Circumcision: can any rational thinker defend it ?

Well, the percentage of circumcised men is very low in Portugal (and most of Europe, I think), and we are definitly not dropping like flies due to infections.

Face it, all the excuses for circumcision are just that, excuses. If 70% of all males in the world are uncut, I guess the medical angle for circumcision goes down the drain. It's a barbaric cultural practice, probably started as one more way for "holy men" to enforce their power over the population. It's depressing that in the 21st century, when we can do things that would put the ancient gods to shame, learned people stand to defend a ritual that should have been left in the Dark Ages.
 
Well, the percentage of circumcised men is very low in Portugal (and most of Europe, I think), and we are definitly not dropping like flies due to infections.

It's very low (~20%) in the rest of the developed world, outside of the USA. The vast majority of men on the planet are not circumcised.
 
The evidence for it being of some benefit is at best limited, at worst non existent. The truth is that by not getting it done until later, you're not putting your child under any realistic risk of ill health or impoverished well being.

Therefore I disagree with removing something from my kid where they should have that right to make a decision later. I wouldn't get my kid's ears pierced until they could choose, and these heal should they not want! Removing skin that won't ever grow back, IMO, is fairly arrogant and authoritarian.

If my child feels that the alleged benefits are worth it, I'm sure they can do it later in life. The very fact that few uncircumcised blokes go for the snipjob later shows that the evidence for it being a good thing can't be all that convincing.

Athon
 
The evidence for it being of some benefit is at best limited, at worst non existent. The truth is that by not getting it done until later, you're not putting your child under any realistic risk of ill health or impoverished well being.

On what basis do you consider it reasonable to dismiss the results of numerous studies that show a marked and consistent benefit - for example, the 50 to 60 percent reduction in the transmission of HIV, a 4-fold (or more) decrease in UTI's in neonates, a 3-fold or more decrease in cancer of the penis - some of which (UTI's and penile cancer) are benefits conferred by neonatal circumcision, but not by circumcision later in life?

I understand that there is an emotional reaction to the idea of removing this particular piece of skin, and that depending upon the population you are part of plus other risk factors, the absolute benefit may be moderate to tiny. But is it really necessary to characterize those parents who don't have a strong emotional reaction against the idea, or who consider the benefit sufficient in their particular situation, as narcissistic, child mutilators with a god complex?

I am always amazed by how objectivity seems to fly out the window on this issue.

Linda
 
The evidence for it being of some benefit is at best limited, at worst non existent. The truth is that by not getting it done until later, you're not putting your child under any realistic risk of ill health or impoverished well being.

Therefore I disagree with removing something from my kid where they should have that right to make a decision later. I wouldn't get my kid's ears pierced until they could choose, and these heal should they not want! Removing skin that won't ever grow back, IMO, is fairly arrogant and authoritarian.

If my child feels that the alleged benefits are worth it, I'm sure they can do it later in life. The very fact that few uncircumcised blokes go for the snipjob later shows that the evidence for it being a good thing can't be all that convincing.

Athon

But humans appear to prefer to be whatever they are. So long as they are happy about it, what does it matter how they ended up that way?

To put it another way: why do we put such a high value on "free" choice or informed consent, when the vast majority of men who have been circumcised as infants and those that were not prefer the way they are?
 
On what basis do you consider it reasonable to dismiss the results of numerous studies that show a marked and consistent benefit - for example, the 50 to 60 percent reduction in the transmission of HIV, a 4-fold (or more) decrease in UTI's in neonates, a 3-fold or more decrease in cancer of the penis - some of which (UTI's and penile cancer) are benefits conferred by neonatal circumcision, but not by circumcision later in life?

I understand that there is an emotional reaction to the idea of removing this particular piece of skin, and that depending upon the population you are part of plus other risk factors, the absolute benefit may be moderate to tiny. But is it really necessary to characterize those parents who don't have a strong emotional reaction against the idea, or who consider the benefit sufficient in their particular situation, as narcissistic, child mutilators with a god complex?

I am always amazed by how objectivity seems to fly out the window on this issue.

Linda

I'dunno Linda. Perhaps some people bought into the whole Rights of the Child idea the UN came up with.
 
Well...

When I was born a large majority of (non-Jewish) American children were circumcised (for "health" reasons). Regardless of the medical aspect (right or not) I am extremely glad I was.

Frankly, a penis, already pretty funny looking, is 1000000 times uglier with the foreskin. Look at all the circumcised male porn stars? See much porn with non-curcumcised men? Doubt you could find much.

I'm sure there are other good reasons for the procedure as well, beyond vanity.

But in essence, the foreskin, like other evolutionary holdovers, is not necessary. It's like when people are born with tails, webbing, etc. Clothing makes having a foreskin superfluous.

Combining circumcision with female genital mutilation (as in the OP) is kind of silly. The two procedures are so far removed from each other. This post should be split asunder as each subject should have it's own post.
 
On what basis do you consider it reasonable to dismiss the results of numerous studies that show a marked and consistent benefit - for example, the 50 to 60 percent reduction in the transmission of HIV, a 4-fold (or more) decrease in UTI's in neonates, a 3-fold or more decrease in cancer of the penis - some of which (UTI's and penile cancer) are benefits conferred by neonatal circumcision, but not by circumcision later in life?

Maybe because all of those are just post-hoc justifications (and iffy ones, at that) for a barbarian practice that's been around for millenia...

I understand that there is an emotional reaction to the idea of removing this particular piece of skin, and that depending upon the population you are part of plus other risk factors, the absolute benefit may be moderate to tiny.

Let me tell you a secret. Decrying the religious mutilation of infants is not an emotional response, it's a social obligation by any rational person. Grasping at straws to justify continuing a primitive ritual is an emotional reaction.

And BTW, since breast cancer is more prevalent than penile cancer, do you defend mastectomies for every teenager? The absolute benefit would be much greater than the "moderate to tiny".

But is it really necessary to characterize those parents who don't have a strong emotional reaction against the idea, or who consider the benefit sufficient in their particular situation, as narcissistic, child mutilators with a god complex?

Unfortunatelly, I think it is (at least for the child mutilators thingy). It has to do with the fact that tit is an accurate description of what they are. You know, you mutilate your child, you're a child mutilator... comes with the territory.

I am always amazed by how objectivity seems to fly out the window on this issue.

Yeah, I know... it's a bummer. Why can't all those people advocating the physical integrity of children just STFU with all those facts...
 
On what basis do you consider it reasonable to dismiss the results of numerous studies that show a marked and consistent benefit - for example, the 50 to 60 percent reduction in the transmission of HIV, a 4-fold (or more) decrease in UTI's in neonates, a 3-fold or more decrease in cancer of the penis - some of which (UTI's and penile cancer) are benefits conferred by neonatal circumcision, but not by circumcision later in life?

HIV? Well, show me the rates of decrease in HIV transmission in children having sex. Otherwise, I'd wait until my child is of an age that we could discuss that so they can choose to have it done to themselves. Perhaps in their teenage years (not to mention that plain old condoms do a far better job in new sexual relationships).

I'm seriously dubious of a 4 fold decrease in UTI's in neonate males. Can you link the full study? It just doesn't make a lot of sense. Even so, what numbers are we looking at here? Does it still balance removing that decision from the child?

I understand that there is an emotional reaction to the idea of removing this particular piece of skin, and that depending upon the population you are part of plus other risk factors, the absolute benefit may be moderate to tiny. But is it really necessary to characterize those parents who don't have a strong emotional reaction against the idea, or who consider the benefit sufficient in their particular situation, as narcissistic, child mutilators with a god complex?

I'm not saying there's zero benefit. I just don't see the figures as that convincing that I would take away that decision from my kid. Sure, it's 'just a bit of skin'. Let them make that choice.

I am always amazed by how objectivity seems to fly out the window on this issue.

Linda

How is it not objective? You're suggesting that there is an appreciable risk of my hypothetical son getting a UTI, or worse, penis cancer, if they're not snipped. I disagree that the slight possible risk outweighs my kid's right to make that choice himself. That's simply respecting one's rights to make their own decisions on such things.

Ivor said:
But humans appear to prefer to be whatever they are. So long as they are happy about it, what does it matter how they ended up that way?

This argument could suit any sort of irreversible body modification on a minor. I could tattoo my kid and you're suggesting that they'd still be happy with it. Perhaps, but it still doesn't make it right.

I'm not suggesting my son would cry foul on being cut. Chances are he really wouldn't care. That's not my point. My point is that it's up to them to decide what stays and what goes on their body.

To put it another way: why do we put such a high value on "free" choice or informed consent, when the vast majority of men who have been circumcised as infants and those that were not prefer the way they are?

Good question. A lot of people disagree with me, and feel quite happy to pierce their kids ears or have them circumcised. If avoiding doing such a thing was going to seriously make their life harder later (such as in the case of drastic cosmetic surgery for something like hair-lip, for instance) I'd have to make that call. But this isn't. It's removing a bit of skin essentially for what amounts to tradition. I feel that's morally wrong.

If and when I have kids, I will bring them up not to be reflections of me and my traditions, but rather instil in them the best skills, knowledge and education possible for them to become their own person. While minor, that includes not modifying their bodies until they're comfortable with that choice.

Athon
 
Last edited:
Frankly, a penis, already pretty funny looking, is 1000000 times uglier with the foreskin. Look at all the circumcised male porn stars? See much porn with non-curcumcised men? Doubt you could find much.

Let's face it, if the penis was an animal, you'd stomp on it.

It's not there to be looked at.

I'm sure there are other good reasons for the procedure as well, beyond vanity.

And here's my point; there is a desire for aesthetic and traditional purposes for people to remove it. And then there is a subseqential search for additional reasons to justify it, seeking out some subtle medical obscurities which lean in that favour.

If it is an aesthetic thing, leave it to the individual to decide that it's ugly and they wish to lop it off. If they don't want to, I guess it's not exactly that hideous it needs to be removed.

Combining circumcision with female genital mutilation (as in the OP) is kind of silly. The two procedures are so far removed from each other. This post should be split asunder as each subject should have it's own post.

I agree.

Athon
 
How is that relevant? Or more specifically, how is that not redundant?

Linda

Because it states the child should be included in the decision to have something done to it at an appropriate level with respect to its cognitive abilities.

As Athon has said, neo-natal circumcision has minimal if not insignificant benefits (by the standards of most rational people) for the child up to an age when it could start to be involved in the decision making process.

Preventative medical intervention is almost always held off until the risk it is reducing or eliminating is significant or will be in the near future.
 
<snip>
If and when I have kids, I will bring them up not to be reflections of me and my traditions, but rather instil in them the best skills, knowledge and education possible for them to become their own person. While minor, that includes not modifying their bodies until they're comfortable with that choice.

Athon

So you won't be disciplining them then?;)
 
Maybe because all of those are just post-hoc justifications (and iffy ones, at that) for a barbarian practice that's been around for millenia...

Let me tell you a secret. Decrying the religious mutilation of infants is not an emotional response, it's a social obligation by any rational person. Grasping at straws to justify continuing a primitive ritual is an emotional reaction.

And BTW, since breast cancer is more prevalent than penile cancer, do you defend mastectomies for every teenager? The absolute benefit would be much greater than the "moderate to tiny".

Unfortunatelly, I think it is (at least for the child mutilators thingy). It has to do with the fact that tit is an accurate description of what they are. You know, you mutilate your child, you're a child mutilator... comes with the territory.

Yeah, I know... it's a bummer. Why can't all those people advocating the physical integrity of children just STFU with all those facts...

See, this is exactly what I mean. I personally advocate for the physical integrity of children. However, that does not make me dismiss the available research as "post hoc", "iffy", "grasping at straws", etc. I don't find it necessary to dismiss objective information simply because it does not say what I hoped it would say. I, like the AAP consider it insufficient to overcome my bias toward physical integrity.

And exactly what "facts" did you think you provided? All I saw was continued vilification and name-calling plus the presentation of a straw man argument.

Linda
 
See, this is exactly what I mean. I personally advocate for the physical integrity of children. However, that does not make me dismiss the available research as "post hoc", "iffy", "grasping at straws", etc. I don't find it necessary to dismiss objective information simply because it does not say what I hoped it would say. I, like the AAP consider it insufficient to overcome my bias toward physical integrity.

And exactly what "facts" did you think you provided? All I saw was continued vilification and name-calling plus the presentation of a straw man argument.

Linda

But don't most of the risks neo-natal circumcision reduces have alternative or better treatments available for them?
 
HIV? Well, show me the rates of decrease in HIV transmission in children having sex. Otherwise, I'd wait until my child is of an age that we could discuss that so they can choose to have it done to themselves. Perhaps in their teenage years (not to mention that plain old condoms do a far better job in new sexual relationships).

I specifically made a distinction between benefits seen with neonatal circumcision and that seen with circumcision generally.

I'm seriously dubious of a 4 fold decrease in UTI's in neonate males. Can you link the full study? It just doesn't make a lot of sense. Even so, what numbers are we looking at here? Does it still balance removing that decision from the child?

I provided a link earlier to the AAP position paper which includes all the references with links to full text.

Does it balance removing that decision from the child? I'd say no.

I'm not saying there's zero benefit. I just don't see the figures as that convincing that I would take away that decision from my kid. Sure, it's 'just a bit of skin'. Let them make that choice.

How is it not objective? You're suggesting that there is an appreciable risk of my hypothetical son getting a UTI, or worse, penis cancer, if they're not snipped. I disagree that the slight possible risk outweighs my kid's right to make that choice himself. That's simply respecting one's rights to make their own decisions on such things.

The not objective part was disparaging the research and denigrating parents who would make a different decision from yours.

The parents are acting as advocates for the child - what would the child decide if he was capable of making the decision? The argument for not waiting is that some of the benefits occur before the child can make that decision. And if the older child would decide to have circumcision anyway, the procedure is simpler when done on a neonate. I also agree that the absolute benefit for my children does not outweigh their right to make their own decision.

Linda
 
See, this is exactly what I mean. I personally advocate for the physical integrity of children. However, that does not make me dismiss the available research as "post hoc", "iffy", "grasping at straws", etc. I don't find it necessary to dismiss objective information simply because it does not say what I hoped it would say. I, like the AAP consider it insufficient to overcome my bias toward physical integrity.

And exactly what "facts" did you think you provided? All I saw was continued vilification and name-calling plus the presentation of a straw man argument.

Linda

The argumentation is naturally post-hoc, because the things stated were never the reason for the circumsision.

More importantly though, your "facts" aren't as clear cut.

http://www.infocirc.org/facts.htm (biased site against circumsision)
 
Because it states the child should be included in the decision to have something done to it at an appropriate level with respect to its cognitive abilities.

So preface everything I said with "Taking into consideration the rights of the child". The argument makes so sense unless that is assumed, anyway.

As Athon has said, neo-natal circumcision has minimal if not insignificant benefits (by the standards of most rational people) for the child up to an age when it could start to be involved in the decision making process.

Athon has already indicated that he/she is not conversant with research demonstrating the benefit, so how do you know that it does not fulfill the "standards of most rational people"?

Linda
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom