Cold Reading Demos at TAM2

Interesting Ian said:


Please desist with the semantic games and confess that I didn't make a gaffe.

Claus,

At least he didn't ask you to die, like he did someone else on the telepathy thread.
 
Interesting Ian said:
Now do you concede that I did not make a gaffe??
On deeper analysis, yes, I do. You did not gaffe.







































































You also did not read the sources. You lied about it. You posted a passage without understanding it. You then were absolutely surprised to hear from me the information you had cut & pasted with neither reading nor understanding. You then lied about that.

But, it cannot properly be called a gaffe.
 
BillHoyt said:


Claus,

At least he didn't ask you to die, like he did someone else on the telepathy thread.

I certainly did not!
 
BillHoyt said:
On deeper analysis, yes, I do. You did not gaffe.







































































You also did not read the sources. You lied about it. You posted a passage without understanding it.

Perfectly wrong on all counts. Indeed, on the contrary, it is quite evident that you fail to understand the source.
 
And here we have a perfect example of why I no longer have any real interest in cold reading threads.

N/A
 
NoZed Avenger said:
And here we have a perfect example of why I no longer have any real interest in cold reading threads.

N/A

Is there somebody near the front row named "Nose?" Yes, "Nozed," that's it. They're speaking softly, almost weakly. I'm getting an "M" here. Yes, that's it, its your late Aunt Moira. She wants you to know, and this is very important; you no longer have any real interest in cold reading threads. Do you understand this?
 
Finished your 'only analyze the letter J to determine if mediums are cold reading' analysis for various mediums yet?

I'm sure a lot of people would like to see your results..
 
T'ai Chi said:
Finished your 'only analyze the letter J to determine if mediums are cold reading' analysis for various mediums yet?

I'm sure a lot of people would like to see your results..

T'ai Chi,

  • Have you any opinions of Schwartz's quotes yet?
  • Have you read the analyses I presented yet?
  • Have you read the pages from Schwartz' book yet?
  • Have you read Schwartz' book yet?
  • Have you read Marc Berard's analysis yet?

I'm sure your argument could benefit from actually knowing what the heck you are trying to argue.
 
CFLarsen said:



  • Have you any opinions of Schwartz's quotes yet?
  • Have you read the analyses I presented yet?
  • Have you read the pages from Schwartz' book yet?
  • Have you read Schwartz' book yet?
  • Have you read Marc Berard's analysis yet?


Ooh, a 'List'. :D

Only one question though:

Why don't cold readers take the Schwartz Research Chair Challenge?
 
CFLarsen said:

T'ai Chi,

  • Have you any opinions of Schwartz's quotes yet?
  • Have you read the analyses I presented yet?
  • Have you read the pages from Schwartz' book yet?
  • Have you read Schwartz' book yet?
  • Have you read Marc Berard's analysis yet?

I'm sure your argument could benefit from actually knowing what the heck you are trying to argue.

Just to prove you do NOT pay attention at times, and therefore your list items are moot, in this very thread I've already stated that I do have opinons of Schwartz (which are not the topic. As I've said, the facts themselves are), and I've already stated I have read Schwartz's book (read my responses to Garrette. What can I say, you must have forgot what you read so carefully over...) and in response to your "Did you read the transcripts and the analyses?" question I already said: "Yes, and you're not addressing...", so again I answered you.

Just to keep you on your toes, as you apparently need it, given that all 5 of your list questions were already addresed, since I'm a fast typer, from now on I will always ask at least twice the amount of questions you ask to me.

I will then, of course, constantly provide links to them in future discussions with you.

Count on it.

  • Why did you ignore my answers and then ask me the same questions again?
  • Do you feel that "triple blinding" makes sense?
  • Where did Schwartz say that he believes in the Tooth Fairy?
  • How is my your example of an astrologer you squabbled with any where close to satisfying my request of recent (post 1980's) examples of skeptics pretending they are psychic or examples of deliberate fraud in parapsychology?
  • Do you consider SI to be a scientific peer reviewed journal?
  • Do you believe BillHoyt's (paraphrasing is mine) 'we can statistically analyze only the letter J to help determine if a medium is cold reading' to be sound?
  • Do you believe it is more difficult for an admitted cold reader to analyze a transcript of a reading and say this is where and how the sitter was fooled, or actually pretend to be a medium themselves and try to fool people under the same experimental conditions that the mediums go through?
  • Do you believe the quality of parapsychological experiments is significantly improving over time?
  • Do you agree that the statistical methods and theory are sound in many parapsycholgical papers?
  • Recently a skeptic of telepathy didn't do so good of a job presenting the case and evidence why it is apparently bunk (the majority of the audience thought the pro-telepathy evidence was far better). How would you do better presenting?
  • Are there cold readers who are claiming they can fool sitters under Schwartz's experimental conditions?
  • In what branches of science/study do you feel magicians are necessary to observe or plan/design experiments?
  • Do you believe colleges and universities should hire on magicians as professors or faculty members or consultants?
  • If BillHoyt can critique my knowledge of mathematics and statistics, isn't he implying that he has knowledge of mathematics and statistics, knowledge that I can then question him on as he questioned me on?
  • Don't you find it interesting that NIST scientists who design tests for non-randomness said (after I emailed it to them) that mine was similar to one they have, yet BillHoyt refers to it as a "crap smear"?
  • Do you believe one cannot prove a negative?
  • If the laws of physics are determined by physical objects, and physical objects are always changing, does this imply that the laws of physics are changing (albeit slowly)?
  • What should my next move be in the chess game in the Puzzle section?
 
T'ai Chi said:
  • Why did you ignore my answers and then ask me the same questions again?
  • Do you feel that "triple blinding" makes sense?
  • Where did Schwartz say that he believes in the Tooth Fairy?
  • How is my your example of an astrologer you squabbled with any where close to satisfying my request of recent (post 1980's) examples of skeptics pretending they are psychic or examples of deliberate fraud in parapsychology?
  • Do you consider SI to be a scientific peer reviewed journal?
  • Do you believe BillHoyt's (paraphrasing is mine) 'we can statistically analyze only the letter J to help determine if a medium is cold reading' to be sound?
  • Do you believe it is more difficult for an admitted cold reader to analyze a transcript of a reading and say this is where and how the sitter was fooled, or actually pretend to be a medium themselves and try to fool people under the same experimental conditions that the mediums go through?
  • Do you believe the quality of parapsychological experiments is significantly improving over time?
  • Do you agree that the statistical methods and theory are sound in many parapsycholgical papers?
  • Recently a skeptic of telepathy didn't do so good of a job presenting the case and evidence why it is apparently bunk (the majority of the audience thought the pro-telepathy evidence was far better). How would you do better presenting?
  • Are there cold readers who are claiming they can fool sitters under Schwartz's experimental conditions?
  • In what branches of science/study do you feel magicians are necessary to observe or plan/design experiments?
  • Do you believe colleges and universities should hire on magicians as professors or faculty members or consultants?
  • If BillHoyt can critique my knowledge of mathematics and statistics, isn't he implying that he has knowledge of mathematics and statistics, knowledge that I can then question him on as he questioned me on?
  • Don't you find it interesting that NIST scientists who design tests for non-randomness said (after I emailed it to them) that mine was similar to one they have, yet BillHoyt refers to it as a "crap smear"?
  • Do you believe one cannot prove a negative?
  • If the laws of physics are determined by physical objects, and physical objects are always changing, does this imply that the laws of physics are changing (albeit slowly)?
  • What should my next move be in the chess game in the Puzzle section?
[/B]

Come on Claus. Answer the questions!
 
Skeptics,

To properly crush nonsense we need to resort to lying and making ◊◊◊◊ up, ruthless personal attacks, misrepresenting the opposition’s views, avoiding questions, being vague, running around the issues, stating our opinions as fact, refusing to consider kooks arguments, etc! This may sound dishonest but it doesn’t matter because skeptics are supporting the ultimate proven truth (materialism)! We will resort to anything to defend science and the undeniable view of a physically closed universe with material minds which tend to get gullible!

You can’t have science without materialism!
 
!Xx+-Rational-+xX! said:
Skeptics,

To properly crush nonsense we need to resort to lying and making ◊◊◊◊ up, ruthless personal attacks, misrepresenting the opposition’s views, avoiding questions, being vague, running around the issues, stating our opinions as fact, refusing to consider kooks arguments, etc! This may sound dishonest but it doesn’t matter because skeptics are supporting the ultimate proven truth (materialism)! We will resort to anything to defend science and the undeniable view of a physically closed universe with material minds which tend to get gullible!

You can’t have science without materialism!
Works for me, dude or dudess. Let me fire up my BongoMatic before I compose a reply.
Ahh, dat's better.
I glean from the screed above that you are attempting to parody your conception of what skeptics believe and how they behave.
A good parody ought to contain more than a fraction of a grain of truth, otherwise the audience doesn't get the parody or satire or lampoon, whatever.
Think "The Rutles" without those other British gents.
Think "This Is Spinal Tap" without all those other British wankers and Yankers.
Think "A Modest Proposal" without the cannibalism problem involving British gents scarfing Irish stew.
But, I agree with your last line.
 
Jeff Corey said:

Works for me, dude or dudess. Let me fire up my BongoMatic before I compose a reply.
Ahh, dat's better.
I glean from the screed above that you are attempting to parody your conception of what skeptics believe and how they behave.
A good parody ought to contain more than a fraction of a grain of truth, otherwise the audience doesn't get the parody or satire or lampoon, whatever.
Think "The Rutles" without those other British gents.
Think "This Is Spinal Tap" without all those other British wankers and Yankers.
Think "A Modest Proposal" without the cannibalism problem involving British gents scarfing Irish stew.
But, I agree with your last line.

Its no parody skeptics must do all of that because believers are incapable of listening to anything outside of fairy tales! Materialism has been proven through extensive tests over the years that have been replicated over and over again! This is not to be questioned! Some may wonder why it is questioned with all of this proof!!! This happens because some people have a deep hatred towards science, logic, and truth!
 
T'ai Chi said:

  • Do you feel that "triple blinding" makes sense?
What is triple blinding? I know what double blinding is but what is the third party you blind?
T'ai Chi said:

  • What should my next move be in the chess game in the Puzzle section?
It isn't your move. Besides isn't asking for help cheating? :coal:
 
T'ai Chi said:
Far be it from me to speak for Claus, but it is early here and I have a bit of time so I thought that I'd comment on a few of your points



  • Why did you ignore my answers and then ask me the same questions again?
  • Do you feel that "triple blinding" makes sense?

    Yes it does. The greater the ignorance of who is doing what to whom and who's results say what statistically, the better. This, of course is a basic tenent of research.
  • Where did Schwartz say that he believes in the Tooth Fairy?

    That refers to this

    "Schwartz observer Marc Berard writes that perhaps TIME writer Leon Jaroff was not incorrect in his assessment of Schwartz's belief structure, when he opined that the scientist believes in the Tooth Fairy:


    It occurred to me recently that you can prove that Schwartz actually does believe in the Tooth Fairy. In his book he mentions how in thinking about stories, we create info-energy systems that can take on a life of their own. In my review of the book, I mentioned how that would mean that Santa, Ronald McDonald, Freddy Kruger, and Romeo, would then all exist as these info-energy system "spirits." In private correspondence with Schwartz, he agreed with that statement, that his theory predicts the existence of such beings.
    Now, the Tooth Fairy has been in many cartoons, jokes, stories, and commercials over the years. Therefore Schwartz's theory actually predicts the existence of the Tooth Fairy. As it is fairly certain that Schwartz believes in his theory, and his theory predicts the existence of the Tooth Fairy, therefore Schwartz must believe in the Tooth Fairy. "

    Contained here:

    http://www.randi.org/jr/03-23-2001.html

    An inference but reasonably sound.

  • How is my your example of an astrologer you squabbled with any where close to satisfying my request of recent (post 1980's) examples of skeptics pretending they are psychic or examples of deliberate fraud in parapsychology?

    I presume that you mean that we know about? Well, Elizabeth Targ was a fraud. Her AIDs/Prayer research was unblinded during analysis in order to get results. This was knowingly done because, presumably, the lack of results did not meet her woo expectations. She also did work on remote healing with Cancer patients. I am not sure of the details but if this "research" in any way interrupted real treatment then it is in the same league as Nazi "experiments" in the death camps. Psironically she died of a brain tumor that was proof against any woo healing approaches. She was a dangerous woman and we are all better off now that she is dead. I am unclear as to whether Schwartz is a fraud or incompetant. Does repeated incompetence, when one is corrected, yield fraud? You judge.
  • Do you consider SI to be a scientific peer reviewed journal?

    Sports Illustrated?
  • Do you believe BillHoyt's (paraphrasing is mine) 'we can statistically analyze only the letter J to help determine if a medium is cold reading' to be sound?
  • Do you believe it is more difficult for an admitted cold reader to analyze a transcript of a reading and say this is where and how the sitter was fooled, or actually pretend to be a medium themselves and try to fool people under the same experimental conditions that the mediums go through?

    I suspect that the former is far easier. Having cold read myself (quite successfully, I might add) there is an aspect of "performance" to it that makes it stressful. Practice makes perfect.
  • Do you believe the quality of parapsychological experiments is significantly improving over time?

    Yes and no. While paradigms might improve (why they "improve" from lousey to sorta good in the first place is an interesting question.) we find that believers take solice in the resultant irreproducable minimum of noise as being indicative of an effect. So, these woo-effects that have been around since the beginning, that have been reported over human history, that are real and big are now, with better designs, only to be found in the fifth decimal place. Hmmmmmmm. The problem is that when you deal with believers, negative results are not in the decision set. The horse is really dead, they just don't realize it.
  • Do you agree that the statistical methods and theory are sound in many parapsycholgical papers?

    Theory? Please give us one. I doubt that you can. The stats suck. Targ is a good example. There was some other prayer research that I read that did the same thing (ie. fishing without an appropriate significance level adjustment.). The misuse of Meta analysis has been dealt with in detail on these forums. The problem is that the researchers "know" the result in advance of the data and the stats are simply a minor irretation. As an analyst friend of mine is wont to say "you can torture data to say anything". Oh, yes, that silly paper that you posted on Vegas was a prime example of sh!tty stats, as you know from the thread.
  • Recently a skeptic of telepathy didn't do so good of a job presenting the case and evidence why it is apparently bunk (the majority of the audience thought the pro-telepathy evidence was far better). How would you do better presenting?

    Unaware of this. I guess (being an American and all) I would get a telepath and sit him in front of the audience and explain to him he was either going to perform well or get his brains blown out. It would be riveting to be sure. Though the ending would not be in much doubt
  • Are there cold readers who are claiming they can fool sitters under Schwartz's experimental conditions?

    Unknown to me. Recognize that reproducing Schwartz's "experimental" conditions would require a degree of performance art. The environment he created was part of the so called design. Bad stuff.
  • In what branches of science/study do you feel magicians are necessary to observe or plan/design experiments?

    In para-psychology. Have you ever taken part in an experiment? As a subject or a researcher? No. If you had you would not ask this. Going down this road is really a bad attempt at misdirection.
  • Do you believe colleges and universities should hire on magicians as professors or faculty members or consultants?

    Yes. I think that critical thinking courses would benefit.
  • If BillHoyt can critique my knowledge of mathematics and statistics, isn't he implying that he has knowledge of mathematics and statistics, knowledge that I can then question him on as he questioned me on?

    He might have knowledge of an aspect that you don't. Dunno, ask him
  • Don't you find it interesting that NIST scientists who design tests for non-randomness said (after I emailed it to them) that mine was similar to one they have, yet BillHoyt refers to it as a "crap smear"?

    Sorry, not enough context to answer
  • Do you believe one cannot prove a negative?

    Prove? No. Make a rational decision based on information to hand and behave as though it were proven? Yes. You cross streets, don't you?
  • If the laws of physics are determined by physical objects, and physical objects are always changing, does this imply that the laws of physics are changing (albeit slowly)?

    Are they? Seems rather too vague to answer
  • What should my next move be in the chess game in the Puzzle section?

    I just telepathed the answer
[/B]
 
T'ai Chi said:
Just to prove you do NOT pay attention at times, and therefore your list items are moot, in this very thread I've already stated that I do have opinons of Schwartz

So, where are they?

T'ai Chi said:
(which are not the topic. As I've said, the facts themselves are)

You do not decide what is the "topic". If you bring something up, that can be the topic.

T'ai Chi said:
and I've already stated I have read Schwartz's book (read my responses to Garrette. What can I say, you must have forgot what you read so carefully over...)

Here's your own quote:

"but I've read it in increments at a local bookstore."

You call that "reading a book"?? It is 364 pages, with some pretty densely written appendices.

T'ai Chi said:
and in response to your "Did you read the transcripts and the analyses?" question I already said: "Yes, and you're not addressing...", so again I answered you.

No, you did not. You claimed you had read it, but you did not address anything in those transcripts and analyses.

T'ai Chi said:
Just to keep you on your toes, as you apparently need it, given that all 5 of your list questions were already addresed, since I'm a fast typer, from now on I will always ask at least twice the amount of questions you ask to me.

I will then, of course, constantly provide links to them in future discussions with you.

Count on it.

Oh, I cannot wait! You see, it will become extremely clear who are willing to answer questions and who are not.

T'ai Chi said:
[*]Why did you ignore my answers and then ask me the same questions again?

Because you have not answered them.

T'ai Chi said:
[*]Do you feel that "triple blinding" makes sense?

Show me the definition of "triple blinding".

T'ai Chi said:
[*]Where did Schwartz say that he believes in the Tooth Fairy?

Who claims that Schwartz says he believes in the Tooth Fairy?

T'ai Chi said:
[*]How is my your example of an astrologer you squabbled with any where close to satisfying my request of recent (post 1980's) examples of skeptics pretending they are psychic or examples of deliberate fraud in parapsychology?

You are moving the goal posts. Now, it is not merely deliberate fraud in parapsychology.

T'ai Chi said:
[*]Do you consider SI to be a scientific peer reviewed journal?

Depends on what "SI" is. Do you mean Skeptical Inquirer?

T'ai Chi said:
[*]Do you believe BillHoyt's (paraphrasing is mine) 'we can statistically analyze only the letter J to help determine if a medium is cold reading' to be sound?

I'm sorry, I prefer to deal with actual quotes in context, instead of your paraphrasings.

T'ai Chi said:
[*]Do you believe it is more difficult for an admitted cold reader to analyze a transcript of a reading and say this is where and how the sitter was fooled, or actually pretend to be a medium themselves and try to fool people under the same experimental conditions that the mediums go through?

I cannot see why these two are exclusive. Please explain why.

T'ai Chi said:
[*]Do you believe the quality of parapsychological experiments is significantly improving over time?

To a degree, yes. In some cases, the controls have gotten better. Unfortunately, that has resulted in weaker results. As one expect, if the signal is just noise.

T'ai Chi said:
[*]Do you agree that the statistical methods and theory are sound in many parapsycholgical papers?

I am not a statistician. Those that have knowledge claim that in some papers, the stats are sound. You must take it up with them.

T'ai Chi said:
[*]Recently a skeptic of telepathy didn't do so good of a job presenting the case and evidence why it is apparently bunk (the majority of the audience thought the pro-telepathy evidence was far better). How would you do better presenting?

What skeptic of telepathy are we talking about? I cannot answer, until I know how the presentation was devised.

T'ai Chi said:
[*]Are there cold readers who are claiming they can fool sitters under Schwartz's experimental conditions?

Yes. Garrette. You know that.

T'ai Chi said:
[*]In what branches of science/study do you feel magicians are necessary to observe or plan/design experiments?

Those that do not have hard data "loud" enough to be independently verified by others. But, in a perfect world, all of them.

T'ai Chi said:
[*]Do you believe colleges and universities should hire on magicians as professors or faculty members or consultants?

Depends on the field.

T'ai Chi said:
[*]If BillHoyt can critique my knowledge of mathematics and statistics, isn't he implying that he has knowledge of mathematics and statistics, knowledge that I can then question him on as he questioned me on?

You'll have to ask BillHoyt for his statistical credentials.

T'ai Chi said:
[*]Don't you find it interesting that NIST scientists who design tests for non-randomness said (after I emailed it to them) that mine was similar to one they have, yet BillHoyt refers to it as a "crap smear"?

I haven't followed that.

T'ai Chi said:
[*]Do you believe one cannot prove a negative?

A negative claim cannot be proven.

T'ai Chi said:
[*]If the laws of physics are determined by physical objects, and physical objects are always changing, does this imply that the laws of physics are changing (albeit slowly)?

Are physical objects always changing? In what ways?

T'ai Chi said:
[*]What should my next move be in the chess game in the Puzzle section?

No idea. I don't play chess. I haven't participated in the thread.

It is fine with me, if you want to ask me questions, but please make them relevant to something I have said, done or claimed. A lot of your questions has to deal with your problems with other people, with what they have - or may not have - said.

Perhaps you could make an effort to distinguish between your beef with me, and your (many, it seems) beef with others?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom