So, in any OTHER situation, a possible disadvantage would prevent us from doing something with possible advantage. Why doesn´t this apply in this case?
Are you suggesting that a "simple cliterodectomy" is not genital mutilation, then?It is more correct to refer to the ongoing process that happens in many countries as 'female genital mutilation', because it is a procedure that goes beyond cliterodectomy, and it avoids the ridiculous doublespeak behind the use of 'circumcision'.
That argument does move me.On March 28, 2007, the World Health Organisation and UNAIDS issued joint recommendations concerning male circumcision and HIV/AIDS.[107] These recommendations are:
- Male circumcision should now be recognized as an efficacious intervention for HIV prevention.
- Promoting male circumcision should be recognized as an additional, important strategy for the prevention of heterosexually acquired HIV infection in men.[108]
I don't really buy the notion that the foreskin is very useful as a protective sheath. I suspect as adolescence hits, any protection is nullified by frequent self stimulation. You'd think all that rubbing would destroy such a sensitive gland.
Yep let’s rename it to something that doesn't offend! That's rubbish and is trying to use words to hide the real meaning - it is mutilation (whether practiced on men or women).
recently called for tact and patience regarding FGC eradication activities and warned against the dangers of demonizing cultures under cover of condemning practices harmful to women and girls
An argument I've heard from quite a few men circumcised as infants is that they prefer being circumcised and would be circumcised now if they had not been as a child.

I've also had it pointed out by a nurse that if you were ever in a position where you weren't able to clean yourself, there's no way you could count on a nurse to do it for you, and infection would be almost inevitable.
The short answer is "Yes." The subject is still highly controversial within the pediatrics community, with substantial opinion on both sides. Rather than state all the arguments, go to the American Academy of Pediatrics (they won't let me post the URL) and search for "circumcision." Very enlightening. Right or wrong, it's definitely controversial.
You must distinguish between newborn male circumcision and female genital mutilation. You can't even call the latter "circumcision" because there is no "foreskin" to remove. The former is a controversial medical procedure. The latter isn't.
BZ MD