Debunking the Stundies - March Edition

To any newcomer, as far as I am concerned this thread is now dead with the main arguments proven and little left to discuss except side issues. Some of the sidetracking has been interesting. I now eagerly await the April nominations which should soon supercede this, particularly as I have been nominated which could make it fun.

I won't personalise this or turn it into some kind of beauty contest but will leave it to you to read and decide who has put forward the credible rational argument.


It's a no brainer. It wasn't you. Not even close. You must be delusional the way you just ignore total ownage upon you and then declare victory.
 
If William still wants to debunk something, perhaps he could take a shot at Rosie's "first time fire melted steel" or the Egg Tower experiment - those are the current poll leaders. ;)
 
I, for one, would like to see the Egg Tower experiment debunked, and maybe also pagan's "Gravy in a batman suit" nomination.
 
little left to discuss except side issues.

Like this one?

Mr. Rea's behavior reminds me of someone I used to know. Reasonably bright fellow in a few select topics, but in possession of far more stubbornness and ego than knowledge in many other areas. Due to (let's call it) politics, he was often in a position of some authority with respect to one of those topics and in that position was usually right about things.

His problem was that he acted as if his authority and knowledge in one area made him correct by definition in everything. Anyone who pointed out something conceptually incorrect, logically incomplete or factually wrong would end up on his [rule8] list for weeks. Unless of course he felt like arguing right then and there, in which case you'd be in for a tour-de-force of invalid debate techniques; Move the goalposts. Redefine terms on the fly. Make vague references to previous statements that upon further reflection aren't actually on point. And my personal "favorite" of his: Answer a question (metaphorically) next to the question you really asked.

I'm glad I never had to deal with him on a professional level.

Now I'm not saying that Mr. Rea is exactly like this former acquaintance of mine, but this whole energy thread sure does feel familiar. (And it really does put his "orthodoxy" comments in a new light, doesn't it?)

ETA: I suppose one could skim this post and accuse me of attacking the person (and not the argument) by analogy, but I will posit that I am commenting on argument techniques used in this very thread by drawing an analogy to a personality type that many people have some personal experience with, thus attempting to put the techniques in a context that may be familiar to others.

An invalid technique invalidates the argument, not the user.
 
Last edited:
To any newcomer, as far as I am concerned this thread is now dead with the main arguments proven and little left to discuss except side issues. Some of the sidetracking has been interesting. I now eagerly await the April nominations which should soon supercede this, particularly as I have been nominated which could make it fun.

I won't personalise this or turn it into some kind of beauty contest but will leave it to you to read and decide who has put forward the credible rational argument.
Ah, proof the ideals of the Stundie are being continued by your very post. Similar to truthers, without proof, you make your last post and declare victory after being soundly crushed. Tally ho.

Of interest, but not to waste time, would be the number of times this has occurred.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom