Debunking the Stundies - March Edition

I have stated my credentials at least three times on this forum, the last time being in this very thread...

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=2507410#post2507410

I cannot state any more than that since the industry I work in is extremely specialist, and any further information will compromise my anonymity.

(I can't find the at least two other times you posted your credentials) The above post is notable in that it does not answer my original question.

1) Do you have a degree from an accredited university? What kind?
2) Are you a certified engineer?

It is on record on the forum as I have stated it before, I am a Mechanical Engineer but in the US sense I majored in Structures.

If that is as far as you are willing to post about your credentials, then fine. I, for one will never ask again.
 
All energy can be equated to a force acting over a distance. While it's true that some kinds of energy (thermal, for instance), can't be litterally be broken down into a specific force over a specific distance, that doesn't mean that the thermal energy doesn't have an 'equivalent' that is force times distance. We can say this amount of thermal energy is this many Joules... which means it corresponds to this many Newtons over this many meters.

Great response. But "Newtons OVER meters"?

Sorry - I was doing the math, not the reading. I think I know what you mean :)
 
Last edited:
My second paragraph was just expounding on how the gravitational force(mg) relates to gravitational potential energy (mg dot h). In this case, GPE -is- a dot product between force and distance. The nuanced distinction between energy and work doesn't exist when we are talking about gravity. However, you are correct that in the more general case, the ability to do work isn't the same as energy.

I understand what you are saying, specifically that there is a fundamental difference between work and energy. There is, yes. But not when we are dealing with only gravity.

All energy can be equated to a force acting over a distance. While it's true that some kinds of energy (thermal, for instance), can't be litterally be broken down into a specific force over a specific distance, that doesn't mean that the thermal energy doesn't have an 'equivalent' that is force times distance. We can say this amount of thermal energy is this many Joules... which means it corresponds to this many Newtons over this many meters.

When we are talking about gravity, the concepts of work and energy are one and the same. The only time the nuanced distinction makes an apperance is when we start to add thermal energy into the mix (or thermal producing processes, like friction).

Once again I am indebted to you for your response.

This isn't directed at you but I find it hard to reconcile this rather loose general use of the terms Energy and Work with the nit-picking attitude shown to my approach.

I was going to nit-pick and add that unless we assume that an object is falling in a vacuum there will be thermal energy from friction with the atmosphere anyway but I won't. Oh darn I just did. :)
 
Last edited:
Could you show the equations involving "Vectoral Energy" and how they work? I do not understand how this relates to basic thermo.

Anti-Sophist has already shown much better than I ever could with mathematics that Energy is not a vector. You can catch up with this at the following link...

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=2516037#post2516037

There are two successive posts explaining it, and I accepted that due to Conservation of Energy the mathematics doesn't work.

The relationship to Thermodynamics is really about application of how the subject treats Energy more universally. The flow of Q from Hot to Cold potentials is directional, I am extending that to conceptualise that the Energy involved in the fall of a free body shows a similar directionality between two potentials High to Low. In the same way that Electrical Energy flows from a High to a Low Potential Voltage.

Ultimately, it revolves around a statement from someone called Griffin...

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=2491103#post2491103

...which was called out as being dumb but which I argue is not conceptually that dumb. In the context of the whole quote it has been pointed out to me that saying the Potential Energy couldn't act sideways was even dumber but was not quoted.

I urge you to read the full thread to get the full journey to where we are now.
 
Last edited:
All energy can be equated to a force acting over a distance. While it's true that some kinds of energy (thermal, for instance), can't be litterally be broken down into a specific force over a specific distance, that doesn't mean that the thermal energy doesn't have an 'equivalent' that is force times distance. We can say this amount of thermal energy is this many Joules... which means it corresponds to this many Newtons over this many meters.

Perhaps a better way of describing thermal energy is actually to break it down into tiny little energies. Put a thermometer into a cup of hot water - what the thermometer reads is basically a statistical sampling of the individual water molecules' kinetic energies summed over the exposed surface of the thermometer multiplied by the energy distribution of the water (modulo the thermal transfer properties of the water and thermometer).

Or perhaps in terms Mr. Rea might find more familiar - thermal energy is an integrated measure of individual particles capacity to do work over a distance.

Consider PV=nRT as it relates to a gedankenexperiment with a rectangular prism shaped chamber filled with an ideal gas. One of the chamber's walls is freely movable. (Frictionless etc. etc.) At STP, a given amount of gas "n" will come to equilibrium so that the volume of the chamber is given by nRT/P.

What happens when you heat the gas?

"Microscopically," the gas molecules hitting the movable wall from the inside are balancing the air molecules hitting it from the outside. When we heat the gas, the molecules closest to the heat source will receive energy from said heat source (generally through collision or radiation) and proceed to transfer energy to other gas molecules (etc. etc.) until the entire collection of molecules come to statistical equilibrium. As this is happening, the now more energetic gas particles are colliding with the movable wall, pushing it outward until a new equilibrium position is reached.

Take the "Macroscopic" point of view. Since the amount of gas doesn't change and external atmospheric pressure is constant, the volume of gas will expand until a new pressure equilibrium is reached.

Same thing (Kinetic energy integrated over each molecule =~ Temperature), same result!

But notice. In both ways of looking at the system, the movable wall moves due to Pressure|Energy Transfer. Does this not mean that the KE/Thermal Energy has a direction that points towards the wall?

No. Consider the same experiment, but with two movable walls. In which direction does the energy point? Or three. Or model a balloon as an infinite set of infinitely small walls.

The answer is that in the first case, the action is in the direction we put the movable wall, because that's where we put the movable wall!

Put another way. In Mr. Rea's example of heating one end of a metal bar, the heat moves from one end to another because that's the shape of the bar. The apparent "vector-like" direction of energy transfer in this case is not a property of the thermal energy itself, but with the vector-like setup of the experiment!

"Hot to Cold" is a 'direction' in the same sense that "Radially Outward" is a 'direction' in the expanding balloon case or the heated disk I asked about elsewhere. It is descriptive terminology, not an inherent property of the energy itself.
 
This is getting further and further away from the only question that really needs to be asked here.

William - is gravitational potential energy a vector?
 
This has been said before, but apparently William has either missed it or decided it only applies in the real world and not his special one. Energy is defined to be a scalar. It is simple as that. There is no argument possible about it, it is a definition. Energy is a scalar. If you find something that has a direction, it is not energy, because that is how energy is defined. No matter how much you argue about something having "vectorial properties", if it does, it is not energy. Energy does not and cannot have any direction at all, because is it did it would be a vector, which energy is not. It doesn't matter what you believe or whether you claim to only be playing Devil's advocate or whatever, energy is energy as it is defined to be, and that definition rules out any possibility of it ever having any kind of directional property. That is what "scalar" means. Did I mention that energy is a scalar?
 
I think he accepted that in post 264. However, in the same post, he also said electrical energy flows from a high to low potential. Current flows, not energy. I'll leave the thermo stuff from that post to the thermo guys.
 
1) Saying that you don't think that Killtown was asking for a link to a non-internet video because you don't believe Killtown would be stupid enough to ask for a link to a non-internet video is pretty much a textbook case of the argument from incredulity. Not speculation on my part.

That was a joke. Hence the smiley. It indeed was incredulity, but I wasn't making an argument from it.

As for why this is the more probable explanation - I've already gone over this in my previous posts to William. There doesn't seem to be anything you've brought up that I haven't already addressed in my analysis.

Well, I just feel that the fact that not one of the two posters followed through about that remark doesn't really tell us which one's more likely. That's why I find your certainty about it puzzling.

But in any event, it really isn't important.
 
I think he accepted that in post 264. However, in the same post, he also said electrical energy flows from a high to low potential. Current flows, not energy. I'll leave the thermo stuff from that post to the thermo guys.

I said it flows from high to low potential, I didn't say it flowed in the conductor.
 
I said it flows from high to low potential, I didn't say it flowed in the conductor.


Where is you humor, William? I mean it's getting summer and
I already feel it ... literally - at least here in germany. Enjoy
life and the stundies! :D
 
I said it flows from high to low potential, I didn't say it flowed in the conductor.

If by "it" you mean energy, you are wrong! Har! (erm, just kidding!?)

More importantly, this goes back to the concept of faux-pas versus ignorance. It's technically incorrect to say electrical energy flows from high potential to low potential, but everyone knows exactly what that means, and as long as we don't take the concept of "enegy-flow" too far and start applying incorrect physical laws to it, it's no big deal.
 
That was a joke. Hence the smiley. It indeed was incredulity, but I wasn't making an argument from it.

[nitpick]Fair call about it being a joke, but one of yor statements was that you 'couldn't believe' that KT would ask for a link to a non-internet video. That IS an argument from incredulity.[/nitpick]

Well, I just feel that the fact that not one of the two posters followed through about that remark doesn't really tell us which one's more likely. That's why I find your certainty about it puzzling.

But one of the two posters DID follow through about the remark, in a way that distinctly supports the interpretation I suggest is far and away the most probable. That Killtown ignores WWGHA pointing out his mistake is no more than would be expected from what we know of Killtown.

But in any event, it really isn't important.

I wouldn't say that, but I definately wouldn't say it is worth arguing over too much. I'd just like William to apologise for his actions and retract his accusations.
 
[nitpick]Fair call about it being a joke, but one of yor statements was that you 'couldn't believe' that KT would ask for a link to a non-internet video. That IS an argument from incredulity.[/nitpick]

Well, I didn't mean it as an argument, just my personal observation. Sorry for the confusion.

But one of the two posters DID follow through about the remark, in a way that distinctly supports the interpretation I suggest is far and away the most probable. That Killtown ignores WWGHA pointing out his mistake is no more than would be expected from what we know of Killtown.

Well, Killtown's silence on that subject doesn't help his case (or mine), but it really doesn't make anything clearer, either.

I wouldn't say that, but I definately wouldn't say it is worth arguing over too much. I'd just like William to apologise for his actions and retract his accusations.

Good luck with that.
 
William:

You've clearly been around these parts, and it was you who started this thread in the first place.

As such, I'm going to ask you politely now - please apologise for your attempt to deliberately mislead the other members of this forum, and please retract your accusation that The Stundies are all about ad hominem attacks. Also please retract your specific accusations about the two nominations you set out to debunk, as it has been fairly clearly shown that you were wrong about both of these things.

I take personal offense to this, as it was me who organised the March Stundies (and likely the April ones too the way things are going), and I took care to eliminate exactly the types of things you have accused me (yes, me) of including in the finals.

Before you even started this thread, there was already a discussion underway as to trial rules to set in place for the April Nominations. These have been put in place, and any nominations breaching said rules will be disqualified automatically.

I eagerly await your response.

Peace Out

Mobyseven
 
If by "it" you mean energy, you are wrong! Har! (erm, just kidding!?)

More importantly, this goes back to the concept of faux-pas versus ignorance. It's technically incorrect to say electrical energy flows from high potential to low potential, but everyone knows exactly what that means, and as long as we don't take the concept of "enegy-flow" too far and start applying incorrect physical laws to it, it's no big deal.

Well at least I didn't say it flows in the charge of the current!

I know from how you answer me that you understand my take on this and I'm fine that you're sensibly critical of it. I personally don't see any contradiction between saying that Energy is scalar and also saying that there are directional restrictions on how it can be turned into Work or Heat.

Purely as a point of interest, do you have any links for educational material on exchanges of photons and gravitons and an understandable explanation of Poynting Fields? I think my knowledge of Electromagnetics is way out of date.
 
I personally don't see any contradiction between saying that Energy is scalar and also saying that there are directional restrictions on how it can be turned into Work or Heat.

Mr. Rea,

Is this an admission that you were wrong asserting that energy has a "vectoral quality" or direction inherent to it?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom