Dana Ullman's Homeopathy Studies Thread

Homeopathic remedies in my pharmacy have labels that simply have one or two words printed on them, such as "Heart." No ingredient list, no ingredient strength, no dosage instructions, and nothing more specific as to exactly what condition it is to treat (i.e. perhaps it is just to treat a "broken heart"? ...or is it to treat serious heart conditions?)

Is this legal?

Don't know about the USA but in the UK, providing they make no claims of efficacy they can sell them. Caveat emptor. And I thought we were in the 21st century!
 
Don't know about the USA but in the UK, providing they make no claims of efficacy they can sell them. Caveat emptor. And I thought we were in the 21st century!


Serious??

I am in the wrong business... :wackygoofy:


Has anyone here read the FDA's "Guidance for Industry on Complementary and Alternative Medicine Products and Their Regulation by the Food and Drug Administration" dated December 2006 at: http://www.fda.gov/cber/gdlns/altmed.pdf?

Will this have an impact on the sales and practices of homeopathic "medicine"?
 
{snip} There are homeopathic "medicines" on the shelves in our local pharmacy that have nothing printed on their labels except for very vague insinuations to treat conditions that can be broadly interpreted to refer to anything from mild to serious conditions.

Homeopathic remedies in my pharmacy have labels that simply have one or two words printed on them, such as "Heart." No ingredient list, no ingredient strength, no dosage instructions, and nothing more specific as to exactly what condition it is to treat (i.e. perhaps it is just to treat a "broken heart"? ...or is it to treat serious heart conditions?)

Is this legal?
If the products are made and sold in your state, I am pretty sure they are not subject to federal regulation.
 
Serious??

I am in the wrong business... :wackygoofy:


Has anyone here read the FDA's "Guidance for Industry on Complementary and Alternative Medicine Products and Their Regulation by the Food and Drug Administration" dated December 2006 at: http://www.fda.gov/cber/gdlns/altmed.pdf?

Will this have an impact on the sales and practices of homeopathic "medicine"?

If you are either/and a liar, unethical, unable to understand the logic applied to evidence based medicine, totally lacking in morals and wishing to make a large amount of money become an alternative medic. No irony intended.
 
From t'other thread:



Good grief.

One particular part of the meta-analysis includes 8 homeoapthic trials and 6 conventional trials. This is the part of the analysis that compares the trials that are most likely to be free of bias. Homeopathy showed no effect beyond placebo, conventional medicine did show an effect.

However, Shang et al. also performed statistics on the whole dataset. This included 48 trials of clinical homeopathy, 35 trials of complex homeopathy, 18 of classical homeopathy, and 8 of isopathy. Shang et al. found that there was no evidence that any of these sub-groups had more pronounced effects than the others. This is the point I was making regarding the 18 trials of classical homeopathy: that there is no evidence that classical homeopathy was any better than any of the other interventions tested. So your assertion that the results might have been positive for homeopathy if only classical homeopathy was included is not backed up by the evidence. I honestly can't see what you fail to understand about this.

As for the International Journal of Epidemiology publishing a comparison of the 21 versus 9 trials that were deemed to be of higher quality, what's the point? That subsample of studies was shown to be biased. YOU CAN'T DRAW ANY USEFUL CONCLUSIONS FROM THIS SUBSET OF STUDIES BECAUSE IT IS BIASED.


Well, well, well.

I waited and waited and waited for somebody here to tell Wilsontown how wrong he is. I know that lots of people know the Shang/Egger review of homeopathic and allopathic clinical trials, and yet, none of you had the balls to tell him the truth...and you all lost your credibility for your loud silence (no big surprise).

Shang's analysis whittled down from 110 "matched" trials of homeopathy and allopathy to 21 high quality homeopathic studies and only 9 (!) allopathic ones. However, he never (!) provided any data or comparison of this group of high quality double-blind and placebo controlled trials. THAT is why another journal will finally publish this data. Whooops.

Instead, Shang whittled the now unmatch trials of 8 homeopathic and 6 allopathic trials. He wanted to only evaluate the large trials, the vast majority of which used only 1 homeopathic medicine for entire large population. While such non-individualized treatment is sometimes effective; it is an exception to the rule.

This comparison therefore utilized biased information that held no external validity. Whooops.

It is interesting to note that Shang did evaluate the 8 trials on the use of homeopathic medicines in acute infection of the upper respiratory tract, where the authors noted a "substantial beneficial effect." Further, their sensitivity analysis suggests that "there is robust evidence that teh treatment under investigation works."

Shang then asserts that there is somehow bias in these double-blind, placebo controlled trials.

You folks are seemingly so critical of every homeopathic trial, even though one of Shang's conclusions was that, on average, more than twice as many homeopathic trials were of a high quality than the allopathic trials.

All of a sudden, your fine-toothed comb of analysis has disappeared. Is the goal of a good scientist a certain amount of objectivity?
 
Shang's analysis whittled down from 110 "matched" trials of homeopathy and allopathy to 21 high quality homeopathic studies and only 9 (!) allopathic ones. However, he never (!) provided any data or comparison of this group of high quality double-blind and placebo controlled trials. THAT is why another journal will finally publish this data. Whooops.

Which journal?

Instead, Shang whittled the now unmatch trials of 8 homeopathic and 6 allopathic trials. He wanted to only evaluate the large trials, the vast majority of which used only 1 homeopathic medicine for entire large population. While such non-individualized treatment is sometimes effective; it is an exception to the rule.
This comparison therefore utilized biased information that held no external validity. Whooops.
Then you will, of course, pubicly denounce the practice of pharmacists selling homeopathic preparations which are by their nature non-individualised.


You folks are seemingly so critical of every homeopathic trial, even though one of Shang's conclusions was that, on average, more than twice as many homeopathic trials were of a high quality than the allopathic trials.

All of a sudden, your fine-toothed comb of analysis has disappeared. Is the goal of a good scientist a certain amount of objectivity?

As you make much of the fact that twice as many homeopathic trials were of high quality than those using conventional medicine, so should you highlight the main point of Shang's analysis, that the better trials of homeopathy showed least benefit. The most important conclusion of a meta-analysis is to to ascertain if there is any justification of embarking on a single definitive trial of the preparation. As the 'better' the trial the less benefit is seen, Shang's paper indicates that no further work is required.

The results of a clinical trial are open to probabilistic error. The test for a difference between treatment arms of a trial are traditionally set at the 5% level. This means that approximately 5% of trials of ineffective treatments would show a significant difference with placebo. Of course bias and poor design could increase this figure. After 200 years homeopathy still hasn't risen above this noise level. It still hasn't found any mechanism for why it should work even after venturing into such disproved effects as memory in water. Any conventional medicine with such a dismal record would have rightly been discarded long ago.
 
While...non-individualized treatment is sometimes effective; it is an exception to the rule.
STOP PRESS! STOP PRESS!

LEADING HOMEOPATH DENOUNCES SINGLE REMEDY TREATMENT AS MOSTLY USELESS!
In a shock announcement today, a leading homeopath, Dana Ullman, declared that non-individualized homeopathy is only "sometimes effective" and that any effects are "an exception to the rule".

Homeopathy has become very popular as an Over The Counter product with sales worth millions of dollars per year. These sales depend on the idea that you can pick up a simple sugar pill to treat a wide variety of illnesses. The evidence for the efficacy of these remedies depends on exactly the same anecdotal evidence base as any other aspect of homeopathy. By criticising these products Mr Ullman cuts at the heart of the entire basis on which homeopaths have judged the alleged success of their remedies.

A disappointed consumer said: "I have always taken Oscillococcinum for the flu [homeopathic-speak for a 'man cold'] and I haven't died yet so it must have worked. But now I realise I may have recovered anyway."

A leading critic of homeopathy was quoted as saying: "For years we have told the homeopaths that their evidence was worthless and now, at last, we have one of their own number effectively admitting this. The problem with homeopathy is that it is riddled with internal contradictions and inconsistencies and as soon as you pick at one corner of the whole shambolic structure it just disintegrates."


STOP PRESS! STOP PRESS!

IN A RELATED STORY, SHARES IN LEADING LACTOSE SUPPLIERS HAVE FALLEN DRAMATICALLY AFTER ONE OF THEIR KEY MARKETS COMES UNDER THREAT FROM THE TRUTH
 
Last edited:
Dana, thought you might be interested in this, a simple test devised by le Canard Noir, to see if the proving aspect of homeopathy works.
 
I waited and waited and waited for somebody here to tell Wilsontown how wrong he is.
Wow! There must be a law of similars at work here because I, too, have waited and waited and waited. Of course, the thing I have waited for is your source for your claim that most homeopaths are physicians.

Regarding the rest of your objections, they have been ably addressed more than once by people quite knowledgeable enough and honest enough to do so.

I must say, James, that as an intelligent layman with no medical expertise and no right to practice medicine in the US (Hey! That's another way that we're similar!), I am quite able to discern who is arguing with substance, objectivity, and honesty as opposed to who is not. You are in the latter group.
 
STOP PRESS! STOP PRESS!

LEADING HOMEOPATH DENOUNCES SINGLE REMEDY TREATMENT AS MOSTLY USELESS!
In a shock announcement today, a leading homeopath, Dana Ullman, declared that non-individualized homeopathy is only "sometimes effective" and that any effects are "an exception to the rule".


BSM, you have to reprint this on the quackometer site, its priceless. :D
 
BSM, you have to reprint this on the quackometer site, its priceless. :D

As Linda has already implied, Dullman is getting so desperate he has starting engaging in a vigorous version of the Balloon Game, where you have to nominate companions successively for ejection from your puncture hot-air balloon.
 
Mr Monkey...Just because a medicine is not in post-Avogadro's number doses does not mean it is not homeopathic. One of my points is that skeptics of homeopathy are extremely slopping in their critique because they lump ALL of homeopathy together. At the very least, ardent skeptics should be big advocates of "health food store homeopathy," though why do I have the sneaking suspicion that your thick skulls have difficulty in saying anything good about any part of homeopathy? Hmmm.

Another homeopath defined a homeopathy medicine for me thus: It is prepared homeopathically, AND prescribed homeopathically. Do you agree, JG?

I am still waiting for someone (!) to acknowledge that there is truly an amazing body of scientific information on hormesis.

Homeopathy has noting to do with hormesis. You just possibly might make a case for isopathy, but even that will be far-fetched. Hormesis is a dose-dependent reaction.

Ultimately, homeopathy is a clever system of determining which substance/medicine a sick person will be hypersensitive.

JG, are you or are you not recognizing that post-avogadro potencies are part of homeopathy?

When you consider that symptoms are primarily defenses of the organism to infection, exposure to toxic substances, and/or stress of some sort, it makes sense to use homeopathic medicines or other therapies that mimic that defense rather than suppress it. Homeopathy does make sense.

Only if you know next to nothing about pathology. Symptoms are not primarily the defenses of the organism. A few of them are, but primarily, they are simply effects of toxins.

And do you know about the $1 million that he gave in 1920 to Ohio State University for the homeopathic research department of their homeopathic medical school? My book has a truly amazing story about what happened with this money and why Ohio State University was forced to return this money to him. Hmmmm.

Do you have any references newer than the first past of the last century? Hmmmmm?

Garette...I will not do your homework for you. Sorry.

Dana, I think most of us would be happy if only you did your own.

Hans
 
Instead, Shang whittled the now unmatch trials of 8 homeopathic and 6 allopathic trials. He wanted to only evaluate the large trials, the vast majority of which used only 1 homeopathic medicine for entire large population. While such non-individualized treatment is sometimes effective; it is an exception to the rule.

This comparison therefore utilized biased information that held no external validity. Whooops.

As opposed to the rest of the available information which is even more biased and without internal and/or external validity? Surely a "Whooops" for the one implies a "Double-Whooops" for the other?

It is interesting to note that Shang did evaluate the 8 trials on the use of homeopathic medicines in acute infection of the upper respiratory tract, where the authors noted a "substantial beneficial effect." Further, their sensitivity analysis suggests that "there is robust evidence that teh treatment under investigation works."

Shang then asserts that there is somehow bias in these double-blind, placebo controlled trials.

This is what he said:
"Such sensitivity analyses might suggest that there is robust evidence that the treatment under investigation works. However, the biases that are
prevalent in these publications, as shown by our study, might promote the conclusion that the results cannot be trusted."

Funny how that works. The data shows significant bias in association with study size in these double-blind, placebo-controlled trials and he uses that finding to conclude that there is significant bias in association with study size in these double-blind, placebo-controlled trials. The results lead to the conclusion. Based on your performance here, I'm not surprised that you find that a novel concept.

You folks are seemingly so critical of every homeopathic trial, even though one of Shang's conclusions was that, on average, more than twice as many homeopathic trials were of a high quality than the allopathic trials.

All of a sudden, your fine-toothed comb of analysis has disappeared. Is the goal of a good scientist a certain amount of objectivity?

When the sum total of the evidence for homeopathy consists of 21 trials, only 8 of which could be considered reasonably free from bias, compared to the tens of thousands for medicine, who can blame us for going for the easy pickings first?

Linda
 
Dana, thought you might be interested in this, a simple test devised by le Canard Noir, to see if the proving aspect of homeopathy works.


I wanted to comment further on that, but unfortunately it seems you have to have a Google or Blogger identity to post to the blog, which I have no intention of acquiring.

I seem to have been going round this very same argument for years, and the actual challenge posed by le Canard Noir goes way back - the first mention of it is in the famous Oliver Wendell Holmes essay of 1842.

In 1835 a public challenge was offered to the best-known Homeopathic physician in Paris to select any ten substances asserted to produce the most striking effects; to prepare them himself; to choose one by lot without knowing which of them he had taken, and try it upon himself or an intelligent and devoted Homeopathist, and, waiting his own time, to come forward and tell what substance had been employed. The challenge was at first accepted, but the acceptance retracted before the time of trial arrived.


Some years ago a homoeopath of my acquaintance threw at me the same challenge we've become familiar with from so many homoeopaths. Just take a few doses of a remedy (in my case it was Belladonna 30C that was mentioned) and you'll be astonished by the very marked effects you'll experience. (As an aside, I did that, and absolutely nothing unusual happened.)

I retorted to him that if the ultradilute remedies produced such striking effects then he should have no trouble with the 1835 challenge quoted above, and challenged him to try it.

I got exactly the same runaround as le Canard Noir is getting. First it would obviously be necessary to have a group of ten people at least to elicit the full remedy picture, and this made it impractical.

So, I changed the suggestion to a simple yes/no distinction. Show that you can tell the difference between Belladonna 30C and blank sugar pills, by noting whether or not you experience these "striking effects", which obviously his original challenge implied could be detected by one person. However, done this way, the test would obviously require a number of repetitions (possibly ten) to eliminate the effect of lucky guessing.

The next excuse was that such a test couldn't possibly be repeated in anything like a reasonable time scale. By now the homoeopath was implying that the remedy would make the prover "very sick", and doing that a number of times wouldn't be nice. Also, delayed effects from one dose might confuse the observing of the following dose.

At this stage I changed the format yet again, to multiply not the repetitions a single tester had to undergo, but to multiply the testers. The final format of the test required a number of homoeopaths (at least ten, but we hoped for 20), each of whom was certain they could recognise the proving effects of any ultradilute remedy of their choice. Each one would be sent either that remedy, or a bottle of blank pills. All they had to do was to say which it was.

It was Yuri Nalyssus who actually ran with this, as he is on good enough terms with a retired homoeopath to be able to ask him to referee the trial. He advertised widely for homoeopaths to take part in the trial, and to be honest we expected he'd get 20 quite easily. (In fact, no testing method was forbidden - they could try the remedy out on patients, do mass spectroscopy or NMR or particle acceleration or even get Rustum Roy to shove it through his magic spectrophotometer if they wanted, but we assumed that as the proving effects were universally declared to be so striking, that would be the preferred method.) Well, Yuri got exactly six volunteers.

Guess what. Three were right and three were wrong.

I cautioned him that it was almost inevitable that some homoeopath would start boasting that 50% of the participants could tell a remedy from a blank, and wasn't that great, but in fact he never publicised the results due to the small number of participants.

Isn't it interesting that so few homoeopaths are prepared to put their mouths where their money is, when actually challenged to a blind test of something they all maintain should be easy even for a non-expert or a sceptic to do unblinded?

I still think this is the best format for the test, to avoid both the difficulties apparently raised by detecting which of a number of remedies is being taken, and by the suggestion that a single person should perform more than one trial. Surely there are 20 homoeopaths who believe they can tell for sure between any remedy of their own choosing, and a bottle of "unmedicated" pills?

But it does seem that there are huge difficulties even here, despite the facile throwing up of the "take a remedy for yourself and you'll be instantly amazed" challenge to every sceptic who engages a homoeopath. Harald Walach was last heard of (several years ago) organising an extremely complicated multi-centre trial along very similar lines, but with all sorts of bells and whistles to try to counter even more objections thrown in the way be every homoeoapth consulted. I don't know when if ever we'll get a result on that. I suspect the final protocol will be so complicated and open to interpretation that it will settle nothing.

However, the predictable and repeatable progression from "just try a remedy, the effects will be so striking you're bound to be convinced" to "no, I can't possibly do that myself under blinded conditions" is awfully telling as regards homoeopath psychology.

Rolfe.
 
Last edited:
When the sum total of the evidence for homeopathy consists of 21 trials, only 8 of which could be considered reasonably free from bias, compared to the tens of thousands for medicine, who can blame us for going for the easy pickings first?

Linda

I should also mention that the 'evidence' from these 8 trials shows that homeopathy is indistinguishable from placebo. That is, while there are only 8 trials that actually speak to the issue of whether or not homeopathy has an effect, what they say is that homeopathy does not.

Linda
 
James Gully said:
I waited and waited and waited for somebody here to tell Wilsontown how wrong he is etc etc...

Well, I've read the Shang paper and I stand by my interpretation of it. I've yet to see any evidence that you have even the faintest understanding of the paper.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom