Cold Reading Demos at TAM2

T'ai Chi said:


So please enlighten us all Bill (you won't), what was flawed in what I said?

(Note: I don't think there was a flaw, but I do think you don't know what you are talking about)
I've already quoted it, sir. You seem to think that triple blinding involves someone to do the statistical analysis. That someone needs to have the raw data to score. That requires that the blinds be removed prior to scoring. Your statistical evaluator is not blind and has added nothing to the degree of protocol blinding.
 
thaiboxerken said:
Tai Chi is so dense that he will not admit defeat. That's about the gist of it all. So, I suggest following my actions. I am going to place him on my ignore list. It worked when he was Whodini, it's bound to work again. If enough people ignore him, he'll have no one to annoy.

TBK, I could really care less what you do, and what you tell others to do. I'm not intersted in debating with people who try to legislate the truth or use bully tactics to present their side of things anyway.

If you or anyone has a flawed argument, or claims one of my arguments is flawed, be prepared to present evidence/intellectually defend yourself. If you jokingly make fun of me or use some bullying tactic to make yourself look good and me look bad, don't be so shocked or sensitive when you get some your own methods thrown back your way by myself or by others. If you dish it, be prepared to take it.

So far, I've attempted to educate on what triple blind means, and am doing a pretty good job. I've only had people poke fun at me so far, probably for things I've said on other threads. These people don't stick to the issues and are pretty easy to spot. The less the merrier.

As for admitting defeat, yeah, I have no problems doing that if that is the case. In this case, it is most certainly not. And, for what it is worth, I don't view debate as a zero sum game.
 
BillHoyt said:

That someone needs to have the raw data to score. That requires that the blinds be removed prior to scoring. Your statistical evaluator is not blind and has added nothing to the degree of protocol blinding.

Um, the statistician is blind to the knowledge of the assignment of the groups. This does add something to the experiment if you stop to think about it.

If you, the statistician, are analyzing the data, you are essentially reporting a p-value and making a decision. P-values have cutoffs as you know. Get small and they are 'statistically significant' and there is therefore a statistically significant difference between groups. If the statistician was partial to one group, he may favor a particular method or interpretation (consciously but probably mostly unconsciously) whihc in turn could make the p-values smaller or larger, this changing the outcome, as an example. Analyzing the data blind overcomes this possible scenario.

By labelling the groups Group 1 and Group 2, the evaluator is blind to which of these groups had the coffee, and which didn't. After the statistican analyzes the blind data, and is completely done, then and only then the group information is coded back in.

Get it?
 
T'ai Chi said:
If we are studying two groups, those who drink coffee and those who don't, and we do a triple blind study where we measure each of their blood pressures, if I give you, the statistician...

But, as a statistician, I would still need to know what I am comparing these numbers to. Numbers themselves mean nothing, you have to know what they refer to.

In your own example, I would need to know what the average blood pressure for "normal" people was. It is not enough just to compare coffee-drinkers to non-coffee-drinkers: You would have to take into account that anyone in any of the groups could have a high or low blood pressure. You have to compare against "normality" to see if there is an effect. You cannot find that from your example. To use your datasets the way you suggest is very bad research.

(Incidentally, blood pressure is not just one number, it is two: Systolic pressure and diastolic pressure.)

Try again with another example: How does triple-blinding work?

I can understand if you feel a little desperate by now.

T'ai Chi said:
TBK, I could really care less what you do, and what you tell others to do. I'm not intersted in debating with people who try to legislate the truth or use bully tactics to present their side of things anyway.

Aw, poor baybeh....
crybaby.gif


T'ai Chi said:
If you or anyone has a flawed argument, or claims one of my arguments is flawed, be prepared to present evidence/intellectually defend yourself.

I just did.

T'ai Chi said:
If you jokingly make fun of me or use some bullying tactic to make yourself look good and me look bad, don't be so shocked or sensitive when you get some your own methods thrown back your way by myself or by others. If you dish it, be prepared to take it.

Please confine this tit-for-tat behavior to your playground.

T'ai Chi said:
So far, I've attempted to educate on what triple blind means, and am doing a pretty good job. I've only had people poke fun at me so far, probably for things I've said on other threads. These people don't stick to the issues and are pretty easy to spot. The less the merrier.

Actually, you are doing a piss-poor job.

Now, please try again.
 
Ladewig said:


You are right. In a group of 400, it is not that impressive. My point is that even though I knew the numbers involved and even though I knew that nothing paranormal was taking place, I still had a strong emotional response. I can now see how easy it is to get caught up in the things mentalists say.

Not impressive at all, I'd say. I find that I've moved about every 8 years or so. That means that for about 1.5 years out of 8, I'm thinking about house fixing and moving stuff.

In a room of 400? Um, that's a many of manys at least.
 
TLN said:


Sure, I'd still do that. :)

What are you saying, if I'm a one-note comic I'll be in for sure? :)

How come you want to go on a date with her? What is appealing about her to you? Do you know what she looks like?
 
Interesting Ian said:
How come you want to go on a date with her? What is appealing about her to you? Do you know what she looks like?

I never said it was a "date", I asked her to dinner once. And what difference does it make what someone looks like?
 
Larson,

You’re obsessive but too soft of a skeptic overall! You need to be more aggressive with your tactics! Now do a paper on skeptiscientisuperioristism in SR dammit! Or be a skeptical outcast!
 
jj said:
Not impressive at all, I'd say. I find that I've moved about every 8 years or so. That means that for about 1.5 years out of 8, I'm thinking about house fixing and moving stuff.

In a room of 400? Um, that's a many of manys at least.

Oh, yeah....

In Denmark, the average Dane moves once every 6 years throughout his life. It takes about two years or so from "let's look for a house" to "we're settled in our new home". Although buying/selling a home in Denmark takes considerably less time than in the US (do not get me started!), we spend a lot more on our homes than Americans do.

Anyway: You do the math.

"I see someone in a new home" is one of the lamest examples of cold reading. That anyone can claim this as an example of ADC is not only the height of gullibility, it is also incredibly ludicrous.


!Xx+-Rational-+xX! said:
Larson,

You’re obsessive but too soft of a skeptic overall! You need to be more aggressive with your tactics! Now do a paper on skeptiscientisuperioristism in SR dammit! Or be a skeptical outcast!

This is "funny"?

And it is "Larsen". Incredible how some people can't read.
 
CFLars[b]o[/b]n said:
This is "funny"?

And it is "Larsen". Incredible how some people can't read.

No it's the truth! You let the believers off too easy and your tactics are soft! Make more hardcore personal attacks and turn your questioning into interrogations! We aren’t going to win the war against irrationality if we start going soft on the believers! Larson is better so that's what I will call you!
 
CFLarsen said:

But, as a statistician, I would still need to know what I am comparing these numbers to. Numbers themselves mean nothing, you have to know what they refer to.


The numbers you calculate are numbers that refer to Group 1 and Group 2. As far as how to determine if the numbers are statistically significant, that is easy, and is standard statistical procedure. You have heard of p-values right?


In your own example, I would need to know what the average blood pressure for "normal" people was.


Sure... there are still no problems. Triple blinding means the evaluator is not made aware of group membership.


It is not enough just to compare coffee-drinkers to non-coffee-drinkers: You would have to take into account that anyone in any of the groups could have a high or low blood pressure.


Sure, whatever. This was just a quick example to present the concept of triple blind and hiding group membership information from the evaluator. Other details of the experiment/analysis are of course up for debate as usual.


To use your datasets the way you suggest is very bad research.


You cannot be serious and claim to gauge my research level from a quick example I made up in 2 second with fake numbers to simply illustrate what blinding group membership means. :rolleyes:


(Incidentally, blood pressure is not just one number, it is two: Systolic pressure and diastolic pressure.)


No kidding (I think I'd also know that blood pressures cannot be as high or low as some of them were). Again, note that I said I made up numbers. Understand, not only read, what I wrote next time and save our fingers some typing.


Try again with another example: How does triple-blinding work?


Yawn. I've told you, bully.


I can understand if you feel a little desperate by now.


I don't think you understand much in this thread.


Please confine this tit-for-tat behavior to your playground.


Since I'm using your list nonsense, I'll see you at the playground. I claim the slide though.
 
TLN said:


I never said it was a "date", I asked her to dinner once. And what difference does it make what someone looks like?

Well, whether one is attracted to a person normally involves a complex interplay of personality and physical appearance.

I mean, despite my wonderful personality, you wouldn't ask me out to dinner would you? LOL I hope! :eek:
 
T'ai Chi said:
Yes, but you're not going to like it. This absolutely confirms my earlier comment that you do not understand what blinding means. That would be the one you dismissed as "attacking the person." I now reiterate it and say to you it is "describing the person."
Um, the statistician is blind to the knowledge of the assignment of the groups. This does add something to the experiment if you stop to think about it.

If you, the statistician, are analyzing the data, you are essentially reporting a p-value and making a decision. P-values have cutoffs as you know. Get small and they are 'statistically significant' and there is therefore a statistically significant difference between groups. If the statistician was partial to one group, he may favor a particular method or interpretation (consciously but probably mostly unconsciously) whihc in turn could make the p-values smaller or larger, this changing the outcome, as an example. Analyzing the data blind overcomes this possible scenario.

By labelling the groups Group 1 and Group 2, the evaluator is blind to which of these groups had the coffee, and which didn't. After the statistican analyzes the blind data, and is completely done, then and only then the group information is coded back in.
No, the statistician adds nothing. The blinding question has no bearing on either the numeric result or the interpretation of said result. If you had the advanced statistics degree you claim, you would have learned that years ago, sir. It is one of the first things taught in any Introduction to Experimental Design course. The statistics to be collected, the type of distribution assumed, the exact test and the p-value cut-off are supposed to be determined up front. Before the first datum is collected. Period. If you have had any course in experimental design, go back and spank your teacher for having made this preposterous post.

At the point the statistician examines the data, the data have already been collected, sir. There is no information to breech the chinese wall. A blind can only be claimed when possible forward information flow contamination has been contained.
 
T'ai Chi said:
The numbers you calculate are numbers that refer to Group 1 and Group 2. As far as how to determine if the numbers are statistically significant, that is easy, and is standard statistical procedure. You have heard of p-values right?

Yes, I have.

Now, what if the numbers were temperatures? The statistician does not know what the numbers mean. You keep avoiding this issue.

What does he compare them to?

T'ai Chi said:
Sure... there are still no problems. Triple blinding means the evaluator is not made aware of group membership.

Stop. There are problems. Where, in your example, do you present the average blood pressure data?

Are you going to tell me, that you will now add to your setup? That is, changing it?

T'ai Chi said:
Sure, whatever. This was just a quick example to present the concept of triple blind and hiding group membership information from the evaluator. Other details of the experiment/analysis are of course up for debate as usual.

Nice evasion. You give an example, and when it is explained that it is thoroughly inadequate, you deem it "a quick example".

If you have a thoroughly adequate example, please let us know.

T'ai Chi said:
You cannot be serious and claim to gauge my research level from a quick example I made up in 2 second with fake numbers to simply illustrate what blinding group membership means. :rolleyes:

No? When I ask for examples, I am not asking for sloppiness. If I had not made that clear before, then I apologize. I just took it for granted that you would also regard this discussion as a serious one, and not one that is a mockery.

My bad.

T'ai Chi said:
No kidding (I think I'd also know that blood pressures cannot be as high or low as some of them were). Again, note that I said I made up numbers. Understand, not only read, what I wrote next time and save our fingers some typing.

I was not referring to the specific numbers, but to the fact that:

1) You did not know how blood pressure was measured.
2) You had no idea in what range a blood pressure would be.

All in all, you had no idea what you were doing.

T'ai Chi said:
Yawn. I've told you, bully.

"Bully"? You have not "told" me, you have come up with an entirely inadequate and flawed example that does not explain what triple-blind is.

Could it be that you simply don't know?

T'ai Chi said:
I don't think you understand much in this thread.

Of course, when cornered, just claim that people are stupid.

T'ai Chi said:
Since I'm using your list nonsense, I'll see you at the playground. I claim the slide though.

My "list nonsense"? What, in my lists, are "nonsense"? Please be specific.

Let's try again:

How does triple-blinding work?
 
I may be wrong about this, but I thought the way Schwartz used "triple blind" was that the sitters didn't know who the mediums were, the mediums didn't know who the sitters were, and the test administrator didn't know which medium and which sitter were involved in which readings.
 
Clancie said:
I may be wrong about this, but I thought the way Schwartz used "triple blind" was that the sitters didn't know who the mediums were, the mediums didn't know who the sitters were, and the test administrator didn't know which medium and which sitter were involved in which readings.

With the scoring still being sitter-centric, immediately breaking the blind? That degenerates to single blind at best. There are ways around this problem, but they all include test procedures that Schwartz, to my knowledege, has ignored.
 
Clancie said:

C'mon, voidx. Don't you ever laugh right out loud at some of his remarks? I'm not saying every single comment is a gem, but I think he -does- often create quite an accurate portrait of a narrow minded, skeptical dogmatist in action. None of his characterization seems familiar to you? Really? Because it often rings very true to me--which is why its so funny!

Plus he's very inventive. He doesn't just repeat the same old sentences over and over (though, as the skeptics he parodies do, of course, there is some of that, too). "Rational" puts a lot of thought into his posts and he's very creative!

If someone went to a comparable "believer board" and parodied what they were saying (as he does, mocking the way of thinking, not just going in and insulting individual believers)...and he could do it as cleverly as !XxRationalxX! does here....well, I'd say....more power to them! :)
Sure I admit, the first few time towelie weighed in with his "insights" I grinned at how utterly absurd he was in his parody of stereotypical dogmatist skeptics. But after the first couple posts he got old really fast. And the fact that his post count now measures in the hundreds I can only shake my head. Sure his characterization seems familiar if you take the utter extreme side of dogmatic skepticism. But he doesn't at all resemble any of the skeptics here that I consider open-minded and even-handed. Its like me going to a "believer board" and constructing an absurd parody character on the most extreme and absurd version of the "typical wacko woo-woo". Sure its kind of clever the first few times, but its hardly genius.

And with all due respect he does repeat the same sentences over and over again. "Skeptics and their superior intellect, Science is all, show it in Science or go home, Science and materialism are proven beyond a doubt, beat believers over the head by any means necessary to enlighten them with our superior science materialism, blah blah blah" Insert new adjectives here and here, and add the topic of the day here and hooray, its a new towelie post.

But hey, if you think he's comedy gold because his absurd parody reminds you of your least favorite skeptics Larsen, Hoyt, and TBK go right ahead. I simply reserve the right to disagree with you :).
 
Posted by Bill Hoyt

With the scoring still being sitter-centric, immediately breaking the blind?
Well, scoring is subjective, but how does it break the blind? The sitter -has- to score his/her own readings. There's no way around it (although personally I think the subjectivity of scoring, although unavoidable, is a problem in any mediumship testing).
That degenerates to single blind at best.
Why? "Medium blind to sitters...sitters blind to mediums....administrator unaware of who did what...." Why is that single blind at best?
There are ways around this problem, but they all include test procedures that Schwartz, to my knowledege, has ignored.
I'd be interested to read your list of what they are.
 
Posted by voidx

Sure I admit, the first few time towelie weighed in with his "insights" I grinned at how utterly absurd he was in his parody of stereotypical dogmatist skeptics. But after the first couple posts he got old really fast. And the fact that his post count now measures in the hundreds I can only shake my head. Sure his characterization seems familiar if you take the utter extreme side of dogmatic skepticism.
Well, I think that's the point.
But he doesn't at all resemble any of the skeptics here that I consider open-minded and even-handed.
True. So....? :confused:
Its like me going to a "believer board" and constructing an absurd parody character on the most extreme and absurd version of the "typical wacko woo-woo". Sure its kind of clever the first few times, but its hardly genius.
I've read some efforts like that (looking for blue fairies...pink unicorns...etc. etc.) I've never seen one done as well as Xx-Rational-xX!'s...primarily because they mock them for things that they don't seem to actually believe. XxRationalxX's characterization -does- ring true for a certain type of skeptic. Capturing that point of view isn't easy! (Try it for mocking believers and you'll see! He's got the lingo down so well that there have been some posters who responded to him here as a fellow skeptic, lol.)

But hey, if you think he's comedy gold because his absurd parody reminds you of your least favorite skeptics Larsen, Hoyt, and TBK go right ahead.
Just for the record, I never said they reminded me of anyone in particular--only the most narrow-minded and dogmatic people in the "skeptic spectrum". You're the one who supplied these particular names (on my behalf, but..no mind reading allowed!) :)
 
Clancie said:
I may be wrong about this, but I thought the way Schwartz used "triple blind" was that the sitters didn't know who the mediums were, the mediums didn't know who the sitters were, and the test administrator didn't know which medium and which sitter were involved in which readings.

Whoa, back up a second.

Where did Schwartz use "triple blind"??

Surely not in any experiment described in his book.

There were serious leaks between sitters, mediums and experimenters.

In some cases, the sitters knew the mediums.

In one case, Schwartz used himself as a sitter.

I don't expect you to answer these points, because they are very inconvenient to your beliefs. But try anyway.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom