Dana Ullman's Homeopathy Studies Thread

I have said it many times, but for many reasons, you folks simply don't like to learn. You love thinking in such black and white terms that you don't and seemingly cannot appreciate complexity. A tad ironic, isn't it.

Once again, the majority of homeopathic medicines sold in health food stores and pharmacies today are in potencies usually under 12C...where there are some molecules, though they are in considerably lower dose than any of your regular drugs. And yet, I have shown again and again and again that these "lower potency" homeopathic medicines have biological action.

Indeed, and no one is going to dispute that if you take some nasty botanical extract, dilute it 1 in 1,000 and 1 in 10,000, for that is the meaning of 3X and 4x, and dump it on some poor unsuspecting cells going about their harmless business in cell culture stuff is going to happen.

But, that ain't homeopathy even if you give the bottle a little shake at each of your dilution stages.

You've been shifting the grounds of your defence so tortuously that I think you have joined our dear Kumar in his Bass-Ackwards machine.

"Homeo"pathy exploits an invented and erroneous concept called the "law of similars".This paper does not test any implications of that "law".

Homeopathy has identified itself with the use of content-free solutions because Hahnemann needed to do that to avoid killing people directly. This paper does not test a content-free solution.

It is not a test of homeopathy.

It is a simple bench-chemistry experiment on cultured cells that happens to have the word "homeopathic" in its title solely and only because the material used has "homeopathic" written on its label.
 
Last edited:
And still Dana provides absolutely zero references for his claim that most homeopaths are also physicians.

Until he corrects this, or unless my own googling shows different (so far it shows exactly the opposite), then I think it is fair to say that those references do not exist.
 
Mr Monkey...Just because a medicine is not in post-Avogadro's number doses does not mean it is not homeopathic. One of my points is that skeptics of homeopathy are extremely slopping in their critique because they lump ALL of homeopathy together. At the very least, ardent skeptics should be big advocates of "health food store homeopathy," though why do I have the sneaking suspicion that your thick skulls have difficulty in saying anything good about any part of homeopathy? Hmmm.

I am still waiting for someone (!) to acknowledge that there is truly an amazing body of scientific information on hormesis. Ultimately, homeopathy is a clever system of determining which substance/medicine a sick person will be hypersensitive.

When you consider that symptoms are primarily defenses of the organism to infection, exposure to toxic substances, and/or stress of some sort, it makes sense to use homeopathic medicines or other therapies that mimic that defense rather than suppress it. Homeopathy does make sense.

Please remember that quote about "thick skulls" was made by a major advocate for homeopathy, Charles Kettering.

And do you know about the $1 million that he gave in 1920 to Ohio State University for the homeopathic research department of their homeopathic medical school? My book has a truly amazing story about what happened with this money and why Ohio State University was forced to return this money to him. Hmmmm.

Garette...I will not do your homework for you. Sorry.
 
When you consider that symptoms are primarily defenses of the organism to infection, exposure to toxic substances, and/or stress of some sort, it makes sense to use homeopathic medicines or other therapies that mimic that defense rather than suppress it. Homeopathy does make sense.

It's a bit like claiming that being run over by an imaginary bus protects you against being run over by a real bus.

Homeopathy doesn't make sense - it makes cents, and bigger. It is snake oil with the oil taken out.
 
Mr Monkey...Just because a medicine is not in post-Avogadro's number doses does not mean it is not homeopathic.


OK, we got that. Now please answer Steenkh's question.

Are you now disowning the entire field of trans-avogadral doses?


Do you intend to confine your apologia for homoeopathy to sub-avogadro-limit preparations? Or does your confidence in its value extend past that limit? Enquiring minds want to know.

Ultimately, homeopathy is a clever system of determining which substance/medicine a sick person will be hypersensitive.

When you consider that symptoms are primarily defenses of the organism to infection, exposure to toxic substances, and/or stress of some sort, it makes sense to use homeopathic medicines or other therapies that mimic that defense rather than suppress it. Homeopathy does make sense.


Do you have the slightest shred of evidence for any part of this statement? (No? Thought not.) Do you have any evidence at all of any biological effect of any homoeopathic preparation which might be said in any way to involve hypersensitivity, or specific natural defence mechanisms? (No? Thought not.)

Dana, you might be able to get away with making it up as you go along, and making totally unfounded assertions, in your usual social milieux. It doesn't work here.

Now, while accepting that pouring actual physical amounts of plant extracts on innocent cell cultures might very well have an effect of some sort, how do you account for the alleged clinical effects of trans-avogadral preparations?

Rolfe.
 
One of my points is that skeptics of homeopathy are extremely slopping in their critique because they lump ALL of homeopathy together.
Can we take it that you will not defend proper homoeopathy, but only "health food homoeopathy?

At the very least, ardent skeptics should be big advocates of "health food store homeopathy," though why do I have the sneaking suspicion that your thick skulls have difficulty in saying anything good about any part of homeopathy? Hmmm.
Why should we? Even if there is a theoretical does in "health food store homoeopathic" pills, there is still no reliable evidence that it actually works.

I am still waiting for someone (!) to acknowledge that there is truly an amazing body of scientific information on hormesis. Ultimately, homeopathy is a clever system of determining which substance/medicine a sick person will be hypersensitive.
Really? Homoeopaths that I have encountered have never claimed that one should take their snake oil in order to determine if one suffers from hypersensitivity.

When you consider that symptoms are primarily defenses of the organism to infection, exposure to toxic substances, and/or stress of some sort, it makes sense to use homeopathic medicines or other therapies that mimic that defense rather than suppress it. Homeopathy does make sense.
You mean "nonsense"! Please explain why it makes sense to you to cure a rash with something that only qualifies because it causes rashes? Your thick skull has been too immersed in homoeopathic lore to realise that is clearly nonsensical.

Please remember that quote about "thick skulls" was made by a major advocate for homeopathy, Charles Kettering.
Who apparently must have had a thick skull himself. Prince Charles is also a big advocate of homoeopathy. Why should that mean anything to me?
 
Last edited:
Once again, the majority of homeopathic medicines sold in health food stores and pharmacies today are in potencies usually under 12C...where there are some molecules, though they are in considerably lower dose than any of your regular drugs. And yet, I have shown again and again and again that these "lower potency" homeopathic medicines have biological action.

That chemicals may have biological action is not a claim of homeopathy, but of medicine. Whether or not you wish to hi-jack discoveries made through medical research, the point is that homeopathy is not the source of these insights. Nor does homeopathy actually use these insights, since a treatment is chosen on the basis of symptoms rather than biological action.

I have referred to the entire field of hormesis (low dose science) that has nothing to do with homeopathy, except that it shows the power, according the numerous fields of scientific experiment, of infinitesimal doses (still material doses, but still very very small). (Do some googling on hormesis...it is a very fertile area of investigation, that is, it is for people who want to learn)

Again, as you point out, homeopathy is not the source of these insights. Nor does homeopathy use any of the insights gathered through the study of hormesis.

Don't you remember all of the times that I made reference to low-dose homeopathy? Have you all killed your brain cells? I then encouraged you to become big supporters of "health food store" homeopathy...and yet, not of you have backbone (or neuron) to acknowledge this. Whooops.

Acknowledging this gets us nowhere. The presence of a few active ingredients does not tell us whether or not there is biological action. It does not tell us whether or not this translates into an in vivo effect. It does not tell us whether an in vivo effect leads to a clinical effect. And even if a particular chemical or combination of chemicals is eventually found to have a clinical effect, it does not tell us how to identify which bottle to pick from the hundreds available to us, since the method of identifying chemicals for use through homeopathy is demonstrably wrong.

Worst of all, you are very sloppy in your critique of homeopathy by grouping together ALL of homeopathy. The irony of your non-scientific thinking is dripping. There is so little difference in your thinking and those religious fundamentalist. More irony.

It is interesting to watch you shave off bits and pieces (and sometimes whole chunks) of homeopathy as we proceed to invalidate each specific claim. It may have seemed like a good idea when you started ("I can't address their criticisms so I'll just remove them from consideration"), but at the rate you're going, you won't have anything left when we're done.

Linda
 
James Gully said:
Mr Monkey...Just because a medicine is not in post-Avogadro's number doses does not mean it is not homeopathic. One of my points is that skeptics of homeopathy are extremely slopping in their critique because they lump ALL of homeopathy together. At the very least, ardent skeptics should be big advocates of "health food store homeopathy," though why do I have the sneaking suspicion that your thick skulls have difficulty in saying anything good about any part of homeopathy? Hmmm.

Didn't you say that 'health food store' homeopathy, where all patients suffering from, say, hayfever get the same remedy, didn't count as real homeopathy? Isn't it only homeopathy if the remedy is 'individualised'?

Of course, skeptics should only be big advocates of "health food store" homeopathy if there is some evidence that it works, which there isn't.
 
From t'other thread:

James Gully said:
Wilsontown makes reference to Shang's 18 (!) studies, and yet, the final analysis only included 8 homeopathic studies and 6 allopathic ones.

In actual fact, he NEVER provided any analysis of the 21 high quality homeopathic studies and the 9 high quality allopathic studies. However, the International Journal of Epidemiology is solving this question, and a review will be published shortly. Be prepared for Mea culpas.

Good grief.

One particular part of the meta-analysis includes 8 homeoapthic trials and 6 conventional trials. This is the part of the analysis that compares the trials that are most likely to be free of bias. Homeopathy showed no effect beyond placebo, conventional medicine did show an effect.

However, Shang et al. also performed statistics on the whole dataset. This included 48 trials of clinical homeopathy, 35 trials of complex homeopathy, 18 of classical homeopathy, and 8 of isopathy. Shang et al. found that there was no evidence that any of these sub-groups had more pronounced effects than the others. This is the point I was making regarding the 18 trials of classical homeopathy: that there is no evidence that classical homeopathy was any better than any of the other interventions tested. So your assertion that the results might have been positive for homeopathy if only classical homeopathy was included is not backed up by the evidence. I honestly can't see what you fail to understand about this.

As for the International Journal of Epidemiology publishing a comparison of the 21 versus 9 trials that were deemed to be of higher quality, what's the point? That subsample of studies was shown to be biased. YOU CAN'T DRAW ANY USEFUL CONCLUSIONS FROM THIS SUBSET OF STUDIES BECAUSE IT IS BIASED.
 
Garette...I will not do your homework for you. Sorry.
Your homework. You made a claim; I asked you to back it up.

I have, in fact, done some homework.

I've looked at the European Guidelines for Homeopathic Education (June 2000, 2nd edition), on the website of the European Council of Classical Homeopathy, and learned that there is exactly zero requirement for medical training.

I've learned that only three states in the United States require any kind of licensing at all to be a practicing homeopath, though all states require licensing to practice medicine.

I've learned that there are no numbers (at least no reasonably available numbers) provided even by homeopathic or naturopathic organizations to support your claim.

I will be generous and assume that you have honestly believed your claim about most homeopaths also being physicians, but if you make the claim again without proper substantiation it will be clear to me and to others reading this thread that you are lying about it.
 
Mr Monkey...Just because a medicine is not in post-Avogadro's number doses does not mean it is not homeopathic. One of my points is that skeptics of homeopathy are extremely slopping in their critique because they lump ALL of homeopathy together. At the very least, ardent skeptics should be big advocates of "health food store homeopathy," though why do I have the sneaking suspicion that your thick skulls have difficulty in saying anything good about any part of homeopathy? Hmmm.

I would say that I don't know whether to laugh or cry but that would be untrue. Laughing is the only option.

Please stop raising silly strawman arguments.

"Homeo"pathy exploits an invented and erroneous concept called the "law of similars".This paper does not test any implications of that "law".

Homeopathy has identified itself with the use of content-free solutions because Hahnemann needed to do that to avoid killing people directly. This paper does not test a content-free solution.

It is not a test of homeopathy.

It is a simple bench-chemistry experiment on cultured cells that happens to have the word "homeopathic" in its title solely and only because the material used has "homeopathic" written on its label.

It would seem I need to repeat myself for the thinking-impaired.

If you look in the quote above I specify two concepts. The former is a necessary component of homeopathy- the clue is in the name. The second is an accidental accretion. Albeit it that the latter is funnier, both are wrong.

Things that are "homeopathic" may contain real amounts of real chemicals, but this is not what homeopaths usually use.

So, a test of homeopathy might choose to test the law of similars or it might choose to test the effect of content-free shaken solvent.

If it does neither of these things, as does your latest paper, IT IS NOT A TEST OF HOMEOPATHY.

I'm sorry you found the ideas confusing, I will try to explain things more simply in future, but I am having difficulty titrating down to that level.


At the very least, ardent skeptics should be big advocates of "health food store homeopathy," though why do I have the sneaking suspicion that your thick skulls have difficulty in saying anything good about any part of homeopathy? Hmmm.

What? Do you mean over-the-counter products that contain actual chemicals but have no individualisation? I would hold them to the same account as I would hold any active pharmaceutical agent: proof of efficacy and safety. Show me one OTC homeopathic product that can satisfy this requirement. The fact that you cannot is a corollary of the fact that the "law" of similars is no such thing.
 
JamesGully - I'm aware that you'll never succeed in convincing the denigrators of Homeopathy that it works. I'm much more open-minded so try to convince me.

As a Phytotherapy practitioner I made my list of medicinal plants that are effective or not, e.g. Avena sativa = nothing, Calendula officinalis = nothing, Hypericum perforatum = does something but not wonderful, Crataegus oxyacantha = very good, etc. Could you make similar examples for homeopathic remedies?

Which are in your opinion the main homeopathic polycrests?

Gripp-Heel belongs to Homeopathy or Homotoxicology?
Thank you.
 
JamesGully - I'm aware that you'll never succeed in convincing the denigrators of Homeopathy that it works. I'm much more open-minded so try to convince me.
I congratulate you on your open-mindedness. I trust you will use it wisely.

You are correct in one thing, and somewhat incorrect in another regarding your statement here.

You are correct that "denigrators of Homeopathy" will not be convinced that it works, because in fact it does not. Were Dana or others able to demonstrate that it does, then there would be no more denigration.

You are incorrect in portraying the skeptics here as denigrators of homeopathy, except indirectly. They are first and foremost, denigrators of those who purvey known falsehoods and of the misapplication of science.

Other than those things, good post.
 
Do you mean over-the-counter products that contain actual chemicals but have no individualisation? I would hold them to the same account as I would hold any active pharmaceutical agent: proof of efficacy and safety. Show me one OTC homeopathic product that can satisfy this requirement. The fact that you cannot is a corollary of the fact that the "law" of similars is no such thing.


We can perhaps tell something from the fact that between 1971 and 1994, when homoeopathic medicines would have needed to demonstrate efficacy in order to be introduced onto the market in the UK, to quote the MHRA website, "attempts to acquire marketing authorisations for new homoeopathic medicines were unsuccessful owing to difficulties in proving efficacy in conventional clinical trials."
 
JamesGully - I'm aware that you'll never succeed in convincing the denigrators of Homeopathy that it works.

We're not denigrating homeopathy so much as denigrating the idea that it is reasonable to ignore all that we have learned in the last 200 years. We have learned that careful observation in the absence of blinding and controls is very unreliable when it comes to discovering whether or not we are wrong. We have learned that we are very good at seeing patterns where none exist. We have learned that matter is composed of atoms - that there are indivisible units (although we did get the indivisible unit wrong when we were applying the name) - so there are limits to what can be accomplished through dilution. We have learned that it is far, far better to know when you are wrong than it is to hold out for the faint hope that you are right.

I'm much more open-minded so try to convince me.

I think the distinction you are trying to make is that you are firmly on the side of not caring whether you are wrong as much as you care about maintaining the possibility that you are right.

Linda
 
JamesGully - I'm aware that you'll never succeed in convincing the denigrators of Homeopathy that it works. I'm much more open-minded so try to convince me.

But, in this thread, he hasn't tried to convince anybody that homeopathy works. There has just been a lot of unsubstantiated statements, no true Scotsmen arguments, arguments from authority and irrelevant references to the amazing fact that chemicals affect cells in culture.

Being open minded implies the ability to accept that the data doesn't show what you want. No evidence has shown that homeopathy works. It may be easy for people to be misled by some of the poor trials in homeopathy into believing that there is something in it. If after being shown the faults in these trials which invalidate them the belief is still held it is not then open mindedness but credulousness.
 
At the very least, ardent skeptics should be big advocates of "health food store homeopathy,"


Why? Many of these "over the counter" (more often "off the shelf", in fact) are nostrums for particular conditions, sold without any consultation. It should therefore be much simpler to test them in randomised double-blind placebo controlled trials than to test classical homoeopathy. If they work as claimed, there is no valid reason that this can't be demonstrated using the same type of tests that real medicines have to pass. And yet, when for almost a quarter of a century any new medicine, including homoeopathic medicines, had to demonstrate efficacy to gain access to the market in the UK, no new homoeopathic nostrums were accepted because they were unable to demonstrate efficacy. They had to change the law to allow new homoeopathic medicines onto the market.

In the absence of evidence that they work, there's no reason whatsoever for skeptics to support them.
 
Does anyone know if the below petition was ever addressed -and if so, what outcome (if any) came of it?

Snippet taken from "Petition Regarding Homeopathic Drugs"
Docket # 94P-0316/CP 1
Filed August 29, 1994​

Action Requested
The FDA Commissioner should initiate a rulemaking procedure, similar to the OTC Review, to require that all OTC homeopathic drugs meet the same standards of safety and effectiveness as nonhomeopathic OTC drugs. In the interim, the Commissioner should issue a public warning that although the FDA has permitted homeopathic remedies to be sold, it does not recognize them as effective.

Statement of Grounds
Although homeopathic products are not recognized as effective by the scientific community, the FDA has tolerated their marketing because a provision of the 1938 Food, Drug, and Cosmetic Act recognized substances listed in the Homeopathic Pharmacopeia as drugs. However, nothing in the law prohibits the FDA from requiring homeopathic remedies to be proven effective to remain on the market.

FDA Compliance Policy Guide 7132.15, issued in 1988, states that "nonprescription homeopathics may be sold only for self-limiting conditions recognizable by consumers . . . [Their] labeling must adequately instruct consumers in the product's safe use." However, the guide warns that compliance with its requirements "does not establish that [a product] has been shown by appropriate means to be safe, effective, and not misbranded for its intended use."
The FDA's laissez-fair regulatory policy has enabled dozens of companies to market hundreds of products with claims (often simply in the name of the product) that are unsubstantiated. All of these products are misbranded because they do not indicate on their label that they can remedy nothing. Nor do they state how much of any ingredient the product contains in a way that the average consumer can understand. Nor can adequate directions for use be written for products that don't work. Because the FDA permits their sale, consumers are being misled into thinking that the remedies are effective, not only for symptomatic relief but for the treatment of serious diseases.

Products designated as 24X, 12C, or higher, should contain no molecules of the original substance from which they are prepared. Yet they are being marketed as though they are potent remedies.


What Stephen Barrett et al are demanding in this petition does not seem to be too much to ask for.

There are homeopathic "medicines" on the shelves in our local pharmacy that have nothing printed on their labels except for very vague insinuations to treat conditions that can be broadly interpreted to refer to anything from mild to serious conditions.

Homeopathic remedies in my pharmacy have labels that simply have one or two words printed on them, such as "Heart." No ingredient list, no ingredient strength, no dosage instructions, and nothing more specific as to exactly what condition it is to treat (i.e. perhaps it is just to treat a "broken heart"? ...or is it to treat serious heart conditions?)

Is this legal?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom