Dana Ullman's Homeopathy Studies Thread

But enough of this, I want to see Dana defend Roy's shoddy ethanol absorbance work.

Or will he just blame it on excessive ethanol absorption? :)
 
Or will he just blame it on excessive ethanol absorption? :)


Mmmm, tasty! I fancy a spot of that.

Hey, BSM, do you reckon our mutually esteemed (derogatory remarks concerning) colleagues Messrs D_y, S____n, H___e, G_____y et al have noticed that publication? A quick look at the RCVS Register would confirm for them that it is indeed me, even without middle initial or post-nomials, as the SAC is given as my affiliation in both places. I would have expected at least one of them would have caught on. Do I hear the snappy tattoo of carpet tacks being spit?

Do you think Manju's 10/10ths response would have satisfied them that all was well? Frankly, I wouldn't be all that surprised.

Rolfe.
 
I don't really want to play into Dana's fantasies, but the graphs in the second of his papers are feckin' weird.

Look at the last graph (bottom right). The line for control data goes straight across, the experimental data drop rapidly then rise. Two points are marked as p<0.01. The nadir of the drop and the last line in the sequence, where each of the four intervening points are higher than the former and lower than the latter. Indications of data spread (SD or SEM) are given for none of the data. Even so, I struggle to imagine what data structure can yield these artefacts. There must be wild differences in variance among the points.

Exactly. Even if you get past the problem of non-significant differences, there are plenty of other problems to chew on.

And this is the paper that claims to be properly blinded!

It may be best not to read the methods section, then. :)

I've said it before and I'll say it again: isn't it remarkable how the homs keep choosing unnecessarily complicated and unstable experimental models, just like Dr BuenaVistaSocialClub and Madeleine Ennis with their degranulating basophils.

I think the real role of these models is to act as random number generators for data that they can then dredge.

They do serve as good examples of how to introduce (or create) bias.

"Chi-square tests were used to compare groups. Different statistical methods had been discussed in connection with the amphibian model previously, including variance analysis, t-test, survival analysis, proportional hazards model, logistic regression.[1], [5] and [10] These usually give comparable results but (1) need larger numbers of basins in one experiment."

Come on guys, pick a test any test.

" Furthermore (2), depending on differences in the overall duration of experiments, S.D. is usually variable when experiments from different laboratories are pooled"

Their initial, more standard analyses, were probably quite embarrassing. ;)

Oh, and a large bucket of heteroscedascity, please.

One of these days, I'm going to manage to work that in to casual conversation.

Linda
 
http://www.reference.com/browse/wiki/Heteroscedasticity

Seems it's spelled heteroscedasticity (or heteroskedasticity)....oops!

(If I have the meaning correct, heteroscedasticity means that, in the different experiments, the standard deviation of the variable being measured is different)

Aw, nuts. Google is definitely not my friend any more. I realised I wasn't sure of the spelling, but obviously I checked with sources that also can't spell.
 
The tadpole papers are hard to understand - primarily because the authors don't give full details of methodology and analysis - They refer to other papers they have written for us to see the details. This is often done in publications, but makes things very difficult.

I am taken however by the introduction, where Figure 1 is prominently displayed (an odd place for results/data to appear, no?). The authors have pooled the results from 5 different studies looking at the same phenomenon. The lines are nearly-identical. Control group tadpoles start out as being significantly different to study group tadpoles (p<0.01), and remain different at all study points thereafter.

Not only does this make nonsense of the conclusion that there is something magically different between the groups that is due to homeopathy, but it points to major randomisation problems in the studies, which must be a critical flaw and is hard to explain unless there is undue influence taking place in homeopathy's favour by biasing group selection. "Slow developing" tadpoles are somehow favoured for selection into the homeopathy study group, which is trying to prove that homeopathy.... wait for it.... slows development.
 
Last edited:
Control group tadpoles start out as being significantly different to study group tadpoles


They haven't actually plotted t=0, so I'm not sure about that point.


0


Figure 1. The influence of highly diluted thyroxine vs analogously prepared water, on highland Rana temporaria. Results from five researchers in five laboratories, pooled data from.[2] and [10] Ordinate—cumulative frequency of 4-legged tadpoles (N); abscissa—points in time; black squares—cumulative frequencies of animals treated with homeopathically prepared thyroxine; white squares—animals treated with analogously prepared water; and **—P<0.01.
 
They think they can see about three different homoeopathic effects in these studies:


The inverse curative effect.

One of the bases of homeopathy, namely the principle of similars, can be demonstrated by first hyperstimulating Rana temporaria by immersion in an aqueous molecular thyroxine solution (10−8 parts by weight, not submitted to an agitation process) and then inducing an inverse ‘curative’ effect by a homeopathically prepared solution of the same hormone.There appears to be a relationship between the effect of homeopathically prepared thyroxine and a naturally or artificially elevated thyroxine level in the animals during metamorphosis. This is in some respects analogous to intoxication/detoxication studies, where organisms are first treated with a high dose of a toxin and then with a sequentially diluted and agitated solution of the same toxin.


The curative effect

Artificial acceleration of metamorphosis can also be achieved by raising temperature of the water in which the animals live. This might be considered a ‘curative’ effect in the light of the homeopathic principle of similiars.


The proving effect

Another characteristic, namely that of a drug proving effect, is illustrated by the finding that very frequent application of the solution, causes first a slowing and subsequently an acceleration of metamorphosis. Here, the effect of the solution is at first inverse to (‘curative phase’) and later concurrent with that of molecular hyperstimulation (‘drug proving’).
 
Last edited:
They haven't actually plotted t=0, so I'm not sure about that point.
(snip)

Question. Why is the y axis scale in %? Is this to show percent change over baseline at different times? And if so, how did they plug this number in, by the mean, median, or 1 - (sum at time=n) / (sum at time 0)? Just curious.
 
This isn't the tadpole study where there was a suspicion they might have used an aqueous solution for the controls and an alcohol-based homoeopathic preparation, was it?

Rolfe.
 
Last edited:
The y axis represents the cumulative percentage of tadpoles reaching the 4-legged stage of development. (At entry to study they all had hind legs)

BJ is correct - I assumed the populations were different at the start of the study, but the first data points are at Time point 1 (whenever that would be). Very odd they do not give time 0 data points.
 
This isn't the tadpole study where there was a suspicion they might have used an aqueous solution for the controls and an alcohol-based homoeopathic preparation, was it?

Rolfe.
Well they say they used double distilled water for test and controls....
 
Hmmm, you've got me musing again why Rao and Roy used ethanol for their experimental work regarding their theories about the Memory of Water.

A topic for the other thread, perhaps.

Rolfe.
 
Last edited:
The y axis represents the cumulative percentage of tadpoles reaching the 4-legged stage of development. (At entry to study they all had hind legs)

BJ is correct - I assumed the populations were different at the start of the study, but the first data points are at Time point 1 (whenever that would be). Very odd they do not give time 0 data points.

The time 0 data points should be assumed to be the same as the tadpoles were all selected to be the same. You are correct that the first data point is going to reflect the result of sorting, rather than the result of treatment, though.

Linda
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom