Cold Reading Demos at TAM2

Clancie said:
Well, I think that's the point.
And my point is that I don't consider most of the honest skeptics here to be anywhere near that dogmatic.

True. So....? :confused:
So I'm merely pointing out that I don't have much sympathy for those that decry the stereotypical labelling of "woo-woo" when they say it doesn't apply to them, but then have a good ole knee slapping at the antics of our Towelie friend when he does the same.

I've read some efforts like that (looking for blue fairies...pink unicorns...etc. etc.) I've never seen one done as well as Xx-Rational-xX!'s...primarily because they mock them for things that they don't seem to actually believe. XxRationalxX's characterization -does- ring true for a certain type of skeptic. Capturing that point of view isn't easy! (Try it for mocking believers and you'll see! He's got the lingo down so well that there have been some posters who responded to him here as a fellow skeptic, lol.)
Just like most honest skeptics don't actually believe so dogmatically that science and materialism are the only answer and that they are proven beyond a doubt. We argue that they merely make the most sense. Mocked for things we don't actually believe...see my point. But that doesn't really bother me at all because for as much as we get blamed for unfairly labelling others, it happens just as often to us in return. So Towelie has just found a new angle, on an already common occurance. Except now its not new anymore cuz he's beaten it to death :).

Just for the record, I never said they reminded me of anyone in particular--only the most narrow-minded and dogmatic people in the "skeptic spectrum". You're the one who supplied these particular names (on my behalf, but..no mind reading allowed!) :)
I know you didn't. And no mind reading required. One merely has to observe the obvious. :)
 
Clancie said:
Just for the record, I never said they reminded me of anyone in particular--only the most narrow-minded and dogmatic people in the "skeptic spectrum". You're the one who supplied these particular names (on my behalf, but..no mind reading allowed!) :)

It is far easier to make a sweeping accusation, pointing your finger at nobody in "particular", than having the guts to fess up who really ticked you off.

Same procedure as in Germany, 1934.
 
CFLarsen said:
It is far easier to make a sweeping accusation, pointing your finger at nobody in "particular", than having the guts to fess up who really ticked you off.

Same procedure as in Germany, 1934.

Which you do constantly Clancie. Name names or stop being such a bigoted coward.
 
voidx,

As long as there are skeptical fanatics posting frequently on this board.... people who use "skepticism" as a tool to (1) misrepresent their "opponents'" ideas, (2) badger people relentlessly, and (3) make personal attacks without any intention of having an honest discussion on the subject*...then, yes, I think !Xx-Rational-xX! will continue to be, imo, a highly valued member of the JREF community...and someone who is making an excellent contribution to promoting critical thinking (i.e. let the chips fall where they may!)

It's true that most here -aren't- like the stereotype that he mocks. But his comments are, imo, like a Greek chorus to the observations of those who are!

I guess, once again, we can agree to disagree. :)


*edited to add: TLN, all I can say, is this is my definition of the dishonest skeptic. I have my ideas....you have yours. I'm talking about the issue of fanaticism among so-called skeptics. There's no need for name calling and finger-pointing--my point is that !Xx-Rational-xX! is thought-provoking in his parody of these types. (But, perhaps you think no such skeptics exist. Then, we disagree, but...to each his own! )
 
Clancie said:
It's true that most here -aren't- like the stereotype that he mocks. But his comments are, imo, like a Greek chorus to the observations of those who are!

Stereotype implies that most skeptics are like this, which is nonsense.

Name one poster here who fits this mold and tell me why you think that's the case.

Show a little backbone or keep your bigotry to yourself.
 
Clancie said:
voidx,

As long as there are skeptical fanatics posting frequently on this board.... people who use "skepticism" as a tool to (1) misrepresent their "opponents'" ideas, (2) badger people relentlessly, and (3) make personal attacks without any intention of having an honest discussion on the subject...then, yes, I think !Xx-Rational-xX! will continue to be, imo, a highly valued member of the JREF community...and someone who is making an excellent contribution to promoting critical thinking (i.e. let the chips fall where they may!)

It's true that most here -aren't- like the stereotype that he mocks. But his comments are, imo, like a Greek chorus to the observations of those who are!

I guess, once again, we can agree to disagree. :)

Who are these 'skeptical fantatics'? Who are these people who 'use "skepticism" as a tool to (1) misrepresent their "opponents'" ideas, (2) badger people relentlessly, and (3) make personal attacks without any intention of having an honest discussion on the subject?'

Come, now, Clancie: You are very specific here, yet you don't have the guts to name them.

Name them, you coward!
 
Posted by TLN

Show a little backbone or keep your bigotry to yourself.
You have a hard time with this idea, I realize, but I'm entitled to an opinion that, yes, fanatical "skeptics" exist. I don't have to give you a list of names, nor do I have to shut up in my opinion--or in my appreciation of !Xx-Rational's-xX! contribution to thought-provoking discussion.

It's not your board, TLN, so just put me on "Ignore" if you find my "bigotry" so offends your sensibility. Or, please, report it to a moderator.

If James Randi, not you, finds that my opinions violate his goal of "intelligent discussion among believers and non-believers" then Hal can PM me and I'll leave. Until then, I'm entitled to my opinions on the issue of good vs. bad skepticism (not individual personalities)....and I'll continue to express my ideas about this whenever I feel like it.
 
Clancie said:

You have a hard time with this idea, I realize, but I'm entitled to an opinion that, yes, fanatical "skeptics" exist. I don't have to give you a list of names, nor do I have to shut up in my opinion--or in my appreciation of !Xx-Rational's-xX! contribution to thought-provoking discussion.

It's not your board, TLN, so just put me on "Ignore" if you find my "bigotry" so offends your sensibility. Or, please, report it to a moderator.

If James Randi, not you, finds that my opinions violate his goal of "intelligent discussion among believers and non-believers" then Hal can PM me and I'll leave. Until then, I'm entitled to my opinions on the issue of good vs. bad skepticism (not individual personalities....and I'll continue to express my ideas about this whenever I feel like it.

Well said Clancie! :)

And keep up the good work "!Xx+-Rational-+xX!"! :)
 
Clancie said:

You have a hard time with this idea, I realize, but I'm entitled to an opinion that, yes, fanatical "skeptics" exist. I don't have to give you a list of names, nor do I have to shut up in my opinion--or in my appreciation of !Xx-Rational's-xX! contribution to thought-provoking discussion.

It's not your board, TLN, so just put me on "Ignore" if you find my "bigotry" so offends your sensibility. Or, please, report it to a moderator.

If James Randi, not you, finds that my opinions violate his goal of "intelligent discussion among believers and non-believers" then Hal can PM me and I'll leave. Until then, I'm entitled to my opinions on the issue of good vs. bad skepticism (not individual personalities)....and I'll continue to express my ideas about this whenever I feel like it.

Precisely what I’ve come to expect form you Clancie: a completely unsubstantiated belief which you won’t explore of evaluate on any level.

Why do you even bother going through the motions?
 
Interesting Ian said:


Well said Clancie! :)

And keep up the good work "!Xx+-Rational-+xX!"! :)

Do you always congratulate yourself when you are pleased with your handiwork, Ian? Either in print or aloud, that is.
 
Clancie, let me show you how this should work (actual opinion follows):

James Randi is a complete jackass who does the cause of skepticism a disservice with his constant insulting and belittling of the very people he claims to want to "reach."

See? That wasn’t so hard.
 
TLN said:
James Randi is a complete jackass who does the cause of skepticism a disservice with his constant insulting and belittling of the very people he claims to want to "reach."

Blasphemy!

Even in a joke we should avoid talking negatively about our great material minded leader known as Mr. James Randi of the James Randi Educational Foundation which provides reliable information on rubbish claims!

I wish he would answer my PM and tell us about some of his epic journeys where he fought against woo-woos!!!
 
!Xx+-Rational-+xX! said:
Blasphemy!

Even in a joke we should avoid talking negatively about our great material minded leader known as Mr. James Randi of the James Randi Educational Foundation which provides reliable information on rubbish claims!

I wish he would answer my PM and tell us about some of his epic journeys where he fought against woo-woos!!!

It wasn't a joke, it's my actual opinion.

You're a joke, and not in a good funny way, but in a sad absurd way. Do you think this terrible, terrible parody is funny? Why not tell us who you really are?

Why are all you believers cowards (hey, since we're stereotyping here)?
 
It wasn't a joke, it's my actual opinion.

I hope it is! This can’t be happening! Why would a skeptic want to insult MJROTJREF!?

You're a joke, and not in a good funny way, but in a sad absurd way. Do you think this terrible, terrible parody is funny? Why not tell us who you really are?

As I’ve been ranting about it’s no joke I’m out to save science from those who go against materialism with their clear delusions!

Why are all you believers cowards (hey, since we're stereotyping here)?

That’s just the way those feeble minded individuals called believers are!!!
 
Posted by TLN

TLN quoting CFLarsen:

It is far easier to make a sweeping accusation, pointing your finger at nobody in "particular", than having the guts to fess up who really ticked you off.

Same procedure as in Germany, 1934.


TLN: Which you do constantly Clancie. Name names or stop being such a bigoted coward.
TLN,

The fact that you think Claus makes a good comparison between my comments above and what the Nazi's procedures were in Germany in 1934 says it all. :rolleyes:
 
!Xx+-Rational-+xX! said:
Mr. James Randi ...I wish he would answer my PM and tell us about some of his epic journeys where he fought against woo-woos!!!
Mr. Randi is very buzy right now on a long journey slapping the cheeks and buttocks of pseudomaterialist cypto-Nazi silly breeks like you with a Pike, named Bishop. Anglican, like Usher.
 
Clancie said:
The fact that you think Claus makes a good comparison between my comments above and what the Nazi's procedures were in Germany in 1934 says it all. :rolleyes:

Frankly, I think that was going a little too far (see, fearless), but you're still stereotyping without referring to anyone directly. You're both bigoted and cowardly. Sorry.
 
Clancie,

I'm not a statistician or scientist so perhaps I do not fully understand the technical meaning of "blinding," but I do not consider the Schwartz experiments blinded in any meaningful way.

Separate from the much-discussed holes in security (gap in the screen, etc.), there are these simple facts:

1. The mediums received responses from the sitters, and knew the sitters were all either believers or people who wanted to believe.

2. The sitters knew that each medium claimed to be legitimate; there were no admitted fakes, and the sitters knew this. In one instance, despite Schwartz's claim that there was no communication between sitter and medium, he let George Anderson give introductory comments. Since you've read The Full Facts Book of Cold Reading you understand how important this can be in setting the tone and getting a cooperative sitter. Interestingly, this one reading is the one Schwartz considered perhaps the most successful of all (except maybe for the telephone reading by Laurie Campbell), and it is the only one for which he gives a full transcript except for the introductory comments themselves, which he leaves out. I wonder why.


3. The test administrator(s) most definitely did know when each sitter went with each medium. They were in the rooms. In one of the experiments, in an attempt to (ostensibly) prevent feedback from the sitters, the administrator(s) watched the sitter nod "yes" or "no" to questions from the medium and then voiced those answers themselves to the medium.


Do you really think this was a blinded experiment?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom