Cold Reading Demos at TAM2

Garrette said:

I don't know if I'm "feeding the trolls" here or not, but what the heck.


Considering only three or four self-appointed hall monitors here label me a troll, I think we can discount that notion.


If you have not read Schwartz's book or at least the summary you can find online, and it does not appear you have,


How exactly does it not appear I have read it? You've said that and BillHoyt has said that. Interesting beliefs, but I have read it. I do not own it, but I've read it in increments at a local bookstore. I thought it was very interesting, but I would have liked to seen more details too.

You make interesting points though and I hope Schwartz gets back to you. Hopefully the corrected email address will do the trick. ;) (I've done that so many times before!) Yes, going to UArizona's Psychology dept. webpage and searching for 'Core Faculty' one finds his email, and there is no z on the end.
 
I'm happy to not call you a troll, TC. No problem.

It appears that you have not read it because I haven't seen you post anything specific about the experiments except that they happened. No offense, but I don't think reading a book in increments at the store is the same as having read it in detail.

That's not the point, though. Whether you've read it or not, questions concerning my issues with the experiments, and more importantly other people's issues, can be found on the internet. Claus linked to some.

I hope Schwartz responds soon, too. Bad on me for screwing up the address.
 
T'ai Chi said:
Considering only three or four self-appointed hall monitors here label me a troll, I think we can discount that notion.

One would think that with that "extensive" education in "mathematics" and "statistics," you might have a shot at counting. The list of those who have already called you a troll is just a tad longer than you claim:

Fade
TLN
Patricio Elicer
Stimpson J Cat
Dr Benway
zakur
Unrepentent Sinner
Lord Kenneth
Upchurch
Peter Soderqvist
thaiboxerken
jj
BillHoyt
RichardR

Shall we do a more extensive search? I wonder how many I've missed? Perhaps "remedial counting" should be your next graduate course?
 
Garrette said:


Earlier I said I had sent it on 2 December. Rechecking this morning, I find it was actually 3 December.

I also found a potential mistake in the address, so there may be no actual delay on Schwartz's part.

I sent the first e-mail to using an address that spells his full last name. In relooking at the address I was provided by Steve, I should have left off the "z".

To rectify and be sure, I resent the e-mail this morning (25 January where I am; still 24 January EST) to both addresses.

:rolleyes:
 
BillHoyt said:


One would think that with that "extensive" education in "mathematics" and "statistics," you might have a shot at counting. The list of those who have already called you a troll is just a tad longer than you claim:

Fade
TLN
Patricio Elicer
Stimpson J Cat
Dr Benway
zakur
Unrepentent Sinner
Lord Kenneth
Upchurch
Peter Soderqvist
thaiboxerken
jj
BillHoyt
RichardR


The problem is, all those people / sockpuppets are trolls. And you, Sir, are the worst of them!

Why won't any cold reader actually take Dr S up on his challenge?

It must be a cinch to tap such supposedly leaky controls and protocols, Shirley?

What, in heaven's name, are they afraid of?
 
Interesting Ian said:


I didn't post anything at 10.47pm. That was only 5 mins ago and I was playing the demo of "Far Cry". Certainly I have not said or implied that the Rhines were implicated in fraud. Again you lie.

I again ask you the question, since you've so far ignored it. Are you alleging there was fraud associated with the research undertook by the Rhines?? :eek:
Ian,

It has been nearly a day since you answered your own question. Only you didn't read it. It was from chapter 17 of Irwin's textbook. Only you didn't read that chapter. You posted the passage from chapter 17 of Irwin's book on Levy being caught red-handed manipulating data at Rhine's lab. You posted it at 10:47, eastern U.S. time, yesterday. Only you didn't read your own post.

We had a *yawn* fascinating exchange yesterday, where fact after fact that I presented came straight from sources I had cited. I gave you the links. You even added more. When you asked question after question about those facts, I fired back, asking if you had not read those sources. Of course, you claimed you had. Of course, you quoted passage after passage from those sources. Maybe attempting to prove you had read the sources? One can only speculate.

But, as with everything else you post here, you did so disingenuously. They were simply cut & paste diversions, not meant to understand my points or the authors', not meant to address my points or the authors', but simply meant to drive the discussion off course so as to avoid addressing your previous claims about fraud and parapsychology.

In the midst of this mad attempt to red herring your previous gaffe, you laid a wondrous egg, Ian. Big, heavy, and white, it fell to the ground while your mouth went suddenly agape in horror. When it hit the craggy rocks below, it cracked open. You haven't yet cleaned it up, and it is beginning to smell. I told you about the egg before it began smelling. "What egg," you cried. I told you to go back and find your egg. "What egg, there is no egg," you insisted. I've told you the exact time you laid it. I've reminded you what it looked like and where you laid it. Mysteriously, you have yet to find it. Mysteriously, you have yet to remember having laid it. Mysterioulsy, you have yet to remember having posted about Levy being caught red-handed at Rhine's lab.

So which is it, Ian? Did you not read your own 10:47 post? Did you not understand it when you posted it? Did you burn those particular brain cells and manage to forget about it a few hours later? Have you since been unable to find that post? After I gave you the time stamp? Even though you know the key word (Rhine) to search on? Even though I've already given you the other key word (Levy) to search on? Even though this thread only has five pages? Do you not know how to use the "find in page" feature of your browser? Do you not know how to use the JREF search feature? Or are you simply a lying, deceitful, disingenuous troll poster? One who knows he's been caught once again in an intellectually dishonest game? No matter how you answer, others will form their own conclusions. No matter how you answer, you've laid the egg and it smells.

Your entertainment value has hit an all-time high. But don't worry, they're not laughing at you... Sorry, that's exactly what they're doing.
 
Interesting Ian said:
Missed this before. You're alleging there was fraud associated with the research undertook by the Rhines?? :eek:

Read what BillHoyt said:

BillHoyt said:
Irwin blames a number of factors, not the least amongst them the history of fraud going back to Rhine's laboratory.

He said "Rhine's laboratory." Here's a snippet of your own post:

Dr. W. J. Levy had worked in RhineÕs laboratory for a few years and was interested
primarily in psi research with animals (anpsi). In Á974 some students
observed Levy tinkering with the automatic recording apparatus being used
in one of the laboratoryÕs anpsi experiments. Secret recordings of the data
were arranged and on comparison with LevyÕs reported results, discrepancies
were found. When confronted by Rhine, Levy acknowledged his fraudulent
activity and was dismissed.


(Emphasis mine)

It would help if you improved your reading skills.

Do you still maintain that there was no history of fraud going back to Rhine's laboratory?

Just yes or no, please.
 
BillHoyt said:

One would think that with that "extensive" education in "mathematics" and "statistics," you might have a shot at counting. The list of those who have already called you a troll is just a tad longer than you claim:


Sorry Bill. As your rhetoric increases... well, it just increases.

As far as your list of people who consider me a troll, I only consider the most vocal self appointed hall monitors who continually call me a troll at every chance they get (and who predictably post right after the other), of which there are about 3. To do so, you must discount or wholly ignore the number of posts I've had where I posted serious, insightful, helpful, and/or interesting material, of which there is plenty if you used the search feature in the other direction.

Since you probably have a different version of events, the facts are that you questioned my statistical and mathematical knowledge (in response to me questioning your statistical conclusions after you said some dubious comments re: your belief in the adequecy of your test for JE cold reading, apparently by juvenille namecalling against me, questioning of my professors, claiming I got my degrees from a Bazooka Joe wrapper, saying my test for non-randomness was a "crap smear", etc.) only later to prove yourself quite inadequate when called on it.

You asked me mathematical statistical questions which I answered effortlessly and completely, only to have you claim I obtained the answers off the internet (I can't help it if I actually know the subject). I contacted NIST re: my "crap smear" test for nonrandomness only to have them say they have a similar test and that while mine had some extremely minor technical issues (I PM'd you the correspondence) it had good aspects. Needless to say with your belief set, you probably reacted knee-jerkingly against my mathematics because similar sound mathematics were being used in the study of anomalous mental phenomena (in the papers of Decision Augmention Theory).

In return I asked you questions to guage your competency in the subject (after all, people here and elsewhere pretty much agree that one has to have some to judge others' and make these claims against people, right?) only to have you ignore them all. Not to mention your non-addressing, but continued making fun of via your signature, of the well-established view that mathematical axioms are assumptions/beliefs.

I suggest you argue against arguments and not the person making the arguments, something which you can't seem to avoid in my and others' cases, which is abundantly obvious.

*shrug* Whatever. I continue to fail to be intimidated, or impressed, by such noise.
 
T'ai Chi said:
As far as your list of people who consider me a troll, I only consider the most vocal self appointed hall monitors who continually call me a troll at every chance they get, of which there are about 3.
Tr'olldini,

No, sir. Here is what you claimed to Garrette:
Considering only three or four self-appointed hall monitors here label me a troll, I think we can discount that notion.
You said three or four label you a troll. Now that I have pointed out to you just a partial list of all those who have labeled you a troll, you try the No True Scotsman maneuver. You try to insert the qualifier, "continually".

Learn to count. Also learn not to engage in fallacies such as the No True Scotsman maneuver.

If you wish to take up that PM, then please post to the original thread. And be sure to post the complete message from NIST. But perhaps you ought to read the complete message first, remind yourself about the definition of "power," ask yourself why the person from NIST wrote what he wrote, and then remind yourself of what I said about the crap smear test. I will not burden this thread with that discussion. Neither will I engage in an off-record, PMs exchange with you.

And... learn to count.
 
BillHoyt said:
It has been nearly a day since you answered your own question. Only you didn't read it. It was from chapter 17 of Irwin's textbook. Only you didn't read that chapter. You posted the passage from chapter 17 of Irwin's book on Levy being caught red-handed manipulating data at Rhine's lab. You posted it at 10:47, eastern U.S. time, yesterday. Only you didn't read your own post.

But this occurred in 1974!! :eek: Rhines research started in the 1930's and this was when parapsychology started. A reasonably interpretation of your remark "Irwin blames a number of factors, not the least amongst them the history of fraud going back to Rhine's laboratory" was that you were referring to this time period i.e that you were referring to the history of parapsychological research starting with Rhine's investigations of these alleged phenomena. But in fact the "history of fraud" is actually less than 30 years! Well . .OK.

And as I said before, the statement "Irwin blames a number of factors, not the least amongst them the history of fraud going back to Rhine's laboratory", even in the modified sense in which you mean it, cannot be substantiated. As I said before, and which you apparently missed:

{quote}
No he doesn't
( i.e Irwin blames a number of factors, not the least amongst them the history of fraud going back to Rhine's laboratory) He blames the irrational prejudices of skeptics and the unfortunate fact they wield a lot of influence.
{/quote}

We had a *yawn* fascinating exchange yesterday, where fact after fact that I presented came straight from sources I had cited.

And still you have not answered my questions such as substantiating your belief that Irwin is a believer, that parapsychological research is sullied, you acknowledging that you were wrong about the fraud issue etc.



In the midst of this mad attempt to red herring your previous gaffe,

It is most unresonable to call it a gaffe. Any reasonable person reading the statement "Irwin blames a number of factors, not the least amongst them the history of fraud going back to Rhine's laboratory" would take it to mean the reseach conducted by Rhine himself in the 1930's which inaugurated the scientific discipline of parapsychology. Not by some other guy 40 years later working in the Rhines lab! Anyway, Irwin most certainly states no such thing. You either are comprehensively failing to understand what he is saying, or you are pretending to comprehensively misunderstand what he's saying. Either way, it's pretty bad.
 
CFLarsen said:


Read what BillHoyt said:



He said "Rhine's laboratory." Here's a snippet of your own post:



It would help if you improved your reading skills.

Do you still maintain that there was no history of fraud going back to Rhine's laboratory?

Just yes or no, please.

In the more common and obvious interpretation of this sentence then it is false. See my response to BillHoyt.
 
Interesting Ian said:


But this occurred in 1974!! :eek: Rhines research started in the 1930's and this was when parapsychology started. A reasonably interpretation of your remark "Irwin blames a number of factors, not the least amongst them the history of fraud going back to Rhine's laboratory" was that you were referring to this time period i.e that you were referring to the history of parapsychological research starting with Rhine's investigations of these alleged phenomena. But in fact the "history of fraud" is actually less than 30 years! Well . .OK..

No True Scotsman maneuver. Pathetic. It is, of course, ironic that, in the midst of debating fraud in parapsychology, you should continually commit intellectual fraud.

But you see, Ian, you expressed surprise that any fraud had happened at Rhine's laboratory. You didn't reply to me with this time qualifier. You simply never read what you cut and pasted here. Your own post. Your own cut & paste. Your own egg.
 
Interesting Ian said:


In the more common and obvious interpretation of this sentence then it is false. See my response to BillHoyt.

II: "Just a flesh wound."
[Headbutts BH in the chest]

BH: "Look, stop that."

II:" Chicken! Chicken!"

BH: "Look, I'll have your leg. Right!"
[whack]

II: "Right, I'll do you for that!"

BH: "You'll what?"

II: "Come 'ere!"

BH: "What are you going to do, bleed on me?"
 

The problem is, all those people / sockpuppets are trolls. And you, Sir, are the worst of them!


You obviously don't understand the definition of "troll" in the context we use here. A troll is simply someone that wants to stir up trouble and cares not about the topic at all. Tai Chi is one of those, he's simply argumentative to be argumentative. It doesn't matter what the topic is, Tai Chi will always be arguing against the skeptics.

Why won't any cold reader actually take Dr S up on his challenge?

Because his challenge is rigged so that Dr S can only win. This has been explained several times.

It must be a cinch to tap such supposedly leaky controls and protocols, Shirley?

Not if when the challenge is rigged.

What, in heaven's name, are they afraid of?

Nothing. Skeptics just aren't foolish enough to go into Dr S's rigged challenge. If Dr S really had evidence of afterlife and mediums, he'd have his studies published for peer review and they would withstand the scrutiny of the scientific community.

Uh, he's the scientist.

Yes, but Schwartz also want's complete control of the results and data from the results as well. It's easy to challenge skeptics to such an experiment if you control all aspects of the experiment, including the results. Sorry, but true scientists don't control the results, they only observe them. True scientists don't keep their experiments secret from the rest of the community while declaring success.
 
BillHoyt said:
No True Scotsman maneuver. Pathetic. It is, of course, ironic that, in the midst of debating fraud in parapsychology, you should continually commit intellectual fraud.

I commited no intellectual fraud, no informal logical fallacies. You however continually commit them and continually demonstrate your lack of ability to understand what others are saying. The latest example here being what Irwin said. :rolleyes:

But you see, Ian, you expressed surprise that any fraud had happened at Rhine's laboratory.

No, no surprise at all. I would be slightly surprised if the Rhines themselves had committed fraud, but certainly not amazed. Fraud happens. It's human nature that some people will commit fraud where there is financial reward, prestige to be obtained etc.

You didn't reply to me with this time qualifier. You simply never read what you cut and pasted here. Your own post. Your own cut & paste. Your own egg. [/B]

Any person who has studied parapsychology in depth would understand the statement as I took it to mean. It is commonly understood that the work done at Rhine's lab is a shorthand way of referring to Rhine's pioneering work. Quit the semantic games.

Now do you concede that I did not make a gaffe??
 
thaiboxerken said:

A troll is simply someone that wants to stir up trouble and cares not about the topic at all. Tai Chi is one of those, he's simply argumentative to be argumentative. It doesn't matter what the topic is, Tai Chi will always be arguing against the skeptics.


I've agreed and continue to agree with some of the skeptics here on many issues. I also do care about the topics I post on. That should be obvious to anyone who reads my posts.

I also state if I disagree with some skeptics, which I do on several issues. For example, when you claimed 'there is no god and that is a fact', I called you on it (and you floundered). Don't expect your claims to go unchallenged because you call yourself a skeptic.

As just a few of many counterexamples to your claim of "It doesn't matter what the topic is, Tai Chi will always be arguing against the skeptics.":

Recently Girl6 brought up the issue of the skeptical community reaching out more to women and minorities. I didn't disagree with this, but agreed and offered my suggestions and comments on it.

Several months ago in threads on Yellow Bamboo I agreed with basically everything each skeptic said in the thread!

You do yourself a disservice Ken when you make sweeping claims like you did above. In short, you remember the "misses" and forget the "hits".
 
Interesting Ian said:
In the more common and obvious interpretation of this sentence then it is false. See my response to BillHoyt.

OK, then: You claim that there was no history of fraud going back to Rhine's laboratory. Yet, your own post clearly said so.

Nice going.
nut.gif
 
CFLarsen said:


OK, then: You claim that there was no history of fraud going back to Rhine's laboratory. Yet, your own post clearly said so.

Nice going.
nut.gif

Please desist with the semantic games and confess that I didn't make a gaffe.
 
Interesting Ian said:
Please desist with the semantic games and confess that I didn't make a gaffe.

No semantic games whatsoever. What I wrote was very clear, and in accordance to what you posted.

There is nothing for me to "confess".

Let's recap that again:

You claim that there was no history of fraud going back to Rhine's laboratory. Yet, your own post clearly said so.

And you want people to think this is a "semantic game". Incredible.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom