Circumcision: can any rational thinker defend it ?

Let me be very clear that you have just wished physical pain and suffering on my unborn son - a boy who has done nothing to you and who is innocent in every regard.

I just want to understand that you believe that it would be just and fair if my mistaken beliefs about circumcision were rewarded with medical complications and anguish in a person who does not share my beliefs and who has never offended you in any way.

The way you think I should be punished is for someone who is not me to be injured.

Have I correctly encapsulated your views?

I am disgusted beyond my ability to express or your ability to comprehend. Whereas I undertake my actions because I believe them to be in my son's best interests, your hopes have nothing to do with his interests at all. They are punitive and pusillanimous. Wishing ill on an infant makes you perhaps the sickest, sorriest, stupidest individual whom I have ever had the unfortunate occassion to meet.

I was reading over this again and I couldnt help but come back to it.

Just and fair, you certainly seem to think so, according to your referencing the law so frequently. I think a great many things that happen are unjust, including your happy little tradition, my feelings of justice dont make much difference though. I think itd be an effective lesson, it was with me ;).

Yes indeed, a boy who is innocent in every regard, correct. And defenseless I might add.

Yes a boy who doesnt believe what you believe, yet youre forcing on him. Youve said before that he believes what you believe yes? Or something to that effect. Self refuting.

Also, you may be disgusted with my comment, likewise however, I am disgusted with your adherence to this practice, at least Im not taking a knife to him. Remembering also that if he does hate you, or if he does have complications, or worse, it will be your fault, not mine. If he does, the practice is more likely to stop with him, at least for any family he may have.

The wishing ill comment is funny to me.

As I said, no reasonable argument. Judaism is a fascinating religion, aside from the genital mutilation, but itl end, or be reduced to residual levels, eventually anyway I would expect. Needless torture.

And finally, I hope you swell with pride, as would be expected, upon gazing at his injured member. Hopefully he will put on a good show for the rest in attendance as well. Take heart that hes at least unlikely to develop complications.

Id explain my feelings further, but youre unlikely to listen, youre in a rationality based discussion with an irrational base to your belief.
 
fls,

The use of the qualifier "potentially dangerous" is probably redundant. Almost anything that can be done is potentially dangerous, so the issue is more appropriately a weighing of benefit and harm.
If it is redundant, that is only because all surgical procedures involve some degree of risk. As for the weighing of benefit and harm, that is really the point of the question. The question already specifies that the procedure is not medically necessary. The whole issue is whether or not it is ok for parents to have their child permanently surgically altered when such alteration is not medically needed.

It has not been established that circumcision does or does not "significantly" alter natural functions when performed in an infant.
This is, of course, complete nonsense. It is trivially obvious that circumcision significantly alters the natural functioning of the penis.

The WHO definition of "health", which guides physicians and other health-care providers when determining medical necessity, includes mental and social well-being.
Are you saying that it would be ok for doctors to brand babies at birth if that is what their parents insist their culture requires?

Anybody who answers this question with a "no" should be opposed to non-medically necessitated circumcision. If they are not opposed to it, then they either do not understand what circumcision actually does, or they contradicting themselves.
If by medical necessity you are only referring to physical well-being, then you need to persuade all involved that mental and social well-being are not an important component of health, I think.
Not in this sense, of course they are not. Permanently altering a healthy child's body for the sake of social conformity is not morally acceptable.

Apparently Loss Leader answers this question with a "yes". I regard this as an example of an extremely immoral position on his part. Apparently others here do as well. He clearly does not.
It is fairly clear to me that many people misunderstand his position. I suspect that it is the desire to find his position "extremely immoral" that prevents understanding.
I do not "desire" to find his position extremely immoral. I simply do. And I would wager that if he were insisting on his right to brand his child, rather than amputate part of his child's penis, that you would find it immoral as well.

Any discussion of to what degree sensitivity is lost, or whether the person will "know what they're missing", or how painful it is, is really not relevant to the issue. If you answer "no" to my above question, then none of these issues matter because it is still wrong even if it is totally painless and no loss of sensation occurs.
Then why did you include the qualifier "significantly alter the natural functions"?
Because those specific questions are not the issue. The issue is whether it is acceptable to permanently alter the body of a healthy child.

If your answer to my above question is "yes" then nothing more really needs to be said. You have already established that you think that parents should be allowed to harm their children. What more need be said?
Yes, it has been well-established, on this thread, that the fallacy of "begging the question" is considered a reasonable method of arguing against circumcision. I have no idea why, though.
How is this begging the question? If surgically removing a healthy, functional part of their body does not constitute harm, then what does it take?

Appeals to religious tradition are complete non-starters. If your religion said brand your baby on the ass with the star of David, doing so would land you in prison. But objectively speaking, that is far less dangerous than circumcision, and would have zero affect on how your body functions.
Branding is another traditional way of indicating commitment to a group. Since laws reflect culture, I doubt it would have been perceived as a criminal act as an established tradition. As far as I know, cultures that include branding or tattooing of children do not form laws against the activity.
Is it acceptable in our society? If you think that it should not be, then you are a hypocrite.


Loss Leader,

Your question contains the following assumptions:

1. Circumcision is potentially dangerous
This is not an assumption. It is a demonstrable fact which has been repeatedly pointed out in this thread.

2. Circumcision alters the natural functions of a baby's body
Again, not an assumption. I am circumcised. As a result my penis functions differently than it would if I were not. Masturbation is different. Sexual intercourse is different. Again, the issue of to what degree sensitivity is reduced, or whether I would ever know the difference, is utterly irrelevant. The bottom line is that it is different. The natural function has been altered.

3. Such alteration is significant
No assumption here either. The difference is significant for any reasonable definition of "significant".

4. medical necessity is the only valid reason to circumcise a child
That's not an assumption. That is what the question is asking. If you answer "no", then you are effectively answering that medical necessity would be the only valid reason to circumcise a child.

What you have done is carefully frame the question in such a way as to make your desired answer more reasonable.
There is nothing "careful" about it. It is a very simple, and very general question. Is it acceptable to surgically alter a healthy child's body? I say it is not, and cannot imagine how one could reasonably argue that it is.

It is logically identical to asking people in a political survey: "Do you believe the US should abandon the Iraqi people even if it means that the ensuing chaos will cause thousands of unnecessary deaths?"
It is nothing like that. My question did not even mention circumcision, for one thing. It is a very general question which should be very easy to answer. The only reason you do not like it is because you know that you cannot justify your answer.

Any yes or no answer has the effect of agreeing with your assumptions.
I did not make any assumptions.

I do not agree with your assumptions (except assumption 1 which is true of everything on earth from brain surgery to buttering toast).
Don't be ridiculous. Cutting off living tissue with lots of nerves and blood-vassals in it is always dangerous. To compare that to buttering toast is simply idiotic.

Either ask a question that makes no judgments or just admit that you are too biased to care about any position other than your own. I don't really care which you do.
I am biased against child abuse. That much I will admit. I just would like to know how you can possibly argue that circumcision is not child abuse without giving parents free reign to do all sorts of things to their children which you would consider to be abusive.

Be honest here. If somebody from some culture you never heard of was insisting that he should be able to brand his children (based on cultural tradition), would you support his right to do so? What about if he wanted to remove part of his daughter's clitoris? Or remove the right pinky toe of his child's foot?

Where exactly does it become abuse? What criteria do you use for deciding that even cultural tradition does not justify the procedure?

By the arguments you have been presenting, you should be able to do literally anything you want to your child, as long as you personally believe it to be in his best interest (whatever that means). Clearly at some point you have to acknowledge that your child has rights. You seem to be arguing that your child has no rights at all, and that instead you have all the rights pertaining to your child's well-being.


Dr. Stupid
 
I would like to ask Loss Leader a question that I haven't seen asked in this thread and that I can't figure out the answer to.

My question to Loss Leader is this: if circumcision was illegal in your country, yet it was still recommended by your religious leaders, would you have your son circumcised or not?
 
If it is redundant, that is only because all surgical procedures involve some degree of risk.

I was referring to the trade-offs in all that we do as parents - from buttering the toast to sending our children to school. That you scoff at some of these suggestions I suspect makes my point - the examples are trivial because the weighing of benefit/harm is trivial (or assumed to be).

As for the weighing of benefit and harm, that is really the point of the question. The question already specifies that the procedure is not medically necessary. The whole issue is whether or not it is ok for parents to have their child permanently surgically altered when such alteration is not medically needed.

Yes, that is the question. We permanently alter our children in other ways without medical necessity (teaching them a language, piercing ears, braces), so it is clear that medical necessity alone is not the basis for our decisions. I think that part of the reason it has been proposed that medical necessity alone should be the basis for this decision is because we are used to associating surgical procedures with medical necessity. If physicians were removed from the equation, I think the discussion wouldn't focus on medical necessity, but rather the issues you bring up later about social conformity.

This is, of course, complete nonsense. It is trivially obvious that circumcision significantly alters the natural functioning of the penis.

Is it not also trivially obvious that circumcised men use their penis for the exact same things as non-circumcised men?

Are you saying that it would be ok for doctors to brand babies at birth if that is what their parents insist their culture requires?

Yes and no - meaning that there are several issues involved. Generally, physicans shouldn't and don't involve themselves (professionally) in cultural issues (the numerous exceptions aren't relevant to my point, I think). Historically, there are several reasons that physicians are involved in circumcision, but it represents an odd-man-out in the field of medicine. Similarly, branding would be an odd-man-out and one could say "no" for that reason. The "yes" is for whether or not it could be considered acceptable for parents to brand their child. I will elaborate on that later.

Not in this sense, of course they are not. Permanently altering a healthy child's body for the sake of social conformity is not morally acceptable.

But it must be very clear to you, that a vast number of people do not share this view. They see value for themselves and for their children in social conformity. And it is easy for us to be complacent about the issue when non-conformity does not affect our livelihood, but it may be a different situation for others.

I do not "desire" to find his position extremely immoral. I simply do.

Those two things are the same to me. This is how it appears. You have a sense that it is immoral, rather arriving at it through a chain of logical reasoning. Which is why it is easier for you to declare it immoral, rather than present a considered argument as to why it is immoral. I think this is what we all do, but your "I simply do" does not give some sort of absolute priority.

And I would wager that if he were insisting on his right to brand his child, rather than amputate part of his child's penis, that you would find it immoral as well.

I find both acts equally immoral, in the sense that I would not choose them for my children, and I would be moved to action against others, especially if the reasons for the act were trivial or without significance. In the case of circumcision, Loss Leader's reasons are obviously not trivial or without significance, but I suspect that is not the case for most parents in the US who are having their boys circumcised. This means that I attempt to persuade wherever I can make a difference. And I happen to think that name-calling is an ineffective means of persuasion in this circumstance. But I don't have proof that I'm right about that, and I'm willing to consider arguments to the contrary.

I also recognize that my sense of the relative importance of physical integrity is a product of my own personality and upbringing. Which means I should step lightly when judging others who are different. I think under most circumstances I would condemn him if he wanted to brand his child, but I can conceive of circumstances where I would consider it acceptable.

Because those specific questions are not the issue. The issue is whether it is acceptable to permanently alter the body of a healthy child.

And it should be clear by now that there is not an absolute answer to that issue?

How is this begging the question? If surgically removing a healthy, functional part of their body does not constitute harm, then what does it take?

This takes us back to the original question of weighing benefit/harm, rather than simply recognizing the presence of harm. When asking whether or not a weighing of benefit/harm can favour benefit, characterizing the act as harmful assumes that the weighing of benefit/harm favours harm. You are assuming the answer as part of your argument that the answer should be assumed.

Is it acceptable in our society? If you think that it should not be, then you are a hypocrite.

How so? I think that under most circumstances, both are unacceptable.

Linda
 
The wonderful irony in LL's and Linda's argument is that while accusing people such as myself as discriminating against religious and cultural groups, the reason for LL circumcising his son is so the majority in his community will not discriminate against a minority (of one).

I.e. Circumcision is an act performed out of fear of discrimination.

Most western societies have long decided that discrimination is wrong and an individual should not be penalized for say, being gay, or female, or non-white. Those individuals and groups that do discriminate against them can be prosecuted.

So how can Jewish people get away with discriminating against uncircumcised men, who wish to follow what amounts to a belief system, based on a almost entirely hidden physical attribute? Especially when the fundamental rules of the club have already been subverted or ignored. E.g., Jews marring non-Jews and stoning blasphemers.

Should hotels be able to have signs that say “No Gays”? Funnily enough there were some B&B owners in the UK complaining that the recent change in the law to stop them doing just this very thing. Can you guess what their excuse was?

Their religion!


Exactly the same argument could be used for offering to bleach black kids white and "cure" gay people.

So Linda’s “logic” is inconsistent.
 
fls,

Yes, that is the question. We permanently alter our children in other ways without medical necessity (teaching them a language, piercing ears, braces), so it is clear that medical necessity alone is not the basis for our decisions.
None of these are examples of causing physical damage to a healthy body.

That is what we are talking about here. Any way you cut it, circumcision involves inflicting injury on your child.

This is, of course, complete nonsense. It is trivially obvious that circumcision significantly alters the natural functioning of the penis.
Is it not also trivially obvious that circumcised men use their penis for the exact same things as non-circumcised men?
What does that have to do with it? I never said that they didn't. What I said is that the natural function is changed.

Are you saying that it would be ok for doctors to brand babies at birth if that is what their parents insist their culture requires?
Yes and no - meaning that there are several issues involved. Generally, physicans shouldn't and don't involve themselves (professionally) in cultural issues (the numerous exceptions aren't relevant to my point, I think). Historically, there are several reasons that physicians are involved in circumcision, but it represents an odd-man-out in the field of medicine. Similarly, branding would be an odd-man-out and one could say "no" for that reason. The "yes" is for whether or not it could be considered acceptable for parents to brand their child. I will elaborate on that later.
This completely evades the point. The point I am making is that the only reason that circumcision is considered OK, but other procedures which are both less risky and less harmful are not, is because it is a common practice which we are all used to.

Either it's ok for a parent to inflict injury on their child for the sake of cultural tradition, or it's not. Which is it?

Not in this sense, of course they are not. Permanently altering a healthy child's body for the sake of social conformity is not morally acceptable.
But it must be very clear to you, that a vast number of people do not share this view. They see value for themselves and for their children in social conformity.
Quite clear. Those people should answer "yes" to my question. I consider them to be immoral. That's pretty much all there is to it. A vast number of people think that it is ok to treat women as property, or to enslave people of what they consider to be "inferior" races, or to murder people who do not believe in their mythology. So what? I'm still going to stand up and say that I think that what they are doing is wrong.

And it is easy for us to be complacent about the issue when non-conformity does not affect our livelihood, but it may be a different situation for others.
I am not complacent about it. I just do not consider it to be justification for child abuse.

I do not "desire" to find his position extremely immoral. I simply do.
Those two things are the same to me. This is how it appears. You have a sense that it is immoral, rather arriving at it through a chain of logical reasoning. Which is why it is easier for you to declare it immoral, rather than present a considered argument as to why it is immoral. I think this is what we all do, but your "I simply do" does not give some sort of absolute priority.
I presented my chain of reasoning. I even did so in such a way as to make it clear that the only way you can logically avoid reaching the same conclusion I have, is to also consider it acceptable to do things which the vast majority of people who practice circumcision do not consider to be morally ok.

If you honestly think that it is generally ok to permanently injure your baby for the sake of cultural tradition, then we really have nothing further to discuss. Our values are simply too different for any sort of agreement to be possible. But if you don't think that this is generally ok, then we have something to discuss. Namely, why you think it is ok in this case, but not in others.

Because those specific questions are not the issue. The issue is whether it is acceptable to permanently alter the body of a healthy child.
And it should be clear by now that there is not an absolute answer to that issue?
Then the issue is what degree of harm is acceptable for the sake of cultural tradition. That's exactly why I brought up the branding issue. That is clearly a lesser degree of harm than circumcision, but most supporters of the right to circumcise would consider branding to be child abuse.

Just to be clear, I am not an "absolute morality" guy. I am not trying to argue that circumcision, or harming children, or anything else, is "objectively wrong". I was attempting to make two points:

1) That all of this discussion about what degree sensation is reduced, or whether the child will ever notice the difference, or how much it hurts, is completely missing the point.

2) That one cannot simultaneously insist that circumcision is OK, but that inflicting other types of injuries (of equal or lesser severity) for the sake of cultural tradition is not ok, without being hypocritical.

Either cultural tradition can justify the degree of injury involved in circumcision, or it cannot. Either way, the current status quo in the US and Europe is unnacceptable, because we are either allowing child abuse when we allow circumcision, or we are denying parent's rights to injure their children when we declare activities which are not-so-common cultural traditions to be child abuse.

The fact of the matter is that if a parent in america has his newborn child branded, he's going to be charged with a crime. And if he tries to claim as his defense that his cultural tradition requires it, that is not going to float.

More generally speaking, since cultural tradition is just a specific example of the parent placing a high enough value on something to justify injuring his child, the issue goes beyond that. Why limit it to cultural or religious tradition? Either the parent should be able to decide that their personal values justify inflicting this degree of injury on their child, or they should not. Why should we give special consideration the values that a parent uses to justify injuring their child, just because they are religiously or culturally motivated?


Dr. Stupid
 
I would like to ask Loss Leader a question that I haven't seen asked in this thread and that I can't figure out the answer to.

My question to Loss Leader is this: if circumcision was illegal in your country, yet it was still recommended by your religious leaders, would you have your son circumcised or not?


Already answered:

The day my religious practices are deemed criminal is the day I join the revolution.

ETA: I´d see that as a "Yes."
 
Last edited:
Already answered:



ETA: I´d see that as a "Yes."


Ive already picketed the criminalization of virgin sacrifice, also feeding babies to hippos, slashing old people's tires, and reading in submarines. All part of my obscenely stupid religion.
 
Originally Posted by Stimpson J. Cat
None of these are examples of causing physical damage to a healthy body.

That is what we are talking about here. Any way you cut it, circumcision involves inflicting injury on your child.

They are all examples of permanent, physical alterations, like circumcision. The question (which you are again begging) is whether they constitute "damage".

What does that have to do with it? I never said that they didn't. What I said is that the natural function is changed.

What is the function of the penis? How is this function different in the circumcised man?

This completely evades the point. The point I am making is that the only reason that circumcision is considered OK, but other procedures which are both less risky and less harmful are not, is because it is a common practice which we are all used to.

I agree with that. I was sorta trying to divide the argument into its component parts in order to make that point (i.e. bringing up the issue of culture).

Either it's ok for a parent to inflict injury on their child for the sake of cultural tradition, or it's not. Which is it?

I recognize that there is a large grey area where there is variation in what someone would perceive as an "injury", or as a sufficient injury to warrant intervention. I trust that I can make this judgment for myself. I also trust that I can make this judgment for those I have under my care. But I do not trust that I can make this judgment for others.

Quite clear. Those people should answer "yes" to my question. I consider them to be immoral. That's pretty much all there is to it.

Yes, I understand that.

A vast number of people think that it is ok to treat women as property, or to enslave people of what they consider to be "inferior" races, or to murder people who do not believe in their mythology. So what? I'm still going to stand up and say that I think that what they are doing is wrong.

Those examples are different from what I am talking about, though. The only thing (at present) I consider an absolute is symmetry, and they could all fail on that basis (examples - role reversal, the veil of ignorance).

I am not complacent about it. I just do not consider it to be justification for child abuse.

Again, you are begging the question by calling it abuse. Under different circumstances, non-conformity may be life-threatening. Choosing non-conformity then could be arguably seen as abuse.

I presented my chain of reasoning. I even did so in such a way as to make it clear that the only way you can logically avoid reaching the same conclusion I have, is to also consider it acceptable to do things which the vast majority of people who practice circumcision do not consider to be morally ok.

You attempted to present a chain of reasoning, but my purpose in going through it point by point was to show where it was broken. I think the reason that you see your argument as compelling and I don’t (remember, I already agree with your contention that circumcision should not generally be performed), is that it appears you did not use the argument to come to the view that you hold, but that you constructed the argument to support a view that you already hold. Of course, this is arguably the source of all rationalizations.

If you honestly think that it is generally ok to permanently injure your baby for the sake of cultural tradition, then we really have nothing further to discuss. Our values are simply too different for any sort of agreement to be possible. But if you don't think that this is generally ok, then we have something to discuss. Namely, why you think it is ok in this case, but not in others.

As I have stated several times, I don’t think it is generally okay to permanently injure my baby. I also suspect most parents of circumcised boys would say the same, but because they do not have an identical perception of what is injurious. And I don’t trust that my judgment should be substituted for their judgment when it comes to their own interest.

Then the issue is what degree of harm is acceptable for the sake of cultural tradition. That's exactly why I brought up the branding issue. That is clearly a lesser degree of harm than circumcision, but most supporters of the right to circumcise would consider branding to be child abuse.

Yes, I think you would find consensus on whether branding was injurious among North American culture.

Just to be clear, I am not an "absolute morality" guy. I am not trying to argue that circumcision, or harming children, or anything else, is "objectively wrong". I was attempting to make two points:

1) That all of this discussion about what degree sensation is reduced, or whether the child will ever notice the difference, or how much it hurts, is completely missing the point.

I would agree with that in the sense that even if it makes no difference, that does not automatically make it okay.

2) That one cannot simultaneously insist that circumcision is OK, but that inflicting other types of injuries (of equal or lesser severity) for the sake of cultural tradition is not ok, without being hypocritical.

Assuming that you are talking about weighing the benefit of cultural tradition, I agree with that as well.

Either cultural tradition can justify the degree of injury involved in circumcision, or it cannot. Either way, the current status quo in the US and Europe is unnacceptable, because we are either allowing child abuse when we allow circumcision, or we are denying parent's rights to injure their children when we declare activities which are not-so-common cultural traditions to be child abuse.

The fact of the matter is that if a parent in america has his newborn child branded, he's going to be charged with a crime. And if he tries to claim as his defense that his cultural tradition requires it, that is not going to float.

I think one could argue that the value of the cultural tradition is much reduced when practiced outside of the culture (and that accounts for the imbalance). However, I agree that there is an imbalance on this issue that I think is based on what we are used to. Which is why (I think) this idea is also undergoing change – not toward finding more cultural traditions acceptable, but toward finding circumcision less acceptable.

More generally speaking, since cultural tradition is just a specific example of the parent placing a high enough value on something to justify injuring his child, the issue goes beyond that. Why limit it to cultural or religious tradition? Either the parent should be able to decide that their personal values justify inflicting this degree of injury on their child, or they should not. Why should we give special consideration the values that a parent uses to justify injuring their child, just because they are religiously or culturally motivated?


Dr. Stupid

It seems to me that the bulk (all?) of our values are religiously or culturally motivated. Rather than the exception, you may be referring to the rule.

Linda
 
It seems to me that the bulk (all?) of our values are religiously or culturally motivated. Rather than the exception, you may be referring to the rule.
Linda

So you would deny that there is a certain set of rights that every person should be guaranteed?

The fun thing about cultural subjectivism is that if its right, then your culture is wrong as are your reasonings(thus making your assertation that its right in fact wrong), if you assume all your morals are just based on whats pumped into you from your religion and surroundings then all cultures are right and the values of all of them are just as valid(invalid) as yours. Including things like institutionalized rape, abuse, genocides, whatever.

Some things simply are right. No person wants to be strapped down and have parts of them cut off for no reason, or someone elses perverted analysis of what protection is. In this day and age I would think that everyone could respect that another person is ANOTHER PERSON, with the same sense of self importance as you. There is no reason not to wait until the person can make the decision as an adult, other than wanting to just force it on them when theyre children and cant protect themselves.
 
Last edited:
This thread could be made into a TV movie, maybe for Lifetime(the Chick Channel), starring Sally Field.

Anyone? Anyone?
 
I think you're more likely to be "all over" that To Catch a Predator show... :eek:

Thats a funny comment, considering the institutionalized nature of infant circumcision in this country. Nothing wrong with a baby boy bleeding from his penis. Ask anyone.
 
So you would deny that there is a certain set of rights that every person should be guaranteed?

I'm suggesting that it is useful to recognize the origins of our ideas.

The fun thing about cultural subjectivism is that if its right, then your culture is wrong as are your reasonings(thus making your assertation that its right in fact wrong), if you assume all your morals are just based on whats pumped into you from your religion and surroundings then all cultures are right and the values of all of them are just as valid(invalid) as yours. Including things like institutionalized rape, abuse, genocides, whatever.

Even following the idea of variation in individual morals (based on whatever)institutionalized rape, abuse, genocides, whatever, can clearly be recognized as wrong because they violate the idea of protection of individual rights. I have to admit that I am dumbfounded by the fact that this very simple, very basic principle has had to be pointed out so many times in this thread already.

Some things simply are right. No person wants to be strapped down and have parts of them cut off for no reason, or someone elses perverted analysis of what protection is. In this day and age I would think that everyone could respect that another person is ANOTHER PERSON, with the same sense of self importance as you. There is no reason not to wait until the person can make the decision as an adult, other than wanting to just force it on them when theyre children and cant protect themselves.

Yes, you have made it clear that you are unwilling to consider any perspective but your own. Your attitude is why I consider the protection of the right of individuals to self-determination very important.

Linda
 
I'm suggesting that it is useful to recognize the origins of our ideas.



Even following the idea of variation in individual morals (based on whatever)institutionalized rape, abuse, genocides, whatever, can clearly be recognized as wrong because they violate the idea of protection of individual rights. I have to admit that I am dumbfounded by the fact that this very simple, very basic principle has had to be pointed out so many times in this thread already.



Yes, you have made it clear that you are unwilling to consider any perspective but your own. Your attitude is why I consider the protection of the right of individuals to self-determination very important.

Linda

You know Linda, I like you, but you never really seem to say much.

The origins of our ideas.... Ok, lets discuss the origin of our ideas. Can I stab you? Yes no? Why not? Where did that idea come from?

How does cutting off part of a baby's genitals not violate their rights? Does cutting off a finger? 2 fingers? 17 fingers? How much or what do you have to cut off for it to violate someones rights? And where does this idea originate?

I said, that if you believe that everything is subjective, then sure, youre right. However, that being said, if I say that you are wrong, I am right, because its all subjective. You have a self refuting argument, if everyone is right, noone is right.

I consider other people's perspectives. And I honestly have no idea what youre talking about with your self determination line. Self determination to what end? Ive self determined that I have no idea what youre going on about.
It seems like you just said the exact same thing I said, but put me down for saying it.
 
Last edited:
Thats a funny comment, considering the institutionalized nature of infant circumcision in this country. Nothing wrong with a baby boy bleeding from his penis. Ask anyone.
Nothing wrong with a C-section either, ask anyone.

Not all C-sections are required, though some are. They are a routine procedure nonetheless. Some are elective. A slightly larger impact on a person in terms of the seriousness of surgery.

Do I get up in arms about people having C-sections electively? (As my sister in law did)

No.

Why?

Choice. Loss Leader's point about who is the medical authority for a child is dead on, since not all persons get their sons circumcised for religious reasons. Indeed, my son cannot have much of any medical procedure done on him, of any sort, without my consent. Wart removal? Needs my consent. Surgery on his wrist? Needs my consent. With the responsibility comes authority.

When making the decision, LL has a ritual to deal with, but he also has a simple Risk Management matrix to fill out, which includes a harm, likelihood of harm, and benefit, cost, and other factors to consider. Some data has been shown here that indicates later in life circ's may raise risk. That's a factor in the decision.

I have watched this argument run on now for some pages, and find that your emotional attachment to anti circumcision position irrational, not rational, yet you and others, to include the less foamy and a bit more rational Ivor, assert that circumcision is irrational. Irony seems to have arrived.

As a custom, it is has certainly grown from curious roots, but as a non Jew who, for whatever reason, had parents who listened to the medical advice of the time (late 1950's) and had all three of their sons circumcised -- Dad wasn't -- I can offer you evidence of my own that

Sex feels great
Function is all go
My penis works correctly
I have no memory whatever of pain, hell, I have no memory whatever of anything before I was one. My first waking memory, since I have been pondering memory in junior high, was between the ages of one and two on the bottom bunk bed in an apartment where I shared a room with my older brother. I mention this because twenty or so years ago, I was in a discussion with a woman who claimed that boys who are clipped remember the pain and are scarred for life by it.

Nope, not this data point.

My penis has been a feel good center for me since my first erection

If there is some slight decrease in sensitivity I'd never know. I do know how wonderful the sensations are, and thank you, they are just fine.

I find that if you stick your nose into someone else's business, you'll rarely see them respond as politely to you as LL did.

For that, his polite responses to you, you mixed in your manufactured sense of outrage and offered him a vile insult, virtually a curse, upon his yet to be born son.

The game is over, and you are the loser.

Do you kiss your mom with that mouth?

DR
 
Nothing wrong with a C-section either, ask anyone.

Not all C-sections are required, though some are. They are a routine procedure nonetheless. Some are elective. A slightly larger impact on a person in terms of the seriousness of surgery.

Do I get up in arms about people having C-sections electively? (As my sister in law did)

No.

Why?

Choice. Loss Leader's point about who is the medical authority for a child is dead on, since not all persons get their sons circumcised for religious reasons. Indeed, my son cannot have much of any medical procedure done on him, of any sort, without my consent. Wart removal? Needs my consent. Surgery on his wrist? Needs my consent. With the responsibility comes authority.

When making the decision, LL has a ritual to deal with, but he also has a simple Risk Management matrix to fill out, which includes a harm, likelihood of harm, and benefit, cost, and other factors to consider. Some data has been shown here that indicates later in life circ's may raise risk. That's a factor in the decision.

I have watched this argument run on now for some pages, and find that your emotional attachment to anti circumcision position irrational, not rational, yet you and others, to include the less foamy and a bit more rational Ivor, assert that circumcision is irrational. Irony seems to have arrived.

As a custom, it is has certainly grown from curious roots, but as a non Jew who, for whatever reason, had parents who listened to the medical advice of the time (late 1950's) and had all three of their sons circumcised -- Dad wasn't -- I can offer you evidence of my own that

Sex feels great
Function is all go

[...] Life is good, women like my penis, blah blah blah [...]

DR

Edit in italics.


Thanks for your inaccurate example and anecdote, Ill file that right in my garbage can.
 
Last edited:
Thanks for your inaccurate example and anecdote, Ill file that right in my garbage can.
The anecdote is very accurate, due to the proximity and first hand observation. :cool:

I am sure that the elements of my post that you file will be in good company with your manners.

Absent your emotional rot, there was a lot of excellent discussion in this thread. Kudos to all.

DR
 
The anecdote is very accurate, due to the proximity and first hand observation. :cool:

I am sure that the elements of my post that you file will be in good company with your manners.

Absent your emotional rot, there was a lot of excellent discussion in this thread. Kudos to all.

DR

An anecdote is inaccurate by its very nature Im afraid.

The elements of your post (the entire thing) will go right next to all the other nonsense produced I have to deal with.

By the way, inability for you to form a rational argument in support of circumcision is no evidence of emotional involvement on my part. Every one of the pro camp cries emotional involvement in lieu of any really substantive argument.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom