Dana Ullman's Homeopathy Studies Thread

[FONT='Arial','sans-serif']According to a British Medical Journal Clinical Evidence review of 2,404 conventional treatments, only
15% were rated as beneficial,
22% as likely to be beneficial,
7% as trade off between benefits and harms,
5% as unlikely to be beneficial,
4% as likely to be ineffective or harmful
and
47% of unknown effectiveness.[/FONT]

[FONT='Arial','sans-serif']In every clinical study the accepted criteria for effectiveness beyond chance is 1 in 100. This standard is below other scientific endeavour. To put this statistics in perspective (in a simple minded way - taking away all the statistical calculation of probability) if 100 people are treated and 2 are found to benefit while in the control group out of 100 only 1 benefit. Then the 1% improvement is then considered as an event beyond chance or placebo. Such studies can then be used to apply to FDA for approval even if 6 or 7 other studies indicated otherwise.

Such evidence of efficacy had failed to recognise that the drug failed to help the other 98 % of the people. In a number of statin
drug trials the effectiveness was even less than 1%.

Such studies will also not reveal that the drug could actually cause harm to almost all of them, in one way or another.

If efficacy is measured in such minuscule, homoeopathic level (I'm just kidding) then how could anyone ever claim that modern medicine has evidence of benefit when the evidence of lack of benefit is even greater. If we have to pay so much money for so little chance of a benefit we are better off buying lottery.[/FONT]

[FONT='Arial','sans-serif']If next time your physician tell you that this drug is a 50% improvement in chance (1/2) ask him what's the ABSOLUTE rate of efficacy. The relative rate of efficacy had always been marketed because it looks large and impressive but when you ask for the absolute number of people helped out of how many went into the trial you will get the real picture.

Then ask for the side-effects. And the cost would be more than the cost of the drug you pay for.[/FONT]
 
Perhaps you could comment on this table of dilutions for us? Thank you!

1st succession 1:100 = 1C
2nd succession 1:100 = 2C
3rd succession 1:100 = 3C
4th succession 1:100 = 4C
5th succession 1:100 = 5C
6th succession 1:100 = 6C

7th succession in water and dilution = 30C
8th succession in dilution = 200C

9th succession in dilution = 1M
10th succession in dilution = 10M
11th succession in dilution = 50M
12th succession in dilution = CM
 
[FONT='Arial','sans-serif']According to a British Medical Journal Clinical Evidence review of 2,404 conventional treatments, only
15% were rated as beneficial,
22% as likely to be beneficial,
7% as trade off between benefits and harms,
5% as unlikely to be beneficial,
4% as likely to be ineffective or harmful
and
47% of unknown effectiveness.[/font]
And now you're quoting from here?
http://www.naturalmatters.net/article.asp?article=3032&cat=85

According to a British Medical Journal Clinical Evidence review of 2,404 conventional treatments, only 15% were rated as beneficial, 22% as likely to be beneficial, 7% as trade off between benefits and harms, 5% as unlikely to be beneficial, 4% as likely to be ineffective or harmful and 47% of unknown effectiveness.
www.clinicalevidence.com/ceweb/about/knowledge.jsp
Funny thing... I follow their own link to find out where they got these numbers from
Of around 2500 treatments covered 13% are rated as beneficial, 23% likely to be beneficial, 8% as trade off between benefits and harms, 6% unlikely to be beneficial, 4% likely to be ineffective or harmful, and 46%, the largest proportion, as unknown effectiveness (see figure 1).
Not to nitpick, but usually when quoting numbers, you actually give the same numbers as the original source.

[FONT='Arial','sans-serif']In every clinical study the accepted criteria for effectiveness beyond chance is 1 in 100. This standard is below other scientific endeavour. To put this statistics in perspective (in a simple minded way - taking away all the statistical calculation of probability) if 100 people are treated and 2 are found to benefit while in the control group out of 100 only 1 benefit. Then the 1% improvement is then considered as an event beyond chance or placebo. Such studies can then be used to apply to FDA for approval even if 6 or 7 other studies indicated otherwise.


This is not how statistics works. Sorry. This is wrong is so many ways, and I haven't had enough coffee yet.

Such evidence of efficacy had failed to recognise that the drug failed to help the other 98 % of the people. In a number of statin
drug trials the effectiveness was even less than 1%.

Such studies will also not reveal that the drug could actually cause harm to almost all of them, in one way or another.

If efficacy is measured in such minuscule, homoeopathic level (I'm just kidding) then how could anyone ever claim that modern medicine has evidence of benefit when the evidence of lack of benefit is even greater. If we have to pay so much money for so little chance of a benefit we are better off buying lottery.[/font]

[FONT='Arial','sans-serif']If next time your physician tell you that this drug is a 50% improvement in chance (1/2) ask him what's the ABSOLUTE rate of efficacy. The relative rate of efficacy had always been marketed because it looks large and impressive but when you ask for the absolute number of people helped out of how many went into the trial you will get the real picture.

Then ask for the side-effects. And the cost would be more than the cost of the drug you pay for.[/font]

Wow, math really isn't your strong suit, is it? Even with your bogus example, you claimed that the control group has a success rate of 1/100, and the drug has a success rate of 2/100. This does not lead to a 50% improvement in chance.

But it's okay, Hans is dealing with this exact same post over here

http://www.otherhealth.com/research...homeopathy/9000-homeopathy-some-issues-5.html
 
Do you have a reference for this information? I was unable to find this review in my search.

Thanks for finding that Baron Samedi.

In every clinical study the accepted criteria for effectiveness beyond chance is 1 in 100. This standard is below other scientific endeavour. To put this statistics in perspective (in a simple minded way - taking away all the statistical calculation of probability) if 100 people are treated and 2 are found to benefit while in the control group out of 100 only 1 benefit. Then the 1% improvement is then considered as an event beyond chance or placebo. Such studies can then be used to apply to FDA for approval even if 6 or 7 other studies indicated otherwise.

Such evidence of efficacy had failed to recognise that the drug failed to help the other 98 % of the people. In a number of statin
drug trials the effectiveness was even less than 1%.

I'm trying to picture a statin study where 99 people out of a hundred had a heart attack. Who cares about the drug! The ability to find, with 99% specificity, those people about to have a heart attack, is surely the far more amazing part of this imaginary study.

Linda
 
Last edited:
In every clinical study the accepted criteria for effectiveness beyond chance is 1 in 100.


No.

This standard is below other scientific endeavor.

It would be if it was true, yes.

To put this statistics in perspective (in a simple minded way - taking away all the statistical calculation of probability) if 100 people are treated and 2 are found to benefit while in the control group out of 100 only 1 benefit. Then the 1% improvement is then considered as an event beyond chance or placebo.

No.

Such studies can then be used to apply to FDA for approval even if 6 or 7 other studies indicated otherwise.

No.


Such studies will also not reveal that the drug could actually cause harm to almost all of them, in one way or another.

Wrong. You can't get a clinical trial approved unless you have built in an evaluation of harmful effects.

Then ask for the side-effects. And the cost would be more than the cost of the drug you pay for.

Side effects will always be listed on the inlay.

You know, Nancy (is it OK for me to call you Nancy?), it is one thing that you try to kick the ball into our court, by attacking conventional meds, instead of defending homeopathy; all homeopaths doe that most of the time, but if you do at least try to get your facts straight, OK?

That said, don't forget that whatever the vices and virtues of conventional medicine (and it certainly has both), none of this can in any way validate homeopathy.

Finally: There is no such thing as "allopathy". Allopathy is a Hahnemannian construct and is defined as a method that seeks to cure by introducing symptoms different from (but not necessarily opposite to) those of the disease. This may have covered quite a bit of conventional medicine at Hahnemann's time, but it has no relevance to modern medicine which does not seek to cure by introducing symptoms at all.

Hans
 
Dear Friends...
The people on this list continually assert that homeopathic medicines are simply too small of a dose to have any biological effect. I will, therefore, be curious what comments any of you will have on the body of research conducted with homeopathic doses of thyroxin and its effects on tadpoles.

Does pretreatment with thyroxin (10-8 M) enhance a "curative" effect of homeopathically prepared thyroxin (10-30) on highland frogs? Results of a multi researcher study
Welles, S.U., Suanjak-Traidl, E., Weber, S., Scherer-Pongratz, W., Frass, M., Endler, P.C., Spranger, H., Lothaller, H.: Accepted by Research on Complementary Medicine / Forschende Komplementärmedizin 2007

The effect of homeopathically prepared thyroxin (10-30 parts by weight) on highland frogs is influenced by electromagnetic fields.
Weber, S., Welles, S.U., Suanjak-Traidl, E., Scherer-Pongratz, W., Frass, M., Endler, P.C, Spranger, H., Lothaller, H.: Accepted by Homeopathy (former Br Hom J) 2007

Treatment of Lowland Frogs from the Spawn Stage on with Homeopathically Prepared Thyroxin (10-30)
Graunke H., Endler P.C., Scherer-Pongratz W., Frass M., Lothaller H. The Scientific World Journal 2007; 7:

Those of you who continue to say that the nanodoses of homeopathic medicines are too small to have any effect are simply ill-informed or prefer to provide mis-information.

As for my word, "nanodoses," please note that the words nanotubes and nanoplankton have nothing to do with one-billionth of anything. The word or prefix "nano" has roots in the word "dwarf" and today is used to mean very small and yet powerful.



more excellent research james. problem is that they have their heads stuck up their...




meow meow
 
more excellent research james. problem is that they have their heads stuck up their...
meow meow

Removing my head from your meow meow, just for fun I looked at the first paper. Their conclusions:
This in itself is an interesting result, but it does not prove the hypothesis that hyperstimulation of highland animals leads to an optimisation of the previous original study protocol i.e. that a curative effect of homeopathically prepared thyroxin is enhanced by pre-treatment with thyroxin in highland amphibians.

Excellent research as you said. :boggled:

Oh, and by the way -- woof WOOF. :run:
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom