Cold Reading Demos at TAM2

Ed said:
It occurred to me recently that you can prove that Schwartz actually does believe in the Tooth Fairy. In his book he mentions how in thinking about stories, we create info-energy systems that can take on a life of their own. In my review of the book, I mentioned how that would mean that Santa, Ronald McDonald, Freddy Kruger, and Romeo, would then all exist as these info-energy system "spirits." In private correspondence with Schwartz, he agreed with that statement, that his theory predicts the existence of such beings.
Now, the Tooth Fairy has been in many cartoons, jokes, stories, and commercials over the years. Therefore Schwartz's theory actually predicts the existence of the Tooth Fairy. As it is fairly certain that Schwartz believes in his theory, and his theory predicts the existence of the Tooth Fairy, therefore Schwartz must believe in the Tooth Fairy. "

He said "can", not "do". I don't know what Schwartz's arguments are, and I'm very sure, in common with most other "skeptics", you cherry picked an isolated statement which might well not be so ludicrous in context. But obviously we cannot instantiate a physical existent purely from thinking about it, or through our imagination etc. Now if he were talking about the afterlife realm that might be a different thing.

But he wasn't?? :confused:
 
Ed said:
[Elizabeth Targ was a fraud.

Substantiate your allegation please.

Her AIDs/Prayer research was unblinded during analysis in order to get results.

References please.

This was knowingly done because, presumably, the lack of results did not meet her woo expectations. She also did work on remote healing with Cancer patients. I am not sure of the details but if this "research" in any way interrupted real treatment

Why on earth should it have done?

then it is in the same league as Nazi "experiments" in the death camps. Psironically she died of a brain tumor that was proof against any woo healing approaches.

It not only constitutes no proof, it also constitutes no evidence.

She was a dangerous woman and we are all better off now that she is dead.

Well Ed, I honestly think you are a dangerous person, that all skeptics are dangerous people. They are imposing their model of reality on people and arrogantly asserting that it is obviously correct (eg Towlies sentiments express this very well). This model of reality asserts that we are material creatures living in a material world, that we are essentially machines with no purpose to our existence, that soon we will cease to exist forevermore. Furthermore, that everything we ever experience, including our most profound emotions such as love, is literally identical to chemicals in the brain (not that such chemicals act as a catalyst). And what is perhaps worse, in this very brief life, we do not even possess any free will, and that everything we ever do is just simply a consequrnce of slavishly following an algorithm. And yet the justification of this model is philosophically unintelligible and ignores a great deal of evidence!

Yes I would say that you and other skeptics are very dangerous people. We would all be much better of if all the skeptics in the world were to suddenly die. Should one therefore wish this? No, I'm not a scumbag like you. Skeptics are dangerous people because they influence those less intelligent than themselves. But I can at least do my bit by coming on here and showing how vacuous all their arguments actually are. And I do that willingly.
 
Interesting Ian said:
Well Ed, I honestly think you are a dangerous person, that all skeptics are dangerous people. They are imposing their model of reality on people and arrogantly asserting that it is obviously correct (eg Towlies sentiments express this very well). This model of reality asserts that we are material creatures living in a material world, that we are essentially machines with no purpose to our existence, that soon we will cease to exist forevermore. Furthermore, that everything we ever experience, including our most profound emotions such as love, is literally identical to chemicals in the brain (not that such chemicals act as a catalyst). And what is perhaps worse, in this very brief life, we do not even possess any free will, and that everything we ever do is just simply a consequrnce of slavishly following an algorithm. And yet the justification of this model is philosophically unintelligible and ignores a great deal of evidence!

Yes I would say that you and other skeptics are very dangerous people. We would all be much better of if all the skeptics in the world were to suddenly die. Should one therefore wish this? No, I'm not a scumbag like you. Skeptics are dangerous people because they influence those less intelligent than themselves. But I can at least do my bit by coming on here and showing how vacuous all their arguments actually are. And I do that willingly.

Saved for posterity.
 
Interesting Ian said:

Skeptics are dangerous people because they influence those less intelligent than themselves.
Apparently not. After all, we haven't managed to change your mind. :D
 
Originally posted by T'ai Chi
[*]Do you believe the quality of parapsychological experiments is significantly improving over time?


Claus
To a degree, yes. In some cases, the controls have gotten better. Unfortunately, that has resulted in weaker results. As one expect, if the signal is just noise.

No they haven't so far as I've been able to ascertain. I'm sure you can find isolated instants where they have, but I do not believe the preponderance of parapsychological research has.
 
Interesting Ian said:
Well Ed, I honestly think you are a dangerous person, that all skeptics are dangerous people. They are imposing their model of reality on people and arrogantly asserting that it is obviously correct (eg Towlies sentiments express this very well). This model of reality asserts that we are material creatures living in a material world, that we are essentially machines with no purpose to our existence, that soon we will cease to exist forevermore. Furthermore, that everything we ever experience, including our most profound emotions such as love, is literally identical to chemicals in the brain (not that such chemicals act as a catalyst). And what is perhaps worse, in this very brief life, we do not even possess any free will, and that everything we ever do is just simply a consequrnce of slavishly following an algorithm. And yet the justification of this model is philosophically unintelligible and ignores a great deal of evidence!

Yes I would say that you and other skeptics are very dangerous people. We would all be much better of if all the skeptics in the world were to suddenly die. Should one therefore wish this? No, I'm not a scumbag like you. Skeptics are dangerous people because they influence those less intelligent than themselves. But I can at least do my bit by coming on here and showing how vacuous all their arguments actually are. And I do that willingly.

This thread just keeps getting better and better...
 
The vacuous arguments of skeptics? You are a treat, Ian.

The more I read your debates, the less impressed I become.

Your arguments are nice, and your thoughts have at some point touched on reality, but they are ultimately without substance.

You play well to the crowd, but the referee calls foul.

You remind me very much of a 19 year old man who was already a black belt in a Taekwondo school I joined (after many years of learning a mish-mash of styles from many informal sources without gaining a belt in any).

This young man was beautiful to watch when he demonstrated his forms. His movements were smooth and elegant; he changed facing without seeming to move his feet; his flexibility astounds me even in memory; he never waivered in his balance; he always extended fully.

One day we sparred using tournament rules. He beat me badly.

Another day we free sparred. He had no chance. I could have killed him if I liked. Easily. He was angry, confused, and in denial. He insisted I didn't really win because there was no way to score it or judge it. If it were a tournament, he protested, he would have won.

But I never suggested otherwise. I expected to lose the fight under tournament rules, and I expected to win the free fight.

Your philosophy is the world under tournament rules. It predicts nothing except that the world under tournament rules operates as if it is under tournament rules, but you refuse to look out the window where real fights happen daily and outcomes that matter are determined.

At some point, a rock will break that window and all your rules will fall to those who do not respect them, regardless how loudly you praise them.

You are that young man, Ian. You are the pretty boy of philosophers. You know form and you know content, but you have applied them under tournament rules while ignoring brutal reality.

Philosophy is a wondrous mental exercise and can point to areas to investigate, but it must always bow before the terrible tyrant of truth.

I am not as adept in this intellectual arena as I am in the physical one, so perhaps I am not the one to demonstrate your emptiness, but I am adept enough to recognize when someone else demonstrates it and when they have knocked you off your horse of unfounded conceit.

BillHoyt is only one of several who have done it to you. Ed is another. If you had the capacity to learn and not just bluster you would be able to list for yourself still others who have done it.

It doesn’t bother me if I am not on that list. I don’t pretend to greater knowledge or intelligence than I have, nor am I so insecure as to think that all my thoughts are wrong if I can not out debate a pretty boy under tournament rules.

I’ll gladly admit you can sometimes out argue me, but my response will be to trundle off to the kitchen for more popcorn before coming back to watch the “Ian Gets Deflated Without Knowing It” show.

Ta
 
To Garrette,

:wow2: never realised you were a babbling psychopathic loon! :( :confused: I'd better make sure I'm always polite to you!

Another day we free sparred. He had no chance. I could have killed him if I liked. Easily.

I hope you don't tell many people this. You'll discover that people will make polite excuses and never contact you again! :eek:

Your philosophy is the world under tournament rules. It predicts nothing except that the world under tournament rules operates as if it is under tournament rules, but you refuse to look out the window where real fights happen daily and outcomes that matter are determined.

Yup, you're clueless at what philosophy is all about. You express the sentiments of drunken idiots in pubs. If intellectual argumentation is so unimportant then go and live your life of base pleasures fighting with people. But be considerate and only fight your own kind.

I am adept enough to recognize when someone else demonstrates it and when they have knocked you off your horse of unfounded conceit.

BillHoyt is only one of several who have done it to you.

Isn't BillHoyt's demonstration of his unadulterated idiocy and lack of comprehension in this very thread not ample demonstration to you that he could never outargue even the most starry eyed believer?

I'm not quite sure if you're taking the piss or not. BillHoyt?? For your sake, I sincerely hope you're not.
 
Garrette said:
The vacuous arguments of skeptics? You are a treat, Ian.

The more I read your debates, the less impressed I become.

Your arguments are nice, and your thoughts have at some point touched on reality, but they are ultimately without substance.

You play well to the crowd, but the referee calls foul.

You remind me very much of a 19 year old man who was already a black belt in a Taekwondo school I joined (after many years of learning a mish-mash of styles from many informal sources without gaining a belt in any).

This young man was beautiful to watch when he demonstrated his forms. His movements were smooth and elegant; he changed facing without seeming to move his feet; his flexibility astounds me even in memory; he never waivered in his balance; he always extended fully.

One day we sparred using tournament rules. He beat me badly.

Another day we free sparred. He had no chance. I could have killed him if I liked. Easily. He was angry, confused, and in denial. He insisted I didn't really win because there was no way to score it or judge it. If it were a tournament, he protested, he would have won.

But I never suggested otherwise. I expected to lose the fight under tournament rules, and I expected to win the free fight.

Your philosophy is the world under tournament rules. It predicts nothing except that the world under tournament rules operates as if it is under tournament rules, but you refuse to look out the window where real fights happen daily and outcomes that matter are determined.

At some point, a rock will break that window and all your rules will fall to those who do not respect them, regardless how loudly you praise them.

You are that young man, Ian. You are the pretty boy of philosophers. You know form and you know content, but you have applied them under tournament rules while ignoring brutal reality.

Philosophy is a wondrous mental exercise and can point to areas to investigate, but it must always bow before the terrible tyrant of truth.

I am not as adept in this intellectual arena as I am in the physical one, so perhaps I am not the one to demonstrate your emptiness, but I am adept enough to recognize when someone else demonstrates it and when they have knocked you off your horse of unfounded conceit.

BillHoyt is only one of several who have done it to you. Ed is another. If you had the capacity to learn and not just bluster you would be able to list for yourself still others who have done it.

It doesn’t bother me if I am not on that list. I don’t pretend to greater knowledge or intelligence than I have, nor am I so insecure as to think that all my thoughts are wrong if I can not out debate a pretty boy under tournament rules.

I’ll gladly admit you can sometimes out argue me, but my response will be to trundle off to the kitchen for more popcorn before coming back to watch the “Ian Gets Deflated Without Knowing It” show.

Ta

All this, from a guy who couldn't even get a simple email address to Dr Schwartz right, and who sat on it for months wondering why he hadn't a response yet. :rolleyes:

Ed's comments about Dr Targ were sick. Do you agree with them?
 
Ian,
Well Ed, I honestly think you are a dangerous person, that all skeptics are dangerous people. They are imposing their model of reality on people and arrogantly asserting that it is obviously correct (eg Towlies sentiments express this very well).

D*mn, I believed rational was your creation, another of your sockpuppets. I would be very disapointed to find this is not the case...
 
All quotations originally posted by Ian:

never realised you were a babbling psychopathic loon! I'd better make sure I'm always polite to you!

No need to worry. Remember, I don't kill people even when I easily can...



I hope you don't tell many people this. You'll discover that people will make polite excuses and never contact you again!

Because I refrain from excessive force?


Yup, you're clueless at what philosophy is all about. You express the sentiments of drunken idiots in pubs.

I never claimed philosophical expertise. I'm only claiming you're misapplying yours.

If I recall, the sentiments of drunken idiots in pubs are what you were expressing on this forum about 24 hours ago, though I may have my timing off a bit.

If intellectual argumentation is so unimportant then go and live your life of base pleasures fighting with people. But be considerate and only fight your own kind

It appears you're rattled. Where did I say it is unimportant? By my own kind I take it you mean those who do not mistake posturing for reality?

Isn't BillHoyt's demonstration of his unadulterated idiocy and lack of comprehension in this very thread not ample demonstration to you that he could never outargue even the most starry eyed believer?

If he demonstrated it, I'd admit it. He hasn't.

I'm not quite sure if you're taking the piss or not. BillHoyt?? For your sake, I sincerely hope you're not.

I am uncertain as to the meaning, but I thank you for your concern.
 
Originally posted by Lucianarchy:

All this, from a guy who couldn't even get a simple email address to Dr Schwartz right, and who sat on it for months wondering why he hadn't a response yet.

Is it really a revelation to you that people make mistakes, even egregiously inane ones, dumb ones, inconceivable ones?

Or is it only inconceivable that some people admit mistakes?

I suspect it is more the latter as you seem incapable of it.

Remember, Luci/Pete, that I didn't just admit to this stupid blunder, I'm the one who brought it to others' attention so they would not unfairly blame Professor Schwartz for something that was my fault, even though I have no respect for Schwartz as a scientist or scholar. It would have been quite easy for me to hide my mistake.

I suppose it is possible you would have acted in the same fashion under similar circumstances.

Possible.

Yes.

I remind myself that it really must be at least possible.


Originally posted by Lucianarchy:

Ed's comments about Dr Targ were sick. Do you agree with them?

I assume you mean the one about the world being better off with her dead?

I have no idea why this is relevant, but I'll answer.

I honestly have no idea. I know very little of Dr. Elizabeth Targ. The little I do know leads me to believe that she is at best highly gullible and incompetent and at worst a malicious fraud, but I do not have enough information or enough certainty to judge in the manner you are asking.

Nor am I avoiding the question. I have no problem admitting that I feel there are people who will leave the world a better place when they are dead. Examples in the past tense are easier to give, such as Hitler.

Do you, Luci/Pete, think there are people about whom it can be said that the world would be better off if they were dead?
 
So if "taking the piss" means "not serious", then Ian double-negatived it?

I'm not quite sure if you're taking the piss or not. BillHoyt?? For your sake, I sincerely hope you're not.

So he hopes I wasn't not serious? Hmmm.....

In any case, I think I was leaving the piss, er, I mean I was serious.

Still am.
 
Originally posted by Interesting Ian


No, I'm not a scumbag like you.

Excellent. A true appraisal of my worth. To the less crass a "scumbag" is otherwise known as a prophylctic, an object whose function is to prevent disease and pregnancy and, on occasion, to make the sexual act more pleasurable. For this metaphor, I thank you Ian. My nature, in your view, is entirely beneficant.

Which, of course, begs the question of what is Ian.

Ian, you are an intellectual bully. You engage in purile arguments with little wit and less knowledge than you would have us believe. You mouth platitudes and shy away when pushed. You put forward positions that are supported by air. You are vacuous and dismissable.

Overall, Ian, you are not terribly bright.

One man's beneficent opinion.
 
Garrette said:


I assume you mean the one about the world being better off with her dead?

I have no idea why this is relevant, but I'll answer.

I honestly have no idea. I know very little of Dr. Elizabeth Targ. The little I do know leads me to believe that she is at best highly gullible and incompetent and at worst a malicious fraud, but I do not have enough information or enough certainty to judge in the manner you are asking.

Nor am I avoiding the question. I have no problem admitting that I feel there are people who will leave the world a better place when they are dead. Examples in the past tense are easier to give, such as Hitler.

Do you, Luci/Pete, think there are people about whom it can be said that the world would be better off if they were dead?

Past tense, Garrett, past tense. She went out in a veil of woo-woo incense.

Nothing befitted her as much in life as the leaving of it.
 
Garrette said:
So if "taking the piss" means "not serious", then Ian double-negatived it?



So he hopes I wasn't not serious? Hmmm.....

In any case, I think I was leaving the piss, er, I mean I was serious.

Still am.

Well, I looked it up, and it is more pointed than I had originally thought. This source says it means to deflate somebody. To make sense of Ian's paragraph, then, I think he means you are trying to deflate him by what you said.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom