Does E = MC2 ... Or What?

I see Iaachus is still clinging tenatiously to that Planck quote which seems to have no conclusive source. Many quotes are attributed to people who never made them but yet are accepted as fact by the heathen masses.

Iaachus is doing what every hack writer, con artist or Dada artist does, steal little bits and pieces from disparet sources with no reguard to understanding, context or meaning and mashing them together and hope the viewer or listener will infer their own meaning and buy into it thinking that all the pretty images or big important sounding words are meaningfull and ligitimate.
All razzle-dazzle and no substance. It's all conceptual slight of hand. Shifting definitions and redefinitions, liberal and literal abuse of analogies and metaphores, obfuscation with a wink of an eye.

It's the Iaachus snakeoil sideshow. Enjoy!
 
Anyone care to argue that we should restate the First Law of Thermodynamics to "Matter cannot be created nor destroyed"?
Would you care to clarify this a little? I'm by no means an astro-physicist, but you are referring to energy here aren't you? ;)
 
So I guess an online encyclopedia doesn't suffice? This is the original link that I posted by the way. Of course if this is not good enough, perhaps we could try looking it up in the Encyclopedia Britannica or something? I know they have an online version of it, but I think they charge you money for any in-depth research. Of course in the three or four hours that I've already spent looking into this damn thing, I haven't seen a single link that decries this quote a foul. So I really don't see what the big fuss is all about.
Actually, no, it is not good enough; you should know that already, as you have cited it many times, only to have the same questions come back. Note that the quote in the encyclopaedia article (from "Computer Desktop Encyclopedia") is not referenced. This is very strange--we would expect any direct quotes to have their original sources attributed, but this one is not. The definition from the source following the quote (from Columbia University Press) has three sources mentioned, but it does not use your quote. Indeed, none of the other sources (Houghton Mifflin, Wikipedia) mention your quote at all.

So, no, you do not have a source other than hearsay. Your encyclopedia source merely reports a widely spread quote attributed to Planck, but does not do the necessary work to verify. And since you, despite quite a bit of work, have also been unable to find a Planck source for this quote, we may begin to doubt it all the more.
 
E=mc2
What is it about this equation that makes people think it has the answers to universe? The only time I've ever used it was in physics lessons to calculate the mass change in nuclear fusion, where the original atom is less than the sum of its parts. Other than that I don't think it really does much for me.
 
Well I guess it will forever remain an enigma then ...

Quite possibly.

In large part, because it doesn't effin' matter anyway.

Planck might well have said it (in a poorly documented forum). To the best of our modern scientific understanding, if he said it, it was wrong.

Science relies on evidence and reason, not exgesis of the writings of Nobel laureates. We have little reason to believe the statement if Planck said it, and none at all if he didn't.
 
E=mc2
What is it about this equation that makes people think it has the answers to universe?
Just take a look at all the woo medicine that invokes some sort of undefined and undetectable "energy": homoeopathy, acupuncture, reiki, crystal therapy, TT...

That's when they're not claiming it's "quantum", of course. :oldroll:
 
The definition from the source following the quote (from Columbia University Press) has three sources mentioned, but it does not use your quote. Indeed, none of the other sources (Houghton Mifflin, Wikipedia) mention your quote at all.

So, no, you do not have a source other than hearsay. Your encyclopedia source merely reports a widely spread quote attributed to Planck, but does not do the necessary work to verify. And since you, despite quite a bit of work, have also been unable to find a Planck source for this quote, we may begin to doubt it all the more.
Oh, speaking of Wikipedia ....

The German version (presumably the original) is also abundantly quoted on the Web without citation, but several pages say that Planck said this in a talk entitled "Das Wesen der Materie" (the essence/nature/character of matter) he gave in 1944 in Florence:
While there seems to be just as many sites that claim he gave the speech in Florence as opposed to during his Nobel acceptance speach.
 
E=mc2
What is it about this equation that makes people think it has the answers to universe? The only time I've ever used it was in physics lessons to calculate the mass change in nuclear fusion, where the original atom is less than the sum of its parts. Other than that I don't think it really does much for me.
You really need to look at Diamond's link, then.
Diamond said:
The equation

[latex] E^2=m^2 c^4 + p^2 c^4 [/latex]

as explained by experts
Thanks, Diamond, that was extremely cool...
 
Oh, speaking of Wikipedia ....

While there seems to be just as many sites that claim he gave the speech in Florence as opposed to during his Nobel acceptance speach.
Your wiki page admits that the quote is without citation. As of April 2004, the last time someone wrote about it on Wiki, somebody offered to dig up a book by Planck and investigate. No word since then. Thus far, then, it is an unreferenced quote. No citation, no context, no way to judge.
 
From this thread

So, what if you took a number, say the number 2, and divided it in half. You would get 1 + 1 = 2 or, 1 x 2 = 2, correct? So, doesn't this suggest that either half of 2, is a subset of the whole of 2? Sure it does, so long as each half is considered in context with the whole. Hence we can say, 2 = 1 + 1 or, 2 = 1 x 2, correct? So, in what way does this differ with respect to the letter "E," in the equation E = MC2? How does "E" not refer to the whole, and the rest of the equation to the constituent parts thereof? Even if you were to say M = E/C2 or, C2 = E/M, it still shows that both are properties of "E."

So, if you insist on saying I am "quite simply wrong," please tell us how I am wrong or, admit that you have no means of refuting it, please.
__________________

To the Mods: Please understand that I'm trying to illustrate the relationship between matter and energy, and show how the patterns we see in nature occur as a result of the way energy is arranged, which then gives rise to the arrangement of matter. Or, simply put, the arrangement of energy is necessary for the arrangement of matter but, not the other way around.

Perhaps you can see the implications to Max Planck's quote in the other thread? ...

So basically what I'm asking, is there another reality or, spiritual reality if you will, that exists and manifests itself through what we deem the material reality?
Bravo, I_lackus, two fallacies wrapped into one post, sprinkle in more puerile arrogance, and you've got another I_lackus moron thread. Research the fallacies of composition and division.
 
This is a classic example of drawing importance by word equality.

The term energy is really important in physics. The word energy is used in woo-woo land. Therefore, energy is meaningful and technical and important in woo-woo land.

~~ Paul
 
E=mc2
What is it about this equation that makes people think it has the answers to universe? The only time I've ever used it was in physics lessons to calculate the mass change in nuclear fusion, where the original atom is less than the sum of its parts. Other than that I don't think it really does much for me.
It is the delusions of grandeur thing, I think. Einstein is known by nearly everybody and known to be d****d smart. Top him and you're on top. It is puerile, and probably certifiable. The deluded ones probably belong in the asylums with all those cats still standing around with their left hands behind their backs, and holding their right hands in the left sides of their shirts, y'know? At least they like to talk more than write.
 
A quote from Diamond's link:

Frank Wilczek
Theoretical Physicist
MIT

E = mc2 famously suggests the idea that you can get a lot of energy out of a small amount of mass. But that's not what Einstein had in mind, really, and you won't find that equation in the original paper. The way he wrote it was M = e/c2 and the original paper had a title that was a question, which was, "Does the inertia of a body depend on its energy content?" So right from the beginning Einstein was thinking about the question of could you explain mass in terms of energy.

What do you know, Iacchus? Apparently Einstein was seeing energy as a property of mass, and not vice versa. Kinda blows your whole "Energy is everything" proposition out of the water, doesn't it?

Or are you also a greater authority than Einstein. . . ?
 
No, it shows that everything is organized within the context of energy.

That's because that's what YOU want it to mean, Iacchus. But that's not what it means. And, by the way, if you want to take it litterally, that equation tells us how much energy we get by converting a certain mass INTO energy. By your logic, energy is a subset of matter.

It still doesn't explain how matter begins to structure itself. Where does the information come that tells it how to do this?

Again, you assume that energy existed before matter. How would you know this ?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom