Evidence on the side of having a significant impact on sexual effect?
When I have looked into it the general sexual aproval rateing of circumcision in adult men was positive. So do you have any studies to back up your claim?
Here are some studies, but see my two caveats below:
There's
this Korean one,
Then there's
this American one, showing slight decrease in erectile function, and increased overall satisfaction.
Chinese survey indicating decreased erectile function, and
American again, from an anti-circumcision site and somewhat tangential, but for once, the full article.
Caveat 1: This is a pretty difficult area of study, seeing as the obvious solution, surveying adults before and after circumcision is going to net you a sample with an overrepresentation of medical conditions (phimosis etc.), and of course getting these corrected is going to lead to an increase in wellbeing. People who were circumcised as infants (or not) simply won't know the difference. BUT, that the foreskin contains nerve endings and is part mucous membrane indicates,
in my common-sense opinion, that it is functional in some way.
Caveat 2: To be honest, discussing this is a bit of a mine field. It's hard to get to the meat of the actual data, not having access to the paper journals and research databases. With this topic, you have heavily biased sources on each side of the debate, and I'm sure parts of both sides are guilty of overstating their cases. I'm sure my (almost non-existant) statistical and medical expertise is not enough to separate the chaff from the wheat.
Thus my response that simple assertions that this is an uncontroversial issue aren't going to cut it. It is controversial in that we have surveys and studies that indicate increased erectile dysfunction in circumcised males, and some that show a dip in sexual satisfaction. So, regardless of how this data stacks up against the other side, it simply
is a controversial issue.
And
in my opinion, this uncertainty alone is enough to rethink routine circumcision in infants. Plus, and here my (European) cultural bias is really showing, the idea of performing routine surgery on a newborn is just absurd - why would you risk it?