Climate change scepticism - its sources and origins

Status
Not open for further replies.
If conclusions can never be reached, because the science isn't "settled", then nothing is ever accomplished for science is never "settled". For science to make any progress conclusions have to be found with the available evidence. Sure, conclusions reached when tomorrow's new evidence is introduced may contradict today's, but if you choose to live by the rule that nothing can be gained from from incomplete science then you're at a stalemate.

If all those bright people who study the topic find that with the existing evidence, even while fully acknowledging the existing unknowns (like unpredictable variables), it suggests a conclusion in support of global warming, how reasonable is it to argue they are wrong because of the acknowledged unknowns?

But that's the thing, conclusions have been reached. Long ago. We need to reduce the amount of CO2 we emit. Short of complete cessation by every country on the planet what can we accomplish without detailed analysis of the measures we are currently taking?

Who are the big offenders and why? If Germany emits 2 kilos of CO2 per person per minute is that the same as Holland emitting 1.5? If Germany can reduce CO2 to 1.5 kilos at a cost of $12000 per person per year, is that as effective as the US reducing from 2.7 to 2.5? (numbers are made up as an example, they are not real, they are only used to make a point)

If we can't say for certain what effect we can have what is the point of enacting or enforcing change? The models aren't detailed enough to assist us in making these decisions. They are coming along nicely, and as I read more of them I am more and more impressed. It won't be long before they are capable of making detailed predictions on the climate.

In the mean time why would we allow ourselves to be led astray by alarmists, activists and politicians? We're in a position of control and this is no time to relinguish it. Foolishly allowing the alarmists to dictate policy, which is their ultimate goal, would be foolish. They need to be able to answer direct questions without ad hom attacks before anyone takes them seriously. Until then they amount to nothing more the doomsday fanatics carrying sandwhich boards proclaiming "The end is near, repent!" and being led by sanctimonious ex politicians who don't practise what they preach.
 
In the mean time why would we allow ourselves to be led astray by alarmists, activists and politicians? We're in a position of control and this is no time to relinguish it. Foolishly allowing the alarmists to dictate policy, which is their ultimate goal, would be foolish. They need to be able to answer direct questions without ad hom attacks before anyone takes them seriously. Until then they amount to nothing more the doomsday fanatics carrying sandwhich boards proclaiming "The end is near, repent!" and being led by sanctimonious ex politicians who don't practise what they preach.

But that hasn't been what I've observed. I've seemed people arguing over whether global warming is real, or whether human's are impacting it, not as much about what should be done about it. The general consensus seems to be a reduction of fossil fuels. Even the opponents seem to agree with that (for the most part), but they still get hung up on arguing that the science of global warming can't be right - I assume out of credulity.

But really, politicians do silly things, but is that a good reason to argue that the science doesn't say what it appears to?
 
3b
such as??
Specifically??

You like grand pronouncements - you do not provide any support for them however.
Nor answer questions put to you about your posts/
Let's see your sources for this accusation :popcorn1

They abound in this thread alone.

The fact is "clouds and cloud formation are not PROPERLY represented in the current climate models"

That gets misrepresented. The alarmists change it to say "What do you mean there are NO CLOUDS in the models? There are plenty" etc. etc.

Obviously SOME of the models incorporate the creation and effects of clouds. But the fact is the scientists acknowledge this as the greatest area of uncertainty. Alarmists do not, they merely lie or misrepresent the facts to detract and steer attention away from the elephant in the room.

I posited the question of how many additional days of cloud cover could reverse the already observed warming.

I then get accused of "denying" AGW. That's a lie. I acknowledge AGW in the above question. Why do I continue to be asked questions under the presumption there is no warming when I clearly acknowledge it? Just another misrepresentation.

The exact same way the creator of the video you cited did. He deliberately overlooked the observed warming by claiming clouds would simply precipitate out without added heat!

This is a result of poor critical thinking skills and reliance on others to do so for them. If the question falls outside a topic someone can't specifically Google and get an answer to they are at a complete loss to formulate one of their own. We saw this with the question of cloud cover, and again it became evident on the discussion of evaporation. If they can't connect the dots for themselves they rely on someone else to do so, short of that they begin misrepresenting the question entirely.
 
In the mean time why would we allow ourselves to be led astray by alarmists, activists and politicians? We're in a position of control and this is no time to relinguish it. Foolishly allowing the alarmists to dictate policy, which is their ultimate goal, would be foolish. They need to be able to answer direct questions without ad hom attacks before anyone takes them seriously. Until then they amount to nothing more the doomsday fanatics carrying sandwhich boards proclaiming "The end is near, repent!" and being led by sanctimonious ex politicians who don't practise what they preach.

Ok, I'm getting tired of you never backing anything up. I'm now calling you out to list what alarmist claims any of us have made that isn't supported by the science.

Also, I would like to hear your infinite wisdom in how much CO2 emission limitation the science supports.
 
But that hasn't been what I've observed. I've seemed people arguing over whether global warming is real, or whether human's are impacting it, not as much about what should be done about it. The general consensus seems to be a reduction of fossil fuels. Even the opponents seem to agree with that (for the most part), but they still get hung up on arguing that the science of global warming can't be right - I assume out of credulity.

But really, politicians do silly things, but is that a good reason to argue that the science doesn't say what it appears to?

But that's just it elbe, the science doesn't say "If you pay $4/liter for petrol and pay 5% more in income tax, along with not mowing your lawn as often and installing motion activated lights the temperature should stabiize in 10 years, with a complete reversal in 25"

Until there is some accountability even the politicians won't say for sure. The only leg they have to stand on is the well established fact that CO2 emissions have to come down. Have you seen anything that establishes a direct relation to what's being done and what effect it will have? I don't think so, because without the models there is little to go on. AR4 comes close, but falls short of directly establishing the effects of mitigation on the climate.
 
They abound in this thread alone.

The fact is "clouds and cloud formation are not PROPERLY represented in the current climate models"

That gets misrepresented. The alarmists change it to say "What do you mean there are NO CLOUDS in the models? There are plenty" etc. etc.

Obviously SOME of the models incorporate the creation and effects of clouds. But the fact is the scientists acknowledge this as the greatest area of uncertainty. Alarmists do not, they merely lie or misrepresent the facts to detract and steer attention away from the elephant in the room.

I posited the question of how many additional days of cloud cover could reverse the already observed warming.

I then get accused of "denying" AGW. That's a lie. I acknowledge AGW in the above question. Why do I continue to be asked questions under the presumption there is no warming when I clearly acknowledge it? Just another misrepresentation.

The exact same way the creator of the video you cited did. He deliberately overlooked the observed warming by claiming clouds would simply precipitate out without added heat!

This is a result of poor critical thinking skills and reliance on others to do so for them. If the question falls outside a topic someone can't specifically Google and get an answer to they are at a complete loss to formulate one of their own. We saw this with the question of cloud cover, and again it became evident on the discussion of evaporation. If they can't connect the dots for themselves they rely on someone else to do so, short of that they begin misrepresenting the question entirely.

I'm tired of your quote-mining as well. Clouds are represented in all climate models. While it is true that they are still the cause of the greatest uncertainty, that is entirely relative to other uncertainties. Best estimates are what we have now, and the say that clouds will probably have a positive effect on temperature trends in the coming century.

You assert that clouds aren't PROPERLY modeled, but you never say what criteria you are using, nor do you explain how to properly model clouds. You seem to believe that you can judge whether scientists are able to properly model clouds when it is obvious that you can't.

The science on this issue is very strong. Strong enough to warrant action to limit emissions. Best estimates regarding future trends is that we have underestimated how fast and severe our climate is changing due to human impact. Your "wait and see" attitude is less grounded in the science and more in ideology.
 
But that's just it elbe, the science doesn't say "If you pay $4/liter for petrol and pay 5% more in income tax, along with not mowing your lawn as often and installing motion activated lights the temperature should stabiize in 10 years, with a complete reversal in 25"

Until there is some accountability even the politicians won't say for sure. The only leg they have to stand on is the well established fact that CO2 emissions have to come down. Have you seen anything that establishes a direct relation to what's being done and what effect it will have? I don't think so, because without the models there is little to go on. AR4 comes close, but falls short of directly establishing the effects of mitigation on the climate.

:hb:

Nations around the world have managed to cut emissions, and plans are in effect that is going to make them carbon neutral by 2050. It works. Why do you keep denying that things can be done and have been done to good effect? Why do you keep asserting that we don't know how to go about combating this issue in the face of evidence to the contrary? This is exactly why we call you a denialist.
 
Ok, I'm getting tired of you never backing anything up. I'm now calling you out to list what alarmist claims any of us have made that isn't supported by the science.

Also, I would like to hear your infinite wisdom in how much CO2 emission limitation the science supports.

Well we'll have to wait until December and beyond for that now won't we? Will this be the hottest year on record? I've heard that bantered about by several people already. But that falls short of climate doesn't it? Does the science support this claim or not? To what extent?

Associating weather to climate is initself a misrepresentation. Is the extent of the ice sheets related to AGW or not? It clearly has been discussed in terms of climate change, so it must be supported by the science right?

Sadly much of this will be hard to determine. I have yet to see a page 1 article on "Record moderate days this Spring". Unless they reach a record high or a low they don't seem to get reported on. So while the alarmists report on sensational changes, we have to wait several years to see if they even out as predicted in the climate models.

As for my infinite wisdom, the science supports and outright ban on CO2 emission yesterday.

My question to you is what can society support in light of the science? Please be specific and don't dodge the question. Thanks.
 
:hb:

Nations around the world have managed to cut emissions, and plans are in effect that is going to make them carbon neutral by 2050. It works. Why do you keep denying that things can be done and have been done to good effect? Why do you keep asserting that we don't know how to go about combating this issue in the face of evidence to the contrary? This is exactly why we call you a denialist.

What nations around the world have managed to cut emissions? The USA, China, India, Pakistan, Japan, you know the big ones, the ones that matter. If China goes up by 10% and all of Africa goes carbon neutral what does that accomplish?

So what if Sweeden and Norway go carbon neutral tomorrow and the US and China go up by 2% instead of 3% at a cost of $200 billion to each right?

If I can go carbon neutral, China can too. Not.
 
I'm tired of your quote-mining as well. Clouds are represented in all climate models. While it is true that they are still the cause of the greatest uncertainty, that is entirely relative to other uncertainties. Best estimates are what we have now, and the say that clouds will probably have a positive effect on temperature trends in the coming century.

You assert that clouds aren't PROPERLY modeled, but you never say what criteria you are using, nor do you explain how to properly model clouds. You seem to believe that you can judge whether scientists are able to properly model clouds when it is obvious that you can't.

The science on this issue is very strong. Strong enough to warrant action to limit emissions. Best estimates regarding future trends is that we have underestimated how fast and severe our climate is changing due to human impact. Your "wait and see" attitude is less grounded in the science and more in ideology.

We have quotes in the lies thread, from both the NOAA and NASA, not to mention members on the AGW side admitting clouds will most likely have a negative effect.

That lack of a cogent narrative here is another reason for growing skepticism.
 
Well we'll have to wait until December and beyond for that now won't we? Will this be the hottest year on record? I've heard that bantered about by several people already. But that falls short of climate doesn't it? Does the science support this claim or not? To what extent?

What has been said, as opposed to the lie you are telling, is that this has been the warmest year so far, and if the trend keeps up, it will be the warmest year on record. The science shows this. Therefore, not alarmism.

Associating weather to climate is initself a misrepresentation.

It is, so why do you denialists keep doing it?

Is the extent of the ice sheets related to AGW or not? It clearly has been discussed in terms of climate change, so it must be supported by the science right?

It is supported by science, yes.

Sadly much of this will be hard to determine. I have yet to see a page 1 article on "Record moderate days this Spring". Unless they reach a record high or a low they don't seem to get reported on. So while the alarmists report on sensational changes, we have to wait several years to see if they even out as predicted in the climate models.

Seriously, why do you keep lying this obviously? Normally, a lie should at least have a modicum of truth to be taken seriously.

For other people like 3body that don't know squat about climate science, we have these things called thermometers. Scientists have been using these things to measure temperature. That's how they know this is an exceptionally warm year thus far. Go to NASA's webpage to read for yourselves, or look for the link in one of these threads.

As for my infinite wisdom, the science supports and outright ban on CO2 emission yesterday.

So why don't you support it?

My question to you is what can society support in light of the science? Please be specific and don't dodge the question. Thanks.

Lol, the irony is thick here, as you have dodged my question all together. I'll repeat it after answering you.

Society can do what some nations already have. Commit to carbon reduction plans. Implement taxation on emissions. Spend more on alternative energy. This has been shown to work.

Now, as you dodged my question, I'll repeat it: What alarmist claim has any of us made that isn't supported by science? Please answer and don't try to dodge the question again.
 
What nations around the world have managed to cut emissions? The USA, China, India, Pakistan, Japan, you know the big ones, the ones that matter. If China goes up by 10% and all of Africa goes carbon neutral what does that accomplish?

So what if Sweeden and Norway go carbon neutral tomorrow and the US and China go up by 2% instead of 3% at a cost of $200 billion to each right?

If I can go carbon neutral, China can too. Not.

Wow, I seriously can't believe the poor logic you spew around. Nations like Sweden and Norway have shown that it is possible to reduce emissions without imploding the economy. Why are you against others following suit? Why do you think us Swedes and Norwegians should carry the full burden - which we cannot do?
 
We have quotes in the lies thread, from both the NOAA and NASA, not to mention members on the AGW side admitting clouds will most likely have a negative effect.

That lack of a cogent narrative here is another reason for growing skepticism.

Show those quotes or retract.
 
What has been said, as opposed to the lie you are telling, is that this has been the warmest year so far, and if the trend keeps up, it will be the warmest year on record. The science shows this. Therefore, not alarmism.

It is, so why do you denialists keep doing it?

It is supported by science, yes.

Seriously, why do you keep lying this obviously? Normally, a lie should at least have a modicum of truth to be taken seriously.

For other people like 3body that don't know squat about climate science, we have these things called thermometers. Scientists have been using these things to measure temperature. That's how they know this is an exceptionally warm year thus far. Go to NASA's webpage to read for yourselves, or look for the link in one of these threads.



So why don't you support it?



Lol, the irony is thick here, as you have dodged my question all together. I'll repeat it after answering you.

Society can do what some nations already have. Commit to carbon reduction plans. Implement taxation on emissions. Spend more on alternative energy. This has been shown to work.

Now, as you dodged my question, I'll repeat it: What alarmist claim has any of us made that isn't supported by science? Please answer and don't try to dodge the question again.

Making predictions about weather in AGW threads. And seasonal averages of ice sheets and hurricanes. The premise is clear, present the weather as relating to AGW. It's of course a lie, the model do not predict specific events (well not to the extent they are represented in these threads)

Your dodge is certainly noted. Nor will I repeat myself again to you.

Likewise your willful ignorance of what has transpired in threads you've participated in has also been noted. This has been discussed to death. You are the only one to my knowledge that continues to state clouds will present a net positve feedback.

Out of curiousity do you think clouds present a positive feedback now???
 
Making predictions about weather in AGW threads. And seasonal averages of ice sheets and hurricanes. The premise is clear, present the weather as relating to AGW. It's of course a lie, the model do not predict specific events (well not to the extent they are represented in these threads)

Are you saying that us noting that the poles are melting is alarmism not supported by science? If not, could you quit being so damned coy? Speak your mind.

Your dodge is certainly noted. Nor will I repeat myself again to you.

My dodge? You have dodged my question twice now.

Likewise your willful ignorance of what has transpired in threads you've participated in has also been noted. This has been discussed to death. You are the only one to my knowledge that continues to state clouds will present a net positve feedback.

So, because I'm the only one here that state it (which is a lie, of course), it's untrue? Could you cite the source like I asked? Could you provide the links to NASA and NOAA claiming clouds will have a negative impact on temperature trends?

No?

Dodge noted.

Out of curiousity do you think clouds present a positive feedback now???

I think - as do climatologists - that our best estimates about cloud impact on temperature trends is going to be positive.

Now, could you start answering the questions I posed to you? You didn't answer a single one of them, instead managing to dodge and weave, making yet further unsupported assertions. Are you even here to discuss the science? If so, why don't you?
 
Wow, I seriously can't believe the poor logic you spew around. Nations like Sweden and Norway have shown that it is possible to reduce emissions without imploding the economy. Why are you against others following suit? Why do you think us Swedes and Norwegians should carry the full burden - which we cannot do?

lol, aside from the fact there are most likely private landowners that own close to as much land as each of those countries? :D

Many Europeans have no idea how massive countries like the US and Canada and Russia really are. I could probably knock down all the houses in Norway and deliver new wood to each worksite with less diesel than it would take to ship a single load across this country. lol. Ive seen wheat fields bigger than your entire country. I think Vancouver island is 1/3 the size of GB!

It's fine and dandy for tiny importing countries with no real manufacturing to say they are going carbon neutral, it's another for a massive country in the middle of industrializing to do so.
 
But that's just it elbe, the science doesn't say "If you pay $4/liter for petrol and pay 5% more in income tax, along with not mowing your lawn as often and installing motion activated lights the temperature should stabiize in 10 years, with a complete reversal in 25"

Since those are social changes, the science isn't going to say anything of the sort. At best it wants to prevent things from getting worse, not magically make everything better if you do x, y, and z.

Until there is some accountability even the politicians won't say for sure. The only leg they have to stand on is the well established fact that CO2 emissions have to come down.

People want to "help" but, honestly, have no idea how beyond reducing carbon use. Politicians want to seem like they have a solution to sell to the public; half the time it's complete BS but people believe all sorts of woo, don't they?

As to your model issue, from my understanding of your complaint you argue that the models aren't accurate enough because they don't take clouds into effect. But it seems that scientists know about the cloud issue and still find the models accurate enough for their needs. You seem to act like you understand it better than the people who do the work.
 
we've been though that before. for every item someone in the US or canada ships across country people in Europe ship something across Europe or internationally. What is different is people in Europe don't drive 50 miles to work, but there is no *need* to do that in the US it's a choice in city design. The wrong choice as it turns out.
 
Since those are social changes, the science isn't going to say anything of the sort. At best it wants to prevent things from getting worse, not magically make everything better if you do x, y, and z.



People want to "help" but, honestly, have no idea how beyond reducing carbon use. Politicians want to seem like they have a solution to sell to the public; half the time it's complete BS but people believe all sorts of woo, don't they?

As to your model issue, from my understanding of your complaint you argue that the models aren't accurate enough because they don't take clouds into effect. But it seems that scientists know about the cloud issue and still find the models accurate enough for their needs. You seem to act like you understand it better than the people who do the work.

No on the contrary. The scientists have clearly stated the cloud issue is a concern. It's people making statements like yours above that keep me skeptical.

Please, research this yourself and let me know what scientists actually say about clouds and cloud formation pertaining to models. In all my research I have found them to state they are currently inadequate and only beginning to touch the surface (or starosphere if you will) I don't think they are in any way adequate for their needs as they remain the greatest source of uncertainty. If they were it would be safe to assume the models have pretty much topped out on what they can achieve right? I mean if your models biggest fault was something that was more than adequate for your needs you're essentially finished. The last bit of tweaking is irrelevant at that point.

Long story short I'm pretty sure you've overstated how well, or how much we know about clouds and what effect they have on climate.
 
No on the contrary. The scientists have clearly stated the cloud issue is a concern. It's people making statements like yours above that keep me skeptical.

And yet they still confidently use the models, hmm, why? Maybe because they still find them to be accurate enough even with the cloud issue.

From my understanding of the issue, and I only got so far because it was all more whining back and forth in the, now moderated, thread, clouds are complex and unpredictable. If they always resulted in a positive change, that would be predictable, negative, still predictable - even without knowing solid numbers. You're the one who seems to be making more of the issue than the people in the field, but that's my opinion.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom