T'ai Chi said:
Well certainly people can have opinions on something, but don't expect your opinions to be taken too seriously if you are a cold-reading skeptic who keeps claiming that it is so easy or so flawed, but yet doesn't want to 'sit in the chair'.
[/B]
Frankly, I have a hard time taking
that opinion seriously. Do you actually hold that opinion, or are you just throwing out stuff to provoke responses?
Banachek did some absolutely amazing mentalism at the meeting. I am a hobbyist and have followed magic for more than 15 years now. I have numerous books, belong to 2 magic organziations, have done shows for money. I don't suck at it.
I will tell you now that not only can I not emulate one of the effects from the meeting; I still have no idea how it was done. He did it that well. By your reasoning, since I cannot emulate his performance to the same level, he obviously has spooky magic powers.
Similarly, Jamy Ian Swiss sis an ambitious card routine during the evening. I know several routines for that. While I have not put together a routine, I am familiar with the sleights involved. Even when I cannot see what happened, I can usually reconstruct it.
He either had a move that I have never come across, or did an old move so well that I could not catch him at it, even knowing what to look for. Since I cannot perform his routine, he obviously has been possessed by the devil.
And, while we're at it, why do I suspect that even
if someone managed to overcome the problems with trying to follow Schwartz' protocals precisely -- problems noted by Garrette and Marc/Dogwood previosuly, among others -- you'd be one of the first in line saying "Just because it can be done with non-paranormal means doesn't mean that the psychics tested don't have real powers"?
And you know something -- it wouldn't. Any number of magicians bending spoons doesn't actually prove anything conclusive about Geller; any number of successful cold readers don't actually prove anything conclusive about any alleged mediums.
I guess -- since any 'proof' of the negative proposition put forward by the skeptics can be immediately dismissed as non-conclusive -- that its a good thing that
the burden of proof remains firmly on the claimant to show that paranormal events or powers exist.
Schwartz' burden. JE's burden. Your burden. Not mine.