Circumcision: can any rational thinker defend it ?

Maybe because all of those are just post-hoc justifications (and iffy ones, at that) for a barbarian practice that's been around for millenia...

So your claim has changed? It is now that there was no medical evidence that it had benefit when it started?


Let me tell you a secret. Decrying the religious mutilation of infants is not an emotional response, it's a social obligation by any rational person. Grasping at straws to justify continuing a primitive ritual is an emotional reaction.

Wrong you are making an emotional argument, this is seen by how readily you dismiss evidence.
And BTW, since breast cancer is more prevalent than penile cancer, do you defend mastectomies for every teenager? The absolute benefit would be much greater than the "moderate to tiny".
But breast feeding offers a great medical benefit to a child.
 
Well the penial cancer is a ridiculous thing to take into consideration, it's the rarest of cancers.

1 in 100,000 males with intact foreskin get penial cancer, this is 5 times lower than the chance for a non-smoker(even when he gets no second hand smoke) to develop lung-cancer.

More importantly, soon there may very well be a HPV-vaccination(it's in the final test stages), and then penial cancer rates will drop even lower.
 
I'dunno Linda. Perhaps some people bought into the whole Rights of the Child idea the UN came up with.

Yet WHO, which is, I believe, the health branch of the U.N. (or similarly related), strongly recommends circumcision as a way to limit the spread of HIV and other diseases...
 
Yet WHO, which is, I believe, the health branch of the U.N. (or similarly related), strongly recommends circumcision as a way to limit the spread of HIV and other diseases...

Don't forget though that this is the same branch that advocates acknowledging homeopathy as a legitimate treatment method.

Yeah yeah... I know that's ad homimin (sp?)

But I like to counter one fallacy (appeal to authority) with another.

:blush:
 
The argumentation is naturally post-hoc, because the things stated were never the reason for the circumsision.

Did someone claim that they were?

More importantly though, your "facts" aren't as clear cut.

http://www.infocirc.org/facts.htm (biased site against circumsision)

I provided a link to the original source of my "facts" so that anyone who was interested could look at them directly. 'Tis true that the fog created with misleading and misrepresentative layers of information can make anything less clear.

Linda
 
Well the penial cancer is a ridiculous thing to take into consideration, it's the rarest of cancers.

1 in 100,000 males with intact foreskin get penial cancer, this is 5 times lower than the chance for a non-smoker(even when he gets no second hand smoke) to develop lung-cancer.

More importantly, soon there may very well be a HPV-vaccination(it's in the final test stages), and then penial cancer rates will drop even lower.

So just because a disease is rare, we shouldn't bother taking steps to reduce our chances of getting it - or, more importantly, our children's chances?

The biggest reason I support neonatal circumcision, is that most men WON'T elect to get it done as an adult - for no other reason than fear and obsessiveness about their todger. Even if they have a dozen infections and are highly at risk, adult men would rather suffer anything than clip their sausage. Much better to snip them before they develop their obsessions and fears, and be done with it.

Of course, my opinions on the subject should be taken with a tremendous grain of salt, considering I'm also for the genetic manipulation of embryos and the removal of aggressive behaviors through gene therapy, etc. Personal rights aren't worth squat, IMO, compared to health, social, and cosmetic benefits. Thus making me a fascist control freak with a serious GOD complex. And I make absolutely no apologies for that.

In fact, if it were up to me, I'd just go in and change the genetic code so that circumcision was simply no longer necessary. Oh, and so that every man could have between five to seven inches, instead of the vast variation men currently suffer.

Then I'd work on improving the genetics so that the male brain could actually function on lower testosterone levels...
 
Well the penial cancer is a ridiculous thing to take into consideration, it's the rarest of cancers.

The only benefit that seems sufficient to me on purely medical grounds is the reduction in HIV transmission in high prevalence areas.

Linda
 
No.

Linda

Could you be a bit more verbose;)

Surely antibiotics are generally considered a better way to treat infections than removing the infected tissue?

The incidence of tight foreskin requiring circumcision in infants is probably overstated in the US because of the willingness of doctors to perform circumcision for no medical reason at all. Is there research from other regions of the world showing how common this "problem" is there and other methods of treating it?

E.g., ingrown toenails on the NHS were routinely completely removed, while there exists a technique that removes just the sides that are causing the problem.
 
Could you be a bit more verbose;)

Surely antibiotics are generally considered a better way to treat infections than removing the infected tissue?

It's more of an issue of prevention than treatment.

The incidence of tight foreskin requiring circumcision in infants is probably overstated in the US because of the willingness of doctors to perform circumcision for no medical reason at all. Is there research from other regions of the world showing how common this "problem" is there and other methods of treating it?

This information provided in the review I have now referenced three times came from New Zealand and Denmark.

You could consider reading it. ;)

Linda
 
See, this is exactly what I mean. I personally advocate for the physical integrity of children. However, that does not make me dismiss the available research as "post hoc", "iffy", "grasping at straws", etc.

From your link "...scientific evidence demonstrates potential medical benefits of newborn male circumcision; however, these data are not sufficient to recommend routine neonatal circumcision...".

Having browsed through the sources, I can tell you that using the results of those studies to justify circumcision is "grasping at straws". Even considering mutilating an infant (or any other surgical procedure for that matter) to reduce a risk of a minor infection from 0.7% to 0.2% is deranged.

It is also iffy, because in the case of penile cancer, if the relative risks for not being circumcised, for smoking and for having a history of genital warts are 3.2, 2.8 and 5.9, and the researcher concludes that "These results suggest that the absence of neonatal circumcision and potential resulting complications are associated with penile cancer", than something is wrong. And this related to an extremely rare cancer.

It is a post-hoc justification, because the research was done much after the establishment of the tradition.

I don't find it necessary to dismiss objective information simply because it does not say what I hoped it would say. I, like the AAP consider it insufficient to overcome my bias toward physical integrity.

I do not dismiss the information, I evaluate it. Maybe therein lies the difference.

And exactly what "facts" did you think you provided? All I saw was continued vilification and name-calling plus the presentation of a straw man argument.

I don't think I provided any facts, except for calling of attention to 70% of men in the globe not being circumcised. I surely provided my opinion, which is fundamented. I also provided some definitions, but they seem to have been interpreted by you as "name-calling". You might not like reality, but that would be your problem.

You seem to think that the advantages exist, altough not significant enough to justify circumcision. I contend that the advantages do not exist, and are used to justify a primitive practice, since it's embraced by a significant part of your population.
 
Well...
Frankly, a penis, already pretty funny looking, is 1000000 times uglier with the foreskin. Look at all the circumcised male porn stars? See much porn with non-curcumcised men? Doubt you could find much.

Listen, stop dissing my penis, all right? I see this argument from time to time, and it's frankly getting old having to listen to how horrible I look. You simply don't know.

And yes, issues of whether porn actors are the pinnacles of beauty (or even normality) we should all aspire to emulate aside, it's possible to find plenty of porn with uncircumcised actors. Mostly the stuff that's not from major American producers (gasp - who'd've thought), which also has the neat side effect of not featuring women with the silicone enhanced (and thoroughly bizarre) 'porn star look'.

Also, in the erect penis, circumcised or not isn't that different in appearance.

So just because a disease is rare, we shouldn't bother taking steps to reduce our chances of getting it - or, more importantly, our children's chances?

Not if the risks are small enough and the steps taken are detrimental to the later sexual development of the child. You have to do a cost / benefit analysis on these things, otherwise you'd end up indiscriminately doing appendectomies on newborn babies as well (might as well get it over with), a dangerous procedure that would scar them for life. But hey, appendicitis is a potentially lethal condition!

Of course, my opinions on the subject should be taken with a tremendous grain of salt, considering I'm also for the genetic manipulation of embryos and the removal of aggressive behaviors through gene therapy, etc. Personal rights aren't worth squat, IMO, compared to health, social, and cosmetic benefits. Thus making me a fascist control freak with a serious GOD complex. And I make absolutely no apologies for that.

Fair enough, and thanks for letting us know where you stand on this. I can't agree with much of what you say, but it seems consistent.

I just want to comment on the one about cosmetic benefits. As far as I'm concerned, cosmetic reasons for surgery are whimsical and change over time. It's fashion, and as such, if permanent body modifications for cosmetic reasons are to be done at all, it should be the person in questions own informed choice. To be frank, the choice to have breast enlargements (pec injections for males) or labial reduction leaves me puzzled. What's wrong with small breasts or a vulva with visible inner labia? Those are not problems to be eradicated, they're sexy! It's called personality!

To each their own, and I don't dispute people's right to have it done. But you can't decide stuff like this for someone else, parent or not.
 
So your claim has changed? It is now that there was no medical evidence that it had benefit when it started?

What are you talking about? I claim that the evidence, as it's being presented, is iffy. The relative risks are small, if you consider the incidence of infections and the potential socio-cultural differences between groups. The significance is quite good in some of the abstracts (although I would like to see how they controled for inter-group differences) but not mentioned in some of the others.

I also claim that it is a barbaric ritual probably designed to increase the "holy men" power and income. Do you have a problem with that speculation?

And I claim that people that mutilate children are "child mutilators". Is that incorrect?

Wrong you are making an emotional argument, this is seen by how readily you dismiss evidence.

What evidence did I dismiss? That you didn't bother to check the sources?

But breast feeding offers a great medical benefit to a child.

Irrelevant if the mother died of breast cancer before becoming pregnant.
The point being that it is not good medical practice to snip human parts for putative benefits, the weak evidence for which appeared much after the practice begun...
 
It's more of an issue of prevention than treatment.

In the old medical text books you collect I'm sure there are many examples of preventative interventions that you would never consider performing now because a newer treatment is easier on the patient.

This information provided in the review I have now referenced three times came from New Zealand and Denmark.

You could consider reading it. ;)

Linda

So if the New Zealand study is taken at face value, then circumcising an infant actually increases penile problems for infants, while providing reduction in problems for older children.

http://pediatrics.aappublications.o...jkey=d83c727913a1cd837baadadf107f37db00d0c6aa

Based on this it still seems to me that it's a lifestyle choice issue. I.e. it should be left up to the individual when they are able to choose for themselves, not by parents.
 
Last edited:
To each their own, and I don't dispute people's right to have it done. But you can't decide stuff like this for someone else, parent or not.

The argument of "let them decide for themselves" doesn't make much sense to me. The issue is that if the procedure is done as an adult, it is intensely painful for days, at least. If done as an infant, it doesn't appear to be as painful, although who can tell because they're crying all the time anyway.

Ironic thought for the day: Orthodox Judaism forbids or discourages pierced ears, tatoos, or other forms of body alteration on the grounds that you aren't supposed to modify God's creation. I've heard Jews say that before and thought, "Hmm. Ok. Makes sense." I never realized the irony before.
 
From your link "...scientific evidence demonstrates potential medical benefits of newborn male circumcision; however, these data are not sufficient to recommend routine neonatal circumcision...".

Having browsed through the sources, I can tell you that using the results of those studies to justify circumcision is "grasping at straws". Even considering mutilating an infant (or any other surgical procedure for that matter) to reduce a risk of a minor infection from 0.7% to 0.2% is deranged.

If someone was using the results of those particular studies as the reason to justify circumcision, I would agree that they were "grasping at straws". However, since I haven't seen anybody do so, I don't understand who exactly you are talking about that is grasping at straws.

It is also iffy, because in the case of penile cancer, if the relative risks for not being circumcised, for smoking and for having a history of genital warts are 3.2, 2.8 and 5.9, and the researcher concludes that "These results suggest that the absence of neonatal circumcision and potential resulting complications are associated with penile cancer", than something is wrong. And this related to an extremely rare cancer.

I don't understand what you think is wrong with that conclusion.

It is a post-hoc justification, because the research was done much after the establishment of the tradition.

It is my impression that the research was done to evaluate the effects of the procedure.

I do not dismiss the information, I evaluate it. Maybe therein lies the difference.

I was looking for some indication that you had done so.

I don't think I provided any facts, except for calling of attention to 70% of men in the globe not being circumcised. I surely provided my opinion, which is fundamented. I also provided some definitions, but they seem to have been interpreted by you as "name-calling". You might not like reality, but that would be your problem.

You seem to have chosen words specifically to invoke emotional reactions, such a mutilator/mutilated, barbarian, primitive, etc. and then insisted that they accurately convey how we should think of anyone who has their child circumcised. It is simply my observation that circumcision is one of those topics that seems to bring out this behaviour, and that I don't see the necessity for the negative characterizations.

You seem to think that the advantages exist, altough not significant enough to justify circumcision. I contend that the advantages do not exist, and are used to justify a primitive practice, since it's embraced by a significant part of your population.

My population? I think you are quite mistaken.

I do not understand how your statement that the advantages do not exist can be anything but a dismissal of the research I mentioned earlier, since the research demonstrates various advantages and you did not provide any specific reasons that the results would be invalid.

Linda
 
In the old medical text books you collect I'm sure there are many examples of preventative interventions that you would never consider performing now because a newer treatment is easier on the patient.

That's pretty lame. ;)

Of course things can and will change over time. I could make up a scenario where having been circumcised saves millions of men from certain death during an alien invasion in the year 2026.

So if the New Zealand study is taken at face value, then circumcising an infant actually increases penile problems for infants, while providing reduction in problems for older children.

http://pediatrics.aappublications.o...jkey=d83c727913a1cd837baadadf107f37db00d0c6aa

Based on this it still seems to me that it's a lifestyle choice issue. I.e. it should be left up to the individual when they are able to choose for themselves, not by parents.

Yes, you've made that clear.

Linda
 
Well...

When I was born a large majority of (non-Jewish) American children were circumcised (for "health" reasons). Regardless of the medical aspect (right or not) I am extremely glad I was.

Frankly, a penis, already pretty funny looking, is 1000000 times uglier with the foreskin. Look at all the circumcised male porn stars? See much porn with non-curcumcised men? Doubt you could find much.

I'm sure there are other good reasons for the procedure as well, beyond vanity.

But in essence, the foreskin, like other evolutionary holdovers, is not necessary. It's like when people are born with tails, webbing, etc. Clothing makes having a foreskin superfluous.

Combining circumcision with female genital mutilation (as in the OP) is kind of silly. The two procedures are so far removed from each other. This post should be split asunder as each subject should have it's own post.

An erect uncircumcised penis looks like a circumcised penis. You don't see many porn stars with a flop-on so how can you tell if they've been done?

Even though they look the same, the benefit of the foreskin is still there during intercourse as it moves up and down over the bell end. Since you're having a go at us un's, I'll raise the stakes and say the only reason your dad had you circumcised is because he didn't want you to go through his red-faced shame of ejaculating 5 seconds after entry :D

ETA: Can someone have a Dig at me for that last comment. I see on my profile I have 404 posts and not a single Dig yet.
 
Last edited:
The argument of "let them decide for themselves" doesn't make much sense to me. The issue is that if the procedure is done as an adult, it is intensely painful for days, at least. If done as an infant, it doesn't appear to be as painful, although who can tell because they're crying all the time anyway.

Yes, but my position is that a potential few days of pain is easily worth the choice to have your body modified or not. That some would want to be circumcised as adults does not justify doing the procedure to all infants. That relatively few choose to have the procedure done as adults speaks volumes, IMHO.

Ironic thought for the day: Orthodox Judaism forbids or discourages pierced ears, tatoos, or other forms of body alteration on the grounds that you aren't supposed to modify God's creation. I've heard Jews say that before and thought, "Hmm. Ok. Makes sense." I never realized the irony before.

Heh, hadn't thought of that. I'd just filed it under weird religious tradition, like married jewish women wearing wigs to cover their hair.
 
Not if the risks are small enough and the steps taken are detrimental to the later sexual development of the child.

...Which circumcision is not. Circumcision is in no way detrimental to the later sexual development of the child, if performed correctly. Period.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom