Debunking the Stundies - March Edition

Well, you have to consider the evidence. I put it to you that the linked paragraph shows that he is not, in fact, able to speak (or at least, hear) English properly.

Uh-huh. But the point is that asking for a non-internet internet link is kinda like asking for a square circle, so I find it unlikely that he's that stupid. Though past experience with truthers now means that nothing would surprise me in that department.
 
Uh-huh. But the point is that asking for a non-internet internet link is kinda like asking for a square circle, so I find it unlikely that he's that stupid.



Well, I think it's just as stupid as being confused about how someone would be able to barbecue when their electricity was out. It shows a fundamental lack of understanding of how real things really work.
 
As with your original assumption, neglecting friction altogether simplifies...snip...Under that assumption, however, I posit that my post holds, and that "vectoral energy" doesn't make sense unless you 1) ignore the direction, or 2) say it's physics are wildly different from normal energy, most importantly, it is not conserved.

I have used your original quote and snipped it to maintain the integrity of the links between our posts. I appreciate that you have not been adversarial in your posts so, you probably would not interpret this negatively anyway but, I'm just kicking this off with an explanation as to why I have done it so you do not interpret this as me editing your post for nefarious reasons.

I enjoyed reading your "what if" analysis of energy as a vector. The conclusion I drew from it was that the Law of Conservation of Energy means that energy cannot be a vector since a change in direction would mean a change in energy. That was neat but, I have already accepted on here that energy is scalar by definition. I will explain this further later in this post.

After reading my posts it is probably no surprise to you if I said that I find the concept of the Stundies offensive, maybe that's just me being over sensitive. In "real life" I am a concilliatory person rather than confrontational and in my daily work I try to work to the ideal that everyone has a right to make an error once in a while and that very few people intend to make an error. In that respect if we put all our mistakes on a notice board at my workplace it would cover a wall in our facility. I don't see the need to do that and I actually find that the vast majority of people are very honest and don't need to be told they have made an error if you foster a no blame culture. In summary, the concept of the Stundies is alien to me in my professional life and I believe these type of concepts lead to negative attitude reinforcement.

I also have an awful habit of throwing things into the arena with minimum explanation during Team briefings to try to generate ideas and feedback. This doesn't work on internet forums, particularly in an adversarial setting so if I remain here I will avoid doing that in future.

One noticeable thing that did happen was the case of HeyLeroy in the March Stundies. The specifics are that he is a "skeptic" that got nominated. I spotted the difference in HeyLeroy's nomination immediately because I have seen this in my workplace. The younger Engineers will have an "in joke" with their team about something daft that one of them has done but, they are laughing with each other. If I spot "laughing at" then I am sure to say something to stop it as I consider it to be bullying and unethical.

I hope that will explain to you why I felt it necessary to give Griffin the benefit of the doubt even though I would probably agree with some that he is an eccentric Theologian not educated in Science or Engineering. Mistakenly and perhaps naively I thought that others might be persuaded to see what I percieved as an injustice so I took a more positive position (inspired by the Positivist attitude of The Almond) regarding his faux pas.

If I may, I would like to return to the starting point of this thread which by necessity repeats some of my previous points but I ask you to bear with me.

Originally Posted by David Ray Griffin
...gravitational energy, which is vertical...

My statement regarding Energy as tangible and not as an "abstract concept" was in response to several people posting straight Physics definitions of Energy only in terms of its potential to do Work through a Force acting over a Distance. I think I confused things somewhat by trying to explain that Energy "tangibly" exists and is not merely something that spontaneously comes into existence when it does Work. In other words I don't consider Energy to be a "God of the gaps" to explain why Work occurs. I felt that the pure definitions ignored other fields where Energy is a concept such as Thermodynamics which I have some experience of.

Perhaps I was being to indulgent of Griffin when I tackled his isolated statement from the point of view that Energy works between potential differences. Heat engines use the energy flow between the two potentials - Hotter and Colder (abstraction recognised in the terminology). Electrical circuits use energy flow between two potentials - Higher Voltage and Lower Voltage (abstraction recognised in the terminology). Kinetic Energy flows between two potentials Higher and Lower (abstraction recognised in the terminology).

No matter which direction the energy finally ends up flowing because of mechanistic designs, it's source is a contrast between two potentials or a direction.

In the simplest and purest case I can imagine of a steel ball bearing being dropped the source Energy is derived from the change in potential and this can only happen in one direction. I don't know of any case where having fallen the steel ball will spontaneously rise to a higher potential. I must take your point on board that this is a special case where our conceptual "Energy Vector" happens to be aligned with the Acceleration and Velocity.

Hope this helps.
 
Last edited:
The conclusion I drew from it was that the Law of Conservation of Energy means that energy cannot be a vector since a change in direction would mean a change in energy.

Indeed.

After reading my posts it is probably no surprise to you if I said that I find the concept of the Stundies offensive
Fair enough.

Mistakenly and perhaps naively I thought that others might be persuaded to see what I percieved as an injustice so I took a more positive position (inspired by the Positivist attitude of The Almond) regarding his faux pas.
Specifically, I disagree that this is a faux pas by Griffin and instead believe he is fundamentally ignorant of the basic concepts involved. When I say something falls at "freefall speed" it's technically incorrect and what I mean is that it falls at an acceleration equal to the acceleration due to gravity. Taken alone, this is a faux pas. If the rest of my argument makes sense, you "know what I meant" and we move on.

However, if I take it one step further and say that an object was falling at "freefall speed" and fell 10 floors in 1 seconds, so in 10 seconds, it should fall 100 floors, you'd rightly say "No, that's completely wrong". My faux pas has become fundamentally wrong and based on a severe ignorance of the physics going on.

Griffin does precisely this when he tries to apply his "vectoral energy". He goes from making a simple faux pas to demonstrated fundamental ignorance of the physics being discussed.

Let me explain..
Originally Posted by David Ray Griffin
...gravitational energy, which is vertical...
He is trying to say that gravity alone cannot provide the lateral forces necessary. He leaves out his implied (and very wrong) assumption that "vectoral energy is conserved". In his mind, since GPE "points down", things need to go down, not sideways. In his mind, "vectoral energy" is conserved. "Downward pointing" energy can only result in "downward" things. As we've established fairly easily, the concept of "vectoral energy" is most certainly not conserved, therefore his entire argument is fundamentally flawed.

Even if we say, yes, the concept of vectoral energy exists, and yes GPE points down, it's completely incorrect to say that it is "conserved" and consequently cannot cause lateral "forces" or "releases" or whatever other term you want to use. It's fairly trivial, in fact, to show that "vectoral energy" can and does change direction under specific conditions. Therefore, the fact that GPE "points down" is meaningless when trying to remove gravity as the "original" source of energy for lateral movements in the tower collapse. This is exactly what Griffin is trying to do, and it's fundamentally wrong.

The real problem here isn't the concept of "vectoral energy" as much as it is trying to apply the physics of standard (scalar) energy to this "vectoral energy" concept. The ignorance isn't in saying that GPE "points down" as that is a forgivable mistake and I'd know what he meant if he was making a cogent argument. The problem is he's not making a cogent argument because he's trying to apply scalar energy laws to a made-up concept of "vectoral energy" to prove a point. His made-up concept does not follow the physical laws he's trying to apply to it.
 
Last edited:
Indeed...Snip...The real problem here isn't the concept of "vectoral energy" as much as it is trying to apply the physics of standard (scalar) energy to this "vectoral energy" concept. The ignorance isn't in saying that GPE "points down" as that is a forgivable mistake and I'd know what he meant if he was making a cogent argument. The problem is he's not making a cogent argument because he's trying to apply scalar energy laws to a made-up concept of "vectoral energy".

Snipped again.

I see your point. I think I wouldn't have had nearly as much problem with the nomination if the whole phrase had been used including the sideways ejection part and it had not been done within the framework of the Stundies.

I don't think we are actually a million miles apart here.

Thanks for the extremely patient and civil exchange, I have enjoyed it.
 
However, if I take it one step further and say that an object was falling at "freefall speed" and fell 10 floors in 1 seconds, so in 10 seconds, it should fall 100 floors, you'd rightly say "No, that's completely wrong". My faux pas has become fundamentally wrong and based on a severe ignorance of the physics going on.

I feel the invention of a freefall vector coming on!

Just Kidding :) .
 
can someone point out to me which way is vertical in this picture?

All vectors on a line passing through the center of that image are vertical.

Even more precisely, all vectors in the vector space with the center of that image as the origin are vertical.
 
Last edited:
Actually, since there is nothing in his post that implies anything else, I would say both possibilities are equally likely.

However, I don't see how Killtown could ask for a link for something that cannot possibly, by definition, have one, and still be able to speak English properly.



Speculation. :D



And I think you're using his confusion as the evidence you're looking for. Perhaps we should ask Killtown himself. He's probably weird enough to actually WANT the stundie.



What is that ? An argument from godzilla-sized strawman ?



Oh, but then he would've had to say "Can you provide a link to a "normal" video ?" He didn't say that, did he ?

You're trying to make something that is vague, crystal clear. Precisely what some of us are accusing CTers of doing with their fuzzy pictures.

There's really not much I can say here that I haven't already addressed...I will clarify some things though:

1) Saying that you don't think that Killtown was asking for a link to a non-internet video because you don't believe Killtown would be stupid enough to ask for a link to a non-internet video is pretty much a textbook case of the argument from incredulity. Not speculation on my part.

2) My comment that the everything that Killtown has written could be a joke wasn't a strawman argument. It was a perfectly valid description of how things could be - we cannot say for certain that this is NOT the case. The example was meant to highlight the fact that when there is a far and away more probable explanation for a comment, it is perfectly valid to assume that the more probable explanation is the correct explanation.

As for why this is the more probable explanation - I've already gone over this in my previous posts to William. There doesn't seem to be anything you've brought up that I haven't already addressed in my analysis.



And as a favour, in case William has put me on ignore, could someone please quote the posts I wrote to him. He seems to think that if he ignores that he's been exposed as a liar it will go away. This is not the case.
 
There's really not much I can say here that I haven't already addressed...I will clarify some things though:

1) Saying that you don't think that Killtown was asking for a link to a non-internet video because you don't believe Killtown would be stupid enough to ask for a link to a non-internet video is pretty much a textbook case of the argument from incredulity. Not speculation on my part.

2) My comment that the everything that Killtown has written could be a joke wasn't a strawman argument. It was a perfectly valid description of how things could be - we cannot say for certain that this is NOT the case. The example was meant to highlight the fact that when there is a far and away more probable explanation for a comment, it is perfectly valid to assume that the more probable explanation is the correct explanation.

As for why this is the more probable explanation - I've already gone over this in my previous posts to William. There doesn't seem to be anything you've brought up that I haven't already addressed in my analysis.



And as a favour, in case William has put me on ignore, could someone please quote the posts I wrote to him. He seems to think that if he ignores that he's been exposed as a liar it will go away. This is not the case.
Killtown is one big stundie and not a very nice guy. Killtown makes up stuff about a 9/11 photo which shows the smoke from flight 93! It looks just like a aircraft smoke cloud you can find many times over on the internet from airbus accidents to B-52 accidents. Almost an exact match for how a crash smoke rising looks like.

Killtown asking for a internet link to a physical video tape would be a good studie, unless he was searching to buy the physical tape. STUNDIE nomination approved! No opinion, just facts. John Swift would agree.

Does William still post here? He likes opinions and would enjoy posting over at LC. http://z10.invisionfree.com/Loose_Change_Forum/
 
can someone point out to me which way is vertical in this picture?
attachment.php
Which system do you want?

12447462057fe3f855.gif

What was your question?
 
And as a favour, in case William has put me on ignore, could someone please quote the posts I wrote to him. He seems to think that if he ignores that he's been exposed as a liar it will go away. This is not the case.



It won't help. He clearly doens't have me on ignore, yet he still isn't bothered by having his lies pointed out. Only the "disrespect".
 
I enjoyed reading your "what if" analysis of energy as a vector. The conclusion I drew from it was that the Law of Conservation of Energy means that energy cannot be a vector since a change in direction would mean a change in energy.

Is this an explicit admission that you were wrong?

If so, then I am satisfied. There is no need to answer any of the other questions I asked, (unless of course you wish to do so anyway).

The two main points I was trying to make by starting another thread still stand, however.

1) Unless we can agree to a common language for describing physics concepts like "energy," "moment of inertia" and such, then I am not going to return to the WTC thread where we both posted some images. I have neither the interest or the energy (hah! a little joke there) to go off on tangents like this 'energy is a scalar' every fifth post or so.

2) In my opinion, a formal education in science/engineering is irreconcilable with such things as the need to convince you that energy is a scalar and chipmunk stew needing to clarify what he meant by 'momentum' as differentiated from 'kinetic energy.' If you don't wish to post your credentials, that's fine with me - simply say so rather than becoming disproportionally offended by the question. I will simply voice the assumption that I am not the only one on this forum to feel this way - and predict that these are not the last such arguments, disagreements and miscommunications you will face here so long as you insist on using words and asserting concepts that fly in the face of well defined standard science.
 
All vectors on a line passing through the center of that image are vertical.

Even more precisely, all vectors in the vector space with the center of that image as the origin are vertical.

What if the picture was taken from the surface of the Moon?
 
Is this an explicit admission that you were wrong?
...snip...so long as you insist on using words and asserting concepts that fly in the face of well defined standard science.

The full quote with the part you chose to leave out..

Me said:
I enjoyed reading your "what if" analysis of energy as a vector. The conclusion I drew from it was that the Law of Conservation of Energy means that energy cannot be a vector since a change in direction would mean a change in energy. That was neat but, I have already accepted on here that energy is scalar by definition. I will explain this further later in this post.

I have stated my credentials at least three times on this forum, the last time being in this very thread...

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=2507410#post2507410

I cannot state any more than that since the industry I work in is extremely specialist, and any further information will compromise my anonymity.

I am not forcing you to go to any forum on here and reply to any of my posts. If you choose not to do so then I have no control over that, you are tapping the keys in front of you, not me.

Making the same post and asking the same questions over and over isn't going to change the answer, at some stage we will have to move on, I am choosing to do so. I am taking Fuelair's advice and will not be suffering fools gladly any more so, while I will not put you on ignore, I will not respond to any posts by yourself or any of the others who know who they are. All of you can take this as some kind of moral victory or vindication if it gives you that kind of pleasure, that is completely your prerogative. I personally think that says more about you than it does me.

I was always taught that asking for clarity is fundamental. If you don't understand the question then there is no point giving an answer. Apparently on here it is a Cardinal sin, go figure.

As I have also said many times on here, if you don't believe the sincerity of my posts then we have nowhere else to go. We are unable to make eye contact or see each others body language to get indicators so all we have is the trust. Without it corresponding is pointless.
 
Last edited:
What if the picture was taken from the surface of the Moon?

It's fairly trivial to define a "vertical" (vertical, of course, being the direction that the object will 'fall') vector for any point in the universe as a function of it's location and the location of all the mass in the universe.
 
The full quote with the part you chose to leave out..
I enjoyed reading your "what if" analysis of energy as a vector. The conclusion I drew from it was that the Law of Conservation of Energy means that energy cannot be a vector since a change in direction would mean a change in energy. That was neat but, I have already accepted on here that energy is scalar by definition. I will explain this further later in this post.

Curiously, your full quote does nothing to change my question.

Is this an explicit admission that you were wrong?

Since Mr. Rea has publicly noted that he will not be responding to my posts, I'll simply summarize the relevant parts of the thread and let any readers decide for themselves (Follow the quote links for Mr. Rea's full posts)

Gravitational Potential Energy acts and releases in a vectorial manner.

In comment to your post, I am being told that energy has no vectoral element so it appears that whilst it is apparent that everyone knows that gravitational energy makes stuff fall down this is simply not so.

I am saying that energy has a vectoral quality, specific examples being that gravitational energy can only be released in one direction which is commonly referred to as vertical

B. I haven't claimed that energy isn't scalar, I simply asserted that it has a sense of direction like a vector and no one as yet has shown me that it doesn't.

I still contend that whatever euphemism you use gradient or vertical there is an instinctively directional or vectorial nature to energy.

In fact Energy has a direction which is towards equilibrium.

And then back to ...

The conclusion I drew from it was that the Law of Conservation of Energy means that energy cannot be a vector since a change in direction would mean a change in energy.





And just for completeness...

Be reassured that if I am wrong I apologise, I have a record for doing this on the forum, in fact I believe that I am probably one of a handful of people on here with the humility to do so when proven wrong.
 
This ended up in the AAH thread along with some other posts and I couldn't figure if it was in there because it was missed by the Mod at the end of a string of posts. I will post it in here again in the hope that it was an Admin error to move it.

@ Thread

I have been carrying out some ongoing experiments for the last week or so which I would like to publish my initial results on the first one...

Experiment 1

A pebble of mass 0.25kg was placed on the ground in my back yard. On a twice daily basis the height of the pebble from the ground was observed for any changes that might indicate a change in the GPE state of the pebble. The pebble is 0.01m high so the measurement of the initial height hi was taken from its centre of mass at 0.005m high. The results to date are as follows...

Obs Height
hi 0.005m
1.2 0.005m
2.1 0.005m
2.2 0.005m
3.1 0.005m
3.2 0.005m
4.1 0.005m
4.2 0.005m
5.1 0.005m
5.2 0.005m
6.1 0.005m
6.2 0.005m

Obviously, it is early days yet but I would like to ask the more scientific on here if they could run this experiment concurrently with me. I am wondering if a pebble of much smaller mass might statistically be more likely to achieve greater than 0.005m height (from centre of mass). I may start to take temperature tests of the surface of the pebble to see if the heat energy of the sun might be affecting the experiment, any theories on that? I am also wondering if my measuring equipment might not be accurate enough to measure the change in height that would result from any spontaneous flow of GPE into the the pebble.
 
I'd love to help you there Bill, but I live on the second floor of a block of flats. So all the pebbles around here have all the GPE they need.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom