Cold Reading Demos at TAM2

Claus,

My request to capture and archive this was a bit premature. The hilarity is NOT over!

:dl:
 
BillHoyt said:
Claus,

Could you do me (and others who will be fascinated by what has been revealed here) a favor? Can you capture this whole thread so we have a permanent record of Ian's persistent claims of having read and understood everything? Only to be followed by that outlandish gaffe? I'm sure he'd rather be in a position to deny he didn't read his own d***ed post.

Meanwhile, I'm off to get some wee heavy. I'm done with Troll and Tr'oll Lite.

I regularly take full backups of this forum. Devastatingly so. Those who think they can sink into oblivion are sadly mistaken.

I record it all.
 
CFLarsen said:


I regularly take full backups of this forum. Devastatingly so. Those who think they can sink into oblivion are sadly mistaken.

I record it all.

That's fine. Many people accuse me of gaffes. Not one has ever been substantiated. I await patiently for BillHoyt to point to anywhere where I have been inconsistent in the remotest manner in this thread (or indeed any other thread).

His failure to do so will speak volumes.
 
Interesting Ian said:


That's fine. Many people accuse me of gaffes. Not one has ever been substantiated. I await patiently for BillHoyt to point to anywhere where I have been inconsistent in the remotest manner in this thread (or indeed any other thread).

His failure to do so will speak volumes.
If some boy scout wants to earn a merit badge here, please help this old lady across the street. Be sure to point out her post, and explain carefully who Levy was, what he did, and what it had to do with the Rhine lab. You may need to shout, she's hard of hearing.

I'm about to take off to have a few wee heavy with one of the finest dancers at the club. We both have the night off, and I don't want to be late...
 
Interesting Ian said:
That's fine. Many people accuse me of gaffes. Not one has ever been substantiated. I await patiently for BillHoyt to point to anywhere where I have been inconsistent in the remotest manner in this thread (or indeed any other thread).

His failure to do so will speak volumes.

Excuse me, Ian...but are you saying that you have never made a mistake here? A "gaffe" usually means "mistake".

Just yes or no.
 
CFLarsen said:


Excuse me, Ian...but are you saying that you have never made a mistake here? A "gaffe" usually means "mistake".

Just yes or no.

I imagine I probably have, although I cannot recall doing so. I certainly have made no mistakes in this thread so far as I am able to discern.
 
Interesting Ian said:
I imagine I probably have, although I cannot recall doing so. I certainly have made no mistakes in this thread so far as I am able to discern.

If you are not aware of what you have answered, how can you possibly say that you have not?

Please, do not make the mistake of back-pedalling. That would render you as a complete hypocrite.
 
CFLarsen said:


If you are not aware of what you have answered, how can you possibly say that you have not?

Please, do not make the mistake of back-pedalling. That would render you as a complete hypocrite.

Where have I stated that I am not aware of my answers in this thread?

If I have made any mistakes in this thread then be so good as to point them out. Failure to do so will confirm my suspicion that you cannot find any.
 
Interesting Ian said:
Many people accuse me of gaffes. Not one has ever been substantiated.

Interesting Ian said:
I imagine I probably have, although I cannot recall doing so.

You make the claim, you provide the evidence.

Please provide the evidence that your "gaffes" have never "ever" been substantiated.

"Ever" means not just this thread. It means "ever".

Do not play word games with me, Ian. You will lose.
 
CFLarsen said:
You make the claim, you provide the evidence.

Please provide the evidence that your "gaffes" have never "ever" been substantiated.

Don't be so absurd! :eek: The evidence consists in the fact that no-one is able to show any gaffes on my part. This is highly suggestful that such gaffes do not exist.

But this is not surprising. I'm not a politician you know ;)

"Ever" means not just this thread. It means "ever".

Do not play word games with me, Ian. You will lose. [/B]

What evidence do you have to suppose this?
 
CFLarsen said:

You sure "forget" easily. Let's recap:


Tangent. Let's not.


It may be irrelevant to you, but I am asking you anyway: What do you think of what he said?


Irrelevant. I am only interested in the facts here, not opinions, not yours, mine, Schwartz's or Randi's.


Perhaps. You are not addressing the issue: Did you read the transcripts and the analyses?


Yes, and you're not addressing the issue of:

A reading and analyzing of transcripts is relatively simple (and doesn't prove anything much). A skeptic or coldreader actually sitting in the chair themselves and practicing what they preach and fooling people might take some more effort and prove more.


Which you got, you just brush it aside and claim it is irrelevant.


Whatever. I'll post it again since you ignored it:

I can't imagine how you believe the above link to be relevant. BillHoyt posted a link to a paper of examples of skeptics pretending they are psychic or examples of deliberate fraud in parapsychological research, like in a lab setting. I'm looking for more recent examples of things of that nature as all of the examples were from the 1980's.

Your example of astrology has nothing to do with anything of what I asked for.


Do you think you are fooling anyone here? You really think people can't spot this pattern of yours?


I'm not interested in playing in the mud with you and Bill. All I've asked for is specific examples of skeptics fooling people in the laboratory or deliberate fraud in the laboratory more recent than the 1980's.


Let's do another recap:


Tangent. I continue to fail to be intimidated by your lists.
 
Interesting Ian said:
Don't be so absurd! :eek: The evidence consists in the fact that no-one is able to show any gaffes on my part. This is highly suggestful that such gaffes do not exist.

I am not asking for suggestions, I am asking for evidence. Can you provide it or not?

Just yes or no. Please.

Interesting Ian said:
But this is not surprising. I'm not a politician you know ;)

Yes, we know. Just provide your evidence that you have ever "gaffed".

Interesting Ian said:
What evidence do you have to suppose this?

Nice try, but no cigar. Please provide positive evidence. Don't ask for others to provide negative evidence.

T'ai Chi said:
Tangent. Let's not.

If you do not want to discuss this, then do not bring it up.

T'ai Chi said:
Irrelevant. I am only interested in the facts here, not opinions, not yours, mine, Schwartz's or Randi's.

If you are not interested in anything else but facts, why do you bring up the opinions of Schwartz?

T'ai Chi said:

Fine. What do you think of it?

T'ai Chi said:
and you're not addressing the issue of:

Let's wait until we have heard what you think of it.

T'ai Chi said:
A reading and analyzing of transcripts is relatively simple (and doesn't prove anything much). A skeptic or coldreader actually sitting in the chair themselves and practicing what they preach and fooling people might take some more effort and prove more.

Fine. Whatever. Let's wait until we have heard what you think of the analyses.

T'ai Chi said:
Whatever. I'll post it again since you ignored it:

No, I did not "ignore" it. I merely pointed out that you are not willing to debate issues.

T'ai Chi said:
I can't imagine how you believe the above link to be relevant. BillHoyt posted a link to a paper of examples of skeptics pretending they are psychic or examples of deliberate fraud in parapsychological research, like in a lab setting. I'm looking for more recent examples of things of that nature as all of the examples were from the 1980's.

Your example of astrology has nothing to do with anything of what I asked for.

What is your critera then? Please be specific.

T'ai Chi said:
I'm not interested in playing in the mud with you and Bill. All I've asked for is specific examples of skeptics fooling people in the laboratory or deliberate fraud in the laboratory more recent than the 1980's.

You got that. You brushed it off. Your problem, not anyone elses.

T'ai Chi said:
Tangent. I continue to fail to be intimidated by your lists.

You continue to be unable to answer them.

Very well, then:

  • You post opinions of Schwartz's. You have no opinion of them.
  • You have not read the analyses I presented. You asked for them, you refused to even read them.
  • You have not read the pages from Schwartz' book. You asked for evidence, you refused to read it.
  • You have not read Schwartz' book at all.
  • You have not read Marc Berard's analysis at all.
Just tell me this: How do you suppose that anyone take you seriously? You ask for evidence, you freely admit that you cannot be bothered to read it.

T'ai Chi said:
Hint: When you can't provide evidence, attacking the person does not work.

You got that right. Now, could you please address some issues?
 
BillHoyt said:


Nincompoop! I am not in your time zone. I did not say p.m.

:dl:

Well it certainly wasn't am because I was in bed between the hours of 5am and 1pm.

Would you care to specify where you believe I have contradicted myself or not?
 
NoZed Avenger said:

I will tell you now that not only can I not emulate one of the effects from the meeting; I still have no idea how it was done. He did it that well. By your reasoning, since I cannot emulate his performance to the same level, he obviously has spooky magic powers.


No, I'm not saying that since you can't emuate his performance that therefore he has real powers. I am saying that if he is being studied in an experiment and you are saying the experiment is so flawed that it is easy to fool the experimenters, yet you can only analyze the transcripts but not actually participate in said experiment or similar experiment and fool people yourself, nor is any other cold reader stepping up to bat, that that is a somewhat funny stance of you or the cold readers to take. I am not saying that therefore the mediums are the real deal, just that the criticism is somewhat amusing.


Schwartz' burden. JE's burden. Your burden. Not mine.

It depends on the claim. If Schwartz claims a medium is the real deal, it is on him. If the claim is that his experiments are flawed enough to where cold readers are claiming they can easily fool the experimenters, it is on them.
 

. I am not saying that therefore the mediums are the real deal, just that the criticism is somewhat amusing.


Do you find it foolish to point out flaws in an experiment and challenge? You find it foolish to show that Schwartz is already cheating to make it impossible for his "mediums" to lose out to any cold-readers?


It depends on the claim. If Schwartz claims a medium is the real deal, it is on him. If the claim is that his experiments are flawed enough to where cold readers are claiming they can easily fool the experimenters, it is on them.


False, Schwartz is making the claim that cold-readers can't do what his "real" mediums can. The burden is upon Schwartz because he is making 2 claims here.

1. That his mediums are real.

2. Cold readers can't do what his "real" mediums can.

Also, Schwartz seems to want to have complete control of his experiment, that data of the experiment and the rights to publish results. Sorry, but that doesn't sit well with skeptics and science. Schwartz is already seeding his challenge for him to win.


What's really amusing here is that you don't see Schwartz' challenge for what it really is. It's just a stunt for him to gain publicity and his vain attempt to discredit any skepticism.

If Schwartz had some real science, he'd be providing raw data and results of his experiments for scientific review.
 
T'ai Chi said:
It depends on the claim. If Schwartz claims a medium is the real deal, it is on him. If the claim is that his experiments are flawed enough to where cold readers are claiming they can easily fool the experimenters, it is on them.
The burden, as has been told to you so many times, is on the claimant. The cold readers did not originate a claim. The cold readers responded to a claim. Moreover, the cold readers operate with the current evidence on their side. The psi guys operate against the evidence of all known science.

It is remarkable that you fail to grasp the idea of burden of proof. If you are the dork that claims you have a talking wombat, it is up to you to demonstrate that. If I then respond that no, you don't have a talking wombat, you still must demonstrate that you do. Why? Because you created the claim. Because there are no known talking wombats, and you are swimming uphill against the evidence.
 
Originally posted by BillHoyt:

Garrette,

For the record, what was the date of your e-mail to Schwartz?

Earlier I said I had sent it on 2 December. Rechecking this morning, I find it was actually 3 December.

I also found a potential mistake in the address, so there may be no actual delay on Schwartz's part.

I sent the first e-mail to using an address that spells his full last name. In relooking at the address I was provided by Steve, I should have left off the "z".

To rectify and be sure, I resent the e-mail this morning (25 January where I am; still 24 January EST) to both addresses.
 
Originally posted by Thaiboxerken:

Also, Schwartz seems to want to have complete control of his experiment, that data of the experiment and the rights to publish results.

I have no problem with Schwartz wanting complete control of the experiment itself. He should have it. In the case of my offer to replicate JE's results, he must, however, agree to the same protocols, including the same flaws and weaknesses.

I do object to any attempt to hide or falsely represent the data.

Regarding the rights to publish, I would like an agreement that it does get published, in full, with complete disclosure. I would also like the right to publish my own comments and analysis, with an opportunity for Schwartz to review and also comment if he likes.
 
Tai Chi,

I don't know if I'm "feeding the trolls" here or not, but what the heck.

If you have not read Schwartz's book or at least the summary you can find online, and it does not appear you have, then I suggest you do so. Alternatively or in addition, you should read any or all the dissections of the experiments. I wrote a detailed analysis on tvtalkshows. You can still find it by search on that board.

Others have written better ones. Claus has mentioned them and has some on his site.

A major difficulty in discussing the results Schwartz got is that he does not, anywhere of which I am aware, fully disclose them.

There are four different, related, experiments in his book.

In the first, five mediums read one sitter; two of them read a second sitter. A total of seven readings. He gives only partial results for all of them: excerpts from the transcripts and only a summary of the analysis, with very little listing of what was considered a hit and what was not or how a numerical rating of accuracy (-3 to +3) by the sitter was turned into a percentage accuracy.

In the second, four mediums read ten sitters. 40 readings.
Schwartz gives excerpts from 8 of them. Again, only a summary of the analysis.

In the third, four mediums read four sitters, two read one other, and one read another (who happened to be Schwartz himself after Schwartz, against his own protocol, stepped into the experiment because the reader (John Edward) appeared to be giving information for Schwartz as opposed to the sitter. No marks against John for missing with the original sitter; positive marks for hitting with Schwartz. 19 readings. Schwartz provides excerpts from 2 of them, including his own.

In the fourth, one medium reads three sitters. Excerpts from one of them, the one who happens to claim to be a medium himself, is fairly well known, and whose recently published book is in the same house as the medium.

---

Which should explain why I anticipate difficulty in reaching an agreement with Schwartz.

Separate from the fact that Schwartz will have to fully disclose his method of analysis so it can be identically applied to my results, I will insist on the same weaknesses in protocol and controls.

Refer to my comments on the third experiment. Bear in mind that one of the things Schwartz touts is that the mediums could not possibly know anything about the sitters before hand. This is untrue, I think, about all the sitters, but patently untrue about Schwartz himself and about the cameraman who was, not for the first time, also in the room with JE.

When I read for a sitter, I want prior knowledge of the nearby experimenter and cameraman, and I want full marks for providing information pertinent to them, without concurrent negative marks for not reading the (ostensibly) unknown sitter.

There's more than just that, though.

I suggest you read up on it if you want to pursue this line of thought.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom