Debunking the Stundies - March Edition

William, you have been online and posting in this very thread, but you have ignored my post here:

William:

You've clearly been around these parts, and it was you who started this thread in the first place.

As such, I'm going to ask you politely now - please apologise for your attempt to deliberately mislead the other members of this forum, and please retract your accusation that The Stundies are all about ad hominem attacks. Also please retract your specific accusations about the two nominations you set out to debunk, as it has been fairly clearly shown that you were wrong about both of these things.

I take personal offense to this, as it was me who organised the March Stundies (and likely the April ones too the way things are going), and I took care to eliminate exactly the types of things you have accused me (yes, me) of including in the finals.

Before you even started this thread, there was already a discussion underway as to trial rules to set in place for the April Nominations. These have been put in place, and any nominations breaching said rules will be disqualified automatically.

I eagerly await your response.

Peace Out

Mobyseven

Would you please respond to this post? In case he has me on ignore, can somebody please quote this post for me?
 
Thank you for your reasoned response, it is very welcome and absolutely in keeping with how I'd like the thread to be.

I was sure when I visited the thread that I read it exactly as I quoted. I cannot get back into the original thread on LCF to check it again (it appears to be closed down). Without any further evidence to back me up I have no option but to agree with your analysis completely. Thank you for pointing this out in a very rational manner and please accept my apology for initially misleading you.

I fully agree with you that this apparent discrepancy on my part does not invalidate the rational argument that asking for a link to "normal" video does not qualify the nomination.

In addition, to reiterate what I have already said on here I do not use the ignore function.
 
I personally don't see any contradiction between saying that Energy is scalar and also saying that there are directional restrictions on how it can be turned into Work or Heat.

This is entirely correct. The missing ingredient is what those restrictions are and how they relate to energy. Namely, they don't relate to energy, at all. The directional restrictions come from the environment in the form of forces. The environment places the restrictions on how the energy can change forms.

It's important to keep the original point in mind when thinking about this, namely that the WTC towers couldn't have had lateral ejections because "gravitational energy points down". The problem is the GPE doesn't "point down" and the restrictions that define how the energy can change doesn't come from the nature of gravity, but from the nature of the building.

The wagon example provides an excellent example of how a slope uses a normal force (and newton's third law) to counteract the gravitational force, and consequently puts a net force on the wagon that causes the GPE to result in horizontal motion.

Purely as a point of interest, do you have any links for educational material on exchanges of photons and gravitons and an understandable explanation of Poynting Fields? I think my knowledge of Electromagnetics is way out of date.
Whoa, whoa. You know of a way to explain gravitons electromagnetically? That'd win you a nobel prize and a place near Einstein & Newton in the pantheon of Science :P

I'm afraid I see what's happening with this question and hope I'm not being too cynical. However, it appears you want to bring up the concept of Poynting vectors as a way of explaining vectoral-energy. Poynting is a vector that does correspond to energy-flux. Saying more is difficult w/o busting out the technical mathematical language. This is a non-trivial issue to tackle in any detail as it requires extensive use of vector-calculus (contour and surface integrals, and the associated differential operators). I fear, however, that this is a case of losing the forest for the trees if this is an attempt to make some justification for 'vectoral energy' because none of these concepts apply to gravity as the original statement intended.

If I've been too cynical and you really just wanted more information, I'd start here:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vector_calculus
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Flux
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Maxwell%27s_equations
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Poynting_vector
 
Last edited:
Whoa, whoa. You know of a way to explain gravitons electromagnetically? That'd win you a nobel prize and a place near Einstein & Newton in the pantheon of Science :P

It was just something I was working on in my spare time between sleep and my Patent Office job.;)

I'm afraid I see what's happening with this question and hope I'm not being too cynical. However, it appears you want to bring up the concept of Poynting vectors as a way of explaining vectoral-energy. Poynting is a vector that does correspond to energy-flux. Saying more is difficult w/o busting out the technical mathematical language. This is a non-trivial issue to tackle in any detail as it requires extensive use of vector-calculus (contour and surface integrals, and the associated differential operators). I fear, however, that this is a case of losing the forest for the trees if this is an attempt to make some justification for 'vectoral energy' because none of these concepts apply to gravity as the original statement intended.

If I've been too cynical and you really just wanted more information, I'd start here:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vector_calculus
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Flux
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Maxwell's_equations
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Poynting_vector

I wasn't intending to link Gravitons and Photons to Electromagnetism, I was just interested.

Your cynicism about Poynting wasn't wholly misplaced. I did start to think that way but quickly pulled back when I realised the detailed science of it was beyond me. I was looking for a conceptual overview of it because it seemed interesting.
 
This is entirely correct. The missing ingredient is what those restrictions are and how they relate to energy. Namely, they don't relate to energy, at all. The directional restrictions come from the environment in the form of forces. The environment places the restrictions on how the energy can change forms.

It's important to keep the original point in mind when thinking about this, namely that the WTC towers couldn't have had lateral ejections because "gravitational energy points down". The problem is the GPE doesn't "point down" and the restrictions that define how the energy can change doesn't come from the nature of gravity, but from the nature of the building.

The wagon example provides an excellent example of how a slope uses a normal force (and newton's third law) to counteract the gravitational force, and consequently puts a net force on the wagon that causes the GPE to result in horizontal motion.

I understand what you are saying but I don't see that these directional restrictions only result from human interventions. Even without the human interventions such as a slope or a building, energy has a natural direction. I see it in reverse, in that we exploit this natural direction to make energy work for us.

Forces result from the exploitation of energy, for instance, pulling a lever requires a Force but if I have no energy available to exert a Force then the Force cannot exist.

That is why I disagree with the assumption that Energy and Work can be interchangeable terms. Energy is the resource and Work is the amount of that resource that we can make use of by exploiting the natural phenomena of Energy.

I fully agree that it is absurd to propose that GPE could not have resulted in sideways ejections of material. I will also reiterate that if the proposed Stundie had encompassed this rather than what it did attack then I would probably only have a moral objection to it.

As it stands on its own the nomination is not justified in my opinion.
 
Your cynicism about Poynting wasn't wholly misplaced. I did start to think that way but quickly pulled back when I realised the detailed science of it was beyond me. I was looking for a conceptual overview of it because it seemed interesting.
A Poynting vector is intimately related to the subject of electromagnetic waves (ie, light). Therefore, in a very real sense we have a particular amount of energy and a particular direction associated with it. In fact, a light beam is about as good an example of "directed" energy as you are going to get.

I could give you a 1-page crash course on vector fields, flux integrals, the E field, the B field, maxwell's equations as applied to electromagnetic waves, and what a poynting vector is, roughly, but I'm not sure I'd do much better then wikipedia.

Forces result from the exploitation of energy, for instance, pulling a lever requires a Force but if I have no energy available to exert a Force then the Force cannot exist.

Every electron in the universe experiences a force from every proton in the universe (both gravitationally and electromagnetically). I'm not sure what 'energy' is needed to exert these forces. I think you may have this conceptually backward, namely, energy as a concept only exists because of the 4 forces, as opposed to the other way around. Without any forces, there'd be no energy.

That is why I disagree with the assumption that Energy and Work can be interchangeable terms. Energy is the resource and Work is the amount of that resource that we can make use of by exploiting the natural phenomena of Energy.
I have no problem with this. Work and energy are not the same thing in practice entirely because of the second law of thermodynamics. In our mental experiments, however, we have the power to suspend the second law and the distinction between the two becomes less apparent.

I fully agree that it is absurd to propose that GPE could not have resulted in sideways ejections of material. I will also reiterate that if the proposed Stundie had encompassed this rather than what it did attack then I would probably only have a moral objection to it.

As it stands on its own the nomination is not justified in my opinion.
As you might have guessed, I got involved in this conversation because it touches on a subject near and dear to me and I'm the intellectually adventurous type, not because I really care about humiliating CTists any more then they already humiliate themselves. I think it's safe to say I see both sides of the argument.
 
Every electron in the universe experiences a force from every proton in the universe (both gravitationally and electromagnetically). I'm not sure what 'energy' is needed to exert these forces. I think you may have this conceptually backward, namely, energy as a concept only exists because of the 4 forces, as opposed to the other way around. Without any forces, there'd be no energy.

I think you guessed exactly that I was thinking about the four forces in terms of any energy exchanges that occur when each of their specific virtual exchange particles interact. Perhaps the forces are the results of governed exchanges of packets of energy in these particles.

This is going way outside my knowledge so I don't see that I can take it any further than to speculate but it has inspired me to look a little deeper into the subject so that must be a result.
 
As you might have guessed, I got involved in this conversation because it touches on a subject near and dear to me and I'm the intellectually adventurous type, not because I really care about humiliating CTists any more then they already humiliate themselves. I think it's safe to say I see both sides of the argument.

I think your lack of emotional attachment to what I call the politics (small p) of it is clear and is actually very helpful.

You have certainly done more to convince me that this forum is not exclusively inhabited by rabidly political (small p) "skeptics". I know you don't want to get involved in that conversation but I thought it was worth saying to you anyway because you have been incredibly helpful and patient with me.

Thanks very much.
 
In addition, to reiterate what I have already said on here I do not use the ignore function.

Wonderful. So you're not not seeing the posts that disagree with you and present arguments against your position, you're seeing them and then wilfully choosing to ignore them.

As I've stated before I find your allegations insulting and offensive. If you can see my posts, the least you could do is respond.
 
Bump to accompany the March voting.

After everything you've done, do you really think that bumping this thread is going to help your cause?

You have now been shown in this very thread to have lied numerous times, and to have been wrong about the very things you were 'debunking'!

To reiterate CS's summary:

Sure. Let's review:

RE: Killtown quote (current votes: 6)--
You lied.

RE: Griffin quote (current votes: 0)--
You were wrong.

Nice job debunking the Stundies.

I'm getting very tired of this, William. You could at least be a man of your word and admit when you've done something wrong, or been wrong. Remember when you told us that?
 
After everything you've done, do you really think that bumping this thread is going to help your cause?

You have now been shown in this very thread to have lied numerous times, and to have been wrong about the very things you were 'debunking'!

To reiterate CS's summary:



I'm getting very tired of this, William. You could at least be a man of your word and admit when you've done something wrong, or been wrong. Remember when you told us that?

I think his best bet now is just to change his user account and avatar and pretend to be a newbe.
 
Apparently so....

Well then, to recap for those who are just joining the thread:

William alleges that The Stundies are no more than unwarrented ad hominem attacks that serve no purpose other than to ridicule the nominees.

This is not the case - in all the nominations, it is the argument, claim, or experiment that is being nominated for its less-than-well-thought-out reasoning. Not the poster. That some people are nominated more than others is what would be expected of such a competition, but nominations are not limited to conspiracy theorists - debunkers can be nominated also.

William further alleged that "at least two" of the March nominations are out-and-out ad hominems, and started this thread with the promise to 'debunk' The Stundies.

He started by 'debunking' the Killtown nomination for this month. However, he was caught out in the middle of a deliberate deception, having altered both the context of the nominated quote and the quote itself in order to strengthen his argument.

He also attempted to 'debunk' the David Ray Griffin quote, "...gravitational energy, which is vertical..." For those of you who are not particularly physically minded, it may help you to know that energy, by definition, is scalar - i.e. It has no direction, and cannot therefore be 'vertical'.

He has refused to acknowledge either his deception in the Killtown 'debunking' or his blatant mistake in the David Ray Griffin 'debunking'.

He also promised a while ago that he would be debunking a third March Stundie finalist. This has not happened.

That should about do it. I just thought that if William is going to be bumping the thread all the time to keep it near the Stundie voting thread, that someone should provide a run down of what actually happened in this thread.

Peace Out

Mobyseven
 
To any newcomer, as far as I am concerned this thread is now dead with the main arguments proven and little left to discuss except side issues. Some of the sidetracking has been interesting. I now eagerly await the April nominations which should soon supercede this, particularly as I have been nominated which could make it fun.

I won't personalise this or turn it into some kind of beauty contest but will leave it to you to read and decide who has put forward the credible rational argument.
 
William Rea said:
To any newcomer, as far as I am concerned this thread is now dead with the main arguments proven and little left to discuss except side issues. Some of the sidetracking has been interesting. I now eagerly await the April nominations which should soon supercede this, particularly as I have been nominated which could make it fun.

I won't personalise this or turn it into some kind of beauty contest but will leave it to you to read and decide who has put forward the credible rational argument.
I'm curious as to whether William will constantly try to get the last word here...lets test this.
In addition to my previous post, I would like to point out that William has been simply ignoring those who have engaged him in debate when he can no longer respond to them.
 
with the main arguments proven and little left to discuss except side issues. ...

leave it to you to read and decide who has put forward the credible rational argument.

I'm curious as to whether William will constantly try to get the last word here...lets test this.
In addition to my previous post, I would like to point out that William has been simply ignoring those who have engaged him in debate when he can no longer respond to them.



Now now, can't we agree that we've proven our points?

Perhaps we should create a poll, to see what others think on the question of "who has put forward the credible rational argument".
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom