Circumcision: can any rational thinker defend it ?

My position is the same as Fran's, as expressed in the other thread, that adults don't have the right to mutilate their children.

M.
 
So, in any OTHER situation, a possible disadvantage would prevent us from doing something with possible advantage. Why doesn´t this apply in this case?

I don't think that's really the case. We choose things all the time for our kids (vaccinations, braces, tonsillectomies) that have a small potential for harm, but a larger potential for benefit. The research demonstrates that the advantages to circumcision outweigh the disadvantages. However, the advantage did not seem strong enough to me to overcome my bias, so I did not have my sons circumcized. It seems to me that both sides use their personal preferences to justify their decision.

Linda
 
It is more correct to refer to the ongoing process that happens in many countries as 'female genital mutilation', because it is a procedure that goes beyond cliterodectomy, and it avoids the ridiculous doublespeak behind the use of 'circumcision'.
Are you suggesting that a "simple cliterodectomy" is not genital mutilation, then?

Even if there is a worse procedure than simply removing the clitoris, doesn't make it horribly barbaric. :rolleyes:
 
I dare say it has a lot to do with different cultures, and I don't mean religion...I didn't even know circumcision was so common in the US until I read a heated debate on LiveJournal (don't ask). In Sweden it's only done as a last resort for medical reasons, as a result I have during my thirty years as a nurse never seen a cut man. :)

And I have seen more male members than I want to think about...
 
Since this thread has been necromanced I thought I'd put my two cents in.

First cent: Per the thread title, as a rational person I can defend my son's circumcision. He was born with severe phimosis. This means his foreskin could not retract. In his case, it would barely budge at all. If he had not been circumcized as an infant, he would most definitely have had to face this painful procedure later in life. This was confirmed by two doctors (The pediatrician and a urologist) I'd rather he did it as an infant without specific memory than face it near puberty.

Second cent: From the wikipedia article on this topic
On March 28, 2007, the World Health Organisation and UNAIDS issued joint recommendations concerning male circumcision and HIV/AIDS.[107] These recommendations are:
  • Male circumcision should now be recognized as an efficacious intervention for HIV prevention.
  • Promoting male circumcision should be recognized as an additional, important strategy for the prevention of heterosexually acquired HIV infection in men.[108]
That argument does move me.

I see the validity in arguments against circumcision. But the HIV angle gives much to consider. When my son was born I was firmly on the fence of this issue. With his medical condition I felt circumcision was the best choice for him. I do not know which argument would have swayed me had this factor not come into play.
 
Last edited:
That society 'accepts' something is not a logical argument. And hygiene is no argument either - we're born that way, and it's natural, and we've propagated. Obviously there is no evolutionary downside to foreskin.

Consider a parallel example - body piercings. How many times have you heard people of both genders freak out over an eyebrow, lip, nose or nipple piercing, all the while sitting there smugly with their pierced ears? That's how sheepish people are.

There is no justification for or rational argument for circumcision. Both male and female circumcision were originally done for religious reasons, which should be your first clue! The female version is considered barbaric by us Westerners because it's not a Judeo-Christian thing. It's also more brutal because it's done by laymen with questionable instruments. If it were done in the finest hospitals, and had been for decades or centuries, no one would think anything about it.

Let this be a lesson to you: anytime a question like this comes up, ask yourself if there is a rational and genuinely logical reason for it, or if you only think it's okay 'because that's how we've always done it.'
 
Miss Anthrope, you show me any evidence that men who contract AIDS are overwhelmingly men who have not been circumcised, and you may rest with a clear conscience. Otherwise, you have no reason.
 
An argument I've heard from quite a few men circumcised as infants is that they prefer being circumcised and would be circumcised now if they had not been as a child.

I find that argument fascinating.

What I conclude from it is that parents should be allowed to do anything to their children that (a) is not likely to seriously harm them in the long term and (b) they can convince the child/adult that it was done out of "love" for them, before or after the fact.

If the person is happy about with what has been done to them (with or without their consent) then what does it matter if it's viewed as right or wrong by anybody else?

E.g., would rape be wrong if a drug was available that altered the victim's perception such that they enjoyed the attack or the memory of it?
 
Perhaps some words from an uncircumcised American.

My mother informed me at a very early age that hygiene was important with every bath. Later in my teens my uncircumcised uncle told me about when he was a teen how his got infected and had to be forced open. Don't have numbers on infections rates etc. but with basic hygiene I never had any issues . I suspect that in early societies this was the motivation for it. I can see that without basic hygiene it could be a vector for a range of diseases and infections. Simple solution is cleanliness and a shower together afterwords can be fun also.

I don't really buy the notion that the foreskin is very useful as a protective sheath. I suspect as adolescence hits, any protection is nullified by frequent self stimulation. You'd think all that rubbing would destroy such a sensitive gland.

Personally I can't imagine having to deal with the irritation of cloths if I got circumcised today. I think I would rather break an arm (for a 5th time). Such activities do not nullify the protection, though it seems to make such activities easier.

I'm undecided on the value of the practice on boys. I don't think it is of much value without immediate cause. On girls it is a horrifying crime.
 
I never really thought much of it until I learned that it was a cultural thing, mostly for Americans and related nations. And yes, I remember that one of the founders of the practice believed it would reduce masturbation. I only really see justification in doing so when it is absolutely medically necessary(As in Miss Anthrope). The hygiene argument is stupid, men can clean down there.

The HIV angle is just silly. "Well, we can give a mediocre reduction in risk in spreading HIV if we slice of the protecting covering for the glans, which contains a large portion of his body's nerve endings." Or you could just tell him to WEAR A CONDOM. That would protect him from all the STIs and even from paying for a baby. And it wouldn't reduce his pleasure, and lob off a piece of him without consent and with out anesthetic.

And how would asking men who have been cut all their lives tell us anything? They don't know what they're missing. A man who was recently circumcised said that he felt less pleasure in sex.

We find anything done to a female unthinkable, but for males we don't even give it a second thought (This is from an white, Christian, American POV). Culturally accepted practices that are just stupid are still just stupid.
 
Last edited:
Yep let’s rename it to something that doesn't offend! That's rubbish and is trying to use words to hide the real meaning - it is mutilation (whether practiced on men or women).

That FGM/FGC is performed without anesthesia doesn't mean it has to be. If it were performed under general anesthesia would that make it Ok?

As to the comparison between the two, if FGC is performed on infant girls just after birth, would it be more acceptable?

Both FGM/FGC and MGM/Circ. have a cultural basis. Do Hasidic Jews have the right to bite off the foreskin with their bare teeth? See below:

http://www.libertypost.org/cgi-bin/readart.cgi?ArtNum=123832

recently called for tact and patience regarding FGC eradication activities and warned against the dangers of demonizing cultures under cover of condemning practices harmful to women and girls

Had to quote again: Hey let's all obey the prime directive, and practice non-interference. -- So the infants born to Hasidic Jews pick up syphilis, in the name of cultural preservation.
 
An argument I've heard from quite a few men circumcised as infants is that they prefer being circumcised and would be circumcised now if they had not been as a child.

As one who was born to Jewish parents, and circumcised as an infant (though not w/ the ritual Briss) I can say that I have nothing to compare it to. However having gone through puberty with it as I remember it, I have no desire to add to it. -- (see a Penn and Teller ********! episode - I hear it's possible)

However interestingly I did not know what the foreskin looked like until around 9th grade biology. That is I was brought up in a culture where most infants, Jewish, or Christian or anything else were circumcised. Therefore at the very least it wasn't one of the many things I was teased about in high school.
 
I remember seeing one kid in gym class that had a very unusual penis and I thought something was wrong with it. I later realized he was the only uncirumcised kid in the school.

We decided not to have our son circumcised, partly on the strength of a friend's testimony who was uncircumcised and said that the part cut off was the part that felt the best. Partly, I just figured it wouldn't be there if it weren't a good idea.

Later, I've had cause to question my decision. I've heard horror stories of men who got infections and had to be circumcised as adults. I've also had it pointed out by a nurse that if you were ever in a position where you weren't able to clean yourself, there's no way you could count on a nurse to do it for you, and infection would be almost inevitable.

I hope I haven't stuck my kid with a real burden on him.

We also made the decision before we decided to send the kid to a Jewish school. That one could be a problem!:jaw-dropp
 
Last edited:
I've also had it pointed out by a nurse that if you were ever in a position where you weren't able to clean yourself, there's no way you could count on a nurse to do it for you, and infection would be almost inevitable.

Is there actually any clinical evidence that infection is almost inevitable if a man does not wash under their foreskin regularly?

Are infections almost inevitable if people do not wash their mouths, noses, vaginas, anuses or other similar areas with more or less exposed mucous membranes? My uneducated guess would be that infections were more likely but not almost inevitable.

It sounds like the kind of thing people woud make up to embroider the existing story that circumcision is justified for hygienic reasons.

I've certainly never heard of infected foreskins being a major killer amongst the bedridden.
 
The short answer is "Yes." The subject is still highly controversial within the pediatrics community, with substantial opinion on both sides. Rather than state all the arguments, go to the American Academy of Pediatrics (they won't let me post the URL) and search for "circumcision." Very enlightening. Right or wrong, it's definitely controversial.

You must distinguish between newborn male circumcision and female genital mutilation. You can't even call the latter "circumcision" because there is no "foreskin" to remove. The former is a controversial medical procedure. The latter isn't.

BZ MD

You're cultural bias is showing. We only consider the former a controversial medical procedure because it happens in our culture.

I think that in cultures where neither happens, both would seem equally cruel.

Especially since in not all cultures where they "circumsize" the labia, do they remove the ability for the women to enjoy sex.
 
All surgical procedures are barbaric. So long as an individual is happy with what's been done to them, why should anyone care?

One of the perks of being a parent is the chance to form your child's world view to be similar to your own. It's every parents right isn't it?

Being a parent is the closest thing to being God many people get; the opportunity of getting another not only to bend to your will, but want to. It must be very satisfying.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom