mass of the final products. That was a keystone to science, and a second keystone was the law of conservation of energy developed in the 19th century.

And what E = mc2 does is tell us that both of those laws are wrong—mass changes. When I combine hydrogen and oxygen to make water, the mass of the water is not equal to the mass of the hydrogen and oxygen. It's a little bit less. And when you take water apart into hydrogen and oxygen, the mass of the hydrogen and oxygen is a little tiny bit greater than the mass of the water, and that difference is the amount of energy that you supplied to take the water molecules apart.
So this is a pretty trivial effect. Lavoisier couldn't possibly know this, because it occurs in the 10th decimal place ordinarily. If you burn a ton of fuel, maybe a few micrograms of matter disappear and are converted into energy, so you don't notice it. You do notice it at nuclear reactors. There, a significant fraction of the mass is converted into energy. And you certainly notice it at particle accelerators, where we convert energy into mass.
(emphasis mine)

Isn't science cool?
 
I see Iaachus is still clinging tenatiously to that Planck quote which seems to have no conclusive source. Many quotes are attributed to people who never made them but yet are accepted as fact by the heathen masses.
"I smell bad and only have one testicle." - Iacchus. I don't recall the source of the quote, but I read it on the intryweb so it must be true.
Iaachus is doing what every hack writer, con artist or Dada artist does, steal little bits and pieces from disparet sources with no reguard to understanding, context or meaning and mashing them together and hope the viewer or listener will infer their own meaning and buy into it thinking that all the pretty images or big important sounding words are meaningfull and ligitimate.
To be fair, that's not quite accurate. Dada artists were challenging the concept of "Meaning" as it applies to Art and the validity of Inherent vs. Perceived Meaning; as well as the very definition of "Art" itself.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom