Furcifer
Guest
- Joined
- Apr 30, 2007
- Messages
- 13,797
If conclusions can never be reached, because the science isn't "settled", then nothing is ever accomplished for science is never "settled". For science to make any progress conclusions have to be found with the available evidence. Sure, conclusions reached when tomorrow's new evidence is introduced may contradict today's, but if you choose to live by the rule that nothing can be gained from from incomplete science then you're at a stalemate.
If all those bright people who study the topic find that with the existing evidence, even while fully acknowledging the existing unknowns (like unpredictable variables), it suggests a conclusion in support of global warming, how reasonable is it to argue they are wrong because of the acknowledged unknowns?
But that's the thing, conclusions have been reached. Long ago. We need to reduce the amount of CO2 we emit. Short of complete cessation by every country on the planet what can we accomplish without detailed analysis of the measures we are currently taking?
Who are the big offenders and why? If Germany emits 2 kilos of CO2 per person per minute is that the same as Holland emitting 1.5? If Germany can reduce CO2 to 1.5 kilos at a cost of $12000 per person per year, is that as effective as the US reducing from 2.7 to 2.5? (numbers are made up as an example, they are not real, they are only used to make a point)
If we can't say for certain what effect we can have what is the point of enacting or enforcing change? The models aren't detailed enough to assist us in making these decisions. They are coming along nicely, and as I read more of them I am more and more impressed. It won't be long before they are capable of making detailed predictions on the climate.
In the mean time why would we allow ourselves to be led astray by alarmists, activists and politicians? We're in a position of control and this is no time to relinguish it. Foolishly allowing the alarmists to dictate policy, which is their ultimate goal, would be foolish. They need to be able to answer direct questions without ad hom attacks before anyone takes them seriously. Until then they amount to nothing more the doomsday fanatics carrying sandwhich boards proclaiming "The end is near, repent!" and being led by sanctimonious ex politicians who don't practise what they preach.
