Dana Ullman's Homeopathy Studies Thread

I think he actually does believe in homoeopathy.
There is no risk of increasing his book sales on this forum.
 
Perhaps you're right - then at least the time he spends here isn't spent on promoting his inane garbage.

Along the same lines, has anyone noticed trends that indicate differences in responses between the deluded and the farudulent? Which ones tend to get all peeved, hit their ignore button and just run away, and which ones tend to stay on and 'fight'? I suppose the deluded tend to be the more persistent, so I suppose based on that pattern Mr. Ullman appears to be seriously attached to his homeopathetic dilution - sorry, homeopathic delusion.

Beginning January 1, 2008, I might cease calling sCAM just sCAM. Hensforth, I'll try to remember to refer to it also as Alternative To Treatment.
 
Probably another alternative therapy that can be explained by the placebo effect. If you can make someone believe that the therapy they are getting is highly benficial, the chances are it will be
 
Well, that depends a lot on what's wrong. If you've broken your leg, then believing a remedy is highly beneficial will hardly unbreak it. But on the other hand, broken legs heal. So the trick there is to persuade the patient to give the remedy credit for what would have happened anyway.

If you're suffering from a chronic, fluctuating illness, how you feel at any one time depends a lot on, well, how you feel. It can be quite psychological. So there, homoeopathy gets two bites at the cherry. It may be that the fluctuating condition was about to enter a period of improvement anyway, so hey, we'll take credit for that. Or else sometimes the "therapeutic consultation" can have such a positive psychological effect that the patient does indeed declare he feels batter even though the condition is objectively unchanged.

What has never been shown to occur is an objectively measurable improvement in an objective physical ailment due to "placebo". Yes, psychological things like anxiety and depression may genuinely improve because of positive reinforcement, but actual physical illness doesn't. In this case, "placebo" is either an improvement that would have happened anyway, being credited to the sugar pill, or a purely subjective report of "feeling better" which is not in fact a reflection of actual objective improvement.

Or, really, just a combination of coincidence and wishful thinking.

Rolfe.
 
If you're suffering from a chronic, fluctuating illness, how you feel at any one time depends a lot on, well, how you feel. It can be quite psychological. So there, homoeopathy gets two bites at the cherry. It may be that the fluctuating condition was about to enter a period of improvement anyway, so hey, we'll take credit for that. Or else sometimes the "therapeutic consultation" can have such a positive psychological effect that the patient does indeed declare he feels batter even though the condition is objectively unchanged.

They also get a third bite of the cherry. If the fluctuating illness gets worse after 'treatment', it is considered a good sign by homeopaths. It shows that they are not just administering lactose/water. :rolleyes:
 
They also get a third bite of the cherry. If the fluctuating illness gets worse after 'treatment', it is considered a good sign by homeopaths. It shows that they are not just administering lactose/water. :rolleyes:

Is that what they call a "healing crisis"?
 
Or an "aggravation".

Basically, anything that happens after the treatment is claimed to have been caused by the treatment. Remember those reports of "provings"...

ETA: And remember manioberoi's report of a severe storm that swept over Northern California two weeks after some sheep had been given a dose of homoeopathic Angustura.
 
Last edited:
Yes.

Most people with a chronic fluctuating illness tend to seek help when their symtoms are at their worst. If the symtoms are at their worst, they must necessarily improve thereafter (regression to the mean) regardless of any treatment given. If they have sought help from a homoeopath, hompeopathy will get the credit.

But, even if the patient jumps the gun and gets treatment while their symptoms are still getting worse, the continuing worsening of their symtoms that occurs after the homoeopathic treatment has commenced is called a "healing crisis", which is said to be the result of the "release of toxins" that must occur before its beneficial effect can be experienced.
 
I'm thoroughly depressed. I should have done this a long time ago but I followed the link in Rolfe's signature. All we have logically debunked has been done before. I thought I'd cheer myself up and go to a local bookshop to purchase a copy of Hitchens' God is not Great. Couldn't find it under science and philosophy, and it, fortunately, wasn't under spiritualism. What really depressed me was that the spritualism section, filled with such rightly named gems as Idiots Guide to whatever non-evidence based idiocy you want to have faith with and numerous books on homeopathy, was three times bigger than the whole of the science section.

Hey ho, more work to do then!
 
What really depressed me was that the spritualism section, filled with such rightly named gems as Idiots Guide to whatever non-evidence based idiocy you want to have faith with and numerous books on homeopathy, was three times bigger than the whole of the science section.


My local bookshop calls that section "Alternative Living" and, yes, it's three times the size of the science section. And since the science section is currently half empty, it has about six times as many books as the science section.
 
I'm thoroughly depressed. I should have done this a long time ago but I followed the link in Rolfe's signature. All we have logically debunked has been done before. I thought I'd cheer myself up and go to a local bookshop to purchase a copy of Hitchens' God is not Great.


Just to add to your misery, I'm not sure Rolfe would approve of your purchase. :D
 
I can't say I disapprove of any book at all, to be honest. Only people who are afraid of the contents disapprove of books.

Rolfe.
 
So, We will be seeing an analysis of the second-rate studies excluded from Shang's main anlysis;

http://www.quackometer.net/blog/2007/12/homeopathic-revolution-by-dana-ullman.html

"What would you say if someone evaluated (finally) the 21 high quality (double-blind and placebo controlled) homeopathic studies and the 9 allopathic ones. Well, someone has finally done this, and it will be published shortly. "

I wonder where it will be published.
 
I'm sure that it will be as good as the Rustum Roy paper that Dana told us all to look forward to.
 
So, We will be seeing an analysis of the second-rate studies excluded from Shang's main anlysis;

http://www.quackometer.net/blog/2007/12/homeopathic-revolution-by-dana-ullman.html

"What would you say if someone evaluated (finally) the 21 high quality (double-blind and placebo controlled) homeopathic studies and the 9 allopathic ones. Well, someone has finally done this, and it will be published shortly. "

I wonder where it will be published.

He said it would be the International Journal of Epidemiology.

Linda
 
But while we're on the subject of AIDS, I found this little paper. I have no attachment to it, and it is NOT submitted as proof of anything.

I just would like to see what your criticisms of this study would be.

http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/10335412?ordinalpos=1&itool=EntrezSystem2

We do ask that the full text of the study be available online before providing a critique. Abstracts represent the biases of their authors and it cannot be assumed that the conclusions are supported by the results (they often aren't). In evidence-based medicine, it is the results that we are interested in. The conclusions of the authors aren't really taken into consideration.

Linda
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom