Debunking the Stundies - March Edition

Could be...

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=2448632#post2448632

Or...

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=2480662#post2480662

Or...

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=2506344#post2506344

To be honest the only common definition I could find was that it was a chance to laugh at how stupid other people are, you can draw your own conclusion about the intent of the Stundies from that.

You can be as arrogant as you want, but if you're going to link to not one but three of my posts, you can sure-shooting bet I'm going to respond.

I those were the only definitions of The Stundie you could find I'm a bit shocked - it has been pointed out multiple times that they are a still evolving concept. I find it very interesting that you posted (with your third link) only two of the trial rules for The Stundie when on the very first page of that thread I clearly list a number of trial rules for April...

Let me point out some things you may have missed though...

Mobyseven said:
... they deal directly with stupid things said by conspiracy theorists...

So the nominations deal with the things that are said, not the people who said them. This has been broadened to include debunkers as well, as can be evidenced by the March Finalists.

Stundie Rules said:
Stundie nominations should 'stand alone'. Do not over-embellish introductions, but do provide comments. Do not use any blatant ad hominem attacks.

In other words, nominations must be about the actual thing being said and not the poster. Nominations must not even be accompanied by ad hominem comments.

From the third link again...

Mobyseven said:
Make sure that nominations are being posted because of the arguments or claims being put forward and not simply because you dislike the person.

And in regards to any ad hominem attacks that are posted...

Mobyseven said:
Be advised too that even if you do post such nominations here, they won't make it through to the final vote.

As for your second link - I don't think that posting the tongue-in-cheek in-joke ridden Stundie speech is entirely convincing as an argument. After all, it is a work of humor, not a strict definition of The Stundies.

Now, once again you seem to have missed my post from above. I'll repost it here:

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=2496528&postcount=79

William, you appear to have completely ignored my analysis here. Admittedly, this could be because I pointed out your complete intellectual dishonestly and requested an apology, but I suppose it is possible you just missed it on your way through.

I would like you to address this, and if you cannot, I would appreciate an apology both for the fact you deliberately tried to lie about the context of the quote and a retraction of your accusation that this is an ad hominem.

-------------------------------------------------------------------------

I would then like you to answer this question:

Is gravitational potential energy a vector?

All this requires is a yes / no answer.

If your answer is yes, then you will have to explain to us all how energy can be a vector, and how you came to this discovery that will overturn most of what we know about Newtonian physics.

If your answer is no, then I would appreciate a retraction of your accusation that, "...gravitational energy, which is vertical..." is an ad hominem attack.

-------------------------------------------------------------------------

Then, as you claimed to have found, "...at least two..." ad hominem attacks in the March Stundie Finalists, I would appreciate it if you could please continue to point out ad hominem attacks that are present there.

I imagine that I am not the only one who would like to see these things addressed, but I thought I'd break it down into sections for you for ease of reference.

Peace Out

Mobyseven

Would you kindly address the issues that have been raised here?
 
1. I have never claimed to be a Civil Engineer. I have no idea why I would need to be uniquely qualified as a Civil Engineer to understand this topic.

I stand corrected. I used the search engine for posts by you with "engineer" and too quickly latched on to your 'uncivil engineer' joke post. Nevertheless, the basic point stands. I have a difficult time reconciling the basic knowledge required to be any kind of engineer with the content of some of your posts.

A. I have not modified my position once.

Kinetic Energy = 0.5mv^2. Velocity has speed and direction.

I would say in this sense that energy has a direction

Reference post #88 above. If Gravitational Energy (remember the nomination said Gravitational Energy NOT Energy) is scalar then why is it proportional to a vectoral quantity?

I read these posts as you claiming that energy is a vector with both magnitude and direction.

I am saying that energy has a vectoral quality, specific examples being that gravitational energy can only be released in one direction which is commonly referred to as vertical, that thermal energy only flows from hot to cold.

Energy is scalar as far as the scientific and engineering community is concerned.

And I read this as backing off to saying "vectoral quality."

If I'm interpreting your posts incorrectly and you meant all along this "vectoral quality," my general point still stands. I can't reconcile the claim of being an engineer with this "energy has a directonal sense" notion.

B. I haven't claimed that energy isn't scalar, I simply asserted that it has a sense of direction like a vector and no one as yet has shown me that it doesn't.

1) Consider a wagon on a slope. If GPE "points down," and "releases vertically" why will the wagon move diagonally down the slope? There is no "horizontal component" to the GPE. Also, how does this "vertical energy" get converted into the rotational kinetic energy of the wheels? And which direction "vectorally" is that rotational KE pointing? For energy to have a "vectoral quality" and also be conserved, you'd better make those directions add up on both sides of the equation!

2) I have a AA battery on my desk. It has roughly 1000 Joules of chemical potential energy in it which will release when the battery is connected to an electrical circuit. In which direction is that chemical PE pointing?

3) There's an atom which is in an excited state; Namely one of its outermost electrons is in a "higher orbit" (The Bohr model is just fine here) than the ground state. In which direction is this excitation energy pointed?

4) There's a crate containing a ton of TNT explosives sitting in a field. In which direction is the chemical potential energy of the explosives pointing?

5) And while we're at it: Using conservation of energy, and without using forces forces, solve the one-dimensional perfectly elastic (no loss of energy) collision between two equal masses;

(M) --> V1 V2<-- (M)

Namely; solve for the velocity of one of the masses after the collision in terms of the mass M and the initial velocities V1 and V2.


In answer to your problem I would simplify it by taking a cross sectional view of the disc showing the direction of transfer of heat energy from the inner to outer edge.

In reference to my heating the center of a disc example, is this your claim? (I hope the ASCII art works out)
___________________
|_____<--*-->_____|

That the thermal energy in this case, which will move radially, has a "vectoral quality?" A vector cannot point in every direction (in the plane of the disk) at the same time. Alternately, if one integrates the sum of the "differential vectors" over all angles, guess what? The directions cancel out, and the thermal energy's "vectoral quality" sums to zero mangnitude.

C. I need you to clarify what you mean when you say I have mixed "work" and "energy" because I do not understand how you then extrapolate this to imply my education must be sub-standard in some way.

Actually it is the work that gravitational energy does on the mass that makes stuff fall down.

This makes no sense at all if one is using the terms "work" and "energy" in their scientific sense.

I am still willing to go through that excercise of modelling the WTC collapses, but not if we're going to have to argue like this over basic concepts and terminology.
 
Last edited:
4) There's a crate containing a ton of TNT explosives sitting in a field. In which direction is the chemical potential energy of the explosives pointing?


All of them!


In reference to my heating the center of a disc example, is this your claim? (I hope the ASCII art works out)
___________________
|_____<--*-->_____|

That the thermal energy in this case, which will move radially, has a "vectoral quality?" A vector cannot point in every direction (in the plane of the disk) at the same time. Alternately, if one integrates the sum of the "differential vectors" over all angles, guess what? The directions cancel out, and the thermal energy's "vectoral quality" sums to zero mangnitude.


Ah, nuts! Spoilsport!



I am still willing to go through that excercise of modelling the WTC collapses, but not if we're going to have to argue like this over basic concepts and terminology.



I think you'll have to wait. Mr. Rea has gone and gotten upset at us nasty people for pointing out his prevarications, and has decided that he should be the judge of what is civil discussion, and what is not.

Perhaps we could start listing the things that he considers to be "civil debate", just so we have a handle on it?
 
Which scientific sense do you wish to use?



How about:

In physics, mechanical work is the amount of energy transferred by a force. Like energy, it is a scalar quantity, with SI units of joules. Heat conduction is not considered to be a form of work, since there is no macroscopically measurable force, only microscopic forces occurring in atomic collisions. In the 1830s, the French mathematician Gaspard-Gustave Coriolis coined the term work for the product of force and distance.[1]

Positive and negative signs of work indicate whether the object exerting the force is transferring energy to some other object, or receiving it. A baseball pitcher, for example, does positive work on the ball, but the catcher does negative work on it. Work can be zero even when there is a force. The centripetal force in uniform circular motion, for example, does zero work because the kinetic energy of the moving object doesn't change. Likewise, when a book sits on a table, the table does no work on the book, because no energy is transferred into or out of the book.

When the force is constant and along the same line as the motion, the work can be calculated by multiplying the force by the distance, W = Fd (letting both F and d have positive or negative signs, according to the coordinate system chosen). When the force does not lie along the same line as the motion, this can be generalized to the scalar product of force and displacement vectors.
 
With respect, since your previous post was so disrespectful I am not inclined to answer you directly on this point. If you really wish to understand it then please read my correspondence with Mr D.


Wha...huh...bu...no...

Are you expecting to get a different scientific definition from Mr D., or are you just deliberately being difficult?

I notice that you are still ignoring my posts. Tell me, how does ignoring arguments strengthen your position?
 
With respect, since your previous post was so disrespectful I am not inclined to answer you directly on this point. If you really wish to understand it then please read my correspondence with Mr D.



Ah, I love how you use a facade of politeness to try and paint others in a bad light. What is "respectful" about manufacturing evidence and misrepresenting sources? What is "respectful" about trying to cover up your transgressions by equivocating about terms that have well-understood definitions?
 
...I have a difficult time reconciling the basic knowledge required to be any kind of engineer with the content of some of your posts.
I read these posts as you claiming that energy is a vector with both magnitude and direction.
And I read this as backing off to saying "vectoral quality."
If I'm interpreting your posts incorrectly and you meant all along this "vectoral quality," my general point still stands. I can't reconcile the claim of being an engineer with this "energy has a directonal sense" notion.

If you refer to my post at...

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=2510944#post2510944

Where I have already addressed this issue.

I had rather hoped that someone would have spotted this by now. Since it has not been taken on board I guess I will have to be more direct. The assumption about Griffin's statement is that there is only a Newton-centric (Physics) concept of Energy based upon Work which is considered as a Force acting over a Distance. In this definition Energy is not a tangible "thing" but only exists when a Force does Work on a Mass.

In fact Energy has a direction which is towards equilibrium.

I have no problem with viewing Work as being the result of humans using mechanisms to exploit this "directionality" of energy. Heat Engines exploit the flow of thermal energy through a working substance between a Hot and Cold (High and Low Energy) gradient. Interestingly the Efficiency of Heat Engines is measured in terms of this gradient.

I plead guilty to the charge of being vague and playing around with the Physics in a Devil's Advocate manner, as I said before, it has told me a lot about the forum.

I will take the liberty of addressing your scenario's one by one so as not to get in a confused mess, which may mean you have to wait a day or two for them.
 
Last edited:
1) Consider a wagon on a slope. If GPE "points down," and "releases vertically" why will the wagon move diagonally down the slope? There is no "horizontal component" to the GPE. Also, how does this "vertical energy" get converted into the rotational kinetic energy of the wheels? And which direction "vectorally" is that rotational KE pointing? For energy to have a "vectoral quality" and also be conserved, you'd better make those directions add up on both sides of the equation!

An interesting scenario and one which I expected to arise because of the horizontal element.

For convenience I will initially start by making the Closed System around the wagon. We can develop it from there but I would like to start basic if you have no objections. I will also assume that the datum is what we would commonly term the bottom of the hill.

Energetically (assuming there are neglegible frictional losses) the slope of the hill is meaningless and would be considered simply as a mechanism to convert the Energy from GPE into a useful direction to use the Kinetic Energy output for whatever reason we choose. This would be like any other mechanical construct that involves a wedge i.e. a screw thread.

The horizontal element therefore is a red herring.

The GPE in the Closed System will work on the mass converting to Kinetic Energy just as it would if falling directly.

Because of the slope the Power Output will reduce (the reverse effect of using the slope to enable us to lift the wagon more effectively).
 
Last edited:
An interesting scenario and one which I expected to arise because of the horizontal element.

For convenience I will initially start by making the Closed System around the wagon. We can develop it from there but I would like to start basic if you have no objections. I will also assume that the datum is what we would commonly term the bottom of the hill.

Energetically (assuming there are neglegible frictional losses) the slope of the hill is meaningless and would be considered simply as a mechanism to convert the Energy from GPE into a useful direction to use the Kinetic Energy output for whatever reason we choose. This would be like any other mechanical construct that involves a wedge i.e. a screw thread.

The horizontal element therefore is a red herring.

The GPE in the Closed System will work on the mass converting to Kinetic Energy just as it would if falling directly.

Because of the slope the Power Output will reduce (the reverse effect of using the slope to enable us to lift the wagon more effectively).
But in the real world, energy is lost through friction. Explain the conversion of the wagon's KE to heat/sound in terms of its "vectoral quality".
 
I am going to wade into this vectoral energy conversation late, having seen the other thread, and having read most of this thread. Please ignore me if I'm repeating myself or others.

First, let me start with the definition of energy. It's scalar. Everyone should agree on that. Similarly, all the physical laws of nature involving energy are defined using a scalar form of energy.

While it can be said that gravitational energy can only be "released" one way, that's a highly imprecise language compared with standard physics. There is no mathematical description for "energy release" along a vector. Similarly, any such quantity as "vectoral energy" or any such equations defining the actions of "vectoral energy" very much differ what what is known as energy.

In other words, on a semantic level alone, the concept of "vectorial energy" isn't energy. This alone doesn't make it meaningless or useless, just different. And different implies that none of the laws relating to energy apply to vectoral energy.


Also, I'd like to clear up some misconceptions from William from early on (I only read his posts, so if someone else corrected him, I might have missed it).

Are you saying gravitational energy has no directional sense?

Potential or Gravitational energy = mgh where g = acceleration. Acceleration is change in Velocity with time. Change in velocity can occur either by change in speed or direction. Gravitational Energy is derived from forces occuring between the centres of mass of two objects, that is a unidirectional relationship.

This is not technically correct and leads to a slightly wrong interpretation. In the equation mgh, g and h are not vectors, but magnitudes. The equation is technically m*||g||*||h||. I use bold for vectors and non-bold for scalars.

More accurately,
GPE = m(G dot H) where the acceleration due to gravity and the "height" are vectors. The dot product of two vectors is always a scalar. This equation demonstrates that there is no direction in the GPE. Consequently, the comment about acceleration also being a change in direction is true but irrelevant in this case. The dot product projects the acceleration due to gravity to a specific vector (no idea if you followed that... in other words... because G and H are gaurenteed to be measured along the same line, the projection of one onto the other is equal to the magnitudes (no direction) multiplied).

No aspect of the vectors involved (acceleration or displacement) "survives" the dot product.

Kinetic Energy = 0.5mv^2. Velocity has speed and direction.
Similarly, the equation for KE contains the term 'v' but that it is -not- a velocity vector. Kinetic energy's full equation (vectors bolded) is 1/2 (V dot V), which simplifies to 1/2 ||V||*||V|| because an identical vector always points in the same direction as itself. The dot product results in a scalar quantity, demonstrating the scalar nature of energy.

I would say in this sense that energy has a direction and is therefore able to be represented vectorally.
However, in that sense (the mathematical one, that is), the exact opposite is true. The directions "cancel", for lack of a better term, and the final unit has no direction.

In our world view Potential or Graviatational energy is described vectorally as acting vertically as opposed to horizontally.
But gravitational energy doesn't act in any direction as demonstrated above. If you have some alternate definition of gravitational energy which preserves direction, I'd like to see it. However, your new "vectoral energy" isn't the same as gravitational potential energy, and all the laws of physics that normal GPE applies to likely won't apply to your new vectoral version.

That is not to say there isn't some physical significance to a vector-energy. It certainly has some "meaning". The only question is what equations can you use to determine it's behavior. My suspicion is that such a quantity is fairly useless, but I might be wrong. The error comes when you try to apply normal physics of energy to "vectoral energy" as the very-original-post did.
 
Last edited:
Energetically (assuming there are neglegible frictional losses) the slope of the hill is meaningless and would be considered simply as a mechanism to convert the Energy from GPE into a useful direction to use the Kinetic Energy output for whatever reason we choose. This would be like any other mechanical construct that involves a wedge i.e. a screw thread.

The horizontal element therefore is a red herring.

The GPE in the Closed System will work on the mass converting to Kinetic Energy just as it would if falling directly.

This is all correct. Although you did neglect to mention that we also need to assume neglible energy loss to the rotation of the wheels of the wagon.

However, there is a keypoint in this thought experiment that you seem to be missing. At the start of your system, using vectoral-energy, you have X energy "pointing down" and at the end of your system you have X energy "pointing sideways".

Normal scalar energy is conserved such that we can say delta-E of our closed system is 0, or
Estart = Efinish, right?
We get X energy = X energy.
Great. Everything looks great.

In your vectoral-energy setup, you started with downwards energy and ended up with sideways energy. What happens if we try to conserve vectoral energy?

VEstart = VEfinish?
X to the left = X down, or,
(X,0) = (0,X), or,
Xi = Xj

In other words, "vectoral energy" is only conserved if left = down, or i=j, or x=y (or whatever your favorite coordinate system is). Vectoral energy isn't useful unless you ignore direction (hinting at the fact that energy is directionless). The problem isn't with the "vectoral energy" concept.. it's with the fact that it produces gibberish results when trying to apply normal energy concepts to it, unless you ignore direction.

This is the exact same mistake the original post made.
 
Last edited:
This is all correct. Although you did neglect to mention that we also need to assume neglible energy loss to the rotation of the wheels of the wagon.

Two good posts that I will need time to absorb before coming back to you fully.

Just as an aside, I believe I pointed out that I would initially assume any frictional losses to be neglegible and I was willing to carry on and analyse that energetically after looking at the significant factors.

Since you show good understanding of what I am alluding to I will add my thoughts now.

Because I assumed the wagon itself was a closed system then the kinetic energy of the wheels relative to the axles transforms to thermal energy which would be be output from the closed system as thermal energy. As per the slope I would consider the wheel bearings to be a mechanism that is energetically irrelevant except that it transforms the energy into a form that can cross the boundary of the closed system. In terms of friction between the wheels and the slope I would consider this the same way except that Work crosses the system boundary and is transformed into heat outside the closed system.

I would be very interested in your comments on the above.
 
Because I assumed the wagon itself was a closed system then the kinetic energy of the wheels relative to the axles transforms to thermal energy which would be be output from the closed system as thermal energy. As per the slope I would consider the wheel bearings to be a mechanism that is energetically irrelevant except that it transforms the energy into a form that can cross the boundary of the closed system. In terms of friction between the wheels and the slope I would consider this the same way except that Work crosses the system boundary and is transformed into heat outside the closed system.

As with your original assumption, neglecting friction altogether simplifies the model immeasurably and has negligible effects on the results.

I think you misunderstood my point about another "influence" that we are also ignoring, and that is the rotational kinetic energy of the wheels. In an actual physical analysis of this system, mgh doesn't go 100% into 1/2mv^2 of the wagon, entirely. You've already mentioned friction as one other place energy goes. The other place is into the rotational kinetic energy of the wheels themselves. A wheel that is spinning has an energy of 1/2*I*w^2, or, 1/2 of the rotational inertia times the angular speed squared.

This is why in physics 101, they usually don't use wheeled objects (or a ball) in these types of mental experiments, because some of the energy goes into getting the wheels turning, not overall velocity of the wagon. In other words, a block of ice sliding on a frictionless surface versus a ball that rolls down a hill (with 0 energy loss due to friction) do not result in the same speed at the bottom, because the ball has some of it's GPE converted into rotational energy.

For the sake of discussion, and for the sake of my posts above, it's fairly safe to ignore both effects. Or, we can reword the problem to be a block of ice sliding on a frictionless slope. In either case, my original post implies that both of the secondary energies are 0. That is, I assume that all GPE goes to KE, and none goes to thermal via friction and none goes to rotational-KE of the wheels. Under that assumption, however, I posit that my post holds, and that "vectoral energy" doesn't make sense unless you 1) ignore the direction, or 2) say it's physics are wildly different from normal energy, most importantly, it is not conserved.
 
Last edited:
As with your original assumption, neglecting friction altogether simplifies the model immeasurably and has negligible effects on the results.

I think you misunderstood my point about another "influence" that we are also ignoring, and that is the rotational kinetic energy of the wheels. In an actual physical analysis of this system, mgh doesn't go 100% into 1/2mv^2 of the wagon, entirely. You've already mentioned friction as one other place energy goes. The other place is into the rotational kinetic energy of the wheels themselves. A wheel that is spinning has an energy of 1/2*I*w^2, or, 1/2 of the rotational inertia times the angular speed squared.

This is why in physics 101, they usually don't use wheeled objects (or a ball) in these types of mental experiments, because some of the energy goes into getting the wheels turning, not overall velocity of the wagon. In other words, a block of ice sliding on a frictionless surface versus a ball that rolls down a hill (with 0 energy loss due to friction) do not result in the same speed at the bottom, because the ball has some of it's GPE converted into rotational energy.

For the sake of discussion, and for the sake of my posts above, it's fairly safe to ignore both effects. Or, we can reword the problem to be a block of ice sliding on a frictionless slope. In either case, my original post implies that both of the secondary energies are 0. That is, I assume that all GPE goes to KE, and none goes to thermal via friction and none goes to rotational-KE of the wheels. Under that assumption, however, I posit that my post holds, and that "vectoral energy" doesn't make sense unless you 1) ignore the direction, or 2) say it's physics are wildly different from normal energy, most importantly, it is not conserved.

Yes, I had misunderstood, apologies for that but if I could outline my reasons for initially not completely understanding what you were putting forward.

I did not see the inertia of the wheels as being significant because in my mind the wheels were inside the closed system boundary and so the internal energy of the system would not be affected. I did not think it necessary in terms of conservation of energy to seperate them from the system since the kinetic energy that would get stored in them would release itself to propel the wagon at a later stage (flywheel).

Of course in my mind the wheels on the wagon are made from aluminium and have very narrow rims and a very small diameter so I neglected the kinetic energy in them. ;)

I am working on your other information between posts.

I hope that even though my responses do not contain any mathematics like yours that they are demonstrating that I do have a grasp of this subject. I will try to include more mathematics if you prefer to converse that way.
 
Last edited:
There is nothing in Killtown's post that suggests his "Link to a "normal" video?" remark is anything other than a request for a link.

Actually, since there is nothing in his post that implies anything else, I would say both possibilities are equally likely.

However, I don't see how Killtown could ask for a link for something that cannot possibly, by definition, have one, and still be able to speak English properly.

Argument from incredulity.

Speculation. :D

Next most importantly, your hypothetical poster's reply to your statement is an unnecessary addition, as there WAS in fact a follow-up to Killtown's post. WWGHA expressed confusion at Killtown's apparent request for a link to a non-internet video.

And I think you're using his confusion as the evidence you're looking for. Perhaps we should ask Killtown himself. He's probably weird enough to actually WANT the stundie.

It is entirely within the realms of possibility that everything Killtown has ever posted has simply been part of a huge practical joke and that he's having a good laugh at us taking him and his ideas as though he is being serious.

What is that ? An argument from godzilla-sized strawman ?

I really don't understand why this debate is even still taking place. WWGHA defined a "normal" video as a non-internet video. Killtown then asked for a link to a non-internet video. This is BASIC linguistic analysis...

Oh, but then he would've had to say "Can you provide a link to a "normal" video ?" He didn't say that, did he ?

You're trying to make something that is vague, crystal clear. Precisely what some of us are accusing CTers of doing with their fuzzy pictures.
 
However, I don't see how Killtown could ask for a link for something that cannot possibly, by definition, have one, and still be able to speak English properly.



Well, you have to consider the evidence. I put it to you that the linked paragraph shows that he is not, in fact, able to speak (or at least, hear) English properly.
 
Yes, I had misunderstood, apologies for that but if I could outline my reasons for initially not completely understanding what you were putting forward.

I did not see the inertia of the wheels as being significant because in my mind the wheels were inside the closed system boundary and so the internal energy of the system would not be affected. I did not think it necessary in terms of conservation of energy to seperate them from the system since the kinetic energy that would get stored in them would release itself to propel the wagon at a later stage (flywheel).

Of course in my mind the wheels on the wagon are made from aluminium and have very narrow rims and a very small diameter so I neglected the kinetic energy in them. ;)

I am working on your other information between posts.

I hope that even though my responses do not contain any mathematics like yours that they are demonstrating that I do have a grasp of this subject. I will try to include more mathematics if you prefer to converse that way.

Think of it this way:
In a space system, a vector, by definition, has 3 components describing direction from a starting point. In a Cartisian system, these are of 3 orthogonal coordinates, referenced to the start point. In a cylindrical system, they would be radial, angle, and length. In a spherical system, they are radial, angular, and angular
In other words, a vector describes a specific direction. "Outward" may be a direction referenced to a point, but it is not specific, and in truth, defines a sphere.
High to low, when describing energy does not define a direction, but statesof energy.
A vector quantity has a very specific, 3 dimensional , quantity and direction. That is in 3 dimensions, not one. The definition of "vector" has that imbedded in it.
Is that any help?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom