Indeed. (Nice blog article, by the way.)
There's
a particular piece of veterinary homoeopathic drivel which homoeopaths like to boast about. It even got its author in front of the TV cameras as part of the
Horizon programme, complete with
All Creatures Great and Small musical accompaniment. It's a train wreck in normal scientific terms, but it's an even bigger train wreck in homoeopathic terms. BSM tells me that a homoeopath once rejected a negative-result paper he mentioned because it wasn't individualised and so on. BSM then mildly pointed out that lack of individualism was common practice, and cited Elliott in that respect. So, if the homoeopath was going to reject another paper because of lack of individualisation, then surely Elliott had to be rejected too? The homoeopath replied, no, that was OK because he had obtained a positive result, so obviously whatever he'd done had worked!
Dana, like so many homoeopaths, is at the same game. Anything that has the word "homoeopathy" in it (even if it really isn't homoeopathy) and describes a positive effect is fine, great, a superb piece of work. But as soon as anyone finds anything negative, out come the criticisms that are held to invalidate the paper - criticisms one finds could be levelled with equal justification against his pet studies!
As you so rightly said in the blog piece, there's pretty much no such thing as a perfect study. Everything can be criticised to some extent or another. The question is, are the criticisms of sufficient seriousness to cast doubt on the conclusions of the study? For that, we have to read the paper carefully and critically. Good authors will often actually include in the text mention of what they feel might be imperfections in the study. I've noticed homoeopaths leaping on any tiny little quibble in basically well-conducted studies and announcing that this completely invalidates them - when of course it does not. I remember one negative study which had a small point of concern regarding the blinding - which nevertheless had almost certainly not been broken. Frustrated homoeopaths leaped on this to denounce the study. Er, how might a problem with blinding have caused a potentially
positive result to become obscured, tell me that?
The main point of course is that, if even a tenth of what homoeopaths claim anecdotally has any basis in reality, why in 200 years have they not managed to build up a decent body of published evidence to support their claims? Nothing's perfect, but even a decent number of respectably-performed studies without fatal errors, showing an effect, would have been bound to get someone's attention.
But where are they? Nowhere.
Rolfe.