Dana Ullman's Homeopathy Studies Thread

Well, well, well.

I waited and waited and waited for somebody here to tell Wilsontown how wrong he is. I know that lots of people know the Shang/Egger review of homeopathic and allopathic clinical trials, and yet, none of you had the balls to tell him the truth...and you all lost your credibility for your loud silence (no big surprise).

I just wanted to make it clear (in case it wasn't already), that I also agree with Wilsontown's analysis of the Shang meta-analysis. You, however, have yet to provide a criticism that that stands up to scrutiny. Bluster doesn't count. Or rather, bluster instead of actually addressing specific points serves to act as evidence against the validity of your criticisms.

Linda
 
I wanted to comment further on that, but unfortunately it seems you have to have a Google or Blogger identity to post to the blog, which I have no intention of acquiring.

I thought that at first, but all you do is click on 'nickname' and you can free-enter an identity for yourself for that post.
 
I just wanted to make it clear (in case it wasn't already), that I also agree with Wilsontown's analysis of the Shang meta-analysis.

I am Spartacus too.

Dullman seems to be Nero, but I can't even hear the sound of his fiddle at the moment.
 
Cuddles said:
To be fair, I was going to tell him how wrong he is. But he isn't, so I didn't.

fls said:
I just wanted to make it clear (in case it wasn't already), that I also agree with Wilsontown's analysis of the Shang meta-analysis.

Badly Shaved Monkey said:
I am Spartacus too.

Heh, cheers all. Dana, several people here have tried to explain why your interpretation of the Shang meta-analysis is flawed. So far you've utterly failed to take on board any of their points, and you're still spouting the same nonsense.
 
Quackbusters confirm effect from homeopathic medicines!

It was Yuri Nalyssus who actually ran with this, as he is on good enough terms with a retired homoeopath to be able to ask him to referee the trial. He advertised widely for homoeopaths to take part in the trial, and to be honest we expected he'd get 20 quite easily. (In fact, no testing method was forbidden - they could try the remedy out on patients, do mass spectroscopy or NMR or particle acceleration or even get Rustum Roy to shove it through his magic spectrophotometer if they wanted, but we assumed that as the proving effects were universally declared to be so striking, that would be the preferred method.) Well, Yuri got exactly six volunteers.

Guess what. Three were right and three were wrong.

I cautioned him that it was almost inevitable that some homoeopath would start boasting that 50% of the participants could tell a remedy from a blank, and wasn't that great, but in fact he never publicised the results due to the small number of participants.
Rolfe.

Rolfe...
Let me get this straight. Three of the six homeopaths were able to determine which of the TEN medicines they had taken? Hmmmm. Thank you! This study, though small, showed an impressive result for homeopathy! If this were a demonstration of ESP, it too would have a very positive result.

Please let me know how to contact Yuri.

Because many medicines cause similar symptoms in people (many medicines, for instance, may cause a frontal headache, or watery eyes, or nausea). So, the fact that 3 of 6 homeopaths were able to correctly determine the medicine they tested out of 10. Fab. Can we move on now?

And for all of you "Shang supporters," if he did all of the analyses that you have suggested, please report what he said was the result of him comparing the 21 high quality homeopathic studies and the 9 allopathic ones?

And finally, of the final 8 homeopathic studies, what would you say if just ONE of the 8 homeopathic studies was removed from the mix? And what would you say when the new statistically analysis shows that this one study with a negative result was so strong that the remaining 7 trials together showed homeopathic medicines as better than a placebo.

Can ANYONE tell me in what ways the final 8 and 6 studies were "matched?"
 
Rolfe...
Let me get this straight. Three of the six homeopaths were able to determine which of the TEN medicines they had taken? Hmmmm. Thank you! This study, though small, showed an impressive result for homeopathy! If this were a demonstration of ESP, it too would have a very positive result.

Please let me know how to contact Yuri.

Because many medicines cause similar symptoms in people (many medicines, for instance, may cause a frontal headache, or watery eyes, or nausea). So, the fact that 3 of 6 homeopaths were able to correctly determine the medicine they tested out of 10. Fab. Can we move on now?

:dl:

Please note I don't think I have ever used that smilie before.

Absolutely priceless.

Thank you for that.

(You might want to read what Rolfe actually wrote instead of what you hoped she wrote.)
 
Ah, well. On that note of yet another abysmal example of a failure of basic reading comprehension I shall bow out for the day.

When I get back, perhaps I'll find that Dana has told us how come Rustum Roy messed up his controls so badly.

And he might even show whether he has actually ready Elia's papers by answering the two questions posed on it.

What are the odds? 50:50 :dl: :dl: :dl: :dl: :dl:
 
Rolfe...
Let me get this straight. Three of the six homeopaths were able to determine which of the TEN medicines they had taken? Hmmmm. Thank you! This study, though small, showed an impressive result for homeopathy! If this were a demonstration of ESP, it too would have a very positive result.

Please let me know how to contact Yuri.

Where does the TEN 'medicines' come from?

From Rolfe:-
At this stage I changed the format yet again, to multiply not the repetitions a single tester had to undergo, but to multiply the testers. The final format of the test required a number of homoeopaths (at least ten, but we hoped for 20), each of whom was certain they could recognise the proving effects of any ultradilute remedy of their choice. Each one would be sent either that remedy, or a bottle of blank pills. All they had to do was to say which it was.

It was Yuri Nalyssus who actually ran with this, as he is on good enough terms with a retired homoeopath to be able to ask him to referee the trial. He advertised widely for homoeopaths to take part in the trial, and to be honest we expected he'd get 20 quite easily. (In fact, no testing method was forbidden - they could try the remedy out on patients, do mass spectroscopy or NMR or particle acceleration or even get Rustum Roy to shove it through his magic spectrophotometer if they wanted, but we assumed that as the proving effects were universally declared to be so striking, that would be the preferred method.) Well, Yuri got exactly six volunteers.

Each recipient had a 50% chance of getting it right through random chance.

Rolfe was prescient in saying that homeopaths would distort the conclusions but you have distorted the experiment as well.
 
:dl:

Please note I don't think I have ever used that smilie before.

Absolutely priceless.

Thank you for that.

(You might want to read what Rolfe actually wrote instead of what you hoped she wrote.)

Ah, let's give DanaJames the benefit of the doubt and assume (like normal) he misread what really happened. Let's say that he interpreted it as 1 bottle out of 10 is homeopathic remedy, and 9 bottles are pure water. Each person is given a bottle at random, and they have to correctly identify if it is water or remedy.

Now, it's no longer 50/50, so does 3 out of 6 sound impressive? Considering if all people simply answered "water", we would expect 5, maybe even 6, to be right.

Ah, it's going to be a Merry Christmas indeed. Thank you all for the early present!
 
This is one of my problem with Dana Ullman. He has written several books which, apparently, have sold very well, but he lacks basic comprehension skills and he has shown this repeatedly. And Rolfe's post was very clearly written. Imagine the trouble he must have - and apparently has had -comprehending the results of clinical trials. This is probably why he doesn't actually bother - as BSM suspects - to ever read more then just the extract of the author's conclusion. The sad thing is that people are relying on this person for information!

My other problem with him is his style. He doesn't have any. How can you possibly write a whole book and expect it to be read if you have absolutely no literary flair? Yet he has done so. Is it possible he has a ghost writer or are his books just as lacking as his posts here. I can imagine several othe individuals on this forum writing a book that I would eagerly look forward to reading. But they have not done so. Where is the justice?

BillyJoe
 
And for all of you "Shang supporters," if he did all of the analyses that you have suggested, please report what he said was the result of him comparing the 21 high quality homeopathic studies and the 9 allopathic ones?

I don't know if he said what it was (or if he did one), but I would think that if an analysis were done, both the homeopathic and medicine studies would find differences between treatment and placebo groups. How could they not, given that his analysis shows that significant bias was present in both groups of studies and bias necessarily creates differences between groups? If you toss a loaded die, do you not expect one particular number to come up most often? My question is, so what? What valid conclusion do you think you can draw from that?

And finally, of the final 8 homeopathic studies, what would you say if just ONE of the 8 homeopathic studies was removed from the mix? And what would you say when the new statistically analysis shows that this one study with a negative result was so strong that the remaining 7 trials together showed homeopathic medicines as better than a placebo.

I would say that demonstrating that the proof for homeopathy is not robust does not help your cause.

Can ANYONE tell me in what ways the final 8 and 6 studies were "matched?"

Yes. Groups were formed by matching on "enrolled patients with similar disorders and assessed similar outcomes". From those matching groups, studies associated with the least bias were selected for one of the analyses.

Linda
 
Last edited:
Dannagain posted this study a few days ago, which was basically a test like that outlined by Yuri.

What is interesting is not that it was a complete failure, but how the authors completely ignored that it was a complete failure and instead published it as support for the validity of homeopathic provings.

Linda
 
Last edited:
Dannagain posted this study a few days ago, which was basically a test like that outlined by Yuri.

What is interesting is not that it was a complete failure, but how the authors completely ignored that it was a complete failure and instead published it as support for the validity of homeopathic provings.

Linda

It is yet another affront to the intelligence from the homs. "We found nothing and that proves homeopathy works."

It reveals their entire mindset. They know homeopathy works. Therefore any counter-evidence has to be bent to that fact. They don't do studies to test an hypothesis. There is no real testing going on because they have already drawn their Conclusions. All they lack at the start of a study are the Results. So they do the study, sometimes using legitimate Materials and Methods, more often not. They obtain whatever Results they can. As we have seen these tend to fall into two groups: either 'signficant' through their fallacious and incompetent methods or non-significant if they conduct fair tests. They then fit the Results to their predetermined Conclusions.

Hey, presto! Homeopathy wins again.

It saves all that tiresome mucking about having to think of new ideas.
 
Oh, it's Harald Walach again. He's figured out that a demonstration of the reality of proving symptoms is the most straightforward way to test whether the claims of homoeopathy have any factual basis. I suspect quite a lot of them realise this, but are reluctant to try it because they also realise that a failure to show any objective proving effects actually holes homoeopathy below the waterline, which a failure to degranulate basophils or cause a hiccup on a spectrophotometer trace actually doesn't.

Dr. Walach, however, is so strongly convinced that he cannot conceive of failure. He's a bit like Neil (Bach) in this respect, because he simply believes any failure is due to poor design of the test, and is very very prepared to read success into actual failure whenever possible.

Some years ago I was persuaded to email him personally to ask whether a certain paper of his was in fact a spoof. His reply demonstrated quite clearly that the man is completely on another planet in this respect.

Rolfe.
 
.... 1 bottle out of 10 is homeopathic remedy, and 9 bottles are pure water. Each person is given a bottle at random, and they have to correctly identify if it is water or remedy.

Now, it's no longer 50/50, so does 3 out of 6 sound impressive? Considering if all people simply answered "water", we would expect 5, maybe even 6, to be right.


No, wait a minute, I see the germ of a good idea here.

The reason they say they can't identify which one of a number of remedies they've taken is that to get the full symptom picture you need a team of at least ten provers.

So, we change the test to a simple matter of distinguishing a remedy chosen by the homoeopath for its ability to produce striking symptoms (however non-specific) in one person, and ask them to say if they've been given that, or the blank pills. A simple either/or test here produces problems because obviously there is a 50:50 chance of a lucky guess.

However, what if we were to give the homoeopath ten or more vials, with the assurance that one and one only contained the specified remedy. Surely they should be able to tell which one quite easily! Now as described that still leaves a 1 in 10 chance of a lucky guess, which is still too much. However, it's a lot better than 1 in 50, as regards working towards statistical significance.

So, we need to find out how many vials a homoeopath thinks it would be practical to screen for remedy presence, assuming only one is the actual remedy. Then we need to work out how many repetitions of that test would require to be correct in order to achieve p<0.001. If in fact this level of significance can be achieved with perhaps only three repetitions, then it could well be practical for one person to undertake the whole thing, just saying when they felt ready to go on to the next set. Even if it was a couple of months, that would be achievable.

Now, what excuses might they find for not doing this one?

Rolfe.
 
Yeah, I did misunderstand Rolf's posting.

That said, having 3 of the 6 people determine that they were given a homeopathic medicine rather than a placebo is actually better than you might realize, though this small trial of only 6 doesn't prove one thing or another. The fact of the matter is that not everyone is appropriate for doing a proving of a homeopathic medicine (to clarify, a "proving" is an experimental trial of using a substance in repeated doses until it causes symptoms in healthy people; this information then analyzed for which symptoms are experienced by multiple people and then added to homeopathic materia medica and/ot to homeopathic software). Only certain people are hypersensitive to a specific medicine, and then, the experimenter noted which precisely described symptoms are experienced by multiple people.

If you're going to do some type of test, you need to first determine which people think that they are hypersensitive to a specific medicine for a proving and then use ONLY these people.
 
I don't know if he said what it was (or if he did one), but I would think that if an analysis were done, both the homeopathic and medicine studies would find differences between treatment and placebo groups. How could they not, given that his analysis shows that significant bias was present in both groups of studies and bias necessarily creates differences between groups? If you toss a loaded die, do you not expect one particular number to come up most often? My question is, so what? What valid conclusion do you think you can draw from that?



I would say that demonstrating that the proof for homeopathy is not robust does not help your cause.



Yes. Groups were formed by matching on "enrolled patients with similar disorders and assessed similar outcomes". From those matching groups, studies associated with the least bias were selected for one of the analyses.

Linda


Sorry Linda. Please list which CONDITIONS of the 8 homeopathic trials were matched to 6 allopathic trials? For instance, one of the homeopathic trials used was for "weight-loss." Which allopathic study did this? Which allopathic trial evaluated the "prevention of influenza?"

While I will certainly concede that the original 110 homeopathic and 110 allopathic trials were matched, the final 8 and 6 trials were not matched in any shape, way, or form. If you can prove otherwise, say it, though I know that you've got nothing here...and you refuse to admit it.
 
Yeah, I did misunderstand Rolf's posting.

That said, having 3 of the 6 people determine that they were given a homeopathic medicine rather than a placebo is actually better than you might realize...

It's exactly what you would expect from chance.

... though this small trial of only 6 doesn't prove one thing or another. The fact of the matter is that not everyone is appropriate for doing a proving of a homeopathic medicine (to clarify, a "proving" is an experimental trial of using a substance in repeated doses until it causes symptoms in healthy people; this information then analyzed for which symptoms are experienced by multiple people and then added to homeopathic materia medica and/ot to homeopathic software). Only certain people are hypersensitive to a specific medicine, and then, the experimenter noted which precisely described symptoms are experienced by multiple people.

If you're going to do some type of test, you need to first determine which people think that they are hypersensitive to a specific medicine for a proving and then use ONLY these people.

Does that mean that this particular homeopathic remedy will only work on these people?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom