Dana Ullman's Homeopathy Studies Thread

It's a small study with questionable results which caused barely a ripple in the scientific literature (in fact we know it has been cited zero times in a scientific context. We all know it's failings. DU is trying on the argument from authority line - "it was in a prestigious journal, everyone!"
There are millions of better quality studies that have never had articles about them in Wiki. Why should this snivelling study make it when more significant articles haven't?
 
Last edited:
One point that it might be worth making about the Chest article is that it can hardly be called "notable" if it has had no clinical impact. I don't know of any Intensive Care Unit in the world that uses homeopathic treatment to manage secretions in intubated COAD patients, and it is not mentioned in any evidence based ICU guidelines. Ive never heard it brought up in any discussion on the literature. Not exactly "notable".
 
One point that it might be worth making about the Chest article is that it can hardly be called "notable" if it has had no clinical impact. I don't know of any Intensive Care Unit in the world that uses homeopathic treatment to manage secretions in intubated COAD patients, and it is not mentioned in any evidence based ICU guidelines. Ive never heard it brought up in any discussion on the literature. Not exactly "notable".

A very good point, you might make the same argument on the Wikipedia talk section. I suspect that if any of the habituees of this forum (I'm a newcomer but include me in) make a comment, Ullman will start screaming POV.
 
Oh? A little rash, wasn't it? Well, you asked for it, I'm afraid:

Oxford Circus


Hans

Tottenham Court Road

Which, I think you will agree, is pretty sharp for this time on a Sunday morning.

Please, no one just play Kings Cross that variation is really DUll :)

Or am I just messing with your heads with a double bluff knip gambit?
 
I would have thought Caledonian Rd is the obvious riposte to that underhand move.
 
Given the subject matter of this thread, surely all moves this side of Barking are invalid?
 
Oh, if only there was a tube station at Havering!

Barons Court will have to do for this move.

Rolfe.
 
Dana Ullman is now posting on the web for stories from homeopaths who have treated people using information from his books for an upcoming story in a woman's magazine. :rolleyes:

I wonder if they would print a sceptical article in response. :nope:
 
Dana Ullman is now posting on the web for stories from homeopaths who have treated people using information from his books for an upcoming story in a woman's magazine. :rolleyes:

I wonder if they would print a sceptical article in response. :nope:


Link please.
We might as well watch him in action even if it looks like his career here is over.
 
Here's Dana on his Wikipedia User Page:
I do listen to others and hear what they have to say, and I learn from everyone.


So he presumably knows that the papers he keeps spamming around the web have been shot down in flames. I wonder why he keeps citing them.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom