Dana Ullman's Homeopathy Studies Thread

As for people with chronic non-self-limiting diseases, read my new book. It is full of such stories, except if you do that fancy footwork that Linda does by defining non-self-limiting diseases as only those diseases that no one has ever survived. Fancy, indeed.

It doesn't have to be no one, but it has to be at least quite unexpected/highly unlikely. To use one of your examples, an individual recovering from sepsis isn't unexpected, since at least a third do recover. A whole bunch of stories about people who recover from an illness, when it's not unexpected, is not particularly useful.

Linda
 
And here's the newest basic science study. I assume that you will now assert that there is some strange placebo effect going on here.

Or you'll say that this drug isn't in beyond Avogadro's number. That's right, it isn't, nor is the majority of homeopathic drugs sold in health food stores and pharmacies. Cool, now, you can feel comfortable in using this large number of homeopathic drugs without traumatizing yourself too much.


Can J Physiol Pharmacol. 2007 Nov;85(11):1084-90. Links
In vitro evaluation of the antiviral effects of the homeopathic preparation Gripp-Heel on selected respiratory viruses.Glatthaar-Saalmüller B.
Labor Dr. Glatthaar, Clinical Immunology, University of Veterinary Medicine Vienna, A-1210 Vienna, Austria (e-mail: [email protected]).

Gripp-Heel(R) is a homeopathic preparation frequently used in the treatment of respiratory viral infections such as various types of influenza and the common cold. The antiviral activity of Gripp-Heel was studied in vitro on human pathogenic enveloped and nonenveloped RNA and DNA viruses. Before the antiviral assays, in vitro cytotoxicity of Gripp-Heel was determined with cells used for the infection experiments (HeLa, HEp-2, MDCK, BGM) as well as with mitogen-stimulated peripheral blood mononuclear leukocytes. A concentration of 0.5 of the commercially available product slightly reduced cell viability and proliferative capacity, and experiments on antiviral activity were determined starting with a dilution of 0.2 of the commercially available product. The antiviral activity was determined against a broad panel of enveloped and nonenveloped DNA and RNA viruses with plaque reduction assay, cytopathogenic assays, virus titrations, analysis of the viral proteins in virus-specific enzyme immunoassays, and haemagglutination tests. Control substances were acyclovir (10 mug/mL), ribavirin (6 mug/mL), and amantadine hydrochloride (5 mug/mL), depending on the virus type. Gripp-Heel demonstrated dose-dependent in vitro activity (significant reductions of infectivity by 20% to 40%) against Human herpesvirus 1, Human adenovirus C serotype 5, Influenza A virus, Human respiratory syncytial virus, Human parainfluenza virus 3, Human rhinovirus B serotype 14, and Human coxsackievirus serotype A9. The mechanisms of this antiviral activity are still unclear, but type I interferon induction might be a possible explanation. Further research on this homeopathic preparation seems warranted.

PMID: 18066110 [PubMed - in process]

In vitro studies testing the possible activity of various compounds is basic medical research. It does not provide support for homeopathy, since it provides no support for the idea of similars or for the potentiation of activity through dilution.

Linda
 
A few years ago I got a nasty strep infection, I felt horrible. I thought it was a simple virus and held off getting any medical care. But finally I did see a doctor and received some antibiotics. ....


Uh, just checking in quickly here.

Funny you should say that. I've been sick for over a week with what I assumed was a nasty "common cold" virus, and in fact was more or less off work for a week though I struggled to cover some teaching commitments. I didn't see a doctor, as it's such received wisdom not to bother the poor chaps with trivial ailments like that, and expecially not to demand antibiotics.

However, the infection has settled on my chest, and I still sound as if I'm coughing up a mine shaft. I'm too darn new in this village to have figured out the local chemist's shop's attitude to veterinary prescriptions that don't really smell as if they're intended for an animal (and not being in general practice I can't just reach up to the shelf!). I was just sitting thinking, maybe I should make an appointment to get checked out in case I really do need treatment for bronchitis, when I read this.

Ah, the power of coincidence.

(Of course I'm sure Dana could have cured me in a day if only I'd had faith....)

Rolfe.

Now where is that pile of Christmas cards, the half-completed presents list, the cash card and the wrapping paper - not to mention the Christmas tree and the fairy lights and the hell with the season of goodwill.
 
...However, the infection has settled on my chest, and I still sound as if I'm coughing up a mine shaft. .... I was just sitting thinking, maybe I should make an appointment to get checked out in case I really do need treatment for bronchitis, when I read this.
....

Well, I hope you do get checked out before trying antibiotics. Though, I hate to tell you this but there is a horrible crud going around (and it may have travelled by airplane* to your neck of the woods) that lasts for more than two weeks. At one point I was feeling better from one cold, only that evening to come down with a fever, and Cold Version 2.0 for another two weeks. Unlike the strep though, I did feel better after mostly sleeping for a couple of days. With the bacterial infection I just kept getting worse and worse, and actually felt much better 12 hours after starting antibiotics. Lovely stuff!

I got the strep infection from the fellow coughing next to me on an airplane.
 
Last edited:
In vitro studies testing the possible activity of various compounds is basic medical research. It does not provide support for homeopathy, since it provides no support for the idea of similars or for the potentiation of activity through dilution.

Linda
I haven't yet looked at this study (but I will).
My first thought was - Why on earth is Dana telling us that a remedy is acting like a conventional antiviral drug?
I thought homeopathy wasn't meant to work like that? Whither the individualisation, the symptomatology, the lovely-sounding guff about rebalancing the host's immune responses and stimulating the host to respond to the illness in a holistic manner?

How does he think this stuff is meant to work???
The internal inconsistencies that exist with homeopathy concepts are just a bit too overwhelming for me at the moment. I think I'll go get some lunch...
 
Last edited:
Throughout Europe, most homeopaths are MDs, especially in France, Germany, Italy, Netherlands, Spain, and Switzerland. In England, I am not certain on the stats, though I think that the medical doctors represent around 50% of the practicing homeopaths.

In India, there are over 100,000 homeopathic physicians who have completed 4 or 5-year homeopathic medical schools.
No. These are still just claims. I'm asking for your source of information.

I do note, however, that you are now excluding the United States from the "most homeopaths are physicians" category.

I also note that you are now simply saying that in India, homeopaths have simply completed homeopathic medical schools, not that the homeopaths are actually physicians.

I would still appreciate your sources for the Europe/England numbers, though.
 
Uh, just checking in quickly here.

Funny you should say that. I've been sick for over a week with what I assumed was a nasty "common cold" virus, and in fact was more or less off work for a week though I struggled to cover some teaching commitments. I didn't see a doctor, as it's such received wisdom not to bother the poor chaps with trivial ailments like that, and expecially not to demand antibiotics.

However, the infection has settled on my chest, and I still sound as if I'm coughing up a mine shaft. I'm too darn new in this village to have figured out the local chemist's shop's attitude to veterinary prescriptions that don't really smell as if they're intended for an animal (and not being in general practice I can't just reach up to the shelf!). I was just sitting thinking, maybe I should make an appointment to get checked out in case I really do need treatment for bronchitis, when I read this.

Ah, the power of coincidence.

(Of course I'm sure Dana could have cured me in a day if only I'd had faith....)

Rolfe.

Now where is that pile of Christmas cards, the half-completed presents list, the cash card and the wrapping paper - not to mention the Christmas tree and the fairy lights and the hell with the season of goodwill.

Good job you had that flu jab.

:boxedin:

(Sorry, I couldn't resist.)
 
According to this, in the late '90s there were approximately 400 doctors practising homeopathy on a regular basis in the UK and approximately 1000 registered lay practitioners - expanding by about 200-300 per year. And this doesn't include unregistered and self taught homeopaths. I'll see if I can find any more recent figures.
 
Linda...I know you're a smart cookie, but let me try this one more time. Low potency homeopathic medicines (such as 6C) generally have short-term effects...and thus, it is possible for these medicines to be used in crossover designs, though occasionally, low-potency medicines can have surprisingly long-term effects, though this tends to be rare.

The severe sepsis trial used higher potencies (higher potencies are those medicines, usually beyond Avogadro's number, that have undergone more serial dilutions with vigorous shaking in-between each dilution). These higher potencies tend to have longer-term effects than the lower potencies.

Let's see if I've got this straight. If you actually give patients something, they can get better. If you don't give them anything, they take longer to get better. And it's taken homeopaths how many centuries to realise this?
 
According to this, in the late '90s there were approximately 400 doctors practising homeopathy on a regular basis in the UK and approximately 1000 registered lay practitioners - expanding by about 200-300 per year. And this doesn't include unregistered and self taught homeopaths. I'll see if I can find any more recent figures.
Much obliged, but one would assume that a scholar of Dana's integrity would have such references to hand else he would not be making the claims to begin with.

Wouldn't one?
 
And here's the newest basic science study. I assume that you will now assert that there is some strange placebo effect going on here.

Can J Physiol Pharmacol. 2007 Nov;85(11):1084-90. Links
In vitro evaluation of the antiviral effects of the homeopathic preparation Gripp-Heel on selected respiratory viruses.Glatthaar-Saalmüller B.
Labor Dr. Glatthaar, Clinical Immunology, University of Veterinary Medicine Vienna, A-1210 Vienna, Austria (e-mail: [email protected]).

Can you provide a link to the full study please?

BTW, This is what we are talking about:
Composition:
Tablets: 1 Tablet Cont.: Aconitum 4X 120 mg Bryonia 4X, Lachesis 12X ana 60 mg Eupatorium perfoliatum 3X, Phosphorus 5X ana 30 mg.
Aconitum exerts a specially stimulating action on the hemoderm (abatement of chilliness), in addition rapidly relieving neuralgic disorders and circulatory lability, while Eupatorium eliminates pains in the joints and the feeling of exhaustion. The content of Lachesis (septic infections, tendency towards hemolysis), Bryonia (thirst, irritation from coughing, retrosternal pain, diseases of the serous membranes such as pleuritis) and Phosphorus (petechiae, elective effect on the lungs in preventing pneumonia) broadens the therapeutical spectrum of Gripp-Heel according to Burgi's principle, perfecting the preparation effectively. The dosage is adjusted according to the disease, the clinical picture and the stage of the illness

As I thought, the action of this remedy are meant to depend upon some mythical effects in the host ("stimulating action on the hemoderm (sic), relieving circulatory lability, eliminating exhaustion", and so on).
Now Dana posts a study supposedly showing the remedy has direct antiviral effects.
So which is it?
 
As for Mr. Monkey...shouting loudly doesn't make your innane question about the fact that "I" haven't "cured" anyone with AIDS any less innane. Sorry, it doesn't.

Dana "The Hypothetical Homeopath" Ullman has cured no one of AIDS himself. After a lot of effort we have now established this. But there are plenty of homeopaths who are treating AIDS patients in Africa.

You seem very keen to spend your time sifting third-hand, biased and incomplete accounts of alleged cures due to homeopathy. How about you apply that prodigious talent to find us one good example of a homeopath anywhere in the world who has cured AIDS and properly documented that fact?

As I have said before, it need not be AIDS, there's a range of things you could choose from. I think you have had it amply demonstrated that utter tosh such as your misleading descriptions of Darwin's attitude to homeopathy 150 years ago do not count.

Until you come up with something that shows real effects in real people there is not much point wasting time in trying to work out what schoolboy errors have been made in yet another irrelevant in vitro study.

Remember what happened to poor old Rustum Roy's paper with which you were so impressed: Heap of smoking wreckage.

So, while not wishing to derail this thread;

"GIVE ONE, YOU ONLY NEED ONE, INCONTROVERTIBLE EXAMPLE, WITH REFERENCES, OF HOMEOPATHY CURING A NON-SELF-LIMITING CONDITION."

Post your documented case history in the thread specially created for that purpose.



(By the way, if I tell you inane has one 'n' you will at least have learnt something useful from these exchanges).
 
Can you provide a link to the full study please?

BTW, This is what we are talking about:



As I thought, the action of this remedy are meant to depend upon some mythical effects in the host ("stimulating action on the hemoderm (sic), relieving circulatory lability, eliminating exhaustion", and so on).
Now Dana posts a study supposedly showing the remedy has direct antiviral effects.
So which is it?

"1 Tablet Cont.: Aconitum 4X 120 mg Bryonia 4X, Lachesis 12X ana 60 mg Eupatorium perfoliatum 3X, Phosphorus 5X ana 30 mg."

Oh, for pity's sake, has he not even bothered to read up what the stuff is? Presumably just pulled the abstract without bothering even to do the simplest check.

I see 4X, 4X, 3X of real biological material that is dumped unceremoniously onto cells in culture.

But, please Deetee give us a reading from the paper to see whether there is anything even more dumb to report.
 
Last edited:
But, please Deetee give us a reading from the paper to see whether there is anything even more dumb to report.
I can only access the Canadian Journal of Phys & Pharm after a 6 month delay.
This paper is from November 11th - part of an issue on the "Safety and Efficacy of Natural Health Products"

I have to wait for Dana to give me a linky to read it in all its glory.

PS - How many "n"s in inane?

ETA - other abstracts from this journal issue (given over to the "natural health" crowd to publish their ground-breaking research) include gems like this one here on Echinacea for URTI.
So what trial do they come up with? A DBPCT powered to distinguish a significant difference between Echinacea and placebo?
Not on your nelly....... It's an open labelled trial which the authors admit was conducted on too few patients to show anything.
So why on earth bother! Is this the best that the alt med crowd can come up with? What a total waste of space! I think I need another lie down.....
 
Last edited:
BTW, This is what we are talking about:
Composition:
Tablets: 1 Tablet Cont.: Aconitum 4X 120 mg Bryonia 4X, Lachesis 12X ana 60 mg Eupatorium perfoliatum 3X, Phosphorus 5X ana 30 mg.
Is this even proper homoeopathy? I thought that real homoeopaths frowned upon combination treatments. You are supposed to use only one remedy at a time, not mix them up. And in this case, the only ingredient that is not actually present is Lachesis, which gives credibility to the claim that these oills actually could have an effect. But which effect?
 
...and, I suppose, they then diluted the contents out of existence and got an even greater affect.

No, I didn't think so. :rolleyes:
 
I have said it many times, but for many reasons, you folks simply don't like to learn. You love thinking in such black and white terms that you don't and seemingly cannot appreciate complexity. A tad ironic, isn't it.

One of my favorite quotes that I including in my book, "The Homeopathic Revolution," comes from Charles Kettering, one of the 20th century's greatest inventors and an ardent advocate of homeopathy. He would be horrified that HIS name is used for the work done by the Sloan-Kettering Institute. When a reporter asked him about his conquests of the secrets of nature, Kettering responded, "Hah, it’s not the conquest of nature, it’s the conquest of our own ignorance. And as for secrets, there is only one secret of nature I want to pry into. Why is the human skull as dense as it is? Nowadays we can send a message around the world in one-seventh of a second, but it take years to drive an idea through a quarter-inch of human skull."

You folks have such THICK skulls, nothing gets through. Nothing. Your loss.

Once again, the majority of homeopathic medicines sold in health food stores and pharmacies today are in potencies usually under 12C...where there are some molecules, though they are in considerably lower dose than any of your regular drugs. And yet, I have shown again and again and again that these "lower potency" homeopathic medicines have biological action.

I have referred to the entire field of hormesis (low dose science) that has nothing to do with homeopathy, except that it shows the power, according the numerous fields of scientific experiment, of infinitesimal doses (still material doses, but still very very small). (Do some googling on hormesis...it is a very fertile area of investigation, that is, it is for people who want to learn)

Don't you remember all of the times that I made reference to low-dose homeopathy? Have you all killed your brain cells? I then encouraged you to become big supporters of "health food store" homeopathy...and yet, not of you have backbone (or neuron) to acknowledge this. Whooops.

Worst of all, you are very sloppy in your critique of homeopathy by grouping together ALL of homeopathy. The irony of your non-scientific thinking is dripping. There is so little difference in your thinking and those religious fundamentalist. More irony.

And yes, I too am honored that Orac has tried to go after me. He thinks that just by calling me "clueless" that his arguments get stronger. Whooops.

Instead of gentlemanly discourse, he resorts to name-calling and imprecise argumentation. Whoooops. Judge for yourself.

No "respectful" insolence here, just insolence.
 
You love thinking in such black and white terms that you don't and seemingly cannot appreciate complexity. A tad ironic, isn't it.
It is ironic that you do not see that the wonderful world of homoeopathy is a tad too simple for the complex real world. Dilute anything and everything out existence while shaking, and you are able to cure every ailment known to man, and magically without side effects. How ironic!

When a reporter asked him about his conquests of the secrets of nature, Kettering responded, "Hah, it’s not the conquest of nature, it’s the conquest of our own ignorance. And as for secrets, there is only one secret of nature I want to pry into. Why is the human skull as dense as it is? Nowadays we can send a message around the world in one-seventh of a second, but it take years to drive an idea through a quarter-inch of human skull."
How true! 200 years have not been enough to make homoeopaths realise that they are fooling themselves and their patients.

You folks have such THICK skulls, nothing gets through. Nothing. Your loss.
Your thick skulls come at the loss of your patients.

Once again, the majority of homeopathic medicines sold in health food stores and pharmacies today are in potencies usually under 12C...where there are some molecules, though they are in considerably lower dose than any of your regular drugs. And yet, I have shown again and again and again that these "lower potency" homeopathic medicines have biological action.

I have referred to the entire field of hormesis (low dose science) that has nothing to do with homeopathy, except that it shows the power, according the numerous fields of scientific experiment, of infinitesimal doses (still material doses, but still very very small). (Do some googling on hormesis...it is a very fertile area of investigation, that is, it is for people who want to learn)
Are you now disowning the entire field of trans-avogadral doses?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom