Does E = MC2 ... Or What?

Let's put it this way, if there was no "before the big bang" then there was no time at which there was no matter or energy.

So since we never went from no matter (or no energy) to matter (or energy), they can't be said to have been created.
Which is to say matter and energy have always existed then, correct?
 
For as long as there was time. But that doesn't imply that time is infinite.
No, simply because the Big Bang implies the "beginning" of matter and energy. Or, would you suggest there was no beginning to time as well? If so, then what are we doing keeping a record of it?
 
Well, look at it this way: there was no time when there was no time.

(I think I'm getting the hang of this. ;) )
 
Which of course suggests nothing about that which existed "before" the Big Bang. Unless of course you're saying that matter and energy were "created" at the moment the Big Bang occurred. But then again by a beginning, in a Universe which, is deemed to be "temporal," doesn't that also imply an end? So, what happens to matter and energy at this point?

Iacchus.

If you want to know so much about the workings of the universe and all, why don't you look for serious, scientific articles about it ? I mean, instead of making up crazy theories and presenting them to us, here, as though you were one of the great thinkers of humanity.
 
No, simply because the Big Bang implies the "beginning" of matter and energy. Or, would you suggest there was no beginning to time as well? If so, then what are we doing keeping a record of it?

Time has a "beginning", but there's no way to put it into terms that make sense for a human, because there's no way to imagine timelesness.
 
Iacchus.

If you want to know so much about the workings of the universe and all, why don't you look for serious, scientific articles about it ? I mean, instead of making up crazy theories and presenting them to us, here, as though you were one of the great thinkers of humanity.
Boy, if that were the case, I must be then, huh? :D
 
Perhaps it's important for you folks to understand one thing. Existence is being, and being has always been ... eternal that is.
 
Iacchus; The old physics definition of matter is along the lines of 'Matter is anything that has mass and takes up space'. A better concept is that entities that travel at speeds less than c exhibit mass, M.

E=Mc**2 links E (which represents entities that travel at the speed of light) with the alternative, mass. E and M together represent the reality scientific empiricism can address.

Dualism imputes some "supernatural" something, and since anything that effects or affects reality is by scientific definition impossible, dualism is illogical. The choice of monism, EandM (materialism) or ~EandM (idealism) defines the most basic attribute of reality (ontology) for any of us. Philosophically the Cartesian split, Body, or Mind, is one way to state it.


As to Time, that remains one of the deepest mysteries for physicists as well as for the rest of us, and no good answers exist to address the topic.

Just my 2cts ...
 
Iacchus; The old physics definition of matter is along the lines of 'Matter is anything that has mass and takes up space'. A better concept is that entities that travel at speeds less than c exhibit mass, M.

E=Mc**2 links E (which represents entities that travel at the speed of light) with the alternative, mass. E and M together represent the reality scientific empiricism can address.
This still doesn't address the nature of structure does it? At what side of the speed of light does structure begin? Does it take its cue from the one side, and begin to acrue (take mass) on the other?

Dualism imputes some "supernatural" something, and since anything that effects or affects reality is by scientific definition impossible, dualism is illogical. The choice of monism, EandM (materialism) or ~EandM (idealism) defines the most basic attribute of reality (ontology) for any of us. Philosophically the Cartesian split, Body, or Mind, is one way to state it.
And what if "God" were that singularity from which all "things" proceed?

As to Time, that remains one of the deepest mysteries for physicists as well as for the rest of us, and no good answers exist to address the topic.
Yes, but isn't time just like any other "tool" -- and/or mechanism -- which, when not in use, need not be displayed?

Just my 2cts ...
Thanks.
 
Last edited:
You want me to seriously address an assertion that offers no reason that anyone should take it seriously?

If you want a serious reply, try to actually offer a serious post.

In other words, why should I believe you when you say "Existence is being, and being has always been ... eternal that is."?
 
And what if "God" were that singularity from which all "things" proceed?

Lately I have become convinced that it is my new alarm clock that has created the complex matrix behind the physical universe.
So, what if my new alarm clock were that singularity from which all things proceed?

And is my question any more or less meaningful than yours?
 
You want me to seriously address an assertion that offers no reason that anyone should take it seriously?

If you want a serious reply, try to actually offer a serious post.

In other words, why should I believe you when you say "Existence is being, and being has always been ... eternal that is."?
Well, would you have us believe that it all came from nothing? What else are you proposing then?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom