Dana Ullman's Homeopathy Studies Thread

It's also worth noting that both Martin Chaplin and Ullman have weighed in on the Wikipedia page for memory of water. Oh, what fun.

"On removing the water from the freezer, it will be observed that the block of ice, though now exposed to room temperature, will remain a block of ice for some time. Thus, there exists in water a property which enables it to "remember" for a certain amount of time that it has been kept in the freezer"

Speechless.
 
Last edited:
shpalman said:
It's also worth noting that both Martin Chaplin and Ullman have weighed in on the Wikipedia page for memory of water. Oh, what fun.

"On removing the water from the freezer, it will be observed that the block of ice, though now exposed to room temperature, will remain a block of ice for some time. Thus, there exists in water a property which enables it to "remember" for a certain amount of time that it has been kept in the freezer"

Speechless.

Can water become demented, then? What would happen if it forgot that it was supposed to obey the laws of thermodynamics?

Linda
 
Reading DUllman arselicking Chaplin was particularly nauseating.

...Is arselicking (the word not the action...) allowed here, or should I edit?
 
Last edited:
On removing the water from the freezer, it will be observed that the block of ice, though now exposed to room temperature, will remain a block of ice for some time. Thus, there exists in water a property which enables it to "remember" for a certain amount of time that it has been kept in the freezer


This has got to be a windup. Surely. :jaw-dropp

Rolfe.
 
Last edited:
I'm most intruiged by this sentence towards the end of the 'More recent experiemets' section:

'The changes in the aqueous properties seem, at least partly, down to the inherent unusualness of water.'

That is not shown as a quote, but as an encyclopedic fact.

Is water inherently unusual?
 
When I did chemistry at school, yes.

Makes you wonder how come they just use ethanol instead when they feel like it. Rustum Roy's "memory of water" results were actually all from ethanol, not water. In fact I think it's the other way round, Hahnemann originally used ethanol, but in modern times people have drifted to water because it doesn't get you tipsy and won't somebody think of the children.

Rolfe.
 
I've just read my way through that "Arsenicum Album" page, and I think my brain just came out through my ears. OffTheFence, you're a saint. I couldn't do that for a pension. (Well, maybe if I was collecting my pension....)

All that fuss for an obscure page on nothing very much. But if it wasn't done, the homoeo enthusiasts would just take advantage of the inertia and hype their woo all over the damn place.

Rolfe.
 
When I did chemistry at school, yes.

Makes you wonder how come they just use ethanol instead when they feel like it. Rustum Roy's "memory of water" results were actually all from ethanol, not water. In fact I think it's the other way round, Hahnemann originally used ethanol, but in modern times people have drifted to water because it doesn't get you tipsy and won't somebody think of the children.

Rolfe.

...and the water nowadays is somewhat safer than it was in his day.
 
I've just read my way through that "Arsenicum Album" page, and I think my brain just came out through my ears. OffTheFence, you're a saint. I couldn't do that for a pension. (Well, maybe if I was collecting my pension....)

All that fuss for an obscure page on nothing very much. But if it wasn't done, the homoeo enthusiasts would just take advantage of the inertia and hype their woo all over the damn place.

Rolfe.

I've been trying to work out why OffTheFence was finding so much difficulty in getting sensible criteria to be applied to those crap papers.

It seems to me that Wikipedia has in place procedures that limit the intrusion of woo into mainstream topics, though that didn't top Depleted Uranus from trying to force that stupid CHEST paper of his into the chemistry page of potassium dichromate.

But, if the whole topic is situated in the realm of woo, such as discussing a particular hom remedy, really it should be discussed from an external viewpoint- People have believed in astrology for thousands of years..., Characteristics are assigned to different star signs and astrologists believe these are reflected in people's personalities. Where it goes wrong is when it is woo stuff being discussed from a perspective inside woo and there is nothing from outside woo that exists to balance it. Why would mainstream science ever bother to counter DU's stupid papers? But in Wikipedia terms this means there is nowhere from which to derive a "reliable source" of material to set against the nonsense. It seems that OffTheFence has, nonetheless, found all sorts of ways that some balance can be introduced, but it appears very difficult to actually put that into Articles without the defenders of endarkenment complaining and tying the whole thing up in procedural knots.

Maybe if you are stupid enough to use Wikipedia to read about particular beliefs inside woo then you deserve to read crap. It's not right, but as Rolfe points, out it becomes a tiringly pointless game of WhackAMole if someone like DU just pulls yet another obscure abstract from his fundament for a paper he has not even read (as I think one can conclude pretty safely that he had not read the Cazin paper that was being discussed). It is a particularly asymmetrical form of intellectual warfare if the good guys stick to the rules of reading and analysing the material honestly while the woos just throw things in at random and there is no one to make them play fairly.

So much stupidity, so little time.
 
I've been trying to work out why OffTheFence was finding so much difficulty in getting sensible criteria to be applied to those crap papers.

Wiki doesn't seem well equipped to recognise Reliable Sources, if (as someone appears to have pointed out) actually reading a paper (rather than quoting what someone else says about it in another paper) seems to be disallowed for being Original Research.

Why would mainstream science ever bother to counter DU's stupid papers? But in Wikipedia terms this means there is nowhere from which to derive a "reliable source" of material to set against the nonsense.

Exactly: again you can't say that all of mainstream physics, chemistry, biology and medicine imposes a tiny prior probability on homeopathy because that once more counts as Original Research or Synthesizing sources. (And "keeping a Neutral Point of View" doesn't mean 0.5 prior probability that it works or it doesn't.)

At least for the Water Memory stuff there's one article in the very same issue of Homeopathy and lots of letters in the next one to cite.

Maybe if you are stupid enough to use Wikipedia to read about particular beliefs inside woo then you deserve to read crap...

It's when that stuff leaks into sensible articles that we have more of a problem.
 
Last edited:
It's when that stuff leaks into sensible articles that we have more of a problem.


It's a problem if there's inaccurate information anywhere on there. People can then link to this to support their arguments elsewhere, and many people will assume that the information is accurate.

Dana, for example, has attempted to edit several pages on Wikipedia so that they support otherwise unsupported claims in his recent book.
 
Last edited:
dilution beyong avogadro number

Edited by Darat: 
Content deleted: Generic notice - this Member has breached their Membership Agreement in several ways in all of their first posts bar one, the breaches cover Rule 11, Rule 6 and Rule 4 and possible other rules! All the content of the offending posts is being deleted and this message left in all posts edited.
 
Last edited by a moderator:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom