fls,
The use of the qualifier "potentially dangerous" is probably redundant. Almost anything that can be done is potentially dangerous, so the issue is more appropriately a weighing of benefit and harm.
If it is redundant, that is only because
all surgical procedures involve some degree of risk. As for the weighing of benefit and harm, that is really the point of the question. The question already specifies that the procedure is not
medically necessary. The whole issue is whether or not it is ok for parents to have their child permanently surgically altered when such alteration is not medically needed.
It has not been established that circumcision does or does not "significantly" alter natural functions when performed in an infant.
This is, of course, complete nonsense. It is trivially obvious that circumcision significantly alters the natural functioning of the penis.
The WHO definition of "health", which guides physicians and other health-care providers when determining medical necessity, includes mental and social well-being.
Are you saying that it would be ok for doctors to brand babies at birth if that is what their parents insist their culture requires?
Anybody who answers this question with a "no" should be opposed to non-medically necessitated circumcision. If they are not opposed to it, then they either do not understand what circumcision actually does, or they contradicting themselves.
If by medical necessity you are only referring to physical well-being, then you need to persuade all involved that mental and social well-being are not an important component of health, I think.
Not in this sense, of course they are not. Permanently altering a healthy child's body for the sake of social conformity is
not morally acceptable.
Apparently Loss Leader answers this question with a "yes". I regard this as an example of an extremely immoral position on his part. Apparently others here do as well. He clearly does not.
It is fairly clear to me that many people misunderstand his position. I suspect that it is the desire to find his position "extremely immoral" that prevents understanding.
I do not "desire" to find his position extremely immoral. I simply do. And I would wager that if he were insisting on his right to brand his child, rather than amputate part of his child's penis, that you would find it immoral as well.
Any discussion of to what degree sensitivity is lost, or whether the person will "know what they're missing", or how painful it is, is really not relevant to the issue. If you answer "no" to my above question, then none of these issues matter because it is still wrong even if it is totally painless and no loss of sensation occurs.
Then why did you include the qualifier "significantly alter the natural functions"?
Because those specific questions are not the issue. The issue is whether it is acceptable to permanently alter the body of a healthy child.
If your answer to my above question is "yes" then nothing more really needs to be said. You have already established that you think that parents should be allowed to harm their children. What more need be said?
Yes, it has been well-established, on this thread, that the fallacy of "begging the question" is considered a reasonable method of arguing against circumcision. I have no idea why, though.
How is this begging the question? If surgically removing a healthy, functional part of their body does not constitute harm, then what does it take?
Appeals to religious tradition are complete non-starters. If your religion said brand your baby on the ass with the star of David, doing so would land you in prison. But objectively speaking, that is far less dangerous than circumcision, and would have zero affect on how your body functions.
Branding is another traditional way of indicating commitment to a group. Since laws reflect culture, I doubt it would have been perceived as a criminal act as an established tradition. As far as I know, cultures that include branding or tattooing of children do not form laws against the activity.
Is it acceptable in
our society? If you think that it should not be, then you are a hypocrite.
Loss Leader,
Your question contains the following assumptions:
1. Circumcision is potentially dangerous
This is not an assumption. It is a demonstrable fact which has been repeatedly pointed out in this thread.
2. Circumcision alters the natural functions of a baby's body
Again, not an assumption. I am circumcised. As a result my penis functions differently than it would if I were not. Masturbation is different. Sexual intercourse is different. Again, the issue of to what degree sensitivity is reduced, or whether I would ever know the difference, is utterly irrelevant. The bottom line is that it
is different. The natural function has been altered.
3. Such alteration is significant
No assumption here either. The difference is significant for any reasonable definition of "significant".
4. medical necessity is the only valid reason to circumcise a child
That's not an assumption. That is what the question is asking. If you answer "no", then you are effectively answering that medical necessity
would be the only valid reason to circumcise a child.
What you have done is carefully frame the question in such a way as to make your desired answer more reasonable.
There is nothing "careful" about it. It is a very simple, and very general question. Is it acceptable to surgically alter a healthy child's body? I say it is not, and cannot imagine how one could reasonably argue that it is.
It is logically identical to asking people in a political survey: "Do you believe the US should abandon the Iraqi people even if it means that the ensuing chaos will cause thousands of unnecessary deaths?"
It is nothing like that. My question did not even mention circumcision, for one thing. It is a very general question which should be very easy to answer. The only reason you do not like it is because you know that you cannot justify your answer.
Any yes or no answer has the effect of agreeing with your assumptions.
I did not make any assumptions.
I do not agree with your assumptions (except assumption 1 which is true of everything on earth from brain surgery to buttering toast).
Don't be ridiculous. Cutting off living tissue with lots of nerves and blood-vassals in it is
always dangerous. To compare that to buttering toast is simply idiotic.
Either ask a question that makes no judgments or just admit that you are too biased to care about any position other than your own. I don't really care which you do.
I am biased against child abuse. That much I will admit. I just would like to know how you can possibly argue that circumcision is not child abuse without giving parents free reign to do all sorts of things to their children which you
would consider to be abusive.
Be honest here. If somebody from some culture you never heard of was insisting that he should be able to brand his children (based on cultural tradition), would you support his right to do so? What about if he wanted to remove part of his daughter's clitoris? Or remove the right pinky toe of his child's foot?
Where exactly does it become abuse? What criteria do
you use for deciding that even cultural tradition does not justify the procedure?
By the arguments you have been presenting, you should be able to do literally anything you want to your child, as long as you personally believe it to be in his best interest (whatever that means). Clearly at some point you have to acknowledge that your
child has rights. You seem to be arguing that your child has no rights at all, and that instead
you have all the rights pertaining to your child's well-being.
Dr. Stupid