Dana Ullman's Homeopathy Studies Thread

This isn't the tadpole study where there was a suspicion they might have used an aqueous solution for the controls and an alcohol-based homoeopathic preparation, was it?


The tested a lot of variables in this study:
Test and control groups were tested against each other
- using aqueous solutions.
- using both aqueous and alcohol solutions exposed to microwave ovens, with and without aluminium foil protection,
- using aqueous solutions exposed to mobile phones,
- using aqueous solutions exposed to airport x-rays.
- using aqueous solutions exposed to red light barcode scanners,.

I kid you not.
 
Last edited:
The way I interpreted the graph was if there was an effect, it only had an significant impact between t=0 and t=1, since the two lines run virtually parallel from the first sample.
 
bump!

OK, let's get this back on page 1 ready for Dana. The tadpoles are busted, but he has still not admitted that Rustum Roy's bomb turned out to be a damp squib. To keep our metaphors mixed (and, thanks to Milgrom we know that homeopaths love a well-mixed metaphor) I want to see Dana sit down here and eat a large plate of crow on the subject of defective UV absorption experiments. So, Dana/JamesGully, would you like that crow warm or cold?
 
Last edited:
Mojo, you are priceless. I especially liked the conclusion in the Potassium Dichromate talk section where Ullman tried to add in the COPD study.

It's a weak study, and a crappy piece of science. End of story. Jefffire (talk) 16:02, 20 January 2008 (UTC)
 
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Talk:Potassium_dichromate#_note-2

Too busy to talk to us, but not too busy to keep shoving that stupid CHEST paper in front of people.

"The COPD study was referenced by the New England Journal of Medicine[4] and JAMA[5] This should end our discussion on the notability of this study. It IS notable. —Preceding unsigned comment added by Danaullman (talk • contribs) 05:26, 19 January 2008 (UTC)"

Come on, Dana. Tell us why Roy produced such a bad paper.
 
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Talk:Potassium_dichromate#_note-2

Too busy to talk to us, but not too busy to keep shoving that stupid CHEST paper in front of people.

"The COPD study was referenced by the New England Journal of Medicine[4] and JAMA[5] This should end our discussion on the notability of this study. It IS notable. —Preceding unsigned comment added by Danaullman (talk • contribs) 05:26, 19 January 2008 (UTC)"

As the editors have pointed out, Dana even gets this wrong. I assume this is through stupidity, rather than an intent to mislead.

Articles in the NEJM and JAMA were cited by authors of the Chest article, and not the other way around.

It's very amusing seeing Dana try and pump this trivial study up as some earth shattering medical revelation.
 
Last edited:
Another day and still no JamesGully/Dana.

So we still don't know what he thinks about Rustum Roy's dud.

Maybe he can't use a keyboard at the moment. Nasty succussion-related wrist strain perhaps.
 
Has Dana finally left the building? Have we broken him at last?

Should he return I expect to hear a unanimous chorus of "Tell about Rustum Roy's dud paper, Dana".
 
Didn't he say he'd be back on Monday? The crucial question is perhaps, which Monday? There's one every week!

Rolfe.
 
He's still trying to get people to take him seriously here;

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Talk:Potassium_dichromate

Talking bollocks is hard to square with Wikipedia's sacred "NPOV".


Recall what the study authors said about their results and homeopathy:
The effect may be best explained by cybernetics, which means that the information of the homeopathic drug acts consensually on the regulator. Thereby, the body regains its original property to regulate physical parameters.
So the article might as well have been in german.
Pseudoscience of the highest order.
 
Last edited:
He's still trying to get people to take him seriously here;

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Talk:Potassium_dichromate

Talking bollocks is hard to square with Wikipedia's sacred "NPOV".

The contributors of wiki are up to the task at the moment but I see signs of battle fatigue. Ullman seems to have moved the argument from whether homeopathy should mentioned in this article to the importance of the COPD study.

Ullman sees this as an opportunity of mentioning homeopathy in every wiki article connected to anything mentioned in vast illiterature of his subject.

We should be alert to give them support when required.
 
I was thinking of linking to the discussions here to show them that DU (depleted something?) has tried and failed to make this trivial study stick elsewhere.

If he had a sense of proportion it wouldn't be so bad but he called it a "fine piece of research" here which is transparently over-egging the pudding.
 
p.s. I was thinking of it, but I find Wikipedia's editing process exasperating even on the talk pages, so if someone else could do it I'd be grateful.
 
If it becomes necessary, I'll mention the analysis of the COPD trial. I hesitate at the moment because it will give Ullman the excuse to start talking about NPOV and POV.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom