Climate change scepticism - its sources and origins

Status
Not open for further replies.
we've been though that before. for every item someone in the US or canada ships across country people in Europe ship something across Europe or internationally. What is different is people in Europe don't drive 50 miles to work, but there is no *need* to do that in the US it's a choice in city design. The wrong choice as it turns out.

I'm skeptical of this claim as well. We export wood we collect from millions of acres.

Chocolates and pen knives tend to be much denser than wood or wheat. Thats across the board. You could probably manufacture the world's supply of fine watches from a facility the size of a single red barn here in Canada :D Well say a facility 10 acres in size, from raw materials to finished goods.

I don't think you are accounting for value added. Nor do I think you are accounting for the distrubution of raw goods and manufacturing. Granted the Europeans are better by necessity, they simply don't have the space.

Canada could go carbon neutral in a few years if we got credits for planting trees and carbon taxed the exports of wood and grains to importing nations.
 
lol, aside from the fact there are most likely private landowners that own close to as much land as each of those countries? :D

Many Europeans have no idea how massive countries like the US and Canada and Russia really are. I could probably knock down all the houses in Norway and deliver new wood to each worksite with less diesel than it would take to ship a single load across this country. lol. Ive seen wheat fields bigger than your entire country. I think Vancouver island is 1/3 the size of GB!

It's fine and dandy for tiny importing countries with no real manufacturing to say they are going carbon neutral, it's another for a massive country in the middle of industrializing to do so.

Ok, so you're going to go with the "it's not the same" approach that a grade schooler would. Nothing to back up why it isn't the same. No explanation of why Sweden and Norway, two nations with substantial manufacturing facilities relative to population size, could plan for carbon neutrality while Canada and the US couldn't.

Also, still no answer to any of my questions. No cites from NOAA and NASA that say clouds will have a negative effect on temperature trends that you said you had. No list of alarmist claims from any of us that isn't supported by science. Just lie after lie after lie. Disgusting.
 
And yet they still confidently use the models, hmm, why? Maybe because they still find them to be accurate enough even with the cloud issue.

From my understanding of the issue, and I only got so far because it was all more whining back and forth in the, now moderated, thread, clouds are complex and unpredictable. If they always resulted in a positive change, that would be predictable, negative, still predictable - even without knowing solid numbers. You're the one who seems to be making more of the issue than the people in the field, but that's my opinion.

You are to yours and I am to mine.

Do I really need to cite the conflicting views on clouds and their effect on climate, let alone the models, or are you genuinely unaware of how they are currently precieved? Or are you just saying the current level of understanding is sufficient?

I ask because every time this comes up is becomes a game of semantics and somebody inherently starts talking about sirrus clouds instead of cumulus and totally derails this completely.
 
Do I really need to cite the conflicting views on clouds and their effect on climate, let alone the models, or are you genuinely unaware of how they are currently precieved?

You need to cite it because you never cite anything to back up your points. Now, cite your sources.

Or are you just saying the current level of understanding is sufficient?

Holy strawman Batman. Don't you ever get tired of lying?
 
Ok, so you're going to go with the "it's not the same" approach that a grade schooler would. Nothing to back up why it isn't the same. No explanation of why Sweden and Norway, two nations with substantial manufacturing facilities relative to population size, could plan for carbon neutrality while Canada and the US couldn't.

Also, still no answer to any of my questions. No cites from NOAA and NASA that say clouds will have a negative effect on temperature trends that you said you had. No list of alarmist claims from any of us that isn't supported by science. Just lie after lie after lie. Disgusting.

Now you're just playing games I'm afraid. lomiller clearly understood what I was saying as to why it isn't the same. The fact that you missed this is a clear indication you are being dishonest. There's no need for either of us to address one another further.
 
Now you're just playing games I'm afraid. lomiller clearly understood what I was saying as to why it isn't the same. The fact that you missed this is a clear indication you are being dishonest. There's no need for either of us to address one another further.

Not gonna happen. Your arguments are bunk, and I'm going to keep pointing it out. Now, please answer why nations like the US and Canada can't go ahead and plan for carbon neutrality like nations like Sweden and Norway has done to good effect.

Please list what alarmist claims that isn't supported by science any of the people you call "alarmist" here have made.

Please provide cites from NASA and NOAA that says that clouds are likely to have a negative effect on temperature trends.

Please explain why you keep saying climatologists don't properly take clouds into account when the climatologists themselves say that while clouds remain the greatest uncertainty, the models are still trustworthy and proper.
 
Do I really need to cite the conflicting views on clouds and their effect on climate, let alone the models, or are you genuinely unaware of how they are currently precieved?

You can do anything your heart desires, but I'm not going to get into it. I tried to encourage rational behavior and and watched people who agreed about the name calling return, in the following posts, to name calling.

Or are you just saying the current level of understanding is sufficient?

*sigh*

We seem to be returning to my original point, here. You don't want to accept the results because of the unknowns, but because there will always be unknowns you should never be satisfied with the results (assuming you were logically consistent). Maybe the results will change when the models are improved, but all you're doing now is discounting all the work they've done thus far in making those models because, it appears to me, you disagree with their results.
 
Don't come across as some sort of expert 3body - you're not.
Your position is indefensible and you fail to answer straight forward questions of a most basic nature.

As demonstrated to you before ad nauseum clouds have both plus and minus forcing nature and are both transient and dependent on local conditions as to any affect on the radiative budget at that moment.

You try and retreat behind a fog of "well maybes" when the one thing that does come across clearly from you is how very little you understand about climate and climate change.

Gammon KNOWS what he's talking about and where his peers have been with the science for over a decade

Here is what Gammon had to say concerning links between humans and climate change.

This is like asking, ‘Is the moon round?’ or ‘Does smoking cause cancer?’ We’re at a point now where there is no responsible position stating that humans are not responsible for climate change. That is just not where the science is.…For a long time, for at least five years and probably 10 years, the international scientific community has been very clear.”

In case there is any doubt, Gammon went on:
This is not the balance-of-evidence argument for a civil lawsuit; this is the criminal standard, beyond a reasonable doubt We’ve been there for a long time and I think the media has really not presented that to the public.”

Dr. Richard H. Gammon
Professor of Chemistry and Oceanography*
Adjunct Professor Atmospheric Sciences, University of Washington

failure to act on that knowledge of our responsibility for AGW, as you are counselling, is criminal.
 
Last edited:
We seem to be returning to my original point, here. You don't want to accept the results because of the unknowns, but because there will always be unknowns you should never be satisfied with the results (assuming you were logically consistent). Maybe the results will change when the models are improved, but all you're doing now is discounting all the work they've done thus far in making those models because, it appears to me, you disagree with their results.

Why would you say that when I clearly indicated that's not the case? Based on what I knew 15 years ago and what we know now I think it's safe to say within 5-10 years the models will provide detailed estimates with exacting certainty.

Take a look at the article I cited earlier in this thread. It clearly indicates the pluses and minuses associated with the current models, their revisions and prior versions. It's almost scary.

In addition I believe the sattellite data will prove invaluable.

Long story short I think we are much further along that I had assumed when starting back in on this issue a couple months ago. I also maintain that if we are behind on this issue today it is a result of alarmists posing as activists over the last 15 years. They've done more disservice to advancing the issue than the oil companies or car companies combined. If the fossil fuel companies seeded doubt the alarmists allowed it to flourish. The alarmists create denialists.
 
Don't come across as some sort of expert 3body - you're not.
Your position is indefensible and you fail to answer straight forward questions of a most basic nature.

As demonstrated to you before ad nauseum clouds have both plus and minus forcing nature and are both transient and dependent on local conditions as to any affect on the radiative budget at that moment.

You try and retreat behind a fog of "well maybes" when the one thing that does come across clearly from you is how very little you understand about climate and climate change.

Gammon KNOWS what he's talking about and where his peers have been with the science for over a decade



failure to act on that knowledge of our responsibility for AGW, as you are counselling, is criminal.

Come on, 1 strawman per post please. I never claimed to be an expert, not even play one on TV :D

Second I understand enough about climate science to formulate an opinion. Your attempt at shutting down discussion based on your interpretation of what I know is laughable. It's no wonder at the current state of affairs when people try to bully others into believing them or risk being called a fool or worse yet incapable of understanding. That's another strawman of your own creation.

Third, Gammon, whoever he is, and whatever he says has absolutely no bearing on the discussion at hand. I have never, ever even mentioned that AGW is not a result of human activity. Ever. It's so off topic and irrelevant I'm wondering if you are really following the discussion or not? It's a blatant misrepresentation and you know it. Strawman numero tres.
 
Why would you say that when I clearly indicated that's not the case? Based on what I knew 15 years ago and what we know now I think it's safe to say within 5-10 years the models will provide detailed estimates with exacting certainty.

Take a look at the article I cited earlier in this thread. It clearly indicates the pluses and minuses associated with the current models, their revisions and prior versions. It's almost scary.

In addition I believe the sattellite data will prove invaluable.

Long story short I think we are much further along that I had assumed when starting back in on this issue a couple months ago.

So you're advocating delaying action until science is further along, but you fail to provide any benchmark for how far along science should be until we act. It's just "not now but in the future" with you. This sort of delaying attitude is one of the major victories of the propaganda mill you claim to have been unaffected by.

I also maintain that if we are behind on this issue today it is a result of alarmists posing as activists over the last 15 years. They've done more disservice to advancing the issue than the oil companies or car companies combined. If the fossil fuel companies seeded doubt the alarmists allowed it to flourish. The alarmists create denialists.

There it is again. Now, would you care to list what alarmist claims have been made that aren't supported by science? You can start by listing those made on these forums, and then expand to other venues. Please provide sources for your assertions.

While you're at it, please answer why nations like the US and Canada can't go ahead and plan for carbon neutrality like nations like Sweden and Norway has done to good effect.

Please provide cites from NASA and NOAA that says that clouds are likely to have a negative effect on temperature trends.

Please explain why you keep saying climatologists don't properly take clouds into account when the climatologists themselves say that while clouds remain the greatest uncertainty, the models are still trustworthy and proper.
 
Damn - there you go asking him questions again...hasn't answered one yet...even simple ones.

Now says he's realized the knowledge base of climate science and climate change is "further along" than he realized.
Fancy that....all in a couple of months....remarkable...:rolleyes:

sorry but I don't buy the humility trip.....just another dodge.

The fundamental issue for valid skepticism is to be well informed...and THEN make informed opinions.
Your's is patently not that and you are defensive about it.
You are not skeptic, merely poorly informed about the topic you wish to make pronouncements about
....two whole months eh??

The denier community just loves your ilk. It's been amusing to watch.

Time to move on to solutions, not footdragging for spurious notions.

Even Exxon is talking about carbon emission solutions.......you ready yet?

:garfield:
 
So you're advocating delaying action until science is further along, but you fail to provide any benchmark for how far along science should be until we act.
...

It's very simple -

First they will use "we don't know enough to act."

Then they will use "the things you have proposed doing are too expensive."

Finally they will use "it's too late to do anything."
 
It's very simple -

First they will use "we don't know enough to act."

Then they will use "the things you have proposed doing are too expensive."

Finally they will use "it's too late to do anything."

Isn't this exactly how thalidomide and DDT got brought to market?

I don't see how anyone can legitimately claim we don't need to research more before we can begin to formulate a comprehensive plan of action? Had we done so when we first learned about the effects of pollution on the environment we wouldn't have fallen short and claimed a victory when our precious automobiles began to emit nothing but harmless CO2!

Why do I have a feeling the final contribution to this planet by the baby boomers is going to be a note on the fridge: "Sorry, we invested all your inheiritance in carbon credits and Eron stock. Who knew?"
 
I'm skeptical of this claim as well. We export wood we collect from millions of acres.

Chocolates and pen knives tend to be much denser than wood or wheat. Thats across the board.


People in Europe use wood and wheat...
 
People in Europe use wood and wheat...

This is actually an interesting topic that deserves it's own thread. You mentioned before that it has been discussed, perhaps you could bump that thread? I'd hate to start yet another AGW thread if it isn't needed.

That being said it's loosely tied to skepticism insomuchas it relates to a realistic way of mitigating CO2. I find it hard to believe Norway or Sweeden relies on fossil fuel or electricity in quite the same way as Canada or even Spain and Italy for its GDP.

Let's assume for argument sake Canada and Norway were able to meet their electric needs carbon neutral. I think that's entirely possible for both countries, perhaps even easier for Canada.

Do you honestly think Canada could continue to harvest lumber, fish, gather wheat and mine for minerals as well as manufacture goods and remain as carbon friendly as Norway? Sure Europeans use wood and wheat, but how much do they actually produce? How much does Norway produce? I'm at a complete loss here at how you can't see the drastic difference inheirent in producing raw goods as opposed to "using" them?

Perhaps you are suggesting we could radically alter the way we do things? Move the entire population into urban centers, create extensive rail systems, create new electric combines, tractors and marine engines?

While I certainly fancy that suggestion, and have in fact promoted such measures for years, I just don't see how we could realistically invest in these technologies and not be seriously crippled in the mean time. It's a paradigm shift, it has to come at some immediate cost to the taxpayer no? And to our GDP.

Meh, I'm at a total loss how you've used "they use wood and wheat too" to dismiss the obvious differences between the two countries. That say nothing about the differences between Sweeden and Russia, or Denmark and China.

Iceland is another country that comes to mind. Surely Iceland could go carbon neutral almost overnight, with little or no cost to the residents and their GDP. No doubt they "use wood and wheat" too?

edit: I just looked and we could prectically fit Norway in our largest park here in Canada. I'm not seeing how we could even begin to compare our country to Norway. As an example certainly, but beyond that there's just no comparison.
 
Last edited:
This is actually an interesting topic that deserves it's own thread. You mentioned before that it has been discussed, perhaps you could bump that thread? I'd hate to start yet another AGW thread if it isn't needed.

That being said it's loosely tied to skepticism insomuchas it relates to a realistic way of mitigating CO2. I find it hard to believe Norway or Sweeden relies on fossil fuel or electricity in quite the same way as Canada or even Spain and Italy for its GDP.

Let's assume for argument sake Canada and Norway were able to meet their electric needs carbon neutral. I think that's entirely possible for both countries, perhaps even easier for Canada.

Do you honestly think Canada could continue to harvest lumber, fish, gather wheat and mine for minerals as well as manufacture goods and remain as carbon friendly as Norway? Sure Europeans use wood and wheat, but how much do they actually produce? How much does Norway produce? I'm at a complete loss here at how you can't see the drastic difference inheirent in producing raw goods as opposed to "using" them?

Perhaps you are suggesting we could radically alter the way we do things? Move the entire population into urban centers, create extensive rail systems, create new electric combines, tractors and marine engines?

While I certainly fancy that suggestion, and have in fact promoted such measures for years, I just don't see how we could realistically invest in these technologies and not be seriously crippled in the mean time. It's a paradigm shift, it has to come at some immediate cost to the taxpayer no? And to our GDP.

Meh, I'm at a total loss how you've used "they use wood and wheat too" to dismiss the obvious differences between the two countries. That say nothing about the differences between Sweeden and Russia, or Denmark and China.

Iceland is another country that comes to mind. Surely Iceland could go carbon neutral almost overnight, with little or no cost to the residents and their GDP. No doubt they "use wood and wheat" too?

edit: I just looked and we could prectically fit Norway in our largest park here in Canada. I'm not seeing how we could even begin to compare our country to Norway. As an example certainly, but beyond that there's just no comparison.

Your argument from personal incredulity fails to take reality into account.


http://www.roadtransport.com/blogs/big-lorry-blog/new logger 2.JPG

Swedish logging.

http://www.borealforest.org/world/images/sweden_landscape.jpg

Typical Swedish landscape.

http://3.bp.blogspot.com/_O6VaaElus.../vMFA9G5vKjA/s400/forest_by_lake+-+Norway.jpg

Typical Norwegian landscape.


Percentage of total area covered in forest - Sweden: 60%

Percentage of total area covered in forest - Norway: 25%

Edited by LashL: 
Removed hotlinked images. Please see Rule 5.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom