Dana Ullman's Homeopathy Studies Thread

Over at Wikipedia, Ullman is pushing this study

From Ullman:- A meta-analysis of 105 trials was published in Human and Experimental Toxicology.[Linde, K., Jonas, W.B., Melchart, D., et al. (1994) "Critical Review and Meta-Analysis of Serial Agitated Dilutions in Experimental Toxicology," Human and Experimental Toxicology, 13:481-92.] Although most of these studies were not high quality research, the studies that tended to show the most significant effects from homeopathic doses were the high quality studies. The researchers found that there were 40 high quality studies, of which 27 showed positive results from homeopathic doses (there were 50% more positive results than negative results). Of special interest were nine studies on mice which tested homeopathic doses beyond 15C that demonstrated a 40% decrease in mortality compared to mice in the control group.

Many people here may be familiar with the high standards of research for which Linde and Jonas are known.
I cannot find the paper. Does anybody have a copy or a link, or a link to any analysis of the study?
 
In the past I tried to understand one of Jonas's other papers:

Mol Cell Biochem. 2005 Mar;271(1-2):51-9.
External bioenergy-induced increases in intracellular free calcium concentrations
are mediated by Na+/Ca2+ exchanger and L-type calcium channel.

Kiang JG, Ives JA, Jonas WB.
Department of Cellular Injury, Walter Reed Army Institute of Research, 503 Robert
Grant Avenue, Room 1N07, Silver Spring, MD 20910-7500, USA.

"External bioenergy (EBE, energy emitted from a human body) has been shown to
increase intracellular calcium concentration ([Ca2+]i, an important factor in
signal transduction) and regulate the cellular response to heat stress in
cultured human lymphoid Jurkat T cells. In this study, we wanted to elucidate the
underlying mechanisms. A bioenergy specialist emitted bioenergy sequentially
toward tubes of cultured Jurkat T cells for one 15-minute period in buffers
containing different ion compositions or different concentrations of inhibitors. ..."

My memory is that the best I could do was to question that they had controlled the conditions properly. (They said they had.)
 
It's at pubmed here: http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/7917505

The Badly Shaved Monkey has ordered reprints. Hum. Exp. Toxicol. online doesn't go back that far yet.

Thank you. The abstract does not give out very much information, I'll await BSM's analysis. Ullman seemed to be losing the argument over Shang's meta-analysis and pulled this one out to press the quote 'The better studies showed an effect'.

In the past I tried to understand one of Jonas's other papers:

Mol Cell Biochem. 2005 Mar;271(1-2):51-9.
External bioenergy-induced increases in intracellular free calcium concentrations
are mediated by Na+/Ca2+ exchanger and L-type calcium channel.

Kiang JG, Ives JA, Jonas WB.
Department of Cellular Injury, Walter Reed Army Institute of Research, 503 Robert
Grant Avenue, Room 1N07, Silver Spring, MD 20910-7500, USA.

"External bioenergy (EBE, energy emitted from a human body) has been shown to
increase intracellular calcium concentration ([Ca2+]i, an important factor in
signal transduction) and regulate the cellular response to heat stress in
cultured human lymphoid Jurkat T cells. In this study, we wanted to elucidate the
underlying mechanisms. A bioenergy specialist emitted bioenergy sequentially
toward tubes of cultured Jurkat T cells for one 15-minute period in buffers
containing different ion compositions or different concentrations of inhibitors. ..."

My memory is that the best I could do was to question that they had controlled the conditions properly. (They said they had.)

Presumably this type of junk science led Ullman to the conclusion:-

Many people here may be familiar with the high standards of research for which Linde and Jonas are known.
 
Has anyone noticed him getting a bitch-slapping here at Wikipedia?

This is mainly from 'offthefence' who first came across as a mild logician but seems to have become enraged at Ullman's technique of ignoring facts and using silly language to make his points. I hope 'offthefence' is either a member here or would like to become one.
 
Has anyone noticed him getting a bitch-slapping here at Wikipedia?

Aw, no one corrected him when he was wrong...

Correct me if I'm wrong: when p < 0.05, this suggests statistical significance, but when p < 0.001, it is substantially significant.

Does Dana/James not know how to interpret a p-value? Or know what 'statistically significant' means? Or what alpha/type I errors are?
 
Ironically, homoeopathy is one discipline where generally the null-hypothesis is not a strawman.
 
Last edited:
Baron Samedi said:
Does Dana/James not know how to interpret a p-value? Or know what 'statistically significant' means? Or what alpha/type I errors are?

Nope! Although he does seem to have improved a little bit. Some time ago, his webpage on why "Homeopathy makes sense and works" [sic] stated that p=0.008 "means that there was a 99.2% chance that this treatment was effective". He now says that "When “P” equals .05, this means that there are 5 chances out of 100 that the effective of a specific treatment happened by chance, and scientists today consider this 5% chance as adequate evidence of a treatment’s effectiveness. In this study, however, there was an extremely high likelihood that the treatment was effective because there were only seven chances out of 10,000 (!) that this result happened by chance.)"

This is at least a little more accurate, but still gives the impression that you can just take a low p-value as being indicative of an effect, without taking into account bias, problems with study design, and so on.
 
Nope! Although he does seem to have improved a little bit. Some time ago, his webpage on why "Homeopathy makes sense and works" [sic] stated that p=0.008 "means that there was a 99.2% chance that this treatment was effective". He now says that "When “P” equals .05, this means that there are 5 chances out of 100 that the effective of a specific treatment happened by chance, and scientists today consider this 5% chance as adequate evidence of a treatment’s effectiveness. In this study, however, there was an extremely high likelihood that the treatment was effective because there were only seven chances out of 10,000 (!) that this result happened by chance.)"

This is at least a little more accurate, but still gives the impression that you can just take a low p-value as being indicative of an effect, without taking into account bias, problems with study design, and so on.

Well, he's learning. But by chance over what? And who in the world uses a strict alpha = 0.05? I've used 0.1 for loose studies, down to 0.001 for very tight studies with large sample sizes. And Bonferroni... ah yes, Bonferroni. Maybe one of you in pure medicine may be able to answer this for me: Do med studies have a generally smaller alpha level, or is 0.05 actually the gold standard?
 
It seems that he's no longer stating that p=0.008 "means that there was a 99.2% chance that this treatment was effective", while still leaving that as an implication. You might call that intellectual dishonesty, but I couldn't possibly comment.
 
Has anyone noticed him getting a bitch-slapping here at Wikipedia?


With regard to his continual demands that people "Assume Good Faith" (usually in the context of his attempts to introduce stuff that he's already seen demolished), I just listened to an old Goon Show ("The Jet-Propelled Guided NAAFI") which included this:
GREENSLADE:
Mr Eccles, we are not for one moment doubting your sincerity. It's just your intelligence that's in question.

ECCLES:
Well, I accept your apology.
 
This is mainly from 'offthefence' who first came across as a mild logician but seems to have become enraged at Ullman's technique of ignoring facts and using silly language to make his points. I hope 'offthefence' is either a member here or would like to become one.


Well it's not me (I woudn't take credit for someone else's stellar performance, who me? - and my PhD isn't in pharmacology). But I don't think you'd have all that far to look.

Rolfe.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom