Circumcision: can any rational thinker defend it ?

I know several men who say that they wish they hadn't have been circumcised as infants, and now think their penises are numb to some degree as a result.

If they were circumcised as a baby, they have no basis for comparison. How do they know that not all penises are "numb to some degree"?
 
They're not comparable, because small holes in ears grow closed if they're not kept open. Foreskins (and the associated nerves and membranes) do not regrow.

Not true. My sister had her ears pierced as a child. When she went to college, she stopped wearing earings for several years. The holes never grew over.
 
An erect uncircumcised penis looks like a circumcised penis. You don't see many porn stars with a flop-on so how can you tell if they've been done?

Even though they look the same, the benefit of the foreskin is still there during intercourse as it moves up and down over the bell end. Since you're having a go at us un's, I'll raise the stakes and say the only reason your dad had you circumcised is because he didn't want you to go through his red-faced shame of ejaculating 5 seconds after entry :D

ETA: Can someone have a Dig at me for that last comment. I see on my profile I have 404 posts and not a single Dig yet.

Actually (and I'm no expert on this but from what observational experience I do have...) most of the time in porn movies the male "actors" are at best barely erect.

But in any case if I made people without circumcisions feel I was poking fun at them it was not intended that way. Just meant to say that NO penis looks not silly (foreskin or not) and that I thought that the ones with a foreskin look a lot more silly.

The point I was trying to make ultimately is that the foreskin, unlike the female clitoris, is completely vestigal. A throwback. Probably eventually humans will almost never have them at all on birth. It comes from a time when one ran around with nothing but fur and you needed a place to keep your dangly bits safe and warm. But now we have underpants. You might at well keep a long part of the umbilical cord attached to you. The foreskin is just as useful.

Here, in the US, almost every male is circumcised. Whether this has any actual health benefit or not is inconclusive, although most studies have pointed to some benefit. The part removed is as important to have as a tail.

Thus I object to the OP lumping circumcision with female genital mutilation.

Circumcision = Removing a functionless, vestigal, unattractive body part
Mutilation = Removing a functioning, important body part.
 
Last edited:
...Which circumcision is not. Circumcision is in no way detrimental to the later sexual development of the child, if performed correctly. Period.

Assert this a strongly as you wish, it remains a controversial point.
 
From your link "...scientific evidence demonstrates potential medical benefits of newborn male circumcision; however, these data are not sufficient to recommend routine neonatal circumcision...".

Having browsed through the sources, I can tell you that using the results of those studies to justify circumcision is "grasping at straws". Even considering mutilating an infant (or any other surgical procedure for that matter) to reduce a risk of a minor infection from 0.7% to 0.2% is deranged.

We should add the following:

The rate of infections due to circumcision is INFINITELY GREATER in circumcised children than non-circumcised children.

The rate of infant deaths due to circumcision is INFINITELY GREATER for circumcised infants than for non-circumsized infants.

So the question is, what is the tradeoff between a 4 four increase in penile cancer vs an infinite-fold increase in deaths?

Yes, these types of complications are rare, but then, as Z says, "So just because a disease is rare, we shouldn't bother taking steps to reduce our chances of getting it - or, more importantly, our children's chances?"
 
Miss Anthrope, you show me any evidence that men who contract AIDS are overwhelmingly men who have not been circumcised, and you may rest with a clear conscience. Otherwise, you have no reason.

Pardon me?

I said my son was circumcised because of severe phimosis. I have an absolutely clear conscience based on the fact that his foreskin could not be retracted and both the pediatrician and urologist said it wasn't going to fix itself, and would indeed cause many problems for him. I have a clear conscience because I feel that his having this done at a month old rather than at age seven at the latest was much better for him. Or are you saying I should let him suffer through painful erections as a pubescent and decide when he's 18 that he would like a functioning penis?

I said I saw the validity in the arguments against circumcision. I said the HIV issue gave me pause. I said I didn't know what decision I would have arrived at because I never had to make the decision. The decision was made for me because my son was born with severe phimosis. His father had it, and personally said he was grateful the circumcision was done as an infant rather than at a point where he would remember it.

The HIV issue is interesting. I offered it as a point of discussion, and something that I was considering in my decision before my son was born. I did not make an absolute statement. Your response to me is inappropriate.

Your whole moral authority about where my conscience should be seems to be a blind spot in your intellectual honesty. It certainly warrants the question: Who the heck do you think you are?
 
Last edited:
Miss Antrope, I defer to your doctors, but I am wondering - why were they expecting a month-olds foreskin to be retractable? Most boys can't retract thier foreskin until they are several years old, and that's perfectly normal.
 
Miss Antrope, I defer to your doctors, but I am wondering - why were they expecting a month-olds foreskin to be retractable? Most boys can't retract thier foreskin until they are several years old, and that's perfectly normal.

It had to do with where the skin connected. Basically instead of a tube like situation, we had the most of the foreskin (the top region) connected to skin in the middle of scrotum.
 
The argument of "let them decide for themselves" doesn't make much sense to me. The issue is that if the procedure is done as an adult, it is intensely painful for days, at least. If done as an infant, it doesn't appear to be as painful, although who can tell because they're crying all the time anyway.

:rolleyes:

"The evidence that neonates feel pain and suffer as much or more than do older children and adults is conclusive and generally accepted today."

Source

Ironic thought for the day: Orthodox Judaism forbids or discourages pierced ears, tatoos, or other forms of body alteration on the grounds that you aren't supposed to modify God's creation. I've heard Jews say that before and thought, "Hmm. Ok. Makes sense." I never realized the irony before.

He he, that's pretty funny. I'll have to remember that :) .
 
Actually (and I'm no expert on this but from what observational experience I do have...) most of the time in porn movies the male "actors" are at best barely erect.

But in any case if I made people without circumcisions feel I was poking fun at them it was not intended that way. Just meant to say that NO penis looks not silly (foreskin or not) and that I thought that the ones with a foreskin look a lot more silly.

The point I was trying to make ultimately is that the foreskin, unlike the female clitoris, is completely vestigal. A throwback. Probably eventually humans will almost never have them at all on birth. It comes from a time when one ran around with nothing but fur and you needed a place to keep your dangly bits safe and warm. But now we have underpants. You might at well keep a long part of the umbilical cord attached to you. The foreskin is just as useful.

Here, in the US, almost every male is circumcised. Whether this has any actual health benefit or not is inconclusive, although most studies have pointed to some benefit. The part removed is as important to have as a tail.

Thus I object to the OP lumping circumcision with female genital mutilation.

Circumcision = Removing a functionless, vestigal, unattractive body part
Mutilation = Removing a functioning, important body part.

Please, Functions of the Foreskin (The last ones are pretty funny).

The foreskin is just as functional as female parts. And your "unattractive" comment just reveals more cultural bias.
 
That's pretty lame. ;)

Of course things can and will change over time.

Including what parts an individual might want left on his body:)

I could make up a scenario where having been circumcised saves millions of men from certain death during an alien invasion in the year 2026.

You could, but it would not address the point I made, which was doctors in the past have been quicker to cut bits off than they generally are now. Why has the rate of circumcision remained so high in certain areas of the world?

The target rate for neonatal circumcisions in the UK has been recommended to be 0.6% by this paper:

Rickwood AMK, Kenny SE, Donnell SC. Towards evidence based circumcision of English boys: survey of trends in practice. BMJ 2000;321:792-3.

Here's the PDF

which is ~1/20th of the rate in the US. Clearly someone has got it very wrong.

This studentBMJ article has more references.

Yes, you've made that clear.

Linda

Where do you think parents rights stop with respect to their child's body?
 
Last edited:
Yes, but my position is that a potential few days of pain is easily worth the choice to have your body modified or not. That some would want to be circumcised as adults does not justify doing the procedure to all infants. That relatively few choose to have the procedure done as adults speaks volumes, IMHO.

The issue is how many would wish that they had had it done as infants, not those who get it done as adults.

From everything I can tell there are marginal costs and benefits on both sides, and it is just that the anti circ side makes massive appeals to emotion and often refuses to look at science since this is not about real risks and benefits but a PRINCIPLE.

So for everyone who argues that there are huge costs, well then think this, if you reversed the costs vs benefits of the procedure would it make sense to make everyone uncircumcised?(if the procedure produced an uncircumcised state), if people argue yes then they simply do not seem have an evidence based decision.
 
Assert this a strongly as you wish, it remains a controversial point.

Evidence on the side of having a significant impact on sexual effect?

When I have looked into it the general sexual aproval rateing of circumcision in adult men was positive. So do you have any studies to back up your claim?
 
I'm impressed that this conversation is still so civil. I can remember some huge flame war/conflicts over this issue, a decade ago or more.

That the question is framed as "defend it", rather than "support it with evidence", a small point perhaps, but one that illustrates the way the conversation can go.
 
Including what parts an individual might want left on his body:)

Of course. Fashions change. It's just that it turns out that we don't do a very good job of predicting this stuff in advance.

You could, but it would not address the point I made, which was doctors in the past have been quicker to cut bits off than they generally are now.

Ah, I thought you wanted me to guess at advances in medicine.

Why has the rate of circumcision remained so high in certain areas of the world?

My guess is that it's mostly cultural. I don't think it's driven by medicine, although it may reflect the degree to which there is a systematic effort by physicians to discourage the practice.

Where do you think parents rights stop with respect to their child's body?

I don't think this practice pushes the limits, if that's what you're asking - i.e. that I can justify interference in what is otherwise a private matter.

Linda
 
Please, "Functions of the Foreskin" (The last ones are pretty funny).

The foreskin is just as functional as female parts. And your "unattractive" comment just reveals more cultural bias.

I find the vast majority of the "functions" to be either wrongly attributing functions to the foreskin performed instead by other parts of the penis or in some cases the functions to be just plain silly.
Just take for instance:


7 Stores and releases natural lubricants ("smega" and pre-ejaculatory fluid)

This is incorrect. Pre-ejaculatory fluid exits the penis from the ureathra. And Smegma is the term the website's author wanted and Smegma is disgusting. Try washing your penis please.


3 Prevents dyspareunia (painful intercourse)

I think this one is a little odd. It's usually in women only and occurs BEFORE intercourse so how a foreskin is involved I dunno...


OF course my favorite is this one:

16 Vascular (rich in blood vessels that bring heat to the tissues), it protects the less vascular glans against frostbite, as Sir Ranulph Fiennes found on his epic transpolar walk.

AGAIN! That's why we have underwear now. If you're stupid enough to go to the ends of the earth without a good pair of thermals you deserve what you get. Next we'll be told not to wear hats but to stop cutting our hair. In fact one cause of impotence amongst men is their testicles are made too hot by clothing and they aren't producing.
 
Last edited:
Of course. Fashions change. It's just that it turns out that we don't do a very good job of predicting this stuff in advance.

Which is more reason not to do something years in advance of any medical indication that it is required.

Ah, I thought you wanted me to guess at advances in medicine.

No.

My guess is that it's mostly cultural. I don't think it's driven by medicine, although it may reflect the degree to which there is a systematic effort by physicians to discourage the practice.

I find your phrasing unusual; Isn't it more strange that a procedure that has such marginal benefits in the developed world has been supported for so long by physicians?

I don't think this practice pushes the limits, if that's what you're asking - i.e. that I can justify interference in what is otherwise a private matter.

Linda

What I'm trying to understand is where your limit is. What act performed towards a child leads you to conclude that it should not be tolerated?

E.g., is a Jehovah's witness withholding blood from their child a private matter? Or ritual practices that do not result in significant long term harm to a child, such as performed by some followers of particular religions? What about removing the toenails of infants to avoid ingrown toenails?

NB: I'm not trying to argue that these are equivalent to circumcision, just putting them forward to try to understand where your limit is. Give another example if you think these are inappropriate.

My position is that circumcision should only be performed to a child when it is medically indicated, with very few exceptions (such as regions of the world where there is a high incidence of HIV). I am not anti-circumcision - it has its place. I think it is fortunate that the vast majority of men who were circumcised as infants are happy (if not down right enthusiastic!) about their state.
 
Evidence on the side of having a significant impact on sexual effect?

When I have looked into it the general sexual aproval rateing of circumcision in adult men was positive. So do you have any studies to back up your claim?

Here are some studies, but see my two caveats below:

There's this Korean one,

Then there's this American one, showing slight decrease in erectile function, and increased overall satisfaction.

Chinese survey indicating decreased erectile function, and

American again, from an anti-circumcision site and somewhat tangential, but for once, the full article.

Caveat 1: This is a pretty difficult area of study, seeing as the obvious solution, surveying adults before and after circumcision is going to net you a sample with an overrepresentation of medical conditions (phimosis etc.), and of course getting these corrected is going to lead to an increase in wellbeing. People who were circumcised as infants (or not) simply won't know the difference. BUT, that the foreskin contains nerve endings and is part mucous membrane indicates, in my common-sense opinion, that it is functional in some way.

Caveat 2: To be honest, discussing this is a bit of a mine field. It's hard to get to the meat of the actual data, not having access to the paper journals and research databases. With this topic, you have heavily biased sources on each side of the debate, and I'm sure parts of both sides are guilty of overstating their cases. I'm sure my (almost non-existant) statistical and medical expertise is not enough to separate the chaff from the wheat.

Thus my response that simple assertions that this is an uncontroversial issue aren't going to cut it. It is controversial in that we have surveys and studies that indicate increased erectile dysfunction in circumcised males, and some that show a dip in sexual satisfaction. So, regardless of how this data stacks up against the other side, it simply is a controversial issue.

And in my opinion, this uncertainty alone is enough to rethink routine circumcision in infants. Plus, and here my (European) cultural bias is really showing, the idea of performing routine surgery on a newborn is just absurd - why would you risk it?
 
Last edited:
I find the vast majority of the "functions" to be either wrongly attributing functions to the foreskin performed instead by other parts of the penis or in some cases the functions to be just plain silly.
Just take for instance:


7 Stores and releases natural lubricants ("smega" and pre-ejaculatory fluid)

This is incorrect. Pre-ejaculatory fluid exits the penis from the ureathra. And Smegma is the term the website's author wanted and Smegma is disgusting. Try washing your penis please.


3 Prevents dyspareunia (painful intercourse)

I think this one is a little odd. It's usually in women only and occurs BEFORE intercourse so how a foreskin is involved I dunno...


OF course my favorite is this one:

16 Vascular (rich in blood vessels that bring heat to the tissues), it protects the less vascular glans against frostbite, as Sir Ranulph Fiennes found on his epic transpolar walk.

AGAIN! That's why we have underwear now. If you're stupid enough to go to the ends of the earth without a good pair of thermals you deserve what you get. Next we'll be told not to wear hats but to stop cutting our hair. In fact one cause of impotence amongst men is their testicles are made too hot by clothing and they aren't producing.

As I said, they get pretty funny. But that does not discount that there are functions for the foreskin, you know, like those other ones on the list.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom