Dana Ullman's Homeopathy Studies Thread

No, wait a minute, I see the germ of a good idea here.

The reason they say they can't identify which one of a number of remedies they've taken is that to get the full symptom picture you need a team of at least ten provers.

So, we change the test to a simple matter of distinguishing a remedy chosen by the homoeopath for its ability to produce striking symptoms (however non-specific) in one person, and ask them to say if they've been given that, or the blank pills. A simple either/or test here produces problems because obviously there is a 50:50 chance of a lucky guess.

However, what if we were to give the homoeopath ten or more vials, with the assurance that one and one only contained the specified remedy. Surely they should be able to tell which one quite easily! Now as described that still leaves a 1 in 10 chance of a lucky guess, which is still too much. However, it's a lot better than 1 in 50, as regards working towards statistical significance.

So, we need to find out how many vials a homoeopath thinks it would be practical to screen for remedy presence, assuming only one is the actual remedy. Then we need to work out how many repetitions of that test would require to be correct in order to achieve p<0.001. If in fact this level of significance can be achieved with perhaps only three repetitions, then it could well be practical for one person to undertake the whole thing, just saying when they felt ready to go on to the next set. Even if it was a couple of months, that would be achievable.

Now, what excuses might they find for not doing this one?

Rolfe.

Well, if you want only 3 trials, this is easy. Pick 1 bottle out of 10 to have the remedy and the other 9 pure water and the person has to get a perfect 3/3 hit rate. If the person tries to get away with being able to be correct either 2 or 3 times out of 3, you have to have 1 bottle out of 55 instead of 1 out of 10, so that's a heck of a lot more tests (30 vs 165). No matter what, though, those 9 bottles of water must be the same as the water used for dilution, or else we'll have more PhDs writing letters about how bad the test is. ;)

Sadly, DanaJames already blurted the typical cop-out -- it wasn't the test that failed, just the person taking the test. If the test fails, the person is too unskilled to properly judge the waters. If you test 50 people and they all fail, well, you just cherry picked lousy people. And if you test 1,000 people, he'll blurt out that one person did pass hence it is possible to tell.
 
Oh, it's Harald Walach again.

More recent stuff from Walach in vol. 96 number 4 of Homeopathy, DOI doesn't work:

It is a well-known lore of homeopathic proving that those in control groups, relatives, or even the pet dog may develop proving symptoms although they have not taken the remedy. This lore, although anecdotal and not scientific evidence at all, is valuable since it suggests that placebo controls might not be adequate.

That whole patient-practitioner-remedy entanglement stuff is complete nonsense, of course.

Walach's letter is part of a debate which seems to have been kicked off by F. Dantas, P. Fisher, H. Walach, F. Wieland, D. P. Rastogi, H. Teixeira, D. Koster, J. P. Jansen, J. Eizayaga, M. E. P. Alvarez, M. Marim, P. Belon, and L. L. M. Weckx. A systematic review of the quality of homeopathic pathogenetic trials published from 1945 to 1995. Homeopathy 96 (1) 4-16 (2007) which says, for example:

The quality of reports was in general poor, and much important information for methodological analysis and reproducibility of HPTs was omitted from many reports... There was a large variation in methods. Quasiexperimental designs, without control groups were the most common type of study, particularly before–after studies, followed by trials using placebo parallel group (36% of the sample)... The nature of the effects was very diverse, but many seemed to be common symptoms, associated with placebo in clinical trials or reported as everyday symptoms, but we did not systematically assess this.
 
Last edited:
If you're going to do some type of test, you need to first determine which people think that they are hypersensitive to a specific medicine for a proving and then use ONLY these people.


Just to clarify, the subjects in the test were professional homoeopaths who had declared that they already knew they could "prove" the chosen substance.

The terms "medicine" and "hypersensitive" are nonsensical in the context of your posting.

Rolfe.
 
Last edited:
Well, if you want only 3 trials, this is easy. Pick 1 bottle out of 10 to have the remedy and the other 9 pure water and the person has to get a perfect 3/3 hit rate. If the person tries to get away with being able to be correct either 2 or 3 times out of 3, you have to have 1 bottle out of 55 instead of 1 out of 10, so that's a heck of a lot more tests (30 vs 165). No matter what, though, those 9 bottles of water must be the same as the water used for dilution, or else we'll have more PhDs writing letters about how bad the test is. ;)


Yes, I think this is a better protocol, possibly, we'll just have to see what wriggle-outs they come up with on this one.

Personally, I think that, given a year, anyone who is certain they can "prove" a particular remedy should be able to pick out which one of ten bottles actually contains that remedy, if the other nine bottles are only blank sugar pills. And I also think that doing one repetition per year is not unreasonable.

However, if they want to take a whole year to decide which is the bottle out of each group of ten, then wait an entire year before starting the next group, fine. That would still give us a result in five years. Since I've been arguing this one round the houses with them for nearly five years already, with nothing but evasions and backtracking to show for it, I'd be very happy to agree to a definitive test that would give an answer so quickly.

And to counter Dana's objections, it is written in the protocol that the subject (or all the subjects, if more than one) should be experienced homoeopaths who are already convinced of their own ability to "prove" their chosen remedy.

Rolfe.
 
Last edited:
Yeah, I did misunderstand Rolf's posting.

That said, having 3 of the 6 people determine that they were given a homeopathic medicine rather than a placebo is actually better than you might realize...

As post-hoc rationalisations go that really is a peach.

You have just placed yourself beyond the access of logical discourse. The size of the trial is irrelevant. If there had been 1000 Homs given a 50:50 trial and 500 succeeded you would declare that they all had special powers and all the rest were just mundanes.

But then the other 500 would have to be 100% right in determining that they had only been given blanks. But the remedies were allocated at random, so what would be the odds of 500 remedies being given to the 500 sensitives and the other 500 being given to 500 mundanes who have the self-contradictory property of being 100% accurate in spotting that this was so....


Please don't try to think about the above too closely it will make your brain bleed, but living in a constant state of reduction ad absurdum is the sad fate of the homeopath.

The stupid...it hurts.
 
Sorry Linda. Please list which CONDITIONS of the 8 homeopathic trials were matched to 6 allopathic trials? For instance, one of the homeopathic trials used was for "weight-loss." Which allopathic study did this? Which allopathic trial evaluated the "prevention of influenza?"

While I will certainly concede that the original 110 homeopathic and 110 allopathic trials were matched, the final 8 and 6 trials were not matched in any shape, way, or form. If you can prove otherwise, say it, though I know that you've got nothing here...and you refuse to admit it.

The point is that the question being asked and the type of study design and analysis used to answer that question does not depend upon matching on the basis of condition. Once you have created two groups that are similar, subsequent comparisons are performed on the groups as a whole or on subsets of the groups selected on the basis of characteristics of interest. The "conditions" are not the characteristic of interest. "High quality" and "relatively free from bias" are.

I'm happy to admit it, because it just doesn't matter.

Linda
 
As post-hoc rationalisations go that really is a peach.

You have just placed yourself beyond the access of logical discourse. The size of the trial is irrelevant. If there had been 1000 Homs given a 50:50 trial and 500 succeeded you would declare that they all had special powers and all the rest were just mundanes.

But then the other 500 would have to be 100% right in determining that they had only been given blanks. But the remedies were allocated at random, so what would be the odds of 500 remedies being given to the 500 sensitives and the other 500 being given to 500 mundanes who have the self-contradictory property of being 100% accurate in spotting that this was so....


Please don't try to think about the above too closely it will make your brain bleed, but living in a constant state of reduction ad absurdum is the sad fate of the homeopath.

The stupid...it hurts.


Actually, I hadn't glommed on to that one! It's a beauty. And of course you're quite right.

If any of them had special powers, the result would have to be better than 50% by exactly that proportion. Because of course the mundanes wouldn't always be wrong, you'd expect them to be right half of the time just by chance. So the presence of any specially-blessed individuals would always skew it above 50%.

I can't find the email now where Yuri told me how many of the correct-responders actually got the remedy and how many got the blank. It might be easiest just to ask him.

I suppose you could argue that while the specially-blessed individuals will always be right whatever they get, the response of the mundanes should be skewed to "I got the blank", because they are incapable of experiencing the proving symptoms even if they get the remedy? Now it's my brain hurting to try to figure how this might affect anything, if it even does, given that both mundanes and specials get either/or by random assignment.

Anyway, like I said, Yuri advertised for experienced homoeopaths who were confident they could in fact prove the remedy they chose. Which rather undermines the entire objection.

Rolfe.
 
More magical thinking......

Dana, ever play that game where you are at a party and the DJ offers a prize to the couple who are left on the dance floor after guessing which way they should line up with each other?

Each person on the dance floor has to assume the position of "front to front" or "back to back" with their dance partner. The DJ has 2 cards which he picks at random - calling out "front to front" or "back to back" each time the card comes up.

So as the couples choose their positions, he shouts out what his card says. Each couple who are correctly matched stay on the floor, the others sit down. After about 7 or 8 turns, there is one couple left who has "guessed" correctly each time, and who wins the prize.

Is this couple endowed with paranormal powers of prediction? Do they have a quantum entanglement linked to the vibrational energy emanating from the cards? There must be a logical explanation - after all, who could possibly conceivably "guess" correctly 8 times in succession? Spooky, huh?

Isn't chance a wonderful thing?
The constant attribution of supernatural powers to the simple circumstances of probability is one of the things I dislike most about Woo.
 
Last edited:
Yeah, I did misunderstand Rolf's posting.


No, Dana, you did not misunderstand Rolfe's post, you misread it. ;)

That said, having 3 of the 6 people determine that they were given a homeopathic medicine rather than a placebo is actually better than you might realize, though this small trial of only 6 doesn't prove one thing or another. The fact of the matter is that not everyone is appropriate for doing a proving of a homeopathic medicine .

And now you are misreading AND misunderstanding. :boggled:
 
PS: They tell me you wrote an authoritative book on homoeopathy recently. :D
 
Last edited:
Sorry Linda. Please list which CONDITIONS of the 8 homeopathic trials were matched to 6 allopathic trials? For instance, one of the homeopathic trials used was for "weight-loss." Which allopathic study did this? Which allopathic trial evaluated the "prevention of influenza?"

While I will certainly concede that the original 110 homeopathic and 110 allopathic trials were matched, the final 8 and 6 trials were not matched in any shape, way, or form. If you can prove otherwise, say it, though I know that you've got nothing here...and you refuse to admit it.

You folks can create your own idea for testing homeopathy, but because you still have such a shallow understanding of the method, you will continue to create bad designs in which only naive homeopaths will participate.

In the meantime, I'm still waiting to hear anyone answer the above questiona. I'll be waiting beside Godot.

And merry Christmas everyone. Whether you and I agree or disagree on one subject or another, I do wish you well.
 
You folks can create your own idea for testing homeopathy, but because you still have such a shallow understanding of the method, you will continue to create bad designs in which only naive homeopaths will participate.

Translation...

Only savvy homeopaths realize that they must avoid testing homeopathy because they already know it will fail.

In the meantime, I'm still waiting to hear anyone answer the above questiona. I'll be waiting beside Godot.

Translation...

I have no comeback for your answers, so I will pretend that they do not exist.

Linda
 
You folks can create your own idea for testing homeopathy, but because you still have such a shallow understanding of the method, you will continue to create bad designs in which only naive homeopaths will participate.


That is easy to say.
What is hard is to explain why the designs you have been given are wrong.
What is even harder is coming up with your own design for an appropriate test.

Take that as another challenge you will ignore.

In the meantime, I'm still waiting to hear anyone answer the above questiona. I'll be waiting beside Godot.


And I'll still be waiting to hear from you why the answers already supplied are wrong.
I'll be waiting beside my dog.

And merry Christmas everyone. Whether you and I agree or disagree on one subject or another, I do wish you well.


It is not about agreement or disagreement.
It is about reading and understanding, and responding in a meaningful way.
 
Last edited:
You folks can create your own idea for testing homeopathy, but because you still have such a shallow understanding of the method, you will continue to create bad designs in which only naive homeopaths will participate.

In the meantime, I'm still waiting to hear anyone answer the above questiona. I'll be waiting beside Godot.

And merry Christmas everyone. Whether you and I agree or disagree on one subject or another, I do wish you well.

fls has repeatedly rebutted your statements on this metastudy. Your inability to understand what is fairly simple speaks volumes. As each point in your arguement is deflated you simply invent more or just repeat the old argument.

You claim that you do not prescribe to people, however you harm them very directly by publishing untruths. You encourage others who may be deluded or just charlatans. Innocent people will spend money with homeopaths to get water or lactose. Others will fail to get proper treatment and will die because of your desire to convince them of something that is just not true.

After 200 years you cannot produce one irrefutable piece of evidence to match BSM's question.

Contrary to your statement, the people in this forum do understand the tenets of homeopathy. They understand the inherent contradiction in 'proving', they understand the science of dilution and they understand that there is no evidence that homeopathy works. Your mistake is in believing that rolling out the proclamations that go down so well with the uneducated and non-skeptical believers is all that is required here.

I cannot see how you could possibly wish us well when advising others to undertake your variety of harm.

BTW Please wait beside Godot, in Beckett's play he never appeared.:p
 
And to counter Dana's objections, it is written in the protocol that the subject (or all the subjects, if more than one) should be experienced homoeopaths who are already convinced of their own ability to "prove" their chosen remedy.
How about adding to the protocol that at first each and everyone gets the "real" homeopathic remedy, so that they can verify that they indeed do experience whatever they are supposed to experience? When they have confirmed that, the actual test can begin.
 
Because then they'll say there are so many delayed effects they really can't say when, if ever, they'll be able to begin again.

See, I've been round this one before.

You folks can create your own idea for testing homeopathy, but because you still have such a shallow understanding of the method, you will continue to create bad designs in which only naive homeopaths will participate.


Dana, you talk about ideas for testing homoeopathy. You've only been asked for simple documented case reports of people with demonstrably non-self-limiting illnesses being cured by homoeopathy. You have none. If you can't demonstrate one actual unambiguous cure, and you don't even seem to have a candidate, however flawed, because all we get are ancient tales, studies on self-limiting conditions, and studies in which it is impssible to say that anyone was cured by homoeopathy, then what's to test?

Now we have another one. Just show that you can reliably differentiate any remedy of your choice from a bottle of blank sugar pills. Any way you like. Get your mate Rustum Roy to do it if you want. Or just see if these amazing proving symptoms show up, it's your choice. You maintain your magic sugar pills have real physical effects on the real physical world, which are different from ordinary mundane sugar pills. So there must be some way to tell.

Unless of course homoeopathy has never cured anyone, and the pills are indeed indistinguishable from any other old sugar pills.

Now there's a hypothesis that fits the observed facts! Care to try to disprove it?

Rolfe.
 
Last edited:
Because then they'll say there are so many delayed effects they really can't say when, if ever, they'll be able to begin again.
Dana, surely you must have an idea on how long a remedy does affect you, otherwise you woudn't know when it's time to switch to a second remedy if the first one didn't lead to the intented effect? So, I'm sure you can tell us how long to wait before you'd be in the clear.

And if this differers between different remedies, just give us a couple of examples.

Thanks!
 
It will differ between different remedies, it will differ between different patients, it will differ within the same patient at different times and places. Hell, it will differ between different practitioners and the same patient. Even the remedy will differ between different practitioners and the same patient.

And what is the common link? Nonsense:


It seems that what is important is not the practitioner, or the patient, or the particular remedy, but the EPR like entanglement between the practitioner, the patient and the remedy bound together by the ritual of serial dilution and percussion.

Or something like that. :D
 
Last edited:
Watching a thread like this is always fascinating in a perverse sort of way. It compares more than anything with watching the Black Knight in Monty Python's "Holy Grail" being dismembered and playing down the fact, or perhaps it compares with 'Comical Ali' in the early days of the (tragic and deeply flawed) US-led invation of Iraq.

Should one admire Mr. Ullman's persistency in repeatedly and without exception being shown he is WRONG, and yet still returning for more flogging? Stupid must have its limit, I suppose, but we haven't found it yet it seems. Anyone with just a grain of common sense and ability to think critically and logically can see that Mr. Ulmann, as any other homeopath, is, digging a hole for himself, and that the hole gets bigger and bigger whether he keeps posting or not. Amazing.

I can't really determine whether Mr. Ulmann is simply deluded, or whether he's a con-man and he knows it. Perhaps it's equal parts of both? The way he keeps plugging his miserable book(s) I'm inclined to think he knows he's wrong, but there's a market for suckers and he's going for it. I'll save my expletives for later, assuming I make up my mind one way or the other.

Merry Yuletide, everyone, even to you, Mr. Ullman. If you're simply deluded you deserve our efforts in providing you knowledge to help opening your eyes, and those of your victims, to reality - if you are just a simple snake-oil peddling con-man, you deserve nothing but contempt. Either way, please keep exposing yourself, and homepathy, as the idiocy it is by continuing to post here. At least that way you are useful, Mr. Ulmann.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom