Cold Reading Demos at TAM2

Interesting Ian said:


I agree :) Did you see his post in the Penn thread last night?? Absolutely brilliant!
Tsk, tsk, tsk, Praising yourself is terribly bad form.
Interesting Ian said:

Hmmmm . . .you seem rather enthralled by him. I wonder if he's your sock puppet? ;) Maybe I should do a poll with all the possible suspects including myself! LOL
You'll have my vote.
 
Kerberos said:

Look who's talking, you still haven't managed to answer my single question: What is triple blinding? Once you have blinded both participants and the "scientists", who is there left to blind? You still haven't answered this very simple question, unless of course you think it has already been answered adequately by BillHoyt. :D

Shhhh!, Kerberos, you've given the game away!
 
Posted by Interesting Ian

I agree Did you see his post in the Penn thread last night?? Absolutely brilliant!
He's definitely one of the most original thinkers here!
Hmmmm . . .you seem rather enthralled by him.
Indeed I am! :) And I'm eagerly waiting for his book on superscientifisuperioricism (or whatever it's called, lol). I've got a great space on my bookshelf for it--right between "Flim-Flam" and "Why People Believe Weird Things". :)
I wonder if he's your sock puppet?
Don't I -wish- I was that clever! :)
 
Clancie said:
quote:
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Posted by !Xx-Rational-xX!

Skeptics,

To properly crush nonsense we need to resort to lying and making ◊◊◊◊ up, ruthless personal attacks, misrepresenting the opposition’s views, avoiding questions, being vague, running around the issues, stating our opinions as fact, refusing to consider kooks arguments, etc! This may sound dishonest but it doesn’t matter because skeptics are supporting the ultimate proven truth (materialism)! We will resort to anything to defend science and the undeniable view of a physically closed universe with material minds which tend to get gullible!

You can’t have science without materialism!
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Dear !Xx-Rational-xX!,

Thank you for sharing your wit and wisdom and brightening up my thread! :)

Sincerely,

Clancie
Oh Please. Pervayer of horribly stereotypical bad skeptic parodies. If you're giving shout outs to Towelie for his above post then I suppose we can no longer expect you to complain too loudly about the horribly vague definitions of "woo-woo's" anymore then hmmm. 6 of one, half dozen of the other as they say. Although I will admit, this type of post is more his style. Anyone wanting a great example of Towelie trying to exercise his considerable "debating" talents should check out this thread:

http://www.randi.org/vbulletin/showthread.php?s=&threadid=33852
I admit it gets silly towards the end, but its rather hard to take him seriously :). I eagerly await his inane response.
 
Kerberos said:

Hmmm. I don't quite get it. How can you analyze results for statistical significancy, without knowing what the correct answer is? That information doesn't seem to be avaliable from google.


The evaluator can obtain various statistics that tells him/her that the results are statistically significant (p-values, etc.).


I really hate to repeat myself but : "Look who's talking". Let's take a look on one of the question you asked Claus:
(snip)
You don't even have to use Google find the answer to this one. The answer is right here on this very thread. :eek: :eek:

Yeah no kidding. I knew the answer.
 
T'ai Chi said:
The evaluator can obtain various statistics that tells him/her that the results are statistically significant (p-values, etc.).
[/b]

Uh, no. Try again.
 
!Xx+-Rational-+xX! said:
Skeptics,

To properly crush nonsense we need to resort to lying and making ◊◊◊◊ up, ruthless personal attacks, misrepresenting the opposition’s views, avoiding questions, being vague, running around the issues, stating our opinions as fact, refusing to consider kooks arguments, etc! This may sound dishonest but it doesn’t matter because skeptics are supporting the ultimate proven truth (materialism)! We will resort to anything to defend science and the undeniable view of a physically closed universe with material minds which tend to get gullible!


Methinks Towlies master is in need of a mirror!

Barkhorn.
 
T'ai Chi said:
The evaluator can obtain various statistics that tells him/her that the results are statistically significant (p-values, etc.).

Compared to what?? He/she doesn't know.

T'ai Chi said:
Yeah no kidding. I knew the answer.

Of course you did. That's why you asked. Right.........

T'ai Chi said:
Terms like....??

Triple-blind. Please explain how that works. Perhaps you can use Schwartz' experiment from his book as an example.
 
CFLarsen said:
Compared to what?? He/she doesn't know.
One might surmise here that T'ai doesn't even fully understand the meaning of "blind." Perhaps he has confused it with Bethke blind, which means "to have one's eyes closed while in the midst of raucous, derisive laughter."
 
Posted by voidx

Oh Please. Pervayer of horribly stereotypical bad skeptic parodies. If you're giving shout outs to Towelie for his above post then I suppose we can no longer expect you to complain too loudly about the horribly vague definitions of "woo-woo's" anymore then hmmm. 6 of one, half dozen of the other as they say.
C'mon, voidx. Don't you ever laugh right out loud at some of his remarks? I'm not saying every single comment is a gem, but I think he -does- often create quite an accurate portrait of a narrow minded, skeptical dogmatist in action. None of his characterization seems familiar to you? Really? Because it often rings very true to me--which is why its so funny!

Plus he's very inventive. He doesn't just repeat the same old sentences over and over (though, as the skeptics he parodies do, of course, there is some of that, too). "Rational" puts a lot of thought into his posts and he's very creative!

If someone went to a comparable "believer board" and parodied what they were saying (as he does, mocking the way of thinking, not just going in and insulting individual believers)...and he could do it as cleverly as !XxRationalxX! does here....well, I'd say....more power to them! :)
 
Clancie, what other one-dimensional comics do you enjoy? Jerry Lewis?
 
Clancie said:
C'mon, voidx. Don't you ever laugh right out loud at some of his remarks? I'm not saying every single comment is a gem, but I think he -does- often create quite an accurate portrait of a narrow minded, skeptical dogmatist in action. None of his characterization seems familiar to you? Really? Because it often rings very true to me--which is why its so funny!

Plus he's very inventive. He doesn't just repeat the same old sentences over and over (though, as the skeptics he parodies do, of course, there is some of that, too). "Rational" puts a lot of thought into his posts and he's very creative!

If someone went to a comparable "believer board" and parodied what they were saying (as he does, mocking the way of thinking, not just going in and insulting individual believers)...and he could do it as cleverly as !XxRationalxX! does here....well, I'd say....more power to them! :)

Clancie,

Has anyone told you what "schadenfreude" means? It seems that you will applaud anyone who tries to make fun of skeptics, no matter how inane the patter is.

You remind me of a little child who will laugh if her hated teacher really gets hurt from falling down the stairs.
 
TLN said:
Clancie, what other one-dimensional comics do you enjoy? Jerry Lewis?

Hi TLN,

Do you still want to go on a date with Clancie? Well now you know what you must do! ;)

Unless you're already doing it! :eek: LOL
 
Interesting Ian said:
Hi TLN,

Do you still want to go on a date with Clancie? Well now you know what you must do! ;)

Unless you're already doing it! :eek: LOL

Sure, I'd still do that. :)

What are you saying, if I'm a one-note comic I'll be in for sure? :)
 
BillHoyt said:

Uh, no. Try again.

So please enlighten us all Bill (you won't), what was flawed in what I said?

(Note: I don't think there was a flaw, but I do think you don't know what you are talking about)
 
Tai Chi is so dense that he will not admit defeat. That's about the gist of it all. So, I suggest following my actions. I am going to place him on my ignore list. It worked when he was Whodini, it's bound to work again. If enough people ignore him, he'll have no one to annoy.
 
CFLarsen said:

Compared to what?? He/she doesn't know.


He/she doesn't know what??? All he/she/they doesn't know is which study participants are in which comparison group.

You can still easily analyze data without knowing which group they are coded for. And you can compare computed statistics to statistics that would be obtained by chance. This is basic.

If we are studying two groups, those who drink coffee and those who don't, and we do a triple blind study where we measure each of their blood pressures, if I give you, the statistician, the data as
(made up numbers)

Group 1
97
345
55
58
87
234
56
78
54

Group 2
45
678
34
23
23
56
87
23
58
45

You can perform all of your standard statistical tests and report the results. No problem. No issue whatsoever. The group (and possibly other) information has simply not been made available to you.
 
T'ai Chi said:


So please enlighten us all Bill (you won't), what was flawed in what I said?

(Note: I don't think there was a flaw, but I do think you don't know what you are talking about)
I've already quoted it, sir. You seem to think that triple blinding involves someone to do the statistical analysis. That someone needs to have the raw data to score. That requires that the blinds be removed prior to scoring. Your statistical evaluator is not blind and has added nothing to the degree of protocol blinding.
 
BillHoyt said:

One might surmise here that T'ai doesn't even fully understand the meaning of "blind." Perhaps he has confused it with Bethke blind, which means "to have one's eyes closed while in the midst of raucous, derisive laughter."

More attacking a person instead of issues...
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom