Cold Reading Demos at TAM2

Interesting Ian said:
He then goes on to say:

"Be this as it may, there is sound phenomenological
evidence of parapsychological experiences and experimental evidence of anomalous
events too, and to this extent behavioral scientists ethically are obliged to
encourage the investigation of these phenomena rather than dismissing them out
of hand."

Why did you neglect to mention this Billy?
You persist in this red herring. I introduced Irwin as a hostile witness. The issue here is not Irwin's belief in the paranormal. The issue here is to address your claims about fraud in parapsychology. I introduced a skeptic on the topic of fraud and introduced a PoMo paraparapsychologist, both of whom steadfastly agree that parapsychology's reputation has been greatly sullied to the present day by both direct researcher fraud and by deceptive subjects who have tricked naive researchers. Please focus on this issue and desist from this red herring.
 
BillHoyt said:
Originally posted by Interesting Ian
An important question here is do non-skeptics agree with him?

Billy
This paper was reviewed by parapsychologists. The job of a reviewer, one would hope even in this sullied field,

Sullied? In what way is it sullied? I've just been quoting extensively from your link to Irwin's chapter who argues that this is most defintely not true. Why are you lying BillHoyt?

is to call out unreasonable and unfounded assertions. It was written by Hansen, who worked in parapsychology labs for eight years.

To be specific then, are you asserting that these parapsychologists agree that the parapsychological research of interest (and what parapsychological research are we discussing here incidentally?) was amenable to cheating in many ways? Which parapsychologists were these?

II
Prominant parapsychologists actually want to involve known tricksters? So why do they want to do this Billy? I'm not denying that they may want to, I'm just wondering why they want to. I could email them to ask them, but unfortunately you've neglected to mention their names. Could you rectify this error?

Thank you.

BillHoyt
Well, you could easily have dug this up yourself, had you read the article and followed its trail of references. Be that as it may:
"The early Society for Psychical Research (SPR) instituted a policy of refusing to work with psychics and mediums who were known to have engaged in deceptive activity.

And so they should.

Recently, Inglis (1984) has vehemently and
bitterly denounced that policy, and a number of people seem to agree with him (e.g., Braude, 1986; Gregory, 1982). Several leaders of the field seem to agree.

OK I admit I'm perplexed. Obviously I would need to read their justification for such a strange stance. Where are you getting this information from? Do you have any link to any of these people justifying their position here?

Right, so you're saying they want to use tricksters in order to get positive results? WOW!! that's quite an accusation Billy! Does Hansen himself also believe this? Hmmmm . .why not just directly covertly manipulate the results rather than shouting to the world they intend to manipulate the results?? Come on Billy bean, give me their names.


I cleaved close to the facts, and would thank you to do the same. I could only speculate as to the motives behind advocating the continued use of known frauds. I have not engaged here in such speculation.

I got the impression that this is what you were saying. But anyway, it seems that neither of us know why these people should want to use known frauds. I tend to agree with you that it seems bad. But surely it is incumbent on us to read the reasons before outright condemning? I admit though that it is difficult to see how they could justify theiur stance here. But still . . .

So H.J. Irwin is anti-skeptical and a pro-postmodernist? Can you substantiate this? I honestly don't know if he is or not. Hmmmm . . pity dharlow isn't around. He'd know.

Yeah, it's an unfortunate fact of life that some people will try to fraudulently manipulate data whatever area of science we're talking about. This is why parapsychology employs tighter experimental protocols than in any other area of science.

BillHoyt

Okay, so you read neither the Hansen article nor the Irwin chapter.

Ummm . . . well I hadn't then, but obviously I have now since I've been quoting loads of it!

BillHoyt
Chapter 17 (and thank you for providing the unmangled link, btw) includes passages such as this:
"In any event, a more extensive accommodation of ÒfeminineÓ values in general science, as advocated by feminists, may provide a context in which a greater variety of parapsychological studies are received as scientically legitimate. The feminization of science would in part entail the implementation of a pluralistic approach (White, 1992), that is, a recognition of the value of many different research paradigms and a rejection of the view that the laboratory experiment is the epitome of the scientiic method. White (1991, 1994) hasurged parapsychologists to join in the process of transforming contemporary science to this end. Thus parapsychology could be the first point of implementation of a significant revolution in the philosophy of science."

This was, by the way, the paragraph immediately preceding the one I quoted before. For those who don't recognize the PoMo jargon here, Irwin is wrapping up a discussion about abandoning science

He does no such thing! He's saying lab based science may not always be appropriate depending on what one is studying.

But anyway, I was more interested in your denial that he is not a skeptic. Can you justify this assertion?
 
Re: Re: OK this is very interesting

BillHoyt said:

I introduced Irwin as a hostile witness. I am aware Irwin thinks there is something real about the paranormal.

Where has he stated this?
 
BillHoyt said:
Originally posted by Interesting Ian
He then goes on to say:

"Be this as it may, there is sound phenomenological
evidence of parapsychological experiences and experimental evidence of anomalous
events too, and to this extent behavioral scientists ethically are obliged to
encourage the investigation of these phenomena rather than dismissing them out
of hand."

Why did you neglect to mention this Billy?

BillHoyt
You persist in this red herring. I introduced Irwin as a hostile witness. The issue here is not Irwin's belief in the paranormal.

We have yet to establish that he does believe in the paranormal. Irwin above is simply stating cold facts. The fact there is sound evidence of anomlous events does not entail that there are in fact anomalous events.

The issue here is to address your claims about fraud in parapsychology.

I do not recall making any claims which are inconsistent with Irwin's. Perhaps you would be so good as to remind me? :rolleyes:


I introduced a skeptic on the topic of fraud and introduced a PoMo paraparapsychologist, both of whom steadfastly agree that parapsychology's reputation has been greatly sullied to the present day by both direct researcher fraud and by deceptive subjects who have tricked naive researchers.

Where does he state that parapsychology's reputation has been greatly sullied? I've read the whole chapter and nowhere does he state this. Indeed, on the contrary, he denies this!
 
Re: Re: Re: OK this is very interesting

Interesting Ian said:
Where has he stated this?
I cannot tell if I am the referrent here or Irwin. Either way, I can tell that you're not paying attention. I leave it to the readers to determine whether a disingenuous approach to the subject matter is the motivation.

Here is how I introduced the first Irwin passage:
"This time, we will hear from a decidedly non-skeptical author. In this otherwise pro-postmodernist, anti-skeptical [chapter], we find the author beginning his concluding paragraph with this startling admission:"
I corrected the previous word omission in the above.

Here is my aper[,c]u immediately following the quoted passage:

"So as of 1999, this parapsychologist continues to describe both hoaxsters being investigated by parapsychologists as if the hoaxes are real and directly fraudulent manipulation of the data by the researchers themselves."
 
Re: Re: Re: Re: OK this is very interesting

BillHoyt said:
Originally posted by Interesting Ian
Where has he stated this?


I cannot tell if I am the referrent here or Irwin.

It's very simple. I'm asking where Irwin states he believes in some aspects of the paranormal?

Either way, I can tell that you're not paying attention.

I have been paying attention. You have not substantiated your assertion that Irwin believes in the paranormal.


Here is how I introduced the first Irwin passage:
"This time, we will hear from a decidedly non-skeptical author. In this otherwise pro-postmodernist, anti-skeptical [chapter], we find the author beginning his concluding paragraph with this startling admission:"
I corrected the previous word omission in the above.

Here is my aper[,c]u immediately following the quoted passage:

"So as of 1999, this parapsychologist continues to describe both hoaxsters being investigated by parapsychologists as if the hoaxes are real and directly fraudulent manipulation of the data by the researchers themselves."TE]

Sorry, this sentence does not scan ie it's gobbledegook. And what has it got to do with you substantiating your assertion that Irwin is a believer in the paranormal??
 
Interesting Ian said:
Sullied? In what way is it sullied? I've just been quoting extensively from your link to Irwin's chapter who argues that this is most defintely not true. Why are you lying BillHoyt?
Why are you incapable of seeing what is there in plain text? Yes he says the reputation is sullied:
Perhaps the ultimate survival of parapsychological research will rest on the demise of parapsychology as a discipline. Stevenson (1988) has questioned parapsychologists' continued determination to represent their research activities as a separate field of study... For example, students with an interest in parapsychological topics would be advised to undertake graduate training in an orthodox field rather than by way of a specialist doctoral program in parapsychology. Having become established vocationally as a mainstream research scientist, the individual could then judiciously apply his or her research expertise to parapsychological issues.
See also the pages leading up to this sad, sad suggestion. Irwin blames a number of factors, not the least amongst them the history of fraud going back to Rhine's laboratory. Of course, Irwin takes pot-shots at skeptics including Randi, but still ends up here. Suggesting the research efforts might only be salvaged by cleansing students through real research education programs. Lest you miss it, he also makes specific mention of the improved research skills they would acquire by not being trained in parapsychology programs. In this, he echoes Hansen's criticisms about the quality of parapsychology teaching programs.
To be specific then, are you asserting that these parapsychologists agree that the parapsychological research of interest (and what parapsychological research are we discussing here incidentally?) was amenable to cheating in many ways? Which parapsychologists were these?
I'm not doing your homework for you any more, Ian. I have now pointed you to specific passages in two papers and one textbook chapter. You continue to evince you have not read them properly. If you read the citations and follow through to the other papers cited, you will see the answer to your question is yes.
I got the impression that this is what you were saying. But anyway, it seems that neither of us know why these people should want to use known frauds. I tend to agree with you that it seems bad. But surely it is incumbent on us to read the reasons before outright condemning? I admit though that it is difficult to see how they could justify theiur stance here. But still . . .
Spin some hypotheses here, Ian. Read the paper first, though.
Ummm . . . well I hadn't then, but obviously I have now since I've been quoting loads of it!
We've had ample examples of posters here at JREF who quote and then demonstrate they hadn't a clue what it was they had quoted. Ample examples of those who cherry-pick the quotes. Case in point:
He does no such thing! He's saying lab based science may not always be appropriate depending on what one is studying.

But anyway, I was more interested in your denial that he is not a skeptic. Can you justify this assertion?
Read the chapter, Ian. The section immediately follows the sad passage I quoted above. Irwin launches into a lengthy, postmodernist / feminist dissertation on the entire framework of science might need to be abandoned.
 
CFLarsen said:

I leave it up to you to again not refer to your user ID, then.


You should get a degree in math because you sure do like tangents.


And? You have no opinion of it?


That is irrelevant as I am talking about what Schwartz himself said, not what I think of him. I'm sure though if I posted my opinion you'd have said 'what, and we're just supposed to accept your opinion?' :D

Again, tangent.


Often, the "yes/no" questions are so vague and cover such a wide area that it would be very difficult not to answer "yes".

That is not a true binary test. That is rigging the results.


So Schwartz did use yes/no questions then? Yes or no?


Yes, it is. You can simply read the various walk-throughs of transcripts here. And here. And here.


A reading and analyzing of transcripts is relatively simple. A skeptic or coldreader actually sitting in the chair themselves and practicing what they preach and fooling people might take some more effort..


However, Schwartz is the one making the claim, so he must provide positive evidence. You know that.


Skeptics and coldreaders who make the claim of flawed research and it being easy to do in Schwartz setting are making a claim too. They must provide evidence, you know that. You yourself have said that "Yes, it is." Well, prove it, contact Schwartz and take the same tests as the claimed mediums did.



I can't imagine how you believe the above link to be relevant. BillHoyt posted a link (http://www.tricksterbook.com/ArticlesOnline/DeceptionBySubjects.html) to a paper of examples of skeptics pretending they are psychic or examples of deliberate fraud in parapsychological research, like in a lab setting. I'm looking for more recent examples of things of that nature as all of the examples were from the 1980's.
 
BillHoyt said:

Since you imply that things have changed since the 80s, let us move forward into the 90s.


Uh no I am simply asking you for evidence. I am not implying anything.


So, as of 1992, some prominent parapsychologists vocally promote research with known, fradulent subjects. Not simply being tricked by tricksters, mind you, but utterly ignoring the fact they have already been detected as frauds, and promoting their continued use in research. More pointedly, these deluded researchers were training, as of 1992, the next generation of researchers. So let's move forward some years and see if things have changed.


Specific examples...?


“In the final analysis what fairly can be said of parapsychology? As far as spontaneous cases are concerned it seems likely that there are numerous instances ofself-deception, delusion, and even fraud. Some of the empirical literature like-wise might be attributable to shoddy experimental procedures and to fraudulent manipulation of data.”


Specific examples...?
 
Mercutio said:
Hoyt, the link in your last post does not work for me. If I can't find it by googling, can you fix your link or PM me the site?

Merc, remove the "%20" from the address and it works great. :)
 
T'ai Chi said:


Well certainly people can have opinions on something, but don't expect your opinions to be taken too seriously if you are a cold-reading skeptic who keeps claiming that it is so easy or so flawed, but yet doesn't want to 'sit in the chair'.
[/B]

Frankly, I have a hard time taking that opinion seriously. Do you actually hold that opinion, or are you just throwing out stuff to provoke responses?

Banachek did some absolutely amazing mentalism at the meeting. I am a hobbyist and have followed magic for more than 15 years now. I have numerous books, belong to 2 magic organziations, have done shows for money. I don't suck at it.

I will tell you now that not only can I not emulate one of the effects from the meeting; I still have no idea how it was done. He did it that well. By your reasoning, since I cannot emulate his performance to the same level, he obviously has spooky magic powers.

Similarly, Jamy Ian Swiss sis an ambitious card routine during the evening. I know several routines for that. While I have not put together a routine, I am familiar with the sleights involved. Even when I cannot see what happened, I can usually reconstruct it.

He either had a move that I have never come across, or did an old move so well that I could not catch him at it, even knowing what to look for. Since I cannot perform his routine, he obviously has been possessed by the devil.

And, while we're at it, why do I suspect that even if someone managed to overcome the problems with trying to follow Schwartz' protocals precisely -- problems noted by Garrette and Marc/Dogwood previosuly, among others -- you'd be one of the first in line saying "Just because it can be done with non-paranormal means doesn't mean that the psychics tested don't have real powers"?

And you know something -- it wouldn't. Any number of magicians bending spoons doesn't actually prove anything conclusive about Geller; any number of successful cold readers don't actually prove anything conclusive about any alleged mediums.

I guess -- since any 'proof' of the negative proposition put forward by the skeptics can be immediately dismissed as non-conclusive -- that its a good thing that the burden of proof remains firmly on the claimant to show that paranormal events or powers exist.

Schwartz' burden. JE's burden. Your burden. Not mine.
 
T'ai Chi said:
You should get a degree in math because you sure do like tangents.

You sure "forget" easily. Let's recap:

BillHoyt said:
Are you kidding?

To which you replied:

T'ai Chi said:
No, I'm T'ai Chi. ;)

Tell me again: Who likes tangents?

T'ai Chi said:
That is irrelevant as I am talking about what Schwartz himself said, not what I think of him. I'm sure though if I posted my opinion you'd have said 'what, and we're just supposed to accept your opinion?' :D

It may be irrelevant to you, but I am asking you anyway: What do you think of what he said?

T'ai Chi said:
Again, tangent.

Hardly. Merely posting quotes without any comment is not a very productive way of debating. But if all you can do is repost the words of others, with no opinion of your own, gee....just say so.

T'ai Chi said:
So Schwartz did use yes/no questions then? Yes or no?

He used them in a way that would make his experiment a success. That is not a true binary test. In a binary test, the questions must give an unambiguous choice: A clear yes or no. Asking "Do you understand that", and getting a "yes" is not the same as asking a binary question about a specific subject that can be answered with a clear yes or no.

Have you read the pages in Schwartz' book I referred to?

T'ai Chi said:
A reading and analyzing of transcripts is relatively simple. A skeptic or coldreader actually sitting in the chair themselves and practicing what they preach and fooling people might take some more effort..

Perhaps. You are not addressing the issue: Did you read the transcripts and the analyses?

T'ai Chi said:
Skeptics and coldreaders who make the claim of flawed research and it being easy to do in Schwartz setting are making a claim too. They must provide evidence, you know that. You yourself have said that "Yes, it is." Well, prove it, contact Schwartz and take the same tests as the claimed mediums did.

I refer you to Marc Berard's excellent review of Schwartz' book.

T'ai Chi said:
I can't imagine how you believe the above link to be relevant. BillHoyt posted a link (http://www.tricksterbook.com/ArticlesOnline/DeceptionBySubjects.html) to a paper of examples of skeptics pretending they are psychic or examples of deliberate fraud in parapsychological research, like in a lab setting. I'm looking for more recent examples of things of that nature as all of the examples were from the 1980's.

Which you got, you just brush it aside and claim it is irrelevant.

Do you think you are fooling anyone here? You really think people can't spot this pattern of yours?

Let's do another recap:

  • What do you think of what Schwartz said?
  • Have you read the transcripts and analyses I linked to?
  • Have you read the pages I referred to in Schwartz' book?
  • Have you read the book at all?
  • Have you read Marc Berard's analysis of Schwartz' book?
 
BillHoyt said:
quote:Originally posted by Interesting Ian
Sullied? In what way is it sullied? I've just been quoting extensively from your link to Irwin's chapter who argues that this is most defintely not true. Why are you lying BillHoyt?

BillHoyt
Why are you incapable of seeing what is there in plain text? Yes he says the reputation is sullied:

Where??

Irwin
Perhaps the ultimate survival of parapsychological research will rest on the demise of parapsychology as a discipline. Stevenson (1988) has questioned parapsychologists' continued determination to represent their research activities as a separate field of study... For example, students with an interest in parapsychological topics would be advised to undertake graduate training in an orthodox field rather than by way of a specialist doctoral program in parapsychology. Having become established vocationally as a mainstream research scientist, the individual could then judiciously apply his or her research expertise to parapsychological issues.

In not the remotest sense does this imply he thinks parapsychological research is sullied. And for those who think that it seems to imply Irwin thinks it is sullied, I advise you to read the stuff before this quote. In particular Irwin states "In view of the reactions of certain inßuential members of the scientiÞc
community it might be asked why anyone would persist in their eÝorts toward
parapsychologyÕs acceptance as a legitimate area for scientiÞc inquiry".
And he makes it entirely clear that such reactions have no rational justification.

See also the pages leading up to this sad, sad suggestion.

It is indeed a sad suggestion, but arguably a necessary one as skeptics unfortunately wield a lot of power.

Irwin blames a number of factors, not the least amongst them the history of fraud going back to Rhine's laboratory.

No he doesn't. He blames the irrational prejudices of skeptics and the unfortunate fact they wield a lot of influence.

Ian
I got the impression that this is what you were saying. But anyway, it seems that neither of us know why these people should want to use known frauds. I tend to agree with you that it seems bad. But surely it is incumbent on us to read the reasons before outright condemning? I admit though that it is difficult to see how they could justify theiur stance here. But still . . .

BillHoyt
Spin some hypotheses here, Ian. Read the paper first, though.

What paper? You have a paper of parapsychologists specifying why they should use subjects who have previously cheated? Excellent! Links please.

Ian
But anyway, I was more interested in your denial that he is not a skeptic. Can you justify this assertion?

BillHoyt
Read the chapter, Ian.

I have. Nowhere does he state or imply he is a believer. He might well be, but where's the evidence??

The section immediately follows the sad passage I quoted above. Irwin launches into a lengthy, postmodernist / feminist dissertation on the entire framework of science might need to be abandoned.

So what? Thius certainly need not imply he believes. He's simply suggesting a method which might be more conducive to good results should such phenomena exist.
 
BillHoyt said:
Irwin blames a number of factors, not the least amongst them the history of fraud going back to Rhine's laboratory.

Missed this before. You're alleging there was fraud associated with the research undertook by the Rhines?? :eek:
 
T'ai Chi said:
Uh no I am simply asking you for evidence. I am not implying anything.
My mistake. You're right. You didn't imply anything. You asserted it as the consequent of the antecedent, "If there are no more recent examples."

Y'ou:

Is there anything more recent than from the 1980's?!

If not, that would tell me that paraspychology experiments and methods are indeed improving! Or that magicians etc. are getting worse.

Specific examples...?
Already given earlier. Several of them.

Specific examples...? [/B]
Irwin provided several. Read the online chapters. Buy the book. Or don't. Actually bothering with real scholarship might interfere with your tr'olling game. Can't have that, can we?
 
Interesting Ian said:


Missed this before. You're alleging there was fraud associated with the research undertook by the Rhines?? :eek:

Read your own post, dated today, at 10:47.

:dl:

And tell us again how you've read everything. It is crystal clear you don't read what YOU write!

Get off the computer superhighway before you get pulled over for posting while intoxicated.
 
Claus,

Could you do me (and others who will be fascinated by what has been revealed here) a favor? Can you capture this whole thread so we have a permanent record of Ian's persistent claims of having read and understood everything? Only to be followed by that outlandish gaffe? I'm sure he'd rather be in a position to deny he didn't read his own d***ed post.

Meanwhile, I'm off to get some wee heavy. I'm done with Troll and Tr'oll Lite.
 
BillHoyt said:


Read your own post, dated today, at 10:47.

:dl:

And tell us again how you've read everything. It is not crystal clear you don't read what YOU write!

Get off the computer superhighway before you get pulled over for posting while intoxicated.

I didn't post anything at 10.47pm. That was only 5 mins ago and I was playing the demo of "Far Cry". Certainly I have not said or implied that the Rhines were implicated in fraud. Again you lie.

I again ask you the question, since you've so far ignored it. Are you alleging there was fraud associated with the research undertook by the Rhines?? :eek:
 
Interesting Ian said:


I didn't post anything at 10.47pm. That was only 5 mins ago and I was playing the demo of "Far Cry". Certainly I have not said or implied that the Rhines were implicated in fraud. Again you lie.

I again ask you the question, since you've so far ignored it. Are you alleging there was fraud associated with the research undertook by the Rhines?? :eek:

Nincompoop! I am not in your time zone. I did not say p.m.

:dl:
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom