Debunking the Stundies - March Edition

@ Thread

I have been carrying out some ongoing experiments for the last week or so which I would like to publish my initial results on the second one...

Experiment 2

I put a gallon drum of water in our shaded garden shed two days ago and on a daily basis measured the temperature of the water when the outside temperature was between 20 and 22 degrees C (We are having a hotter than average Spring over here). Using the Temperature of the water as a guide to a change in its thermal energy state I made the following preliminary observations.

Obs Temp (degrees C)
1.1 18.6
2.1 18.5

Early days yet but I'll keep observing.

Obviously, Mrs Rea is not scientific and thought I was mad but, she soon latched onto it when she realised money was involved and expects us now to save thousands of pounds sterling on our heating bills simply by waiting for a spontaneous increase in the thermal energy.
 
William Rea... what is your hypothesis for the pebble experiment? Do you expect the pebble to randomly levitate itself above the ground at some point? Or do you expect it to remain where it is?

What do you hope to learn through doing this experiment?

-Gumboot
 
@ Anti-Sophist

If you are still lingering in this thread I would appreciate some commentary on the diagram in the attached link.

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=2491662#post2491662

The diagram is from a Bazant Paper presented at the 15th U.S. National Congress of Theoretical and Applied Mechanics.



You just don't know when to quit, do you?

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=2491690#post2491690


They're forces, dude! Just accept it! Get over it! You're at rock bottom, stop digging!
 
@ Anti-Sophist

If you are still lingering in this thread I would appreciate some commentary on the diagram in the attached link.

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=2491662#post2491662

The diagram is from a Bazant Paper presented at the 15th U.S. National Congress of Theoretical and Applied Mechanics.
Why is Jew Hating in your avatar?

Are you protesting the Red Cross, or knocking idiot neoNAZIs.

Who are the Jew Hating idiots you are protesting?

Why does an engineer have so many problems with gravity and physics. (dynamics)
 
This ended up in the AAH thread along with some other posts and I couldn't figure if it was in there because it was missed by the Mod at the end of a string of posts. I will post it in here again in the hope that it was an Admin error to move it.

@ Thread

I have been carrying out some ongoing experiments for the last week or so which I would like to publish my initial results on the first one...

Experiment 1

A pebble of mass 0.25kg was placed on the ground in my back yard. On a twice daily basis the height of the pebble from the ground was observed for any changes that might indicate a change in the GPE state of the pebble. The pebble is 0.01m high so the measurement of the initial height hi was taken from its centre of mass at 0.005m high. The results to date are as follows...

Obs Height
hi 0.005m
1.2 0.005m
2.1 0.005m
2.2 0.005m
3.1 0.005m
3.2 0.005m
4.1 0.005m
4.2 0.005m
5.1 0.005m
5.2 0.005m
6.1 0.005m
6.2 0.005m

Obviously, it is early days yet but I would like to ask the more scientific on here if they could run this experiment concurrently with me. I am wondering if a pebble of much smaller mass might statistically be more likely to achieve greater than 0.005m height (from centre of mass). I may start to take temperature tests of the surface of the pebble to see if the heat energy of the sun might be affecting the experiment, any theories on that? I am also wondering if my measuring equipment might not be accurate enough to measure the change in height that would result from any spontaneous flow of GPE into the the pebble.
Why is Jew Hating in your avatar?

Are you protesting the Red Cross, or knocking idiot neoNAZIs.

Who are the Jew Hating idiots you are protesting?

Why does an engineer have so many problems with gravity and physics. (dynamics)

rocks?
 
Last edited:
@ Anti-Sophist

If you are still lingering in this thread I would appreciate some commentary on the diagram in the attached link.

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=2491662#post2491662

The diagram is from a Bazant Paper presented at the 15th U.S. National Congress of Theoretical and Applied Mechanics.

As has apparently already been pointed out, the quantities in the red box appear to be forces, which are vectoral in nature. The force due to gravity is mg, where g is a vector. Therefore the force is also a vector as a scalar multiplied by a vector remains a vector. By an identical analysis we were able to determine that energy is not a vector because it consists of a scalar mulitplying the dot-product between two vectors. This quantity must be scalar.

Energy is nothing but the dot product of a force with a displacement. This always results in a scalar quantity. The physics of forces is well understood and it's interation with (scalar) energy is also well understood.

I fail to see the relevance to the discussion of the concept of "vectoral energy". Are you implying that there is some relationship between forces and "vectoral energy"? And I repeat, there's nothing inherently wrong with "vectoral energy" other then the fact that there are no useful laws of physics that govern it's behavior. Furthermore, the entire presmise of the discussion is the ignorance that it belies when one tries to use the laws governing scalar energy to "vectoral energy".
 
Last edited:
It appears as though he is in the process of constructing some sort of strawman that will have something to do with spontaneous changes in energy.

:con2:



To me it looks like he's taking some lessons from the Creationists. His pebble in the garden experiment is a lot like the tornado in the junkyard in concept.
 
As has apparently already been pointed out, the quantities in the red box appear to be forces, which are vectoral in nature. The force due to gravity is mg, where g is a vector. Therefore the force is also a vector as a scalar multiplied by a vector remains a vector. By an identical analysis we were able to determine that energy is not a vector because it consists of a scalar mulitplying the dot-product between two vectors. This quantity must be scalar.

Energy is nothing but the dot product of a force with a displacement. This always results in a scalar quantity. The physics of forces is well understood and it's interation with (scalar) energy is also well understood.

I fail to see the relevance to the discussion of the concept of "vectoral energy". Are you implying that there is some relationship between forces and "vectoral energy"? And I repeat, there's nothing inherently wrong with "vectoral energy" other then the fact that there are no useful laws of physics that govern it's behavior. Furthermore, the entire presmise of the discussion is the ignorance that it belies when one tries to use the laws governing scalar energy to "vectoral energy".

In the context of our previous discussions and upon reflection I think I jumped into that Bazant example too early. I still believe that the way he used those terms (mg instead of F) was to acknowledge the energetic relationships in the system which he does elaborate on in the paper but, I accept the strict notation of the example makes it Force driven. I guess that being isolated from Academia and not having done Post-Graduate studies I am not in the habit of using that notation system.

I disagree with your second paragraph on the basis that the definition you give is the classic definition for Work, this has been quoted to me in previous posts. The more universal definition I understand for Energy is the capacity for doing Work. I don't consider myself a Physicist but the Force acting over a Distance definition rang alarm bells and I assumed it was a definition of energy peculiar to pure Physics. Hence my comments regarding a "Newton-centric view of Energy", "Energy is not an abstract concept" and "in which scientific sense the term Energy was being used".

I don't suppose that thermodynamics is something that comes up much in here but I don't consider Energy to be defined only by the Work it can do. I see Energy as a "tangible" quantity, some of which is potentially available to do Work. Since Energy is a universal currency I don't see how that concept of Energy cannot apply to Physics as well.

Since I trust your posts I was merely trying to get a rational view of the example to check how far I was diappearing up my backside. :)

Thanks for taking the time to check it out for me.
 
Killtown post was clearly a good stundie, as is the pebble experiment 1.

Why is Jew Hating in William's avatar?

Is he protesting the Red Cross, or knocking neoNAZIs.
main.1172317457.jpg


Who are the Jew Hating people he is protesting in his avatar?
 
Last edited:
Physics is physics, and one of its characteristics is that it uses equations, as anti-Sophist pointed out. Some of the problems with your definition of energy is that you seem to be using terms in unfamiliar ways. Maybe if you stuck to equations we could figure out what you mean.
 
Killtown post was clearly a good stundie, as is the pebble experiment 1.

Why is Jew Hating in William's avatar?

Is he protesting the Red Cross, or knocking neoNAZIs.
[qimg]http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/z/user/5/7/5/1/1/main.1172317457.jpg[/qimg]

Who are the Jew Hating people he is protesting in his avatar?

Wild guess, the avatar was in response to accusations that had been levelled at him. That's what I assumed when I first saw it, but WR could tell you for sure. I don't think the avatar is accusing anyone of jew hating. Of course I may have missed the point of it entirely.
 
Physics is physics, and one of its characteristics is that it uses equations, as anti-Sophist pointed out. Some of the problems with your definition of energy is that you seem to be using terms in unfamiliar ways. Maybe if you stuck to equations we could figure out what you mean.

I couldn't agree more that using mathematical models is an integral part of science and engineering.

I can understand that this concept of "Vectoral Energy" as it is being described appears left field but I don't understand how my definition of Energy is left field? Could you show me some examples so that I can possibly address them?

My concept of "Vectoral Energy" is no more than fairly basic thermodynamics.
 
Wild guess, the avatar was in response to accusations that had been levelled at him. That's what I assumed when I first saw it, but WR could tell you for sure. I don't think the avatar is accusing anyone of jew hating. Of course I may have missed the point of it entirely.

You hit the nail on the head Pipirr.

Not that it is relevant to this thread in any way whatsoever but, as you seemed to be able to discern with relative ease in a single post the key word in the avatar is "Apparently". It is based upon the old Pepsi adverts (if you can recall them) and is an ironic take on many of the things I have been accused of in the past.

I think it goes well with my William Rea = Bill Rea = liBeRal user name.

The red cross on a white background is obviously the flag of my country of origin of which I am very proud.

Sorry that it's not a Conspiracy Theory.
 
Last edited:
I couldn't agree more that using mathematical models is an integral part of science and engineering.

I can understand that this concept of "Vectoral Energy" as it is being described appears left field but I don't understand how my definition of Energy is left field? Could you show me some examples so that I can possibly address them?

My concept of "Vectoral Energy" is no more than fairly basic thermodynamics.

Could you show the equations involving "Vectoral Energy" and how they work? I do not understand how this relates to basic thermo.
 
I disagree with your second paragraph...

My second paragraph was just expounding on how the gravitational force(mg) relates to gravitational potential energy (mg dot h). In this case, GPE -is- a dot product between force and distance. The nuanced distinction between energy and work doesn't exist when we are talking about gravity. However, you are correct that in the more general case, the ability to do work isn't the same as energy.

I don't consider myself a Physicist but the Force acting over a Distance definition rang alarm bells ....

I understand what you are saying, specifically that there is a fundamental difference between work and energy. There is, yes. But not when we are dealing with only gravity.

All energy can be equated to a force acting over a distance. While it's true that some kinds of energy (thermal, for instance), can't be litterally be broken down into a specific force over a specific distance, that doesn't mean that the thermal energy doesn't have an 'equivalent' that is force times distance. We can say this amount of thermal energy is this many Joules... which means it corresponds to this many Newtons over this many meters.

When we are talking about gravity, the concepts of work and energy are one and the same. The only time the nuanced distinction makes an apperance is when we start to add thermal energy into the mix (or thermal producing processes, like friction).
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom