Dana Ullman's Homeopathy Studies Thread

Dana Ullman, MPH

And pleeeeeze, don't expect me or any homeopath to provide free treatment to you as a "test subject." At the best (or worst, depending upon your point of view), you would lose your crediblity if homeopathy was helpful, and no one would consider a single case to be an example of anything.

Anyone else expect this response? I always get it or something else similar when I offer to try homeopathic remedies. In fact the more I get involved in discussions I am finding the same responses from all sides, supporters, homeopaths and professional bodies. "You'll lie about the results", "You can't be trusted".

But remember that since homeopathy treats the whole person you can't just take the first suitable remedy, history and personality has to be taken into account. So explain the huge shelves full of remedies in most pharmacy stores...

Plus, aren't we asking for a single case in the other thread (albeit with some constraints)? Sorry - I can't link yet...
 
Last edited:
Last edited:
I'm glad that someone acknowledged some reality by calling me "Sir Brave Dana." Thanx.
Someone should put him out of his misery:

http://www.stmoroky.com/sirrobin/fleeing~~.au

Don't forget to post saying that you knew all along that was what they meant.

For the record, I didn't previously mention my own AIDS article,
We know you didn't. You don't need to put what happened on the thread on "the record", the thread is "the record", don't you see how that works? But good attempt to make yourself look as though you're addressing a point without actually doing so.
 
Also...you're not remembering: there is a simple reason that I have commented upon the Rao/Roy spectroscopy study, I do not know the answers to this very technical study, though I did correctly acknowledge the high respect that Roy's lab at Penn State University is known for. Whether you agree with him or not, please consider his body of work.

And isn't that (almost) the entire problem. You are quick to laud a study merely because it supports your position, regardless of whether you have read it and even if you don't understand a word of it. This is why nonsense like Lionel Milgom's quantum bollox papers are so popular with homeopaths. They don't understand a word of it, and they don't care as long as it is "on their side".

And the fact that the author seems to have done good work before does not in any way negate the criticisms of this particular study. That's not how science works.
 
Also...you're not remembering: there is a simple reason that I have commented upon the Rao/Roy spectroscopy study, I do not know the answers to this very technical study, though I did correctly acknowledge the high respect that Roy's lab at Penn State University is known for. Whether you agree with him or not, please consider his body of work.
OK, we consider his body of work: that makes it even more sad that he is no longer able to put a scientific study together that holds up to the simplest scientific standards.

Was that what you meant?
 
Here's another one for you all...the walrus was Paul...arsenic poisoning is not a self-limiting condition:
http://ecam.oxfordjournals.org/cgi/content/abstract/2/4/537

Arsenic poisoning is a self-limiting condition once the source of the arsenic has been removed or reduced.

Although this is a preliminary trial due to the limited number of people who agreed to be in the placebo group, it is a part of a larger body of environmental toxicology. Hopefully, there are people on this list who have an interest in this subject. Although prevention must obviously be the first priority, we must also consider ways to treat people who have already been exposed. Will homeopathic doses of environmental poisons be one solution to consider?

Just don't look at the clinical results, check out the liver enzymes between the treated group and the control group.

Excuse me? There is no control group for the liver enzyme measurements. And I told you this the last time you cited this study. Have you even read any of the studies you keep referencing?

Part of the study was double-blind, randomized and placebo-controlled and involved measuring arsenic levels in the urine. It showed no difference between the two groups once you take into account that the arsenic levels in the urine were significantly higher in the control group before the treatment was even started. Sheesh.

The second part of the study had no controls. The results are what you would expect to see in the absence of any treatment in a group of people who are being extra careful about limiting their arsenic exposure.

This study provides no support for homeopathy.

Next?

Linda
 
James Gully said:
Also...you're not remembering: there is a simple reason that I have commented upon the Rao/Roy spectroscopy study, I do not know the answers to this very technical study, though I did correctly acknowledge the high respect that Roy's lab at Penn State University is known for. Whether you agree with him or not, please consider his body of work.

Hm, you seemed happy enough to claim the study as justification for homeopathy in the past. It does seem to be true that Rustum Roy is highly respected in the field of materials science. Sadly, that doesn't make his work on 'water memory' any less woeful. I've read some hopeless papers in my time, but I think that Rao et al. has a good claim on being the worst of the lot. As you're surely aware, the paper has been considered in great detail here.
 
Here's Ullman just the other day on Comment is Free, talking about the 'highly significant' results of Rao et al. If you 'do not know the answers to this very technical study', perhaps you should refrain from touting it around as evidence for homeopathy.

He also states that the 'silica hypothesis' is scientifically sound, although it has no supporting evidence whatsoever.
 
Homoeopaths frequently claim that critics of homoeopathy don't understand it. Projection.
 
It is interesting to note that skeptics love to mention that the above meta-analysis said, "we found insufficient evidence from these studies that homeopathy is clearly efficacious for any single clinical condition." However, do they ever mention what the authors of that meta-analysis say was their definition of "sufficient evidence?" They said that there must be 3 clinical trials conducted by independent investigators.

In 1998 (a year after that meta-analysis published in the LANCET was published), a third such trial on Oscillococcinum was published. And by the way, this meta-analysis showed that patients given a homeopathic medicine had a 2.45 times greater chance of experiencing a therapeutically beneficial effect than those patients given a placebo.

Skeptics can no longer say that homeopathic medicines are proven to be effective in treating a specific condition.

If anyone is asked, does Oscillococcinum have an effect on influenza or influenza-like syndrome, one must say YES. I'll say it for Linda: but this is a self-limiting condition. Sure...but it is worthwhile to reduce the time YOU have the flu to make a cheap medicine without side effects? Yes...except for some of you who like to suffer.

The most recent meta-analysis does not support your claim.

And this is the absolute best that homeopathy has for evidence. It is the only evidence that comes even remotely close to the sort of evidence that supports medical therapies. And what does it say? At best, special water can shorten the duration of the flu symptoms by a few hours. After the hundreds of years of time and effort that has been put into homeopathy, all you can show for it is the possibility (and the possibility that this is all a fluke is still more likely than the possibility that special water had anything to do with it) that some people had relief from their aches and pains for a few hours.

You know what this means? The entire practice of homeopathy can be substituted with the advice to "take two aspirins and call me in the morning."

As for that sepsis study...it is a tad ironic (again) that Mr Monkey says that this study doesn't count because the patients were also given conventional drugs. Yeah, Mr. Monkey that is right, but those patients who got individually chosen homeopathic medicines (chosen according to their own unique syndrome of severe sepsis) had a 50% (!) reduced mortality rate. Hey Linda, is this a "self-limiting condition?" Believing in reincarnation doesn't make it such.

I didn't call it a self-limiting condition. I said that people in the control group recovered, so that it would be foolish to assume that any individual couldn't have recovered unless they received homeopathy.

The sepsis study showed that if you take two heterogeneous groups of ill people and measure the number of deaths at various points in time over the next six months, that there is a good chance that at least one of those points in time will show a difference between the two groups. There's no reason to attribute that difference to homeopathy though, since it's exactly what you'd expect to see in the absence of any homeopathic treatment.

Thank you. Yes...plants do have this hypersensitivity, and plants are so much more sophisticated that humans, so there is no way that humans can have this type or any type of hypersensitivity. Hmmm.

The irony here is that homeopathy is said to be based on SIMILARS, when a better term might be RESONANCE...and there is hypersensitivity from resonance (any music appreciators out there?).

That you have to resort to pseudoscientific drivel does not help your case.

Linda
 
The most recent meta-analysis does not support your claim.

Sorry, this meta-analysis says exactly what I said it does. I said that the Cochrane report called the results of the treatment of influenza "promising." I made it clear that its use in the prevention of the flu is not proven, though this has not been its use anyway.

In reference to "severe sepsis," you wrote
I didn't call it a self-limiting condition. I said that people in the control group recovered, so that it would be foolish to assume that any individual couldn't have recovered unless they received homeopathy.

The sepsis study showed that if you take two heterogeneous groups of ill people and measure the number of deaths at various points in time over the next six months, that there is a good chance that at least one of those points in time will show a difference between the two groups. There's no reason to attribute that difference to homeopathy though, since it's exactly what you'd expect to see in the absence of any homeopathic treatment.

Hmmm. Did you say that you were an expert in statistics. Eeeks. First, just because some people survive a life-threatening condition does not mean that the entire condition is self-limiting. If that were true, almost ALL disease would be self-limiting (ergo, you've proven yourself: homeopathic medicines cannot be helpful for non-self-limiting conditions because such conditions are so rare). Cool.

As for the two groups...both groups had a life-threatening condition in which other studies show that 40-70% of the people die. In 6 months, 50% of those given the placebo died, while only 25% of those given a homeopathic medicine died. How you can say that these significant differences are just what you would expect from NO treatment is a statistical improbability (thus, the impressive p-value). These results not only show an effect, but they show some long-term effects of homeopathic medicines. Thank you. He shoots; he scores.

And now that I have your attention, I'm going for a 3-pointer. Here's what I posted earlier today at quackometer.

Below is an excerpt from my ebook, "Homeopathic Family Medicine: Evidence Based Nanopharmacology." I update this ebook every 3-4 months, adding new research.

This is a partial excerpt from the chapter on fibromyalgia. I know some of you will grunt when you see this diagnostic category, and yet, whether you believe it is a real pathology or just a common disease pattern, you will find two high quality studies, one of which was published in the BMJ and one of which was published in RHEUMATOLOGY (the journal of the British Society for Rheumatology). Some of the objective data (described below) was published in the International Journal of Neurosciences.

(You're not going to call these journals "junk journals" too, are you?)

The BMJ study was double-blind, placebo-controlled WITH a cross-over (you cannot do better than that). The second study is worthy of your attention because not only was there greater CLINICAL improvement in the homeopathic treated patients (some of you can call that "subjective," except when improvement in YOUR own symptoms is observed), the researchers also conducted EEG readings while the patients were given their dose or a placebo via olfaction. Yeah...this study will blow your mind...and maybe your nose too...

The syndrome of fibromyalgia includes a disparate group of physical and psychological symptoms, including pain and tenderness in a dozen or so sites, stiffness, fatigue, headaches, dizziness, abdominal or pelvic pain, diarrhea, memory and concentration problems, and various states of anxiety and depression.

The fact that this ailment is recognized as a syndrome is unusual for conventional medicine. In homeopathy, it is believed that ALL ailments are syndromes, that is, all disease is a constellation of physical and psychological symptoms and each patient has their own subtly different version of the disease. The fact that people with fibromyalgia tend to have sometimes slightly and sometimes overtly differing symptoms from each other is no significant problem for homeopaths because each person is observed to have his/her own syndrome of symptoms, no matter what disease doctors diagnose them to have.

Because people with fibromyalgia tend to have distinct and unusual symptoms, this actually makes it easier for homeopaths to treat them successfully. However, homeopaths have also observed that a small percentage of people with fibromyalgia are so ill and their immune system is so compromised that it is difficult for homeopaths to provide effective treatment.


Scientific Evidence

Researchers in England found that patients with fibromyalgia were (obviously) a varied group with differing symptoms but that there was one homeopathic medicine, more than any other, that seemed to be indicated for a certain sub-set of fibromyalgia patients (Fisher, 1986). This medicine, Rhus toxicodendron (also called Rhus tox) was found to be indicated in 25% of fibromyalgia patients.

The researchers found 30 patients who seemed to fit the symptoms of Rhus tox, and they were given a homeopathic dose of this medicine, 6C (this dose is considered a “low potency,” that is, it is a dose that generally does not have long-term effects). The researchers found that there was a significant degree of improvement in the reduction of pain and tender points and improved sleep when the subjects were taking the homeopathic medicine, as compared to when the subjects were taking a placebo.

The results of this experiment were so significant that the researchers found that there was a 5 in 10,000 chance (P<.005) of this occurring from chance.

This study, therefore, strongly suggests that homeopathic medicines can be effective in reducing the pain and tender spots and in improving sleep in some patients suffering from fibromyalgia.

In addition to this study, a more recent study published in the highly respected journal, Rheumatology (published by the British Society for Rheumatology) also found statistically significant results from homeopathic treatment. Researchers from the University of Arizona in collaboration with homeopaths conducted a double-blind, randomized, placebo-controlled trial with 62 fibromyalgia patients (Bell, Lewis, Brooks, et al., 2004). Patients were randomized to receive an oral daily dose of an individually chosen homeopathic medicine in LM potency (or a placebo). Patients were evaluated at baseline, 2 months, and 4 months.

The study found that 50% of patients given a homeopathic medicine experienced a 25% or greater improvement in tender point pain on examination, as compared to only 15% of those who were given a placebo experienced a similar degree of improvement (P=0.008). After 4 months, the homeopathic patients also rated the “helpfulness of the treatment” significantly greater than did those who were given a placebo (P=0.004). It is therefore not surprising that the study also showed that the average number of remedies recommended by the homeopaths was substantially higher to those in the placebo group as compared with the real treatment group.

One special additional feature of this trial was that the first dose of medicine was given by olfaction (by smell) and that both groups were monitored with EEG. The researchers found that there was a significant and identifiable difference in the EEG readings in patients who were given the real homeopathic medicine as compared to those given the placebo (Bell, Lewis, Schwartz, et al, 2004a).

Each patient had three laboratory sessions, including at baseline, at 3 months, and at 6 months after initial treatment. The researchers found that the active treatment group experienced significant increases in the EEG relative alpha magnitude, while patients given a placebo experienced a decrease in this measurement (P=0.003).

The combined evidence of clinical improvement along with objective physiological response from the homeopathic medicine makes the results of this trial of additional significance.

REFERENCES:

Bell, IR, Lewis, DA, Brooks, DJ, Schwartz, GE, Leis, SE, Walsh, BT, and Baldwin, DM, Improved Cilnical Status in Fibromyalgia Patients Treated with Individualized Homeopathic Remedies Versus Placebo, Rheumatology, January 20, 2004:1111-7.

Bell IR, Lewis Ii DA, Lewis SE, Schwartz GE, Brooks AJ, Scott A, Baldwin CM. EEG Alpha Sensitization in Individualized Homeopathic Treatment of Fibromyalgia. Int J Neurosci. 2004;114(9):1195-1220.

Peter Fisher, Alison Greenwood, EC Huskisson, et al., “Effect of Homoeopathic Treatment on Fibrositis (Primary Fibromyalgia),” BMJ, 299(August 5, 1989):365-6.


So, Linda, is this drivel too, and are these journals drivel, and is everyone but you and your buddies on this list drivel? I think that the problem is that some people have a problem in seeing patterns.

A 3-pointer and I was fouled on the shot.
 
And this is the absolute best that homeopathy has for evidence.


"More research is needed". We've been hearing that since Kleijnen et al, if not longer. After all, they've only had a couple of hundred years...
 
James Gully disputes Linda's precise statistical analysis. One would presume that he knows something about the subject (well he wouldn't be one of those pseudoscientists who just pretends he knows stuff, or exaggerates statistics for his own purposes, would he....?)
The results of this experiment were so significant that the researchers found that there was a 5 in 10,000 chance (P<.005) of this occurring from chance.

Errr....Ooops!
:blush:
 
Last edited:
James Gully disputes Linda's precise statistical analysis. One would presume that he knows something about the subject (well he wouldn't be one of those pseudoscientists who just pretends he knows stuff, or exaggerates statistics for his own purposes, would he....?)


Errr....Ooops!
:blush:

Should he be more embarrassed by his incorrect calculation, or by his incorrect description of what a p-value means?
 
Last edited:
This could explain the results the fibromyalgia studies:

http://www.medscape.com/viewarticle/538449

Fibromyalgia (FM) patients with larger pain fluctuations are more likely to respond to placebo, and those responses might be enough to cloud the results of placebo-controlled clinical trials, Dr Richard E Harris (University of Michigan, Ann Arbor) reports in the November 2005 issue of Arthritis & Rheumatism

"These results have direct implications for drug trials in FM and perhaps broader implications for other pain syndromes," Harris writes. "To counteract or control for this effect, one could either stratify participants based on baseline pain-variability index [PVI] or even remove individuals with high pain variability prior to randomization."

Here's the first referenced study by Dana:

http://rheumatology.oxfordjournals.org/cgi/reprint/keh111v1

The unadjusted differences in table 2 on page 5 do not look particularly impressive.

ETA: In Table 1 it shows that the homoeopathy group had higher scores on Tender point pain, POMS depression and POMS anger-hostility than the placebo group at baseline. In Table 2, the placebo group's score on the Tender point pain had not changed by much, but the two POMS scores increased. After treatment, the homoeopathy group's POMS scored dropped to values similar to the placebo group's POMS score at baseline. It would seem to me this study observed natural cycles in the variables it measured, and the effects can be explained by regression to the mean.
 
Last edited:
Sorry, this meta-analysis says exactly what I said it does. I said that the Cochrane report called the results of the treatment of influenza "promising." I made it clear that its use in the prevention of the flu is not proven, though this has not been its use anyway.

This is what you said:

"Skeptics can no longer say that homeopathic medicines are proven to be effective in treating a specific condition.

If anyone is asked, does Oscillococcinum have an effect on influenza or influenza-like syndrome, one must say YES."

I assumed the first sentence was a typo, otherwise we could all end the conversation in agreement. The meta-analysis does not support your claim that Oscillococcinum has an effect on influenza. It was qualified as "might".

In reference to "severe sepsis," you wrote

As for the two groups...both groups had a life-threatening condition in which other studies show that 40-70% of the people die. In 6 months, 50% of those given the placebo died, while only 25% of those given a homeopathic medicine died. How you can say that these significant differences are just what you would expect from NO treatment is a statistical improbability (thus, the impressive p-value). These results not only show an effect, but they show some long-term effects of homeopathic medicines. Thank you. He shoots; he scores.

Badly Shaved Monkey has provided a demonstration that shows statistically significant differences can be expected most of the time if your initial group shows heterogeneity in the absence of any differences in treatment, such as special water. I have also experienced this problem in actual practice (except that I recognized it was a problem I needed to deal with rather than manipulating it to my advantage to claim something that isn't true).

But now you have another problem. Here you are claiming that the effects of homeopathy are long term. That they don't show up in the short term is something to be expected. However, your fibrositis references all depend upon homeopathy having no long term effects, as they are all cross-over studies. If you have any suspicion that the effects carry over from one treatment period to another, you cannot analyze them as though they do not.

So you face a choice. Either cling to your sepsis study as proof of homeopathy's effectiveness or your fibrositis studies, but they cannot both be true.

The BMJ study was double-blind, placebo-controlled WITH a cross-over (you cannot do better than that). The second study is worthy of your attention because not only was there greater CLINICAL improvement in the homeopathic treated patients (some of you can call that "subjective," except when improvement in YOUR own symptoms is observed), the researchers also conducted EEG readings while the patients were given their dose or a placebo via olfaction. Yeah...this study will blow your mind...and maybe your nose too...

Scientific Evidence

Researchers in England found that patients with fibromyalgia were (obviously) a varied group with differing symptoms but that there was one homeopathic medicine, more than any other, that seemed to be indicated for a certain sub-set of fibromyalgia patients (Fisher, 1986). This medicine, Rhus toxicodendron (also called Rhus tox) was found to be indicated in 25% of fibromyalgia patients.

The researchers found 30 patients who seemed to fit the symptoms of Rhus tox, and they were given a homeopathic dose of this medicine, 6C (this dose is considered a “low potency,” that is, it is a dose that generally does not have long-term effects). The researchers found that there was a significant degree of improvement in the reduction of pain and tender points and improved sleep when the subjects were taking the homeopathic medicine, as compared to when the subjects were taking a placebo.

The results of this experiment were so significant that the researchers found that there was a 5 in 10,000 chance (P<.005) of this occurring from chance.

This study, therefore, strongly suggests that homeopathic medicines can be effective in reducing the pain and tender spots and in improving sleep in some patients suffering from fibromyalgia.

The researchers performed a faulty analysis. When an appropriate analysis was performed, there were no statistically significant differences found. I am surprised that you don't seem to be aware of this.

In addition to this study, a more recent study published in the highly respected journal, Rheumatology (published by the British Society for Rheumatology) also found statistically significant results from homeopathic treatment. Researchers from the University of Arizona in collaboration with homeopaths conducted a double-blind, randomized, placebo-controlled trial with 62 fibromyalgia patients (Bell, Lewis, Brooks, et al., 2004). Patients were randomized to receive an oral daily dose of an individually chosen homeopathic medicine in LM potency (or a placebo). Patients were evaluated at baseline, 2 months, and 4 months.

The study found that 50% of patients given a homeopathic medicine experienced a 25% or greater improvement in tender point pain on examination, as compared to only 15% of those who were given a placebo experienced a similar degree of improvement (P=0.008). After 4 months, the homeopathic patients also rated the “helpfulness of the treatment” significantly greater than did those who were given a placebo (P=0.004). It is therefore not surprising that the study also showed that the average number of remedies recommended by the homeopaths was substantially higher to those in the placebo group as compared with the real treatment group.

If you look at table 2 in this study, you will see that there are no statistically significant differences between the two groups on any of the measures. The researchers elected to adjust the values for some of the differences in baseline measures, and it is the adjusted values that show statistically significant differences. That these two analyses lead to divergent results weakens your ability to draw conclusions from the data. And it invalidates any claims of certainty.

One special additional feature of this trial was that the first dose of medicine was given by olfaction (by smell) and that both groups were monitored with EEG. The researchers found that there was a significant and identifiable difference in the EEG readings in patients who were given the real homeopathic medicine as compared to those given the placebo (Bell, Lewis, Schwartz, et al, 2004a).

Each patient had three laboratory sessions, including at baseline, at 3 months, and at 6 months after initial treatment. The researchers found that the active treatment group experienced significant increases in the EEG relative alpha magnitude, while patients given a placebo experienced a decrease in this measurement (P=0.003).

The combined evidence of clinical improvement along with objective physiological response from the homeopathic medicine makes the results of this trial of additional significance.

I don't have access to the full text of this study. Until I see otherwise, I have to be suspicious that this study suffers from the same problems as the other two. And I find this line confusing - "...sniff alpha-1 and alpha-2 increases at 6 months versus baseline [did not correlate with] clinical outcomes in the active group." Are they saying that the EEG findings were unrelated to the clinical outcomes? Wouldn't that weaken the idea that the homeopathic treatment influenced either outcome?

REFERENCES:

Bell, IR, Lewis, DA, Brooks, DJ, Schwartz, GE, Leis, SE, Walsh, BT, and Baldwin, DM, Improved Cilnical Status in Fibromyalgia Patients Treated with Individualized Homeopathic Remedies Versus Placebo, Rheumatology, January 20, 2004:1111-7.

Bell IR, Lewis Ii DA, Lewis SE, Schwartz GE, Brooks AJ, Scott A, Baldwin CM. EEG Alpha Sensitization in Individualized Homeopathic Treatment of Fibromyalgia. Int J Neurosci. 2004;114(9):1195-1220.

Peter Fisher, Alison Greenwood, EC Huskisson, et al., “Effect of Homoeopathic Treatment on Fibrositis (Primary Fibromyalgia),” BMJ, 299(August 5, 1989):365-6.

So, Linda, is this drivel too, and are these journals drivel, and is everyone but you and your buddies on this list drivel? I think that the problem is that some people have a problem in seeing patterns.

Humans see pattern wherever they look, even when there is no connection to the elements. I think the problem is that while we recognize that the appearance of a pattern does not necessarily mean that there is a connection, many people have trouble letting that idea go. The "patterns" that you attribute to homeopathy are the same patterns that we expect to see from chance, bias (including cognitive), and a little fraud. There doesn't need to be a true treatment effect from homeopathy to generate the pattern that we see.

A 3-pointer and I was fouled on the shot.

Two of these studies were outright negative. One study showed "significant" results that would be expected at least 50% of the time in the absence of treatment effects. That you consider this a "slam dunk" reflects very poorly on the veracity of your claims.

Linda
 
Last edited:
How did the fibromyalgia studies Dana just provided make it into peer-reviewed journals?

Shouldn't the peer review process ensure the conclusions of the study are supported by its results?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom