Deetee
Illuminator
- Joined
- Jul 8, 2003
- Messages
- 3,789
This could explain the results the fibromyalgia studies:
http://www.medscape.com/viewarticle/538449
Here's the first referenced study by Dana:
http://rheumatology.oxfordjournals.org/cgi/reprint/keh111v1
The unadjusted differences in table 2 on page 5 do not look particularly impressive.
ETA: In Table 1 it shows that the homoeopathy group had higher scores on Tender point pain, POMS depression and POMS anger-hostility than the placebo group at baseline. In Table 2, the placebo group's score on the Tender point pain had not changed by much, but the two POMS scores increased. After treatment, the homoeopathy group's POMS scored dropped to values similar to the placebo group's POMS score at baseline. It would seem to me this study observed natural cycles in the variables it measured, and the effects can be explained by regression to the mean.
Fibromyalgia is a particularly nebulous medical condition. It is largely a somatisation disorder, and overlaps with multiple other similarly nebulous disorders such as ME, irritable bowel and multiple chemical sensitivity syndrome (indeed the article states that because of the overlap, the active homeopathic remedies were prepared in such a way as to not trigger chemical sensitivity in the group (and apparently patients have previously "reacted" to preparations of nothing but pure water - homeopathically speaking). Now there's irony for you).
Again we see homeopathy being shown to be "effective" for a disorder with huge variability in symptoms, significant psychological overlay, and a natural tendency to vary with relapses and remissions and spontaneous improvement. Not only that, but again there are very few clear cut objective outcomes that can be measured - they resort to subjective pain scores as the main measure.
When Oh when are we ever going to see a trial of homeopathy that is claimed to be effective for a straightforward medical condition that posesses an objective measurement of its progression or severity?
Can I claim the Randi $million for predicting never?
Even homeopathy studies on illnesses such as asthma are fudged - I don't see mention of serial peak flow rates, or pulmonary function or reversibility results being shown, we instead get patients "impressions" of how breathless they felt that day, or similar rubbish. Are these homeopaths ever going to get anything worthwhile to study, or just continue ad infinitum in their endless circle-jerk of wiffly-waffly diseases which have nothing to measure?
Regarding this study, I agree with Ivor that regression to the mean would be an important factor. The authors do grudgingly mention this, and go on to say:
I am not statistically savvy enough to know if this is an acceptable way to gloss over the problem - I doubt it though.Although regression to the mean might account for some of the apparent improvement in the active group [24], the improved status of the active group compared with the placebo group at 3 months for tender point pain, tender point count, global health and fibromyalgia-related quality of life (Appraisal of Fibromyalgia Scale) remained after covarying for the baseline value of the relevant dependent variable, as well as baseline differences in depression and anger–hostility.
One way to ensure that the groups were equivalent would have been to randomise patients on the basis of their primary endpoint - the pain scores. This would ensure both groups started at the exact same level and would have negated any regression to the mean issues completely. This was a design flaw in the methodology IMO.
Last edited: