Cold Reading Demos at TAM2

Erasmus Montanus is a play by the Danish/Norwegian playwright Ludvig Holberg, written in 1723. The subject of the comedy is education - what do we need it for? This was written in the Age of Enlightenment, and Holberg creates a number of very funny characters, each designed to hold various views.

The leading character is a young man, Rasmus Berg. He has studied at the university, and is coming home to his family. He thinks that the height of education is to win a "dispute" (discussion). He is so infatuated with his own knowledge, that he insists on being called "Erasmus Montanus" - latin for his name. Latin was, in those days, the language of education.

He can use logic anyway he sees fit, and one of the key scenes is where he "proves" that his own mother is a stone.

Erasmus: "A stone cannot fly."
Mother: "That is the truth, unless one throws it."
Erasmus: "You cannot fly."
Mother: "That is the truth."
Erasmus: "Ergo, is Mother a stone?"
(The mother begins to cry)
Erasmus: "Why does Mother cry?"
Mother: "Oh, I am so afraid that I am turning into a stone, I can feel my legs go cold!"
Erasmus: "Be satisfied, Mother, I shall at once make you into a human again. A stone cannot think or speak."
Mother: "That is the truth. I don't know if I can think, but speak, I cannot!"
Erasmus: "Mother can speak."
Mother: "Yes, thank God, like a poor peasant wife, I can speak!"
Erasmus: "Good. Ergo, Mother is no stone."

Erasmus is later in trouble, because he finds himself up against someone who has both studied and is smart.

Ian is an "Erasmus Montanus."
 
CFLarsen said:
He can use logic anyway he sees fit, and one of the key scenes is where he "proves" that his own mother is a stone.

Wow, classic! What an exellent example that sums up all things Ian.
 
CFLarsen said:

So, where are they?


Already told you in last post.


You do not decide what is the "topic". If you bring something up, that can be the topic.


When I in fact bring up the topic of what Schwartz said, I do decide the topic.


You call that "reading a book"?? It is 364 pages, with some pretty densely written appendices.


Yes, I do. I said I read it. I read it in its entirely. I read it. I read it about 30 or so pages at a time. You cannot say that I didn't read it. I remember it being more near 400 pages.


No, you did not.


That is a wrong. In response to your "Did you read the transcripts and the analyses?" question I already said: "Yes, and you're not addressing...", so again I answered you that YES I did read them.


Because you have not answered them.


Wrong.


Show me the definition of "triple blinding".


That is not answering the question of "Do you feel that triple-blinding makes sense?" Claus, but you know that...


Who claims that Schwartz says he believes in the Tooth Fairy?


Yawn.


You are moving the goal posts. Now, it is not merely deliberate fraud in parapsychology.


You have failed to address the question.


Depends on what "SI" is. Do you mean Skeptical Inquirer?


Of course, so answer the question please.


I'm sorry, I prefer to deal with actual quotes in context, instead of your paraphrasings.


You read the entire thread I refer to.


I cannot see why these two are exclusive. Please explain why.


You did not answer the question.


What skeptic of telepathy are we talking about? I cannot answer, until I know how the presentation was devised.


Again, you read the thread I refer to.


You'll have to ask BillHoyt for his statistical credentials.


Evade. I am asking YOU what YOU think on the issue, hence me asking YOU a question. Replace the name "BillHoyt" with any name you like.


Are physical objects always changing? In what ways?


You know very well you don't answer questions by asking questions.


Perhaps you could make an effort to distinguish between your beef with me, and your (many, it seems) beef with others?

You answered a couple questions, but you didn't answer more. I don't have any beefs, just engaging in a little turn about is fair play here.

Lists are fun aren't they?
 
T'ai Chi,

It is obvious that you have no intention of discussing honestly. It is obvious that you do not answer questions. It is obvious that you have no answers.

You are nothing but a troll. A very boring one, too, as well as one of very little intelligence. You treat serious issues as if they were merely toys, and complain when you are not taken seriously.
 
So, getting back to your original question, Claus:

The "difference", is that cold readers will not replicate under the same conditions as John.

why is that, Claus?
 
Lucianarchy said:
So, getting back to your original question, Claus:

The "difference", is that cold readers will not replicate under the same conditions as John.

why is that, Claus?

I'm sorry, I don't recall asking that "original" question. Perhaps you can show me where?

And, while we are at the questions, please answer the questions in the thread "Questions for Lucianarchy"
 
CFLarsen said:
T'ai Chi,

It is obvious that you have no intention of discussing honestly. It is obvious that you do not answer questions. It is obvious that you have no answers.

You are nothing but a troll. A very boring one, too, as well as one of very little intelligence. You treat serious issues as if they were merely toys, and complain when you are not taken seriously.

Saved for posterity.

You still have some questions to answer.

Someone doesn't like the taste of their own medicine....
 
The "difference", is that cold readers will not replicate under the same conditions as John.

why is that, Claus?


You mean in a staged environment in which the replays can be editted to depict factual or fictional stories? Cold readers have and do replicate this. If you watch Penn and Teller's BS, it was done very nicely on one of their episodes.
 
T'ai Chi said:
Saved for posterity.

You still have some questions to answer.

Someone doesn't like the taste of their own medicine....

Oh, please! :rolleyes:

You want to drag me into your beef with other people, you cannot even define what you are asking about, and you invent problems, so you can create a list of questions for me?

Try to take this a bit more seriously, kiddo. Or is this just a game to you? A droll pastime, in which you try to pit your wits against other people here?

If so, you fail miserably. If not, try to stick to the serious issues.

I have no time for your childish games. You are nothing but a troll. If you want to create a list of questions, at least come up with something else than this tripe.
 
NoZed Avenger said:


Frankly, I have a hard time taking that opinion seriously. Do you actually hold that opinion, or are you just throwing out stuff to provoke responses?

Banachek did some absolutely amazing mentalism at the meeting. I am a hobbyist and have followed magic for more than 15 years now. I have numerous books, belong to 2 magic organziations, have done shows for money. I don't suck at it.

I will tell you now that not only can I not emulate one of the effects from the meeting; I still have no idea how it was done. He did it that well. By your reasoning, since I cannot emulate his performance to the same level, he obviously has spooky magic powers.

Similarly, Jamy Ian Swiss sis an ambitious card routine during the evening. I know several routines for that. While I have not put together a routine, I am familiar with the sleights involved. Even when I cannot see what happened, I can usually reconstruct it.

He either had a move that I have never come across, or did an old move so well that I could not catch him at it, even knowing what to look for. Since I cannot perform his routine, he obviously has been possessed by the devil.

And, while we're at it, why do I suspect that even if someone managed to overcome the problems with trying to follow Schwartz' protocals precisely -- problems noted by Garrette and Marc/Dogwood previosuly, among others -- you'd be one of the first in line saying "Just because it can be done with non-paranormal means doesn't mean that the psychics tested don't have real powers"?

And you know something -- it wouldn't. Any number of magicians bending spoons doesn't actually prove anything conclusive about Geller; any number of successful cold readers don't actually prove anything conclusive about any alleged mediums.

I guess -- since any 'proof' of the negative proposition put forward by the skeptics can be immediately dismissed as non-conclusive -- that its a good thing that the burden of proof remains firmly on the claimant to show that paranormal events or powers exist.

Schwartz' burden. JE's burden. Your burden. Not mine.
 
CFLarsen said:

(snip)
You are nothing but a troll. If you want to create a list of questions, at least come up with something else than this tripe.

You can complain all you want, but you have still not answered several questions.

Just so you know.
 
T'ai Chi said:
You can complain all you want, but you have still not answered several questions.

Just so you know.

But of course I haven't! I am not denying that at all.

But tell me this:

How can I answer a question like "Do you feel that triple-blinding makes sense?", if you cannot even tell me what "triple-blinding" is?

How can I answer a question like "Where did Schwartz say that he believes in the Tooth Fairy?", if you cannot even tell me if anyone claimed that he did?

To pick a few.

Asking questions like that is not very smart, T'ai Chi. It's actually quite stupid.

I really hope you can see that. But I seriously doubt it.
 
Posted by !Xx-Rational-xX!

Skeptics,

To properly crush nonsense we need to resort to lying and making ◊◊◊◊ up, ruthless personal attacks, misrepresenting the opposition’s views, avoiding questions, being vague, running around the issues, stating our opinions as fact, refusing to consider kooks arguments, etc! This may sound dishonest but it doesn’t matter because skeptics are supporting the ultimate proven truth (materialism)! We will resort to anything to defend science and the undeniable view of a physically closed universe with material minds which tend to get gullible!

You can’t have science without materialism!
Dear !Xx-Rational-xX!,

Thank you for sharing your wit and wisdom and brightening up my thread! :)

Sincerely,

Clancie
 
T'ai Chi said:


You can complain all you want, but you have still not answered several questions.

Just so you know.
Look who's talking, you still haven't managed to answer my single question: What is triple blinding? Once you have blinded both participants and the "scientists", who is there left to blind? You still haven't answered this very simple question, unless of course you think it has already been answered adequately by BillHoyt. :D
 
CFLarsen said:

How can I answer a question like "Do you feel that triple-blinding makes sense?", if you cannot even tell me what "triple-blinding" is?


So you haven't heard of triple blinding, ok. Neither did Randi judging by his amazement "whatever that means" in response to Schwartz's use of the term, in this commentary:

http://www.randi.org/jr/03-23-2001.html.

A very quick search yielded this:

http://www.cochrane.dk/cochrane/handbook/hbookTriple_blind.htm


How can I answer a question like "Where did Schwartz say that he believes in the Tooth Fairy?", if you cannot even tell me if anyone claimed that he did?


Read that link too for the Tooth Fairy bit.

Sorry, I thought you read the commentaries.
 
Kerberos said:

Look who's talking, you still haven't managed to answer my single question: What is triple blinding? Once you have blinded both participants and the "scientists", who is there left to blind? You still haven't answered this very simple question, unless of course you think it has already been answered adequately by BillHoyt. :D

No it couldn't have been answered by Bill as it is still very hot where I am.

Anywhoo, a "triple blind" refers to not only blinding the experimenters, and the experimentees, but also the evaluators.

If I'm not near the computer, and you need to know what a word means, you have my permission to go to Google and type it in and press return/enter and read what comes up. ;) ;) ;)
 
T'ai Chi said:

Anywhoo, a "triple blind" refers to not only blinding the experimenters, and the experimentees, but also the evaluators.
Hmmm. I don't quite get it. How can you analyze results for statistical significancy, without knowing what the correct answer is? That information doesn't seem to be avaliable from google.
T'ai Chi said:

If I'm not near the computer, and you need to know what a word means, you have my permission to go to Google and type it in and press return/enter and read what comes up.
I really hate to repeat myself but : "Look who's talking". Let's take a look on one of the question you asked Claus:
T'ai Chi said:

Are there cold readers who are claiming they can fool sitters under Schwartz's experimental conditions?
You don't even have to use Google find the answer to this one. The answer is right here on this very thread. :eek: :eek:
 
T'ai Chi said:
So you haven't heard of triple blinding, ok. Neither did Randi judging by his amazement "whatever that means" in response to Schwartz's use of the term, in this commentary:

http://www.randi.org/jr/03-23-2001.html.

A very quick search yielded this:

http://www.cochrane.dk/cochrane/handbook/hbookTriple_blind.htm

I've heard about it, but I fail to see where the "triple-blind" comes in. Can you please explain how it works?

T'ai Chi said:
Read that link too for the Tooth Fairy bit.

Sorry, I thought you read the commentaries.

I did. A long time ago. There is no direct quote there about tooth fairies.

(I know where it is, though, but I am not doing your homework for you)

All this clearly shows that you do not understand the issues you are talking about, and you have no idea where to find the original quotes. You think you can go by hearsay and by throwing out fancy terms you have no idea what means.

Nice.
 
Clancie said:
Posted by !Xx-Rational-xX!

Skeptics,

To properly crush nonsense we need to resort to lying and making ◊◊◊◊ up, ruthless personal attacks, misrepresenting the opposition’s views, avoiding questions, being vague, running around the issues, stating our opinions as fact, refusing to consider kooks arguments, etc! This may sound dishonest but it doesn’t matter because skeptics are supporting the ultimate proven truth (materialism)! We will resort to anything to defend science and the undeniable view of a physically closed universe with material minds which tend to get gullible!

You can’t have science without materialism!

Clancie
Dear !Xx-Rational-xX!,

Thank you for sharing your wit and wisdom and brightening up my thread!

I agree :) Did you see his post in the Penn thread last night?? Absolutely brilliant!

Hmmmm . . .you seem rather enthralled by him. I wonder if he's your sock puppet? ;) Maybe I should do a poll with all the possible suspects including myself! LOL
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom