Climate change scepticism - its sources and origins

Status
Not open for further replies.
Isn't this exactly how thalidomide and DDT got brought to market?

I don't see how anyone can legitimately claim we don't need to research more before we can begin to formulate a comprehensive plan of action? Had we done so when we first learned about the effects of pollution on the environment we wouldn't have fallen short and claimed a victory when our precious automobiles began to emit nothing but harmless CO2!

Science is an ongoing process and you have to work with the best knowledge you have. That's always been the case, always will be. By the time we have definitive proof of AGW that even the almost most hardened denialist* will have to acknowledge as being true, it will be too late to do anything about it.

* i have no doubt there will be denialists even when the proof is enough for the vast majority of the population.
 
Science is an ongoing process and you have to work with the best knowledge you have. That's always been the case, always will be. By the time we have definitive proof of AGW that even the almost most hardened denialist* will have to acknowledge as being true, it will be too late to do anything about it.

* i have no doubt there will be denialists even when the proof is enough for the vast majority of the population.

But we have definitive proof and we are doing something???

Let me explain it very simply and see if we can get on the same page. We know AGW exists, we know it's due to CO2. Some people may argue the extent of the current warming may be a combination of things, but I think most people agree we're changing the climate and we should stop.

Then it starts to fall apart. Some people maintain we are doing enough already, perhaps even too much. The offset by current measures just doesn't legitimize the added costs.

Some of us say we're doing enough for now, we certainly need to do more, but the offset hasn't been established to validate the added costs. Thats's kinda where I find myself. I'd be willing to put another I don't know, $50 per year without saying much. I'd be willing to contribute $500 per year if someone could tell me what effect it would have. I mean I would vote, and encourage other people to vote for these measures.

Then there seems to be the pro-AGW crowd that wants more change and is willing to do what it takes, but seem spilt between different methods at accomplishing this.

Then there seems to be the alarmists, who run around screaming the sky is falling and the end is near, but they don't have any real idea what to do. They just don't seem to have any other purpose but to preach AGW and fearmonger. If you do get them to adit to some mitigation strategy it usually involves purging the planet of excess humanity, or something as equally strange.

Oh and of course the outright deniers who assume it's a conspiracy or think it's an act of God.

Did I generalize too much or does this just about cover the spectrum?
 
Then there seems to be the alarmists, who run around screaming the sky is falling and the end is near, but they don't have any real idea what to do. They just don't seem to have any other purpose but to preach AGW and fearmonger. If you do get them to adit to some mitigation strategy it usually involves purging the planet of excess humanity, or something as equally strange.

As you've called several of us alarmists, could you list which ones of us fall into this category?
 
We know AGW exists, we know it's due to CO2. Some people may argue the extent of the current warming may be a combination of things, but I think most people agree we're changing the climate and we should stop.
This is true, but unfortunately the minority who don't agree are very vocal and completely impervious to reason. So any attempt to move on to a discussion about what the consequences are most likely to be, what mitigation is possible and/or economically justifiable etc etc on a board like this is constantly sabotaged by a few deniers flatly refusing to accept the premise of such a discussion.

I've been following these threads for years and I've never seen the various positions you go on to describe advanced by any of the regulars who accept the reality of AGW because they are all too busy describing and defending the science which supports its existence over and over and over again to a few resident deniers and the occasional newbie who has read a denier site and swallowed the lies whole.
 
This is true, but unfortunately the minority who don't agree are very vocal and completely impervious to reason. So any attempt to move on to a discussion about what the consequences are most likely to be, what mitigation is possible and/or economically justifiable etc etc on a board like this is constantly sabotaged by a few deniers flatly refusing to accept the premise of such a discussion.

I've been following these threads for years and I've never seen the various positions you go on to describe advanced by any of the regulars who accept the reality of AGW because they are all too busy describing and defending the science which supports its existence over and over and over again to a few resident deniers and the occasional newbie who has read a denier site and swallowed the lies whole.

Mmm. Well I think the "Oh my god it's getting hot, can't you feel the heat?!?" generates the "What are you talking about it's fine, I'm going to put on a sweater"

I know it did for me 15 years ago. I explained how I saw a well respected scientist seemingly go completely overboard in a presentation by presenting something as established fact, went it most certainly wasn't.

That turns you off as a young scientist. These guys are supposed to be impartial, allowing the science to dictate not their emotion.

But then I also realized along with the science comes passion and passion has a tendency to distort things. It gives you reason to filter out things. And like I said this was 15 years ago, it most certainly wasn't fact, and the predictions being made ran the entire gambit, from an extinction level event to a New Eden.

So you do your own thing, you sit back and wait for the science to disolve those filters and let what's really true to come trickling thru.

In the mean time I still see a lot of passion and I still see those same filters. Since the mid 90's I think we've come along way, and I think we are doing many more things based on what we currently know with any real certainty.

How much more we could do is really a matter of perspective. We could all give a weekend a month volunteering at a local shelter or soup kitchen but we don't. There's always more we could be doing that we don't. That's part of our nature it seems.

And I don't find it strange that people respond to the alarmists by saying "You know what, the last thing I have to do before I die in this world is give more of my money to prevent the planet from warming up a bit"

That's why I'm inclined to believe if you're going to shove something down the publics throat you better make it taste good. And frankly as long as these uncertainties remain the whole thing is rotten. That's figuratively mind you.

But of all the things we really should be doing, CO2 reduction has got to be one of the most unrewarding. Not only can we not see it physically, but we can't even see it in theory.

You know what I mean? You get to see the smile on someones face when you slide them an extra slice of ham, you get a letter from that orphan you adopted, you have some measurable impact with these things. With AGW right now you don't. You might get some personal satisfaction but that just isn't enough to get everyone on board here. And until you can get everyone on board this isn't going to get much further, and frankly I think barring the feedbacks I mentioned it's going to take a lot more than some crazy carbon credit scheme to get this under control.

/rant off
 
If something is alarming, does that mean that we can ignore it? I regularly see the term 'alarmist' used here.

If the predictions of the IPCC are correct, then I think they are alarming. For some reason, that means they can be ignored. I don't get it.

In fact something alarming, ignored, is the domain of fools.

Its like smelling smoke and staying in bed thinking "It's just smoke, NO WAY is my house on fire!"
 
I seriously don't understand 3body's position. It seems so intellectually dishonest. In every post he swings from "AGW is real" to "We don't know enough to do anything" to "Alarmists retard the science". He never defines anything, for example his continued use of the word "alarmist" to describe the position of people arguing against him here. He never describes the benchmark for when we can start doing something against the warming, and he claims without any backup that the nations that have done something are somehow special cases and their techniques are not applicable to anyone else.

It all seems to be the last desperate rearguard of a denialist who realizes that the battle is lost and tries his darnedest to argue for delaying action despite him having no scientific ground to do so. In a way, this sort of argument is worse than flat out denial of the science, as this is much more devious. Denialism can at least be brushed off as crack-pottery.
 
Its like smelling smoke and staying in bed thinking "It's just smoke, NO WAY is my house on fire!"

Especially when you know you left a cigarette burning in the ashtray. :rolleyes:

No, let's pull the alarm and go running out into the street in our pj's because everyone knows where there's smoke there has to be fire.
 
If something is alarming, does that mean that we can ignore it? I regularly see the term 'alarmist' used here.

If the predictions of the IPCC are correct, then I think they are alarming. For some reason, that means they can be ignored. I don't get it.

Sorry I missed this earlier.

This is where the ridiculous extreme card gets played. On the far end of the spectrum is an asteroid on a collision course with Earth, that's pretty alarming. Killer bees? They're frighteningly alarming. Aliens? I can name a few others that are certainly alarming, but their probability remains pretty low as well.
On a more related note what are we doing to prevent a super virus? Shouldn't we limit human interaction, install hepa filters everywhere, outlaw malls and start internet based home schooling? How do we know that isn't a better place to focus our attentions on? What about space junk?

There are plenty of alarming things facing society aren't there? Are you certain AGW is one of them? I mean one of the big ones? How many people will die from lack of fresh water in the next 30 years? That's not from lack of water, that's from lack of fresh water. That's something I find much more alarming than a 0.2 degree increase in global temperature.

If we can't solve the problems that can easily be solved why are we trying to save the world 50 or 100 years from now? And we are commiting to doing this with absolutely no idea what it will do. No real measurable effect to speak of.

What's really alarming in the world today?
 
This is where the ridiculous extreme card gets played. On the far end of the spectrum is an asteroid on a collision course with Earth, that's pretty alarming. Killer bees? They're frighteningly alarming. Aliens? I can name a few others that are certainly alarming, but their probability remains pretty low as well.
On a more related note what are we doing to prevent a super virus? Shouldn't we limit human interaction, install hepa filters everywhere, outlaw malls and start internet based home schooling? How do we know that isn't a better place to focus our attentions on? What about space junk?

There are plenty of alarming things facing society aren't there? Are you certain AGW is one of them? I mean one of the big ones? How many people will die from lack of fresh water in the next 30 years? That's not from lack of water, that's from lack of fresh water. That's something I find much more alarming than a 0.2 degree increase in global temperature.

If we can't solve the problems that can easily be solved why are we trying to save the world 50 or 100 years from now? And we are commiting to doing this with absolutely no idea what it will do. No real measurable effect to speak of.

What's really alarming in the world today?
So it's not that AGW isn't dangerous, it's that there are other dangerous things in the world, too, so AGW shouldn't be fought?

I seriously don't understand 3body's position.
You're in good company.
 
So it's not that AGW isn't dangerous, it's that there are other dangerous things in the world, too, so AGW shouldn't be fought?

You're in good company.

*sigh

I find no matter how any times you repeat yourself with this issue people seem to read whatever they want, just so they can get their say in.

Not ONCE in my life, ever, never, not even fooling around if memory serves, did I whisper, talk or put into writing that AGW
SHOULDN'T BE FOUGHT. EVER.

In fact not more than what, 3 posts ago I said efforts could be improved upon and I'd pay for it out of my pocket.

Do people even bother to pay attention when they read these threads? It seems like all you ever get is people with an agenda and they will do whatever it takes to get it out on the internet.
Even if that means totally misrepresenting someone.
 
*sigh

I find no matter how any times you repeat yourself with this issue people seem to read whatever they want, just so they can get their say in.

Not ONCE in my life, ever, never, not even fooling around if memory serves, did I whisper, talk or put into writing that AGW
SHOULDN'T BE FOUGHT. EVER.

In fact not more than what, 3 posts ago I said efforts could be improved upon and I'd pay for it out of my pocket.

Do people even bother to pay attention when they read these threads? It seems like all you ever get is people with an agenda and they will do whatever it takes to get it out on the internet.
Even if that means totally misrepresenting someone.

So, you think we should do more to fight against AGW, but you don't think we should use the methods that worked for nations like Sweden and Norway, and you don't really think science supports doing much about AGW because that's just alarmism, but you think science will probably be strong enough to warrant more action in a decade or two.

Did I miss any of your mutually exclusive positions?
 
So no example where I've denied anything. Awesome.

Of course I knew you'd fail to do so because I don't "deny" anything. All I've ever said is that I've been around this issue for a while and reacting to alarmism should be kept in check. The science doesn't support the overreactions this issue tends to invoke in people. There's still more to discover and more we need to get a handle on before we can start tp make a concerted effort and know what effect it will have on the climate.

Right now we are making token efforts. We don't know what, if any effect it will have on the climate. It will most likely be positive, but to what extent simply can't be known.

ok, so what exactly are you skeptical about? because after rereading you posts, especially the most recent, I havent the the foggiest.

Is your bedroom a mess because your reasoning seems to be.
 
Is your bedroom a mess because your reasoning seems to be.

Explain. (and stop the ad homs OK?)

The reason you're confused is most likely due to people putting words in my mouth. I never said we should do nothing and I never said AGW isn't real. Those were deliberate misrepresentations by the people in this thread.

That's part of the reason I'm skeptical. The people you see involved in this issue are willing to lie and fabricate arguments to support their stance. If you think this is only limited to people here on the internet I suggest you think again. The scientists don't do this, they usually remain reserved and make statements of fact supported by research and evidence. Once it leaves their hands however all bets are off.

If you read AR4 objectively you'll get an entirely different picture of AGW and the climate than if you tour the internet and read the alarmist websites.
 
Last edited:
ok, I retract the ad hom..

I can see why people are confused though, here’s some of your posts:
In the time it took you to read this post, 150 smokers dies of lung cancer, 2500 children died of hunger, 7500 familes became homeless, 1500 women were beaten within an inch of their lives and oh yah, the planet warmed by 0.0000000186 degrees"

Of these predictions, all but one are well documented as fact. 1 is a best guess estimate based on admittedly flawed models.

other than a few cranks, most people are aware of the serious issues facing society. Are you counted amongst them?

You point here is? Well its not explicit but you appear to be suggesting that AGW is not a serious issue - and the "documented as fact" point appears that you are suggesting AGW science is flawed, or at least the models are flawed to the extent that we shouldn't take AGW seriously. If not, what was your point?


No doubt, there are some seriously smart people working on these models. They are as good as it gets until they get better.
That’s funny. That’s a funny quote.

The actual amount of warming and that predicted by models remains in a statistical cloud of uncertainty. As do the effects of said warming on the globe.

The misrepresentation of this by AGW proponents is the major reason for the upswell of skepticism.

In an attempt to cover this up the AGW proponents have created a smear campaign, trying to lump GW skeptics in with the likes of Holocaust "deniers".

This will undoubtedly lead to more "negative feedback", a term most AGW proponents are completely unfamiliar with

ok, I take this point and believe I understand what you are saying. But I don’t think the situation is as you describe. I think, as has been suggested, that legitimate gaps in the science (scientifically speaking), has been used by AGW opponents to upset the apple cart which then leads to skepticism (and for some casual readers of the media - denialism). To me it IS like the 911 truthers using the apparent superficial similarity to a controlled demolition to undermine the facts. Just to qualify what I mean by "legitimate gaps" - that is to say areas that are not yet fully understood but understood enough to not overturn the overall conclusion and huge scientific consensus. The models from what I understand are good enough to show that we are in deep doodoo.


In case you haven't heard we are curbing emissions. What we don't know is what effect they will have. The excellent reason to curb emissions lies soley in the fact that we put it there, not flawed models, or climate science or polar bears. We put it there and it needs to go. End of story.

This I think is really odd. When you say “we put it there” you mean the current Co2 correct? If so, you are therefore suggesting we ignore all the science and just remove what we put there? If there is such a thing as alarmism on this subject this sounds just like it. Whatever happens in the future has to be a measured approach me thinks.

I'm skeptical because I see a lot of scientists saying "We're getting a handle on what's going on here. We're running tests and creating models and doing proxy searches and verifications and we know this isn't good but we're not sure to what extent exactly and we'd like to know for sure, but yah we were right fyi" and then there's a lot of people latching on and going "OMG what do we do, tell us what to do, for the love of dog we need to something" and big business is going "oh we've got your fix right here, a trillion dollar scheme that no one can really validate one way or the other if it will be cost effective or not"

Now you see this is where people get confused. You have said in previous posts, making you point very firmly, that you are a proponent of AGW, then you post this. Now, I understand that you are trying to say you are a skeptic and not a denier, and there maybe specific scientific points of issue that you can be skeptical about within climate science. But this is not the same as saying “I believe in AGW and am not skeptical about it but the scientist keep doing stuff that encourages skepticism”. You are saying you ARE a skeptic on AGW. I’m sure within the research there is different opinions about particular aspects of the science. However you talk as if you are skeptical of AGW here. I don’t think you can be skeptical in one post and then rigidly point out that you believe AGW is real in another and not expect people to get confused with you position.

I see where you coming from overall, but think you are probably wrong. The stakes are too high based on the knowledge we have now to wait for the science to become more certain than it already is.

(BTW I noted plenty of ad homs in your posts that I skipped – you may want to knock it off to)
 
I see where you coming from overall, but think you are probably wrong. The stakes are too high based on the knowledge we have now to wait for the science to become more certain than it already is.

(BTW I noted plenty of ad homs in your posts that I skipped – you may want to knock it off to)

First, please feel free to link them so I can defend myself. I'm getting pretty sick of this tactic. I post something and then the adhoms start flying immediately from various sources. I respond in kind, eventually, and someone comes along, ingnores the numerous attacks I've taken and starts making their own on me again. This only flies on the internet because you know what response this would draw on the street. Normally people restrain from making these stupid attacks to people they don't know.

You don't really have any say in how I respond to anyone else, first because you're not a moderator and second you don't have enough info to do so. But if you want to link them so I can show you how things transpired that's fine. I'm very pleasant and respectful of people until provoked.

"The stakes are too high", indeed they are. So why would you not want to know exactly what effect you are having? What if you pour $1 trillion dollars into CO2 trading and the 25 coal plants being built in Indonesia totally negate that investment? What if Gen IV reactors can be comissioned 20 years earlier with a $1 trillion R&D budget? What if carbon sequestering technology is just $8 billion short of being viable?

We don't have answers to these questions be we're not at a point of being able to know what effects we can have. Short of stopping output alltogether what do we know a 4% reduction in some are of industry will have? What if it's better for Asia to go green than the US and Brazil because of geography? It's because the stakes are high we should approach this issue calmly.

And yes, it's possible we have other pressing issues that would be better served by throwing money at them rather than AGW. We could have 10 extra hurricanes and the loss of 100 miles of beaches over the next few years but we know X amount of people will die because of this issues and Y amount of people will die because of that issue. Both X and Y have known fixes at known costs, but we don't have any clue what a 10% reduction in CO2 will have on those hurricanes and lost beaches.

So yes, I'm skeptical of people claiming we should do something we don't have any clue what effect it will have, when there are other things we could be doing with measurable effects. It seems a little self serving to me. Oh yah let's worry about future generations when we can take care of this one? WTF?
 
The people you see involved in this issue are willing to lie and fabricate arguments to support their stance. If you think this is only limited to people here on the internet I suggest you think again.

Why don't YOU stop the adhoms? Prove that people have lied or shut up.

Those were deliberate misrepresentations by the people in this thread.

Prove this.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom